r/HFY • u/SciFiStories1977 • Oct 12 '23
Meta TikTok accounts taking HFY stories and making $$ - How do you feel about that?
[removed] — view removed post
225
Upvotes
r/HFY • u/SciFiStories1977 • Oct 12 '23
[removed] — view removed post
46
u/r3d1tAsh1t Oct 12 '23
Just write something bad about china in your story or hide other things that are banned in china in there and watch them burn their account down.
31
u/Lord_of_Thus Oct 12 '23
Depends, if they ask and link back it's all right, otherwise I'd look into TikToks copyright system. If you can afford it lawyer up and sue those fuckers
9
u/JadeTatsu Human Oct 12 '23
This seems very much like taking a fanfic from one site and posting it on another either for cash or just the recognition.
If they have asked permission then you said okay but I really doubt that people will ask permission and tell you how much money they could stand to make. But if they do ask, and you give permission then okay but there should also be acknowledgement of who wrote the original idea.
4
u/tarlakeschaton Oct 12 '23
can't you report it to tiktok in this case? i mean sueing is okay but a really expensive and tiresome thing
4
u/Ghostatworkk Oct 12 '23
I was a frequent reader of hfy stories just via chrome without account. Through TT i found a lot other interesting stories to read.
That caused me to create an account, to simply give an upvote or a nice comment cause i cherish good writing.
One one hand yes its shit someone else making mone off of your stories but still it causes some more attraction i guess
3
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
It's been happening on YouTube for years. Difference is that a lot of the YouTubers ask nicely.
2
u/night-otter Xeno Oct 13 '23
Another aspect to keep in mind is with other reposting your content. To other sites, different format Person or AI reading, or as one guy does with r/EntitledPeople & similar subreddits, creates animations to go with the stories.
It can confuse ownership, which is red flag to agents & publishers. It can disqualify you for awards.
I've been on the Hugo Awards team. Not on the validation team, but been in the room several times as they discuss the review the top nominees to ensure they qualify. This is all done by volunteers, with limited resources. So if there is any confusion or difficulty in resolving issues, they err on the side of caution and disqualify a nominee.
126
u/NorthPolar Oct 12 '23
Considering it’s the creator’s intellectual property and potentially copyright, I’d personally send a DMCA notice over it. But I’m an asshole.
64
u/Outrageous-Salad-287 Oct 12 '23
Since TikTok is Chinese, I am not suprised by their attitudes toward intelectual property. I say sue them, simce making money out of someone' else work without their permission is pretty much theft. Rep them any time you see it😈
9
u/EchoingCascade Oct 12 '23
I write for fun, mostly when I get a story stuck in my head and have free time, I have never said no to anyone who has asked if they could read a story I wrote on their youtube and I always assume they make money off of that.
The problem as I see it on TT, is that they don't ask and they make no effort, it's always that subpart AI voice.
Guys like Net Narrator, Aggro Squirrel Narrates, etc. Do voice acting, they bring the story to life, they earn their money.
TT though? Just a bunch of thieves...
2
u/SciFiStories1977 Oct 12 '23
I wonder who's downvoting this post...?
5
u/HFYWaffle Wᵥ4ffle Oct 12 '23
/u/SciFiStories1977 has posted 13 other stories, including:
This comment was automatically generated by
Waffle v.4.6.1 'Biscotti'.Message the mods if you have any issues with Waffle.
7
u/Lugbor Human Oct 12 '23
I just hate that in order to police it, I would have to actually engage with the cancerous cesspool of tiktok.
3
u/ComStar_Service_Rep Oct 12 '23
Reddit, YouTube, and click bait Facebook ads have been monetizing Reddit almost as long as the platform existed.
If you want to monetize your work, then use reddit to build a following, then publish on a platform that you can actually get revenue from.
3
u/Fontaigne Oct 12 '23
You could take the infringer to small claims court, but collecting would be a problem.
One potential solution would be to get together a bunch of people who were infringed by at least 2-3 accounts, issue takedowns one at a time, then sue the accounts and TikTok in small claims court, jointly and severally. You will have to properly serve/notify TikTok, but the other accounts can be "John Does".
