r/HFY • u/world-shaker • Aug 02 '23
Meta YSK People are stealing your writing submissions and posting them to TikTok
If you're not currently in the loop, people are reposting your work to TikTok (often without credit).
It’s a very annoying trend where people steal stories from Reddit, have an AI read them, and play it over a video of someone playing Minecraft that they stole from YouTube. Here’s an example on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZT8Ld7BLQ/
Here’s a full on TikTok channel with over 165k followers, lapping up Creativity Program money with your stolen content: https://www.tiktok.com/@wisdom_therapy (Reddit Bros Sci-Fi)
They break stories into multiple videos so people can’t watch the whole thing. This keeps people coming back to their account, and maximizes their payouts from the Creativity Program.
If you find a video that’s used your work without your consent you can report it here: https://www.tiktok.com/legal/report/Copyright
EDIT: Line breaks were broken.
•
u/sswanlake The Librarian Aug 02 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
To the authors, please check to see if your content has been infringed upon — if it has, please use TikTok's built-in reporting services to request that the video be taken down
The mods here at Reddit have no legal methods to do so on your behalf on a different platform, you must do this yourself via the official channels provided by TikTok.
You as the author, regardless of what platform you post you story on, always own the copyright. If someone is doing something with it in its entirety without your permission, you have the right to take whatever measures you see fit to have it removed from the platform. Especially if they intend to profit off of said content. Especially if no credit is given to the original author, then it is plagiarism in addition to IP theft. And not defending your copyright makes it harder for you to defend it in the future, which is why so many big companies take an all or nothing approach to enforcement.
To all the users who found their way here to r/hfy thanks to TikTok videos like the ones mentioned above
Hello and welcome! I'm glad that you managed to find us! That does not change the fact that what these TikTok'ers are doing is legally and morally in the wrong.
Edit: Not all narrations are bad, the proper way to go about narrating someone else's stories is to ask their permission, provide any and all attributions the author requests (original story link, Patreon link, etc), and preferably to state in your narration that you are doing so with permission, so that everyone is aware. Any narrations that are posted to r/hfy, for example, are required to state in their post body that they've gotten permission from the original author, or else they will be suspected of being plagiarism and be removed. Additionally, unless the author has specifically signed a copyright license over to you, they still hold the rights to the content, and therefore are free to request that you remove your narration at any time—while circumstances that would require requesting a narration with permission be taken down are rare, they do still exist.
A Public Service Announcement and FAQ for the uninformed:
The fact that it is posted in a public place does not mean that the author has relinquished their rights to the content. Unless they have explicitly stated otherwise, they reserve ALL rights to their content by default, other than those they have (non-exclusively) licensed to Reddit. This means that you are free to read their content here, link to it, but you can not take it and do something with it, any more than you could (legally) do with a blockbuster Disney movie or a professionally published paperback.
This is doubly wrong. In the first place, there are many authors in this community who make money on their writing here, so someone infringing on their copyright is a threat to their income. I'm personally aware of several that don't just do this as a side-hustle, but they stake their entire livelihood on it: it is their full-time job. In their case, it could literally be a threat to their life.
Secondly and perhaps more importantly, even if the author wasn't making money from their writing and never did, it doesn't matter. Their writing is their writing, belonging to them, and unless they explicitly grant permission to someone to reproduce it elsewhere (which, FYI, is a right that most authors here would be happy to grant if asked), nobody has the right to reproduce that work. Both as a matter of copyright law, and as a matter of ethics--they worked hard on that, and they ought to be able to control when and where their work is used if they choose to enforce their rights.
Most of these narration channels are simply taking the text as-is and reading it verbatim. There's not a mote of transformative work involved, nothing new is added to the underlying ideas of the story. In a fanfiction, the writer is at least putting a new spin on existing characters or settings--though even in that case, copyright law is still not squarely in their favor.
Public Domain is a very specific legal status which does not apply to nearly any of the stories on this sub. A work only enters the public domain when the copyright expires (thanks to The Mouse, for newly published work this is effectively never), or when the author explicitly and intentionally severs their rights to the IP and releases the work into the public domain. A work isn't "public domain" just because someone put it out for public viewing.
One of our community members wrote up a great explanation about this here that is better than what I'd come up with on my own, so I'll allow him to explain it. To summarize, for those who don't click through: no, it's not fair use. Copyright fully applies here.
If a person does not enforce their rights when they find out that their copyright has been infringed, it can undermine their legal standing to challenge infrigement later on, should they come across a new infringement they want to prosecute, or even just change their mind about the original perpetrator for whatever reason. With that in mind, it is simply prudent, good sense to clearly enforce their copyright as soon as they can. If an author doesn't mind other people taking their work and doing whatever they want with it, then they should state that, and publish it under a license such as Creative Commons (like SCP does) or MIT (like much open-source software does).
Special thanks to u/Glitchkey, and u/AiSagOrSol3-43912 for their informative comments on this post and elsewhere; several of the answers I provided in this comment were strongly inspired by them.
6
u/Mu0nNeutrino Aug 02 '23 edited Aug 02 '23
So how would one figure out if someone's posted your stuff there? Would you need to have a tiktok account? Cause I really don't want anything related to that place on my phone/computer. >.>
It's not like I've written much, but the idea still bugs me.
3
u/world-shaker Aug 03 '23
Here’s another account that’s posting five stories a day and selling HFY merch: https://www.tiktok.com/@authenticreddit
148
u/MasterCrab Aug 02 '23
I always knew that freebooting was a problem for video creators but it never occured to me that written stories would be experiencing the same issue.
108
u/hixchem Human Aug 02 '23
I've found half a dozen of my more-upvoted posts scattered across the internet. In fact, only one YouTuber, u/AgroSquerril has ever asked for permission to use my work (Shout out to their YouTube channel)
It's made me not want to post anything anymore, because it'll just get stolen and monetized for someone else's gain.
23
u/hdufort Aug 02 '23
I've had narrators politely asking me if they can read some of my stories on YouTube (hello AgroSquerril!) and only once, someone narrated one of my stories without asking and without properly naming me (I lodged a complaint).
Now it hasn't occurred to me that there might be people doing this shit in tiktok. I don't have the application. I don't want the application. I'm not sure how I can look up videos that might have used my titles / stories.
Thanks for posting this, I'll try to figure what I should do.
12
u/cryptoengineer Android Aug 02 '23
Same happens on Youtube.
11
u/PrimateOfGod Aug 02 '23
This should be bookmarked at the top of the sub
19
u/MuchoRed Human Aug 02 '23
Here's an example: https://www.tiktok.com/@authenticreddit
6
u/LordCoale Aug 03 '23
I had confronted Wisdom Therapy about him stealing my story. But I let it slide. After reading this, I decided that I needed to file the copyright complaint. Everyone whose stories were hijacked should do so, too.
5
u/lucianspy Aug 02 '23
Referring to the first bullet in the pinned comment, how does this work if someone were to just crtl P the reddit page the story is on and keep those in a folder for offline reading? I thought in order for it to be infrigment an attempt to monetize, distribute, or pass off as your own would need to be made?
I have been getting into rebinding damaged books with nice leather hardcovers and have been thinking a leather-bound "Best of r/HFY" compilation would look really cool.
Since I have seen professional YouTubers re-cover books, i assumed as they are not attempting to distribute or pass off the content (only the cover) as their own work, and credit the OG author on the new cover, it was fine. I can't imagine they reached out and received a response from the original authors.
8
u/humanity_999 Human Aug 02 '23
Well that is unfortunate. Now I have to check Tik-Tok just to make sure the few things I've posted are not there.
There is a reason I despise Tik-Tok.
