r/ProjectRunway • u/makeitworkoryouout • Jan 04 '13
All Stars Season 2 Episode 10 discussion
Discussion thread for Project Runway All Stars S02E10 "All Stars and Stripes"
Image album: http://imgur.com/a/dbzaJ
5
Upvotes
11
u/makeitworkoryouout Jan 04 '13
How many times did Carolyn remind us that there is always a winner and someone sent home? I should have picked up on the foreshadowing more but was too distracted by the fact that Joshua's outfit was stronger than AR's and Emilio's. That was my fear all week: "What if Joshua knocks it out of the park this week and gets through to the finale despite what I consider to be a far weaker overall portfolio than the other three?" Then that scenario started to form right in front of my eyes. Should have been obvious to me that they were all going to make it but I was too incensed at Joshua winning this week. I fell right into the producer's trap!
8
u/makeitworkoryouout Jan 04 '13
At least there wasn't the pretense of a button bag this week and they just pre-assigned the client to the designer.
Uli This was tops in my book. Yeah, I know, she did monochrome again. This doesn't actually doesn't bother me as much as when other designers (was it Mila?) can't do anything any other than black. Uli adds in enough texture to her dresses that her portfolio doesn't seem as one note as other designers. I didn't find the trim that bad either but I can see it being left off as well.
Emilio I'm surprised that the fit was so poor. I'm guessing that was a time constraint issue because he's clearly good enough to do better than that. I didn't notice the issue with the fabric from the video but it's probably more visible in person. I don't care for the upper back treatment. I would have preferred something like a "V" back to the bulky bra back that he went with. It doesn't look elegant, sexy, or fun. Even tapering the angle or width would have been better than what looks like a purely structural element.
Anthony Ryan I was totally on board with his fabric selection. Then the draping happened and I was less interested. When he added the belt it was time to abandon ship. The look overall did not compliment the client and acted more like a sheet covering her than anything. That dress doesn't look like it would be flattering even on the regular models.
Joshua First and foremost I'm glad that the client was as happy with it as she was. That counts for a lot. However, I didn't really strike me as event appropriate. I guess I always assume more formal for a military ball and for that I would expect something at least knee length. I would have loved to see either an angle cut or left leg slit to feature her prosthetic. I think that would have been fantastic. As it was, the length, trim, the sheer fabric, and cut of the skirt all made the dress lean too junior for my taste. I'm happy that the client is thrilled with it but I have too many issues with this to have put it as the winner.
13
u/evergleam498 Those pants flood my basement! Jan 04 '13
As much as I wanted Josh to get sent home, the dress (skirt+top?) he made was actually really pretty.
I really liked the beading embellishment Uli put on her dress. I'm glad she finally got a challenge where she could make her flowy, fun-print, Uli-dresses like she made on her original season.
I didn't like Anthony Ryan's or Emilio's dresses. I'm glad they didn't send anyone home. I couldn't decide whose dress I liked worse.
9
u/MistressMary Jan 04 '13
Have they given them more than "the rest of the day" for any challenge so far? Especially for this challenge - another day would have drastically improved all of the outfits. Drives me crazy they have less than 12 hours to make something stunning that fits perfectly.
7
u/everythingisopposite Chiffony Jan 04 '13
Anthony Ryan's dress was extremely unflattering to say the least. Josh's dress deserved a win, especially the doggie outfit. Loved Uli's dress as well though I don't know why they were harping on the embellishment.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '13
Anthony Ryan's dress was basically a gray gradient sack of potatoes.
7
u/fragilehearted Jan 04 '13 edited Jan 04 '13
Ditto to pretty much everything evergleam said. Just have one thing to add - I did like Uli's print but still kind of wished she'd found a print with some color.
Oh yeah, did anyone who thought AR might get sent home think it was interesting that he did poorly in his original season in a similar challenge / way? For those who don't remember, it was another challenge with non-models in which he tried too hard to please the client, rather than gently pushing them towards something more fashion-forward.
Edit: AND Josh also won the same challenge! Really crazy. He can edit if a client wants him to, but he doesn't always edit for himself, apparently!
4
u/KillKillJill Jan 05 '13
I feel like Emilio's dress was so off the mark. It didn't fit well, nor did it strike me as something someone would normally wear to a Vegas bachelorette party. It looked more like a day-to-night dress. Blazer and flats for day, lose the blazer add heels and jewelry for night.
1
u/milleribsen Jan 04 '13
If Josh's outfit walked into a formal event it would be lambasted.