r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jun 06 '23
Announcement Reddit API Changes, Subreddit Blackout, and How It Affects You
Update: /r/anime will go private starting June 12th
TL;DR: We're raising awareness of reddit issues and want community feedback on /r/anime potentially participating in the June 12th blackout. If you're unfamiliar with what's going on please read the rest of the post, otherwise weigh in on the issue in the comments. /r/anime**'s moderators have not yet decided on our full involvement.**
!img
Last week, reddit announced significant upcoming changes to their API that will have a serious negative effect on many users. There is a planned protest across more than a thousand subreddits to black out and go private for 48 hours (at least) on June 12th. While /r/anime has traditionally stayed out of site-wide protests similar to this one, we believe this particular case is serious enough that we're getting involved.
What's Happening
- Third-party reddit apps (such as Apollo, Reddit is Fun and others) are going to become ludicrously more expensive for their developers to run, which will in turn either kill the apps, or result in a monthly fee to the users if they choose to use one of those apps to browse. Each request to reddit within these mobile apps (e.g. to load posts, make a comment, or upvote anything) will cost the developer money, and the developers of Apollo were quoted around $20 million per year for the current rate of usage. The only way for these apps to continue to be viable for the developer is if you (the user) pay a monthly fee, and realistically, this is most likely going to just outright kill them. The end result is that if you use a third-party app to browse reddit, you will most likely no longer be able to do so, or be charged a monthly fee to keep it viable.
- NSFW content is no longer going to be available in the API. This means that even if third-party apps continue to survive you will not be able to access NSFW content using them, but rather only via the official reddit apps or desktop site. This isn't a major concern for /r/anime as we generally limit what kind of NSFW content can be posted, but there are NSFW key visuals and similar things at times that will become locked down.
- Many users with visual impairments rely on third-party applications in order to more easily interface with reddit, as the official reddit mobile apps do not have robust support for visually-impaired users. This means that a great deal of visually-impaired redditors will no longer be able to access the site in the assisted fashion they're used to.
Open Letter to reddit & Blackout
In lieu of what's happening above, an open letter has been released by the broader moderation community. Part of this initiative includes a potential subreddit blackout (meaning a subreddit will be privatized and users will be unable to see any posts) on June 12th, lasting 48 hours or longer.
We would like to get community feedback on this. Do you believe /r/anime should fully support the protest and blackout the subreddit for at least June 12th-13th? Feel free to leave your thoughts and opinions below.
Sincerely,
318
u/_____pantsunami_____ Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
i enjoyed the use of camas commentsearch and reveddit, and i can only imagine RES’s time may be limited as well if these trends continue. so if you guys wanna shut down to support the blackout thats fine by me, id support that idea
173
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Personally speaking, I use Apollo for browsing reddit and really dislike the official iOS app as far as usability goes. Modding's also much easier with Apollo; few nitpicks there but it still had features for years that the official app only added recently.
The various tools that we manage directly shouldn't be affected much so I didn't say anything about them in the post, but that's also partially due to admins walking back some changes after the initial announcement more than a month ago.
Overall though this is just one more change in a long series that shows how reddit's been taking steps toward maximizing profitability over everything else. It continues to be a disappointment even as I try to help maintain the community I came to love years ago.
632
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jun 06 '23
Might be the only way to get me off /r/anime
Honestly don't think it'll change anything if /r/anime joins the blackout or not but hey guess it doesn't hurt. Owe to RiF alone for how great that app has been over the years.
The karma ranking people might get their feathers ruffled.
385
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Jun 06 '23
I am 100% in support of the protest. It's ridiculous that Reddit would give a middle finger to such a large section of their userbase. Losing access to this sub, and others, for 2 days or more is a very small price to pay for the chance of getting Reddit to reverse this policy.
153
u/M8gazine https://myanimelist.net/profile/M8gazine Jun 06 '23
Honestly I was wondering when this announcement would come.
I support it, I use RIF on mobile all the time. Similarly, I use old Reddit on desktop all the time, even if that's not in the danger zone yet, apparently? In any case, the more subs taking part in it, the better.
I don't mind it if it's continued for longer than that either, 2 days feels like it would be too little to make any sort of a major impact.
144
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jun 06 '23
As much as I'd hate this throwing off all the daily rewatches I'm in (including the one I'm personally hosting), I'm all for supporting the third-party apps in this. With r/anime being a sub with as many subscribers as it does, I think we should definitely participate!