6
u/murderouskitteh Aug 02 '23
Tiktok was a terrible mistake.
3
u/-parkthecar- Aug 03 '23
Problem is, these tiktok accounts are so easy to make and get running I don’t see how we can stay ahead. They have to put in minimal effort to start a new account and start doing this all over again. I don’t know what the solution is
5
u/icallshogun Android Aug 02 '23
Damn it, they finally figured out how to make me get a TikTok account.
2
u/singedmaximus Aug 03 '23
I joined/discovered this sub through tt, I’m sorry this keeps happening, and I’m sorry you guys aren’t properly credited for your work :/
2
u/viper9172 Aug 03 '23
I get around this issue by not writing anything that people want to read! But seriously, it’s lame that it’s being done at all.
2
u/Slight_Ad3348 Aug 03 '23
Those tiktok accounts are the only reason I found this sub and read the stories here. Have had a few friends tell me the same when I’ve sent them various vids.
2
u/The_Mad_Crafter AI Aug 03 '23
As an author on this sub, I've always been happy to give permission for creators on YT to do narrations of my work when they reach out and ask for permission, however, if I ever find one of my stories with being used without my explicit consent I will absolutely file Copyright claims against the channel.
AgroSquirrel, NetNarrator, Aimee's Literary Empire and Hooded Mystic have all been outstanding at reaching out to request permission and are examples of what the Narrator Community should be like, not these trawling AI voice bots just stealing our work.
2
u/SciFiStories1977 Oct 10 '23
I'm a new HFY story writing and I have my own channel on YT and TT as well. I only post my own content. I came across this post and did a quick check of just one of my stories. I found 3 TT account using it! I've raised a copyright infringement request so I'll see how that goes. Checking a few other stories, it looks like the same few accounts doing it (+ some smaller ones).
https://www.tiktok.com/@authenticreddit
https://www.tiktok.com/@redditscifistoryguy
https://www.tiktok.com/@writingprompts.bros
https://www.tiktok.com/@hfy_reddit_stories
Netnarrator u/Spartawolf has always asked and I've always been happy to give consent. Some of the view numbers would definitely earn them some bucks!
People just need to ask me... it's not too difficult.
I'll let you know how it goes
6
u/slightlyassholic Human Aug 02 '23
Happened to me, but I was quite pleased it did. Allow me to explain.
Someone was scraping r/WritingPrompts and grabbed the initial arc of The Great Erectus and Faun. They then used a crappy sped up robo-voice and text copy of the story alongside a gaming clip over multiple videos.
Someone noticed and informed me about it.
At first I was annoyed and was looking into the takedown procedures and then I noticed the view counts and enthusiastic "more!" echoing through the comments including someone wishing that someone made a book about it.
One video had over 150k views!!!
I stopped being mad.
I spammed the comments identifying myself as the real author and cheerfully expressing my happiness that they liked my work. I then added links to both it and and Tales From the Terran Republic on each and every comment. I worked over the last video hard. I mean there is no way someone who followed the entire story being absolutely butchered by the worst robo voice ever would miss the fact that there was indeed more and where to get it.
My readership enjoyed quite the nice spike as a result. I mean, I added quite a few readers.
Personally, I wish my work got ripped off more often instead of less (as long as I find out, of course.)
Any TikTok raiders out there, feel free to use my shit. If you could be so kind as to provide credits and links that would be awesome. If not, don't worry. I'll find out and do it for you.
2
u/Ethereal_Stars_7 Aug 02 '23
This came up last year too I think and yeah its apparently pretty rampant.
Also there are crooks selling stories of others on like Amazon and probably other platforms.
1
u/Spectre322 Aug 02 '23
I definitely think content shouldn't be used this way without permission. However, I will say that the only reason I am only aware of this sub because my friend listens to a lot of these stories on tiktok and so I am thankful, really glad to be here.
1
u/Valianttheywere Nov 30 '23
I put what I do in public domain. So I dont care.
1
u/WonderFiz81 Human Aug 03 '23
I’m fine with it as long as they give proper credit. I’ve had numerous people reach out to me asking if they can post my stories on other platforms, and I enjoy it when people do this as I get to see even more people enjoy my stories, plus I like hearing different people narrate my stories in their own way. However, I do draw the line at videos like this where they just use text to speech and put in little to no effort. I wouldn’t be bothered by it except for the fact that accounts like the one in the link are reposting my content not intending to spread the story but to make money from creator fund.
-9
u/MewSilence Human Aug 02 '23 edited Aug 03 '23
You should actually send a ticket to Reddit to file a copyright claim because they aren't stealing OUR writing - they're stealing Reddit's writing (as well); Ever since the new TOS, everything posted on Reddit automatically
makes them the only rightful ownergives them the license of the text.Nobody cares about some Noname users, but TikTok might check if it's from Reddit itself.
Since they changed the Terms of Service, they might as well put their weight behind those issues. Or so I believe. ;)
EDIT: thought it was exclusive, but overall that doesn't change much in this context.
-15
u/SketchAndEtch Human Aug 02 '23
That's hardly news now is it? People have been reposting reddit works in various forms on various platforms for years now. Seems like just another case of that.
-8
u/Tlamatini21 Aug 02 '23
Fostering a Thriving Community: An Apology and a Vision
Dear Reddit Writers,
I hope this message finds you in good spirits. I would like to extend my sincerest apologies for not addressing an important issue sooner—a matter that impacts our community's integrity and vitality. I deeply regret any disappointment that may have arisen due to the mishandling of credit and originality in our shared creative space.
Over time, I have become increasingly aware of instances where content has been used without proper acknowledgment, a practice that runs counter to the principles that drive the success of our community. It's a disheartening issue that deserves immediate attention and resolution.
Allow me to introduce myself and the role I play in this community. While I am not a fellow writer like you, I am one of the individuals responsible for creating videos from the content shared here. I recognize the responsibility that comes with this role, particularly when it comes to ensuring that every piece of content is treated with the respect it deserves.
My aim in creating these videos has always been to provide exposure and recognition to the talented writers among us, shining a light on their work and inviting others to appreciate their craft. The importance of proper credit and recognition cannot be overstated. Each of your creations contributes to the vibrancy and depth of our community, and it is my utmost goal to ensure that this contribution is acknowledged appropriately. I understand the importance of giving credit where it's due, and I am committed to rectifying any shortcomings that may have occurred in the past.
In light of this, I would like to share my vision for the future—a future where our community thrives, where every writer's voice is heard, and where each of us benefits from our collective creativity, work, and effort. Moving forward, I am committed to rectifying this issue and fostering stronger relationships within our community. My aspiration is to create an environment where every writer's contribution is valued, celebrated, and properly credited. I believe that together, we can nurture a space where each individual benefits from their creative endeavors.
In pursuit of this vision, I am taking steps to monetize my videos with the goal of creating a digital repository that not only showcases your stories but also ensures that they are rightfully attributed. To ensure that this initiative aligns with your preferences and needs, I am open to discussing various methods of support—whether it's through Venmo, CashApp, Cups of coffee or other means that resonate with you.
I want to emphasize that my primary goal is to build a community where creativity thrives, originality is cherished, and all members reap the rewards of their hard work. I understand the importance of credit and compensation, and I am dedicated to rectifying the missteps of the past while working together to shape a brighter future for us all. I have in the short history of my Tik Tok channel have credited and even tagged the author if I had identified them.
I welcome your thoughts, insights, and suggestions on how we can collaboratively move forward. It's my hope that through open dialogue and collective effort, we can restore trust and create an environment where credit is always given where credit is due.
Thank you for your understanding and patience. I am eager to learn from you, collaborate with you, and contribute to the flourishing community we all cherish.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment