r/anime • u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel • May 07 '23
Infographic /r/anime Karma Ranking & Discussion | Week 5 [Spring 2023]
2.6k
Upvotes
r/anime • u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel • May 07 '23
62
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel May 07 '23
Japanese Streaming Ranking Links
133
u/entelechtual May 07 '23
Since KamiKatsu is now too mainstream for me to shill, here's some shows under the radar you might have missed:
My Clueless First Friend - At first I thought this show was just cute goth girl meets manic pixie dream boy, so I was pleasantly surprised to find that episodes 4-5 showed us how well-written the characters are, and how mature the storytelling is.
Rokudo’s Bad Girls - This one isn’t extraordinary; I certainly wouldn’t place it on the level of something like Mob Psycho 100. But there’s an immense charm about the show. Despite the premise sounding like it’s straight out of an h-manga, and the wish-fulfillment-y twists, ultimately the show is about how there’s more to “bad girls” than meets the eye. And not just that, but also bad boys, and good girls. When nice, happy things happen, it melts every ounce of cynicism in your body.
Blue Orchestra - It’s been plagued by a lack of global distribution and a lack of animation, but it’s a very earnest story with good drama. The characters are all pretty charming, and both Aono and Akine have demonstrated many layers to their characters already. Curious to see where this is leading.
Sacrificial Princess and the King of Beasts - I know what you’re thinking: “Isn’t this just a Magus Bride clone?” Well, no, and moreover if Ancient Magus Bride delves into the politics of magic, Sacrificial Princess delves into the politics of, well, beast kingdom management and racism. Sariphi is an absolute ray of sunshine, and her bubbly attitude makes everything in the show enjoyable. And even though I came into the season expecting to love Magus Bride, I found it a lot less engaging than this.
World Dai Star - I don’t think any of us were expecting this.
Chibi Godzilla - Imagine Rieri plays a beautiful celeb with two strangely overprotective sibling fans. Forget Kamikatsu, this is the real unexpected stacked casting of the season. AKA Inosuke and Kazuma go around visiting monsters. And it’s free on youtube!
214
u/HarshTheDev May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23
Damn, it fell off even more from the last episode, and the unstable thread release schedule doesn't help much either...
BUT it seems that the latest episode of Heavenly is performing really well, it has
almostreached the karma here already and a complete day hasn't even passed yet. Yesterday's episode could very well be Heavenly's best performing episode yet.Good days are coming heavenly bros
194
u/TheLazyWorkingSloth May 07 '23
I’m glad the recent Vinland Saga episode is getting the attention it deserves. The anime did such a good job at portraying Gardar’s feelings compared to the manga when I read the chapter it covers later and yet some people called the anime worse for being longer? But whatever, the Vinland Saga team is doing an amazing job for an amazing source material.
8
u/Fools_Requiem https://myanimelist.net/profile/FoolsRequiem May 07 '23
Otaku Elf finally on the board depsite. Which is odd because the board indicates that no change in its ranking occurred despite it definitely not being there last week.
Still, Otaku Elf definitely deserves more attention if you like comfy shows with an adorable lead character, and some Japanese history sprinkled throughout.
100
u/cppn02 May 07 '23
Week 5 of Spring!
Oshi no Ko doesn't lose karma for the first time this season while comfortably staying in fierst place.
After already gaining one rank last week Vinland Saga takes another victim and moves up into 3rd getting pretty close even to Demon Slayer.
Very happy to see Skip and Loafer going up two ranks into 7th. It was actually a pretty nice battle between that, Mashle and Megumin.
The winner of the week for me though is once again Kamikatsu which one week after making it into the top 15 now climbed into 13th and got over 1k for the first time. After dropping as low as 24th in week 2 the top 10 now seems a realistic aim in the coming weeks.
Its score rising also meant that we had more shows above the 1k threshold than in the previous two weeks.
On the right we can see Raeliana rising by 5 ranks atleast in small part due to actually making it to the top of the sub for a bit which frankly is insane for an episode with a score below 500.
Still holding out for Ao no Orchestra and Uma Musume making the ranking with the latter having its last shot at it today.
50
u/mrnicegy26 May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23
As always interesting choice for the image to represent The Legendary Hero is Dead.
I have no idea what the anime is about and honestly I want to keep that mystery alive and just make up my own theories through banner pics for it on karma chart.
226
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman May 07 '23
We are 5 weeks in, and while there are no shows that have increased in Karma every week, there are 10 shows currently on the chart that have decreased in Karma every week:
It's an interesting group of anime with a few that I'd consider among my favorites of the season (G-Witch and Insomniacs) and another that in opposition to its Karma trend, I feel has gotten better every episode (Yuri is my Job).
62
u/mrnicegy26 May 07 '23
With the WGA strike beginning this week and one that has the potential to last quite a while, I am wondering if there might be another period similar to the pandemic where more people will be consuming anime.
Considering that the strike could lead to a shortage of Western productions, maybe some people will switch over to anime for their entertainment.
116
u/ReinhardLoen May 07 '23
Vinland Saga's last episode was so damn sad...
...and it doesn't look like it's about to get any happier in the next episode.
36
u/CT_BINO https://myanimelist.net/profile/CT_BINO May 07 '23
Season has been great, offering some entertaining new shows like heaven delusion, skip to loafer, Uma musume, dangers in my heart and others but Vinland saga s2 has been in another level, with last week episode being such a great emotional episode, finishing this little arc with some great production values. Also Arnheid VA was great in this arc.
Still some eps to go but would be suprise if S2 isn t in my top 5 at the end of the year.
59
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar May 07 '23
Good to see Skip to Loafer jumping up 4 spots. Definitely well-deserved!
And it looks like the brakes aren't stopping with KamiKatsu! The legendary tractor scene really helped pull some people to check it out. Hopefully, everyone will continue to follow it, especially after what happened in the last episode.
29
u/Lounge_leaks May 07 '23
Whys it called megusuba? Xd
61
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius May 07 '23
Damn, Dr. Stone, Insomniacs and Tonikawa being this low was not on my bingo list at the start of the season. At least Skip and Loafer is doing well.
Also I feel like there was a missed opportunity for Komekkosuba44
u/Sir-Alpha69 May 07 '23
I’ve been loving the Dangers of my heart, such a cute anime 😭
46
u/Vermillion_Crab https://anilist.co/user/CeruleanCrab May 07 '23
27
u/polaristar May 07 '23
So many shows this season consistently toping 1000 karma. I wish Magus Bride was one of them.
Can't wait to see next week's seeing how many great episode 6's we had
26
u/Urgnu-the-Gnu https://myanimelist.net/profile/Urgnu_the_Gnu May 07 '23
I'm really looking forward to the image being used next week for The Dangers in my Heart - there really is only that one scene that makes sense to use. Preferrably with a jump up a couple of places.
Sad to see Heavenly Delusion so "low". Not that the shows above don't belong there, there isn't any that should place lower as well. But Heavenly Delusion should easily be a top three show of the season. Then again, there are probably a literal dozen shows airing right now that should be top three, even if that's impossible.
58
u/PeaceAlien https://myanimelist.net/profile/PeaceAlien May 07 '23
I'm surprised by how well Oshi No Ko continues to do. Aka Akasaka really is a great writer, always keeps me entertained.
31
u/[deleted] May 07 '23
People did not like that Lvl999 Yamada-kun episode huh? Including me to be honest, I spoke about it in the discussion thread but I thought with the replies I got, I was in the minority.
Nice to see gains to Skip and Loafer and KamiKatsu though. Two of my favourites this season along with Oshi no Ko, The Dangers in my Heart and Heavenly Delusion.
23
u/dododomo May 07 '23
Happy to see Yamada-Kun, Skip and Loafer, Mashle, Heavenly Delusion, hell's paradise, Demon slayer and Oshi no ko in top 10. My love story with Yamada at lv 999 and skip to Loafer are my top 2 favourite series of the season :D
I Wish Realiana, a galaxy next door and my home Hero were higher too. Also, sad that Blue orchestra and sacrificial princess didn't make it to the top 30 :(
18
u/Ashteron May 07 '23
The 4th episode of Ranking of Kings was stellar and it was very relevant storywise.
16
u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin May 07 '23
Based Skip and Loafer going up the rankings, AOTS so far.
16
u/Tarhalindur x2 May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23
Wait wait wait. Did we finally get a thighighs-on-a-daikon pic for Legendary Hero is Dead? I FUCKING APPROVE!
EDIT: ... No I haven't been keeping up on the show this week, how can you tell?
20
u/Jriri1452 May 07 '23
Please, watch Danger in my heart, guys, it's a really good romantic. Unexpectedly good. Stupid mc thoughts disappear almost in the first episode, so it is really worth it. Trust my word.
14
u/squirrelhoodie https://anilist.co/user/stefandesu May 07 '23
Perfect image for KamiKatsu!
12
u/Arthas_Firedragon May 07 '23
Another week, another V
11
u/PeaceAlien https://myanimelist.net/profile/PeaceAlien May 07 '23
Isn't demon slayer much lower than its last season? Any reason for that? I thought the show has been good.
11
u/Zeed_Toven77 May 07 '23
You people should watch Kamikatsu more! It's such a shitpost anime with a really really interesting plot. Also the Bad Cgi is done on purpose.
20
u/IC2Flier May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23
Separate column for other shows later. For now, I wanna post this comment here because this is a better place to put it. That, and I think I finally found the reason why The Witch from Mercury is so fun to track.
Gundam now at the final 8 episodes of this run! And also next week is our first break for the second half.
Because of that, I tracked G-Witch engagement stats based on the karma ranking tables on r/anime, which generally have a 48-hr cutoff. A smarter person can lie with statistics, but a dumb bitch like me can do a worse job at it, so here we are.
There is definitely a big dropoff in terms of karma after E6 (where much of the delays are) so it's right around 21 May where we'd see the effects of another delay, butt in fairness, comment count is still pretty high relative to manga adaptations running alongside it last fall 2022. And with average karma totaling 3300 it does prove that on Reddit, G-Witch is performing admirably well.
Now, I did this mostly to sanity-check my claim that it'd take a miracle for Gundam to maintain 2000+ karma and 1000+ comments if it somehow suffers any more delays, which I wrote back in E6. This was the crux of the rant I did here: it'd take total perfection for Gundam to keep up, but it's living up to the hype despite a hellacious, time-to-wing-it production that raises more redd flags than an average IBO episode.
So now that we've got another break in airing AND in the championship rounds for a show to stick their landing, I'm even more interested to see how Sunrise can step up to the plate. They're getting away with a lot of fault, but that unbreakable wall of suck is far closer than they anticipate. If these last eight episodes can sustain two more delays and still stay over 2000 upvotes and over 600 comments the rest of the way, I am gonna be utterly gobsmacked.
15
u/Warm-Enthusiasm-9534 May 07 '23
Kana looks shocked to see us.
I got derailed from watching most anime this season. Right now I'm only watching Oshi No Ko and Raeliana (and Demon Slayer, but that's just because I'm waiting for the big ufotable moments this season). I'm not sure what else to watch. I watched a few episodes of Hell's Paradise, and I thought it was pretty good, but then I just fell behind without feeling much drive to catch up.
I guess I'm looking for something new and surprising. Oshi No Ko episode 1 is the ultimate example. Does anything else fit the bill?
6
u/actuallyrndthoughts :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NaNiNuNeNo May 07 '23
Some thoughts on the least popular shows i'm following:
The least popular show on my currently watching list is The Marginal Service. For those who don't know, it's a low budget man in black ripoff with tons of references(and quotes) to other western works. Outside of a stacked male voice cast and Miyano Mamoru singing a cheesy OP, it got very little redeeming qualities. Cant recommend.
Next in line is Yuri is my Job and you'd think passione would amp up the spice but it's rather tame. It's mostly a yuri cafe yuri drama with high cringe levels at certain scenes, but the girls are sweet and you get what you get. Still it got some good story telling and i'd say let the girls cook.
Mahou Shoujo Magical Destroyers finally had a decent episode! Yes you've heard it right, latest episode was pretty good. Maybe they manage to string together a good second half, who knows? Still that OP is something else, i'd recommend everyone to check it out if you haven't.
Goddess cafe terrace... I don't get the appeal of the mc at all. Like what are his strong sides, since i don't see it. That guy does nothing for me, perhaps i needed to talk to his grandma too..
6
u/koteshima2nd https://myanimelist.net/profile/Koteshima May 07 '23
So happy Skip and Loafer is being talked about more, such a wholesome series. Reminded me of the first time I watched Kimi ni Todoke.
3
u/ManateeofSteel :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/daysun22 May 07 '23
BokuYaba and Insomniacs have done significantly worse than I anticipated
3
u/Keltoigael May 08 '23
Tengoku Daimakyou is so raunchy, weird and hilarious. I love it.
5
u/VorAtreides May 07 '23
God.. Vinland Saga is just so good and so sad :(
5
u/KorekaBii May 07 '23
Dead Mount Death Play oh so very close to making the Top 15 and only lost by 1 or 2 points this week. Hopefully as the show keeps picking up more people will catch on. Tomorrow's ep will hopefully be a great one after the cliffhanger from the last.
5
u/Actual-Oil6390 May 07 '23
Kamikatsu pulling some impressive numbers for it's rating. Episode had nice plot twist and set up the stage for real story
5
u/Time-Ladder4753 May 07 '23
Had no expectations for Kamikatsu, but was pleasantly surprised by it, with Magical Destroyers situation was complete opposite sadly, hope it'll get better
10
u/_AR3 May 07 '23 edited May 07 '23
There’s just so many bangers this season it’s hard to keep up. I think my favorite 3 so far have been Oshi no ko, Skip and Loafer, and Hells paradise. Lots of other great shows though.
Demon slayer continues to get better and better in my opinion.
Mashle has been a pleasant surprise for me. I saw the trailer and thought it looked mid but man it’s actually a really fun watch every week. (That ED might be the worst in the history of ED’s though 😭)
Megasuba has been hot and cold for me but the last episode was fantastic.
Every-time I watch dangers in my heart I end up enjoying it more then I thought I would at the start of the episode.
Loving yamada and heavenly dillusion have also been really good.
Personally, I also have really enjoyed Raelina. I think if more people gave it a chance they’d enjoy it!
The legendary hero is dead is also very watchable. There’s some cringe mixed in but the show itself has good self awareness which leads to some good comedy. There’s nothing over the top cringe that would make me wanna shut it off. The OP and ED are also great.
Overall a really nice szn so far
P.s haven’t started szn 2 yet cause I’m gonna wait till they’re all out but Vinland Saga and Witch from mercury both had very good 1st szns.
4
u/LookOutSlipperySlope May 07 '23
Nice choice of images with Boku no Kokoro no Yabai Yatsu and Tonikaku Kawaii being right next to each other.
4
u/godjacob May 07 '23
Raeliana getting a big jump, makes me wonder what other smaller shows would benefit being stuck on the front page like it was this week. Either way a good show that deserves the love.
6
u/toilodi https://anilist.co/user/Luca5 May 07 '23
Am I the only one that is really enjoying Magical Destroyers? I feel like each episode they consistently deliver with some pretty good animation, interesting and unique world development, great soundtrack and voice acting, fun to watch action scenes and crazy plot development and yet it's karma is only dropping every week, I know it's humor is kinda niche but still I would suppose the overall production quality would hold at least some popularity.
6
u/GokaiRed64 May 07 '23
Does Mashle ever get good? Haven't laughed once. Dr Stone has been great this season, why is it so low?
5
u/[deleted] May 07 '23
vinland saga’s episode 17 was maybe the best mini story in a anime of the year
2
u/FatiTankEris May 07 '23
Oh, it's another week of a huge amount of titles that I'll never have time to watch and get to know which I'd like...
2
u/Unalive_Not_Sleeping May 07 '23
I'm really liking Kuma Kuma Kuma Bear Punch! And My Clueless First Friend. Glad that their still on the list.
2
u/SpaceMarine_CR May 07 '23
u/Abysswatcherbel why you keep changing megukonosubamin's name? :v
2
u/Sufficient-Ocelot-47 May 08 '23
Can I watch heavenly delusion in Canada on Disney or no ?
5
u/-Zeratulot- May 08 '23
I've been loving Oshi No Ko so far and I can't wait for more episodes
5
u/Heda-of-Aincrad https://myanimelist.net/profile/Heda-of-Aincrad May 07 '23
Oshi no Ko continues to hold that #1 rank! It's the show I'm anticipating most week to week, and the most recent episode was the best one since the premiere. Nice to see Insomniacs After School in the top 15 again as well, and both Kuma Bear and Otaku Elf making it to the list in the top 30! I'm also glad GWitch is doing well. I haven't started season 2 yet, but really looking forward to it.
3
u/Utharion_ https://myanimelist.net/profile/Crescent_ May 07 '23
This season is FR filled with heavy contenders LOL. Definitely in contrast with the previous one.
3
u/67noskcaz May 07 '23
Ayo Tonikawa looking quite sus
5
u/BOBIIN May 07 '23
Vinland saga being anywhere below 1st is an atrocity
4
u/Dababy28193 May 07 '23
Insomnia gets better but drops in karma. If that happens again this upcoming episode, I’m ditching this chart until the end of the season I guess.
4
u/00pirateforever May 07 '23
So I am not only one who is disappointed with demon slayer.
I really need to watch Vinland S2. I am seeing quite alot of good reviews.
Oshi ko is really shining. I need to watch that too.
3
u/Hazel-NUTS May 07 '23
Vinland Saga ep 17 was a masterpiece for me. Everything was done soo good it was the first time in a while that I cried and felt so invested in an airing anime.
5
u/keereeyos May 07 '23
Jigoraku's decreasing score over the weeks reflects my decreasing interest in the show. Man, has the past three episodes been disappointing. I feel like it's mainly running on the hype of the manga and Mappa because, so far, it's definitely not in my personal top 5.