I guess my only question for this would be what would happen to all the seasonal discussion threads? Would the bot still post them on time, we just won't be able to get to them until the blackout is done? Or would there be a ton getting posted at once after the blackout finishes.
97
u/chilidirigible Jun 06 '23
Do it.
Do it because even if Reddit's slide down to being a money-grubbing husk of itself is inevitable, we'll all know that at least once, you tried to do something about it.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
This theory is a fun one.
58
u/afon13 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I absolutely support it. As an Apollo user myself, it’s absolute bullshit that Reddit is trying this. At least make the native app better to encourage people to use it instead of forcing people to use it by pricing out the competition.
64
u/JockstrapCummies Jun 06 '23
This whole "announcing it's just 48 hours" thing is going to cause undue confusion, even if you're opening it up for potentially extending the blackout.
Imagine: come 48 hours, there's going to be a spike in traffic of users trying to ask if their subs are opening, and then some subs will, which then causes other subs mods to feel that "ah well we might as well". And since the whole space will be in confusion due to communication blackout, there will be no proper coordination.
You can never achieve anything if you leave the "maybe extend" clause up to individuals in a collective action.
12
u/Tresnore FS:FTmyanimelist.net/profile/Tresnore Jun 06 '23
Full support. Been using third party since Alien Blue. I will never use the official app.
58
u/Manitary https://myanimelist.net/profile/Manitary Jun 06 '23
Did these kind of protest have any effect in the past? I feel like this comment alone is more damaging to Reddit than any protest.
Regardless, the official mobile app is appalling, new reddit is terrible, and new new reddit is even worse, old.reddit and 3rd party apps are the only reasonable way to browse the website.
Any attempt to take any of these away is worth protesting against
If anything, two days is nothing, the should keep going until they walk it back to a reasonable stance.
Even if they do, never get complacent, don't get fooled that Reddit was the good guy all along because "they listened" and adopted a more reasonable pricing, that's just the bare minimum (and also it's a common negotiation tactic: announce something ridiculous, walk it back a bit, "wow they good now", something something boiling the frog)
Their newer post is worth nothing, words like
are empty and meaningless, not reassuring.
I hope a lot of people only ever used new reddit and/or the official app because they didn't know better get to know about these alternatives and how Reddit is basically trying to fuck everyone over just to funnel more users into the crappy official app, while users generate content for them, and mods work for free to keep subs from falling apart from spam, scams, and whatnot, and keeping them in order (spoiler, I will never reinstall it, once old.reddit is dead, so is my account).
47
u/LavaRoseKinnie Jun 06 '23
If you’re going to protest, do so indefinitely. A protest with a designated end is useless. All they have to do is wait it out. Go all in or go home.
20
u/baseballlover723 Jun 06 '23
I'd be in favor of /r/anime joining the protest, this seems important enough to warrant it. Plus this will directly effect users and mods of /r/anime.
10
u/Masfoodplease Jun 06 '23
Black it out
28
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jun 06 '23
Said it twice in the Meta Thread and I’ll gladly say it again, I’m in full, whole-hearted support of any and all joining of sitewide protest efforts.
19
u/JSchirmacher :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dyingbreed Jun 06 '23
1000% support it. Go as dark for as long as needed.
19
u/ja_noble https://anilist.co/user/halfofmarco Jun 06 '23
If this is done, you have to do this indefinitely. Two days is nothing in terms of a message and will have no lasting impact.
18
u/n080dy123 Jun 06 '23
I like that a lot of subs aren't deciding amongst the mod team to blackout but are asking their communities which are generally giving overwhelming support. Really helps legitimize the whole thing. Good on you, mods.
11
u/ooReiko :Ey::Ez::E1::E2:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ooReiko Jun 06 '23
I dont care but if you want to make a stand you should close the sub for good until they reverse their changes and if they dont reverse then that is end of r anime for good. if you just gonna wishwash for couple hours that literally has no impact on anything.
49
u/Bloodglas Jun 06 '23
I think blackout style "protests" are a joke. the point of a protest is to keep protesting until your demands are met or both sides can at least reach an agreement.
giving reddit a warning for when it will start and then reassuring them like "it'll only last 2 days and then all your users will come back and keep using your site like normal again" makes the whole thing seem like a pointless bluff.
14
u/junbi_ok Jun 06 '23
Make it happen. The longer, the better.
7
u/baboon_bassoon https://anilist.co/user/duffer Jun 06 '23
STRIKE
as every social media becomes more shit and unusable, I can only hope to show some form of defiance
19
u/Tehoncomingstorm97 https://anilist.co/user/tehoncomingstorm97 Jun 06 '23
Looking to the future, I know the mods are aware, but for general information changes to the API fees would strongly affect some high participation r/anime content, like seasonal episode scoring, "best boy/girl" contests or the annual awards - anything that uses an account verification. I dont participate much in the first two anymore, but despite the low participation relative to the sub's members, the awards season content always generates great discussion here - especially when compared to the other longform content presented on the sub.
For a team that already works as volunteers, having to rebase the backend will pile on significantly more strain if this makes the reddit API is no longer feasible to use. That likely has a strong correlation to cancelling awards, or a far diminished experience for all involved, from an event which has had industry professionals recognise, especially in recent years. I would really hate to see 6 years of continuous hard work from a strong and growing community quashed by reddit's greed.
13
u/susgnome https://anime-planet.com/users/RoyalRampage Jun 06 '23
2 Days
I'd prefer the indefinite blackout, as it really proves the point.
I won't be using their app if they kill Baconreader.
I wouldn't be surprised if RES/old.reddit are next, which will stop me completely.
18
u/_Ridley https://myanimelist.net/profile/_Ridley_ Jun 06 '23
I use new reddit like a total square and have no personal stake in this, but I love protests against tech executives' shitty ideas, so you have my support and encouragement to get involved in the blackout.
12
u/Raiking02 :Id::Ie::If:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NSKlang Jun 06 '23
I'd go along with it. I personally don't use 3rd Party Apps but I do understand why they're so useful to a lot of people so... yeah, I'm down with this.
6
u/TheReapingFields Jun 06 '23
Fight the power, seek to kill it when you do.
6
u/RGBdraw Jun 06 '23
I support
6
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Jun 06 '23
There are some subreddits that are planning to go dark until Reddit changes their stance, i find that to be way more effective and wouldn't mind seeing this here as well.
20
u/ElmekiaLance Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I think we should fully support the protest. It sounds like a big enough issue for it to be worth this sub participating. Those API changes seem as if they will affect a lot of people, and I'm especially unhappy to hear that it'll mean problems for visually-impaired users.
11
u/Dagonsnake https://anilist.co/user/Dagonsnake Jun 06 '23
Throwing in my support for the protest as well. RIF is a fantastic app and I use it all of the time when I don't have access to my PC; so I would personally hate to see the app killed off because of this change.
While yeah, it would suck a little bit not being able to read the seasonal threads when new episodes drop; I think the small sacrifice would be more than worth it.
10
u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
The one thing that I hope to find any kinds of mitigation would be the seasonal episode discussion threads - many people are not going to come back after 2 days unfortunately, either to upvote or discuss, and shows like Vinland Saga are going to be hit hard right at the climax. Is there any way to ONLY keep these posts open and accessible from direct links (posted to other social media etc.) while the sub-reddit main door is closed? Lots of forums elsewhere (in other languages) use this sub-reddit’s data to specifically track anime popularity in the West and the tracking are going to be completely screwed.
I also fear that we don’t get enough feedbacks just from a sticked thread alone - I think most visitors here will completely miss this notice, and I think the general opinion will be much less supportive of the blackout than what it seems here right now. The most serious effect would be mass exodus of casual members here.
Otherwise I don’t see much of a problem with this, although I doubt it will be of any effect alas - when was the last time we see a real social media that really listens to what users said after going big?
P.S. I never used any 3rd party apps for Reddit, which one is the best here?
10
u/ShadowWasTakensTaken https://anilist.co/user/hakuren Jun 06 '23
DO IT
Time to tally how many times I accidentally open CDF before I remember the sub is private.
17
u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
Do it. Protest like the Toei animators in 1961!
5
u/Bean888 Jun 06 '23
In a world without reddit, or /r/anime, where else would you all go?
A few years ago, I thought facebook groups was going to be short-lived, but I ended up joining some groups there. But outside of fb groups, and maybe something like the communities at my anime list, I really don't know what else is out there. Discords? I joined some discords a couple years back but I could never really get into the channels I joined, and those channels are also kind of dead right now. This is just some rambling about what happens next, it's weird for me to think about a reddit-less future.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I’m in full support of the protest r/anime involvement or not.
5
u/StormblessedFool Jun 06 '23
I support the blackout
5
u/Alukrad Jun 06 '23
I think we need to tell people to stop visiting reddit all together.
Strike reddit where it hurts.... Ad revenue.
If a huge crowd of people stop visiting this site for a few days, it'll show.
5
u/allanime01 Jun 06 '23
I support it. You're joining a good cause and I could use the excuse to like, actualy watch my "plan to watch" list. Probably. We will see lol.
13
u/UltimateKane99 Jun 06 '23
If you're going to do it, commit.
Lock it down until they change it.
9
u/laughing-fox13 https://myanimelist.net/profile/laughingfox13 Jun 06 '23
Apollo has been good for me the past few months so I hope something can come out of this
9
u/HobnobsTheRed Jun 06 '23
Completely behind the action, and would be fine with it for as long as it needed to continue.
9
u/BluePhantomHere Jun 06 '23
I wonder how this blackout will affect the activity of this sub afterward, it might take some time to recover
9
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jun 06 '23
I'm all for the blackout.
Pushshift and third party apps like RiF are terrible to lose, and I can only imagine what's next on the chopping block.
11
u/collapsedblock6 myanimelist.net/profile/collapsedblock Jun 06 '23
We give Reddit the finger and I get to not come here? This is a win-win.
But for real, fuck the official app. RiF lads rise up.
8
u/KingOfDiamonds069 Jun 06 '23
With absolute honestly I don't care as I don't use 3rd party apps.
But, I also say fk the corporate overlords and their greed. SO ofc r/anime should protest too. XD
8
u/locomofoo Jun 06 '23
It's great to see all my favourite subs deciding whether to get involved with the cause. I'll just lend my voice here to the yeses. I'm another third party app user and Reddit for me has always been viewed through that lens.
I never got behind any of the other huge site-wide 'movements' like this but this is something that I feel really affects a lot of different people. App devs are at the core of it all, but a lot of niche communities will also experience whiplash from the abrupt changes Reddit is making. The visually impaired, third party app users, mods using third party apps on mobile for moderating, etc.
8
u/DurdenVsDarkoVsDevon https://myanimelist.net/profile/U18810227 Jun 06 '23
You have my full support.
But also if you don't blackout, I understand. I don't expect the admins to meaningfully budge on this given a two day blackout. And I fear repercussion if subs extend it any further.
8
u/isthatsoudane https://myanimelist.net/profile/ojoulover Jun 06 '23
I hope the sub will take part in the blackout. I don't think it will do anything, but doesn't mean we shouldn't try
4
u/claraalberta Jun 06 '23
I don't personally use any Reddit APIs (that I know of, anyway), but the pricing is frankly ridiculous. I agree with this sub taking part in the blackout.
4
u/Twigling Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I support a 48 hour blackout but feel it should, if necessary, continue past that until Reddit fully relents. I look on the first 48 hours as a 'shot across the bows' just to get Reddit's attention, if that doesn't get them to back down then the next rounds fired aren't across the bows.
4
u/zadcap Jun 06 '23
While I have nothing against the blackout, I do have concernes about awareness of it. As it happens, I use the Reddit app on my phone for pretty much all of my browsing here, and the vast majority of that is coming straight to r/animen and immediately filtering by Episode or Rewatch, because these are honestly the only things I use Reddit for. If this didn't get a mention in one of those discussions, I wouldn't have known this was a thing at all, I rarely look at the pinned Daily Discussions. I would have been very surprised when I came to check the next discussion and couldn't get in here at all.
Reading through the comments here, it does look like it's almost all in favor of the blackout. But also look at the other numbers. As of writing this comment, there's about fourteen hundred karma on and a couple hundred posts on the topic, in a subreddit that boasts over seven million. I doubt all seven million are actually active members here, but that's still a 0.02% engagement rate.
15
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jun 06 '23
as i said in CDF, i definitely dont mind and support this: RIF is honestly a big part of why i've been so active there with its ability to kinda see commentfaces even when im on my phone. I paid for it a while back, and honestly have more than had my money's worth.
I hope to suggest that there be some sort of mitigation around the scheduled discussion threads (both rewatches and seasonal posts) though, either through the creation of a discord channel group for people who want to discuss them with the community here, or something similar. Though i realize that only a week is not a lot of time for a plan to formulate there.
7
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 06 '23
I have no reason to object and plenty of reasons to support such a measure. If the community and mods want to do it, I'm all for it!
6
u/cherstal Jun 06 '23
Do it, and for however long it takes Reddit to feel it.
6
u/xtsim https://myanimelist.net/profile/xtsim Jun 06 '23
I use and paid for Relay on my android devices when I am commenting on rewatches due to it's superior text editor and comment preview. So Relay has been an important app for me to participate in rewatch discussions on the go. Not to mention, the official Reddit app does not have a dedicated landscape mode for tablets, which means third party is the only choice.
Hope I could keep using Relay since it has been my favorite reddit app since I have switched from an iPhone to an android phone 8 years ago. I would be less inclined to participate in upcoming rewatches if I cannot use Relay.
I want to throw my support for r/Relay!
6
u/steven4869 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maskirade Jun 06 '23
I don't care much about it as I have been using their mobile app ever since I created an account here, though the app ain't that good but it gets the work done. But I support the protest :)
6
u/danmarce :ADB:https://anidb.net/user/107202 Jun 06 '23
Do it.
If reddit does this, it will not be far in the future when it dies (like many other sites before it) and there will be no r/anime anyway.
WE have to remember, Reddit is made BY THE USERS, the company provides the platform. But the content, the moderation, all is given by the users.
6
u/Praise_the_Tsun https://anilist.co/user/PraisetheTsun Jun 06 '23
I support the blackout, indefinitely until acceptable change is put forward.
6
u/NekoCatSidhe Jun 06 '23 edited Jun 06 '23
I get why it is a shitty thing for Reddit to do, and I sympathise with visually impaired people who have no choice but to use those apps, but I personally don’t use third party apps and I am fine with the official Reddit app, so I won’t be affected by those changes as far as I know.
I am also not sure if the subreddit blackout will really help, although I appreciate that the mods of r/anime decided to ask the users about it before making a decision. So I am quite neutral on the issue. In the end it won’t disturb the site much, but if that can make Reddit rethinks those changes, then maybe it is worth a try. But doing it for more than 48 hours would just end up penalising the users who don’t use those third party apps and are not involved in that conflict, in my opinion.
6
u/Venom1462 :IJ::IK::IL: Jun 06 '23
I honestly think a 2 day blackout isn't enough, we need to stop using reddit until they actually listen. I wouldn't use reddit on my mobile if not for boost, rif and other apps like there
8
u/ChonkyOdango myanimelist.net/profile/chonkyodango Jun 06 '23
I’m 100% in support of this. While I don’t use third-party apps myself, the reddit app is appalling and I do know that a large number of CDFers that use third-party app. I can’t say for sure how many of the active members here do so, I’m guessing a decent number since we have commentfaces and the reddit app doesn’t allow us to see it.
Whether this will have any impact on the final decision is questionable but I believe it’s a issue worth raising awareness about and fighting for. Especially with how Reddit has been trending towards maximising profits
19
u/kimdogra Jun 06 '23
Anyone who thinks this blackout will do anything is delusional.
3
u/lenor8 Jun 06 '23
On another sub, a discussíon on the Capitoline Wolf was autotagged NSFW. Reddit censorship policies are just plain ridiculous.
Next, they'll kill old.reddit so it will became unreadable even on pc. It's a horrible future from both mods and users point of view.
I'd love if there was a community like this on Lemmy, the site seems like the old reddit but the power of this site is the user base, and it still feels pretty empty down there. Unfortunately, there are no real alternatives at the moment.
Please, support the protest. Ganbatte kudasai.
3
u/sfisher923 https://myanimelist.net/profile/sfisher923 Jun 06 '23
Do it but I have one small question
How would this affect the Horimiya Rewatch on the 17th if this lasts more then 2 days
3
u/atocci :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/atocci Jun 06 '23
100% support this as a third-party app user.
3
u/blixt141 Jun 06 '23
You should participate. If a majority of the large subreddits participate, Reddit will be more likely to negotiate. If not everyone will lose including Reddit. Mobile use will plummet.
3
u/DidacticDalek https://myanimelist.net/profile/DidacticDalek Jun 07 '23
SOLIDARITY COMRADES!
12
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Don't care, honestly
7
u/liggieep :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/liggieep Jun 06 '23
the sub should absolutely go black, indefinitely with the other subs that are going out indefinitely, until this is resolved.
5
u/allthecolorssa Jun 06 '23
Apollo has always been easy to use for me so I hope it goes well
5
u/actuallyrndthoughts :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NaNiNuNeNo Jun 06 '23
I personally hope that the yearly dose of reddit activism leaves this sub out, but i either way i don't care. The quicker reddit gets replaced with something more grassroots, the better.
5
u/MadMike91X Jun 06 '23
You have my support to blackout for as long as necessary.
5
u/AsterJ https://myanimelist.net/profile/asteron Jun 06 '23
What's the point of announcing an end to the blackout before you even start? Have you ever heard of a strike where they announce when the strike will end before getting what they want?
If you're going to do it the sub needs to be shut down indefinitely until Reddit reverses course. Otherwise it's stupid since Reddit would know they can just wait and not change anything
5
u/amyanimalover https://anilist.co/user/Amy Jun 06 '23
Full support of you guys doing this and even extending indefinitely. I'm glad you guys are joining the blackout. Rif is my main way to consume. Guess I'll just hit up your discord if I'm curious enough for the episode discussions.
5
u/drostan https://anilist.co/user/Drostan Jun 06 '23
I support the blackout absolutely
bacon reader and RES user, I despise reddit as reddit does it the app is hideous and riddled with bad advertising, the site is impractical and ugly
they have people making their website better and more accessible, they should pay them not highway rob them
5
u/thisisfakediy https://anilist.co/user/thisisfakediy Jun 06 '23
I'm all for r/anime joining the protest. I can do without episode discussions for a few days if it helps to send a message to the corporate overlords that we peons are unhappy.
It was bad enough when the new Reddit mobile site started nagging to use the app constantly, and removed the ability to turn off the nag. But to screw over superior third party apps with insane API pricing is a bridge too far. And I don't even use those apps!
5
u/PsychedelicHaru https://myanimelist.net/profile/Harutai Jun 06 '23
Well, as long as it ends before the new oshi no ko episode...though, I feel like a poll would be a better way to gauge interest, because most people who are against it probably won't comment.
5
u/No_Rex :Bv:Bw:Bx:By:x2 Jun 06 '23
In support. Regardless of whether it works or not, we have to try to stave off reddits endless march towards worse user experience in the name of profit.
5
u/Razorhead https://myanimelist.net/profile/Razorhat Jun 06 '23
Fully in favour of /r/anime joining the blackout. As someone visiting the site frequently on mobile the official app and mobile website are atrocious, and I've been using a third-party app for years.
The fact that it ostracises people with disabilities is even worse, and I am totally behind a shutdown of the sub to raise awareness for these issues.
8
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Jun 06 '23
I am in favor of r/anime joining the blackout.
6
u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jun 06 '23
Blackout for more than 48 hours.
6
u/Final-Ad-6694 Jun 06 '23
Nope don’t do anything
8
u/ergzay Jun 06 '23
I say don't participate in the blackout. There's little chance of it doing anything and it doesn't affect me anyway as I've never used reddit from a cell phone. The cell phone user experience is always worse than the desktop experience, which isn't affected.
9
u/entelechtual Jun 06 '23
Yeah I support it. I’ve used Reddit so much more since downloading Apollo and it’s annoying to see history repeat itself after (when did digg die?)
4
u/Kakito104 Jun 06 '23
I support it
4
u/Batgod629 Jun 06 '23
I would not mind either way but I think it would be nice sign of solidarity of r/anime did join in. Though I personally won't be affected once the changes take place
4
u/King_Reddit_Banana Jun 06 '23
Go for it. I've been at least sporadically checked-in here for at least 2 years (I'm no "community voice") but I would say that this would be something I'd be behind. Reddit's highest-ups routinely do showy and horrible things for horrible reasons, I don't think there'd be a relevant taboo factor on this blackout and in reading this and some of the other info this sounds like a good cause (that could maybe keep things from going further south). Best of luck to you decision-makers out there though.
4
u/InternalShadow Jun 06 '23
I’ve been on here a few years and didn’t know there were alternatives to the regular app, so this has almost no effect on me. However, i think it’s important to take a stand now against all these over-monetization attempts or they’ll ruin the app (faster than I’m comfortable with). Im in. Shut it down. I hope all the top subs shut it down until they acknowledge their greed/stupidity. This platform is not like the platforms that are already public
4
u/Competitive_Law_1293 Jun 06 '23
It's important to do what we can against ridiculous policies like this. I fully support the blackout, and hope it continues for more than just a day
4
u/GrimMind Jun 06 '23
I support it completely. After the API changes I'm only going to browse this sub.
They turned the best website on the internet into 9gag and now they're doing this?
The more subs people cannot access the better. I don't care if we just mildly annoy them, anything other than taking it lying down.
4
u/Ripard_A Jun 06 '23
I'd say I'm for this.
I use the official app personally, but a big fan of options, ESPECIALLY for those who rely on features (not on the official app) that help them with their impairments.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
i think we should support it. deep down i feel this protest won't change anything, but no harm in trying, right?
4
u/Pers0n_Of_Reddit https://myanimelist.net/profile/grimsworth Jun 06 '23
Anything for my precious Rif
4
u/EmmyWeeeb Jun 06 '23
Honestly the only reason I slightly care about it is because of it effecting the visually impaired and probably other disabilities.
4
u/MardiJuice Jun 06 '23
Blackout until they revert the changes 2 days aint gonna change shit
4
u/Redo-Master Jun 06 '23
Yes please
4
u/atropicalpenguin https://myanimelist.net/profile/atropicalpenguin Jun 06 '23
I support the blackout.
4
u/wzm115 Jun 06 '23
Reddit will control ads, will likely not curate comments as well as mods do. Mods use third party apps to make a difficult task easier. Reddit will charge for third party apps. During subreddit blackout, do not use the official app, do not gild. Reddit doesn't need to make more money. Reddit is making money already.
4
u/IWasEatingThoseBeans Jun 06 '23
This sub should absolutely join in the blackout.
4
u/PiotrekDG Jun 06 '23
Full support for blackout. Not for two days. For as long as they don't back out of their changes.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I support a lock down
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Let me amend my vote. I am in favor of a permanent blackout until Reddit folds. Screw 2 days.
6
u/Impossible_Map_4895 https://anilist.co/user/Sweetsami Jun 06 '23
I support r/anime joining the blackout
5
u/cppn02 Jun 06 '23
I 100% support r/anime joining the blackout.
2
u/SilkyMilkySmo Jun 06 '23
Best way to get me off Reddit
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I don't get it how does this affect normal reddit users and communities i never used a 3rd party app for reddit
2
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
It will not change anything but who knows… Twitter dropped third-party clients and nobody gives a shit now.
2
u/vericlas :KN::KO: Jun 06 '23
As others have said it should be till Reddit doesn't do this change. But I still support the black out. As someone who browses 95% on a third party app this change already effectively kills reddit for me.
2
u/rockredfrd Jun 06 '23
I say go for it. The more people who get involved in this, the higher chance we have at actually making a difference. All or nothing!
2
u/Shanibestwaifu Jun 06 '23
I can support this cause even as a plain desktop old reddit user, by even not going to this site as a whole on those two days, even if the certain sub did not participate. Hopefully this will show the mistake of the higherups and their wrong policy. A participation of a 7M+ sub like this should have an impact.
I have a small concern regarding the episode discussion threads, which is handled by a bot. I thinking about these two days, but what if the blackout happens much longer? As for example Vinland Saga will be hit so much, even their sub is also joining too. Rewaches are also a good question too, and I'm also affected by it, as I showed my interest to participate in two of them (Horimiya and Spice and Wolf).
If they ever kill old reddit, then this will by my final and permanent farewell to this platform as a whole, mark my words.
2
u/MysteryNeighbor Jun 07 '23
I fully support a blackout and even suggest going beyond the 2 days.
Reducing traffic to the site is the only leverage subs have against the admins and should be used for as long as possible
2
u/Eotremen Jun 07 '23
Do it
2
u/jardex22 Jun 07 '23
There are subs out there that use NSFW for other things. I know a few sale subreddits that use it to mark when a deal has expired. I believe some others use it to cover spoilers as well.
I know Reddit taking some responsibility for content posted sounds good on paper, but it won't work in this fashion.
I'll say go ahead with the blackout. Take as long as you need, and we can discuss shows elsewhere during that time.
2
u/Random_J08 Jun 07 '23
I truly support the protest. If the subreddit needs to blacked out, then go for it
2
u/Nvaaaa Jun 07 '23
go for it, i wouldn't even mind if it's longer than 2 days to make a point
2
u/n0ticeme_senpai :LJ::LK: Jun 07 '23
As I use 3rd party app myself, I am in full support of the protest. I am personally willing to see it last even a month if 48 hours isn't enough to get the message across.
Ngl though to have all NSFW blocked on mobile app, it didn't affect me much since I am usually looking at NSFW content through a laptop at home anyway
2
u/Progenitor Jun 07 '23
I feel to support we should shut down /r/anime until admin backtracks like /r/movies. If this change is done, it would kill reddit for a lot of people!
2
u/heimdal77 Jun 07 '23
48 hours is far to short. That is basically just a long maintenance and won't even affect the whole site. It really won't matter to the admins. If really want to make a statement then should go dark for a week.
2
u/nitrohigito Jun 07 '23
I'm in support of it as long as Oshi no Ko's episode discussion post is not affected.
2
u/hintofinsanity Jun 08 '23
Thank you for joining the protest. We should definitely stay dark until Reddit drops their plans for the api changes.
2
u/Funlife2003 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/andril Jun 09 '23
I'm not personally affected by the changes, but I do think what Reddit is doing here is stupid, and I sympathize with everyone who is affected. I definitely support the blackout.
2
u/Thick_and_4orty Jun 10 '23
I support/r/anime joining the black out and also extending it if neccessary. I peruse this sub a bit but i hadnt subscribed till just now. thank you for considering it and i hope you join.
5
u/YeetTheRich13 Jun 06 '23
Gonna fuck up some karma rankings and episode threads, but I don't see why not. Reddit's making a scummy decision, although I don't use 3Papps, I can see why people do. Gotta let em know we're dissatisfied.
4
u/djthomp https://anilist.co/user/djthomp Jun 06 '23
I am in favor of the sub participating. I've been a RIF user for a very long time (far longer than my activity here) and am pretty unhappy about it potentially going away.
4
u/V8_Only Jun 06 '23
If it upsets mods and redditors, I’m general for it not against it
4
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I don't own a mobile phone so the Reddit thing doesn't affect me at all while the blackout would slightly inconvenience me to an incredibly mild degree. So naturally I vote "no" on my support for this one.
3
u/vermilion-secrets Jun 06 '23
Another vote here for supporting the black out
I think the blackout start and end time should be announced so people won't get confused with timezones and all though
3
u/HemanthK1 Jun 06 '23
Yes please do. I can't go on reddit without Relay
3
u/Lyngoop79 Jun 06 '23
what the dick?!? on my birthday as well?? thats it reddit upper admins are being cringe
3
u/ultrahkr Jun 06 '23
I fully support the blackout
3
u/iAmGats Jun 06 '23
Please do.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
I'd like the black out to be indefinite. There's no point in doing it for only 2 days; it won't change anything.
3
u/Moose-Live Jun 06 '23
I support it the blackout - for all the reasons stated but primarily this one.
3
u/Syokhan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Syokhan Jun 06 '23
I say go for it.
Personally I don't browse reddit on my phone and I use RES/oldreddit on desktop so I probably won't be affected by the changes, but I wholeheartedly support everyone who will.
So hopefully these protests will have some kind of effect.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23
Do a permanent one. 2 day protest is just a slap on the wrist at best.
3
u/sparknife Jun 06 '23
Fully support the participation!
3
u/RulerKun_FGO Jun 06 '23
hopefully r/anime will join
3
u/nurrishment https://myanimelist.net/profile/nurrishment Jun 06 '23
We should join the blackout
3
u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Jun 06 '23
I’m not really in the weeds of this site enough to really understand what’s going on, but I wont complain if I have an excuse to not be on Reddit for a spell
3
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '23 edited Oct 01 '24
soft quickest workable wakeful noxious one bright drunk humor pet
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/Rustic_Professional Jun 06 '23
Support the blackout.
3
u/Celcius_87 Jun 06 '23
Yea but it needs to be for at least a week
3
u/Akuuntus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zanador Jun 06 '23
I support blacking out the sub, but if you're going to do it, do it indefinitely until Reddit capitulates. 2 days with warning ahead of time is not a protest, it's a mild inconvenience.
3
u/biochrono79 Jun 06 '23
I would support this. I can’t imagine using Reddit without Apollo, and trying to price them out instead of actually making a better product is a scumbag move. As other commenters have said, maybe consider a longer blackout, as that would draw more attention.
3
u/LiminyWrenn Jun 06 '23
Yes. Please participate in the blackout.
3
u/Appleman5000 Jun 06 '23
Shut it down. Shut it all down. We need to show them we wont put up with their garbage.