TikTok is giving these individuals money for violating your IP. The amount of the money sets the value of the stolen IP. If you can show knowledge of a procedure of infringement — ie TikTok has been informed the account is doing that — then the collusion becomes knowing/intentional. That means that TT itself can be reached in the lawsuit, regardless of the user agreement.
What will happen assuming you win is that TT will claw back any damages from the account, so they lose nothing. The real question is whether you can get multipliers or statutory damages on top of the money paid to the infringer.
I would expect 3x damages is available if you due in the right state... and, amusingly, legal fees may count as damages, again depending on state.
Some young lawyer could make book on this.
I don't see it as a viable class action, though. It would probably do better as a named party lawsuit.
3
u/humanity_999 Human Oct 12 '23
If they don't ask for the creator's permission, it's called being lazy & theft. There is a reason I don't go onto TikTok, because most of the posts on it are either uninspired theft of another's hard work, dangerous challenges, or blatant lies about well-known facts/conspiracies that have been disproven dozens of times.
There are some legitimate TikTok accounts, but the vast majority are not worth viewing.
This is part of the reason I haven't really uploaded a lot of stories. I have well over two dozen drafts raring to go, but between constant revising & hesitation due to potential theft by people who can't even be bothered to ask my permission first... my uploading is sparse.
Now I have gotten requests for some of my stories to be narrated for Youtube.... so I'm eager to see how those go. They come out sometime this month (at least one of them).
3
u/Away-Location-4756 Oct 12 '23
I've let my work be narrated on YouTube but the guy always asked and that was fair for me.
To do it without asking is rude.
2
u/UpdateMeBot Oct 12 '23
Click here to subscribe to u/SciFiStories1977 and receive a message every time they post.
2
u/ForestsOverMountains Oct 12 '23
Start a TikTok channel called Stolen Stories and point out the stolen stories and where they were stolen from
2
u/aod42091 Oct 12 '23
it's theft of intellectual property and should be punished.
2
u/Ngete Oct 12 '23
If it's done without the permission of the original writer of the story then go full dmca, all that kinda stuff, IF the ticktoks got the permission from the original writer of the story then oh well
2
u/Skitteringscamper Oct 12 '23
Copyright your work then sue them for the money made off of you
This is literally why copyright exists, so ppl can't just steel your work.
If the accounts were not making money then there isn't much you can do
But if they're earning money from your copyrighted material then they're legally fucked
It would be like me selling batman comics I made myself. DC would sue me into the dirt
2
u/reality_aholes Oct 12 '23
Reality is it's illegal and the authors have the right to file a DMCA takedown on the videos, but it's the author or their representative that has to start that process. TT will side with the author and take down the videos. They will also ban the accounts that repeatedly violate their TOS on the issue. (They have to, it's how DMCA works for every platform).
I do understand this sucks for the author who effectively has to be their own detective to catch this stuff but it's not the planet's job to figure out who has a copyright issue for stuff posted somewhere. You as an author might put it here on reddit for people to read freely and have an amazon self-published book for people to buy and help you profit, that's entirely fine and not a bad idea. But there's no way for anyone including the platforms to know who you've given rights to republish on your behalf to. It's why we have the DMCA written the way we do. It's a case of if the author doesn't see a problem, there isn't one.
2
u/Solid-Childhood-4876 Oct 13 '23
Two of mine have been posted without permission by three accounts. I intend to file a complaint with TT. Only Net Narrator has messaged me for approval. In my opinion, I don't care if I don't make anything off my stories, but anyone else needs to ask. If they ask, there is a good chance I will agree.
2
u/forwritingprompts80 Nov 03 '24 edited Nov 03 '24
Well damn, they took one of my stories. That sucks. I guess I'll have to actually put some effort into keeping my stuff controlled. Thanks for bringing this to our attention.
EDIT: I have given some permissions, but not a lot. I also don't think I have given any permissions for tiktok, but it could have slipped by me. I also don't think I have given permission for Big Strong Humans, but it seems reddit has made finding past messages harder.
2
u/Pretzel_Boy Oct 12 '23
I've always been of the opinion that if you haven't received explicit permission from the content creator, then you have no right to repurpose it or make money off it.
Explicit permission either being done on a case by case basis, or as a blanket permission is fine (such as with royalty free music, for example).
The only exception is if enough time has passed that it would enter the public domain, then it's fair game for anyone to use.
1
u/firefighter_raven Apr 23 '24
Late to the party but here is another tik tok acct using our works. https://www.tiktok.com/@redditninja_
1
u/Motor_Print3731 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
TL:DR https://creativecommons.org/about/
That’s awesome that you address this. I don’t mind sharing either but it does take heart and soul sometimes to convey an idea. It’s the principle of the matter, it irks me. The term I use is frogging. Pretending to be you , taking everything for free , benefiting , lying cheating ..It’s more prevalent than you can ever know. I’m not going to get into it all. Ideas are copied all the time or improved upon. Yes, that’s one thing, what I don’t like reading is something I’m writing, take it to make a YouTube or Tumbler, YuKu or QQ , and in the sum of the sexier sides of Reddit you’re very images. I don’t care who you are it just isn’t right.
it’s fun and healthy to share to express and discover a bunch of people that are nodding at something maybe never talked about before. Especially when it stories. I’ve always had a runny commentary in my head or made stories up around something.
Seriously, I’m doing the work , my ideas, things I’ve cried over , you don’t even know the background . It’s disrespectful, it’s creepy , get your own ideas.
The thing is is we used to write in our diary. We wanted to share that thing but we locked it up with key it should have the same importance online. We have our data taken away for free everything we do in the Internet, at least allow me to have some privacy.
I just wish that I had known about all this before . I’ve had all of my private works stolen . Everything. I am not in a position right now to have has it all backed up but I could’ve uploaded it somewhere else where it’s protected . So I am basically my digital creativity has been sold over and over. I’m synthetically dissected , copied , my very digital footprint or data get cherry picked for whatever use the buyer needs it for nefarious or otherwise.
I have some really good stories that I wrote down in some cases collaborated with another person. It was private completely private. We have artificial intelligence now and there are clamouring for your data everything that you do so make sure that you somehow put your name on it at least.
we did that at school remember? Sign your name, I WAS HERE.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
Seen a few on Yt as well. Oh, don't assume us stupid Americans can't just google exchange rates...
1
u/Jdonavan Oct 12 '23
I'll just say that I've subscribed to three different authors Patreon as a direct result of catching an audio version of their work on TikTok.
1
u/ownzone817 Human Oct 12 '23
I mean... It is a problem...
1
u/Archaic_1 Alien Scum Oct 13 '23
I'd say you absolutely need to copyright strike those fuckers, but does TT even acknowledge copyright complaints being from a country that does not recognize them?
1
u/Primary-Specific-196 Oct 13 '23
I doubt many ppl will follow tiktok for stories. YouTube is the better option for fans since you can actually search and find stories you want and save them easily.
As for profit as a creator I wish you luck I have seen several creators go mainstream and get their stories published and turned into full books. Thanks to the popularity and attention gained from having them read aloud on youtube, this is the way!
What we are seeing is the western market slowly catching on to what Asia has been doing for decades to allow novice/ hobbyists writers go mainstream with their work.
On the flip side one must take care to protect their intellectual property from day one.
And fans have to do their part and only listen to content presented by or with the approval of the author.
0
u/chojinra Oct 12 '23
I never read stories here, I listen to them on YouTube. Not sure what the thoughts are on that.
I don’t want to offend the creators on here, but if you’re that worried about your IP, I’d post less on an open site for Schrute Buc… ahem, karma, and more on TikTok, Amazon, YouTube, etc. You can still post your lesser or rough draft versions here. Everyone wins.
-9
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
The internet isn't a shop. It's a notice board in the middle of town. You can post your notice with a polite sign saying "read only" or "do not copy." But at the end of the day it's still posted up in the middle of the street unattended most of the day.
This is just the nature of the internet.
-3
u/Multiplex419 Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23
How do we feel about it? This subreddit's terms of service literally forbid us from saying anything other than "Yes, you're 100% right. We agree with you." If we disagree, it's "supporting or encouraging theft."
0
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment