r/anime • u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: • Jan 21 '24
Announcement Best of /r/anime 2023: Winners!
Welcome to the finale of Best of /r/anime 2023!
Spoiler warning: some comments and posts below contain spoilers for the series indicated in the [square brackets].
Without further delay, the winners are:
Best Comments
- /u/Verzwei’s perfectly brief-but-comprehensive rundown of the Aniplex USA rights/licensing debacle and history. It shines a light on why some shows are still stuck in production limbo. Nominated by /u/AniMayor
- /u/backoftheac’s documentation of the history of Astro Boy, which is not only a compelling story on its own but also includes a fascinating look into its production and its influence on TV anime. Nominated by /u/gamerunglued
- /u/zadcap’s insightful analysis into the language of flower and how it relates to character relationships in [Bloom into You]. Nominated by /u/Shocketheth
- /u/Gamerunglued’s response to the “personal touch” in recent anime that highlights the diverse and personal creativity found in anime. Nominated by /u/macrame2
- /u/Tarhalindur’s comprehensive breakdown on the cinematography of [Madoka Magica] for the annual subreddit Rewatch. An effective crashcourse that is sure to deepen appreciation of the show. Example comments for Ep 1 and Ep 12. Nominated by /u/FlaminScribblenaut
Most Enjoyable Rewatches
- /u/Shocketheth Gintama rewatch. Going above and beyond their station, Shocketheth provided personalized drawings of the best comments, provided trivia, responded to every comment, and ran popularity polls and a trivia quiz for when the sub went dark. Nominated by /u/Shimmering-sky
- u/laughing-fox13 Bloom into You rewatch. Smooth and thorough, insightful and enjoyable, Fox’s rewatch was as engaging for first time viewers as it was for veterans as it’s packed with running jokes and analysis. Nominated by /u/Shocketheth
- /u/raichudoggy’s Fruit Basket (2019) rewatch. Filled with delightful theorizing and a hardy mix of rewatchers, it is the perfect watch-along for everyone. Nominated by /u/Shimmering-Sky
- /u/Tarhalindur’s Madoka Magica rewatch. Every year the host imparts their own style into the annual and rewatch and for Tarhalindur’s it is jam-packed with comprehensive analysis, historical documentation, and a waterfall of fun tidbits that all enriched the rewatch experience. Nominated by /u/FlaminScribblenaut
- /u/Shimmering-Sky’s Macross rewatch. Lasting a staggering eight months, Sky consistently pumped out an inhuman amount of wallpapers and effort to keep this rewatch afloat. Nominated by /u/JollyGee29
Most Valuable Contributor
- /u/FetchFrosh’s highly impressive run with their charts, churning one out every 7 days alongside continuing their modding duty and helping those in /new. Nominated by /u/steven4869
- /u/AbyssWatcherbel, for their continuous work on the weekly seasonal rankings and their knowledge on anime productions that aids the discussion. Nominated by /u/steven4869
- /u/Durinthal, by being the cornerstone of the sub. Daily Thread upkeep, active in rewatches, helpful in recommendations. There’s nothing he can’t do. “He’s helping the next generation become better weebs.” Nominated by /u/FetchFrosh
- /u/Gamerunglued, for eloquently articulating their thoughts on the ideas, themes, and subtle nuances of a work, and bringing with them a level of appreciated discussion for the sub. Nominated by /u/HereticalAegis
- /u/Shimmering-sky, for being the backbone for the Rewatch culture on the sub. Providing wallpapers, covers, and trivia bits, they are a pillar for this community and a joy to read. Nominated by /u/Shocketheth
Best Original Content
- /u/Paukshop’s numerous educational infographics which are perfect for the layperson as they’re easy to understand, concise, and rich with examples. A true ace for the subreddit. Here's an example featuring [Healer Girl]. Nominated by /u/Manitary
- /u/KendotsX’s “Anime is back” Gintama edit for being the perfect gift for the reopening of the subreddit. Nominated by /u/Shimmering-Sky
- u/ja_noble’s AMV containing a whopping 104 different anime-styled works. Nominated by /u/Shocketheth
- /u/Shimmering-Sky’s gorgeous wallpaper of Tokai Teio and Mejiro McQueen in the [Uma Musume] rewatch. Nominated by /u/ZapsZzz
- /u/ChenDumpling’s delightful acoustic guitar cover for Chainsaw Man’s OP “Kick Back”, complete with a cosplay of Denji. Nominated by /u/Shocketheth
Best Original Essay
- /u/FlaminScribblenaut’s six part feature on [Revue Starlight] that spotlights both the revues and their love for the series. A grand undertaking to behold. Nominated by /u/MyrnaMountWeazel
- /u/lilyvess’s wonderful essay on [Utena, The Tempest, and The Witch from Mercury]. Part analysis, part historical retrospective, and ultimately a part of their own story, it's a wonderful read that'll make you further appreciate the show. Nominated by /u/Lemurians
- /u/Idz4gqbi’s four part Character Appreciation and Analysis on [Bocchi the Rock]. A phenomenal sendoff to the 2022 show and a lovely opening for 2023, they collectively represent high-effort, loving, and thoughtful content that is a treat to read. Nominated by /u/FlaminScribblenaut
Best Original Review
- /u/aniMayor deftly weaves in moral relativism, the Red Scare, and the complexities of an increasingly interconnected world fueled by rapid technological change, all into one compelling Watch for Concrete Revolutio. Nominated by /u/MyrnaMountWeazel
- /u/Suhkein Pale Cocoon WT perfectly captures the unshapely middle-distance wrestling within the show. Though the show may be difficult to understand, their WT is anything but. Nominated by /u/MyrnaMountWeazel
Congratulations to all our winners! You will receive a message from us later today on your custom flair.
And finally, a big thank you to...
- Everyone who spent the time to scour through the sub to find content to nominate. Many of the nominations have excellently detailed write-ups that we have trimmed for the sake of brevity, and so we urge you to re-visit the original voting threads or the best of 2023 wiki page for a better look at everything.
- And everyone who participated in the voting process!
We hope you enjoyed Best of /r/anime 2023. See you next year!
94
Upvotes
10
u/cppn02 Jan 21 '24
Congrats to the winners.
I see me jokingly pointing out the error in the original nomination got completely ignored. Fetch's polls are weekly and thus every 7 days and not 10.
23
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Jan 21 '24
Biscuits, you can at least edit it to be accurate
That said, I appreciate the sentiment and am glad that people have been enjoying the stuff I've been working on. I've got some stuff cooking for this year that I'm pretty excited about.
11
u/FlaminScribblenaut myanimelist.net/profile/girlbeast_val Jan 21 '24 edited Jan 21 '24
AAAAAAAAHHHH I WON I WON I WOOON
For real, I’m incredibly honored and grateful. I am proud beyond words of that post series and overwhelmingly happy that all the feelings therein are out there in the world, and seeing it be appreciated by others just fills my heart up with such warmth and joy.
Thanks so much to /u/MyrnaMountWeazel for nominating, and utmost kudos to /u/lilyvess and /u/Idz4gqbi whose essays were also fantastic and truly worthy of appreciation. Thanks to everyone who read, responded, and is still reading and/or responding. Thanks so, so, so, so, so, so much!
9
u/lilyvess :Df::Dh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lilyvess Jan 21 '24
I won?!
i didn't think I'd actually win considering the great competition. I'm just glad they have multiple winners cause even I'd have voted for /u/FlaminScribblenaut excellent Revue Starlight posts.
I'm glad r/anime enjoyed my G-Witch essays so much. I fell in love with the show and wanted to help share my love with others. I'm still obsessed with SuleMio. I bought my first Gunpla last year and now I have a backlog of Gunpla to work on!
thank you everyone who read my posts and thank you for /u/Lemurians for nominating me!
8
u/Shocketheth Jan 21 '24
Woohoo!!!
/u/laughing-fox13 congratulations to winning with your Bloom into You Rewatch and /u/zadcap congratulations for winning with your analysis in Bloom into You Rewatch
14
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jan 21 '24
Oh I wasn't expecting the results this soon!
u/Shocketheth you did it.
My second-ever rewatch win ahhhhhhhhhhh
And I also placed in Most Valuable Contributor and Best Original Content, ahhhhhhhhh! Thanks to the people who nominated my stuff and the people who voted for it!
7
u/chilidirigible Jan 21 '24 edited Jan 21 '24
Congratulations Happyclap
6
u/laughing-fox13 https://myanimelist.net/profile/laughingfox13 Jan 21 '24
Very thankful to be here with the others. Congratulations to everyone who won
6
u/Tarhalindur x2 Jan 21 '24
That said, you would have to have the new custom flair option drop right when I'm contractually obligated to use the Lain flair until the rewatch ends, heh.
(Now the fun part: finding the right PMMM frame to use for a flair. Preferably one that isn't obviously a giant spoiler
(and repress the urge to use a certain notoriously spoileriffic episode 3 one, come on now Tar it would be funny but it doesn't even have Madoka herself in it)and also not too difficult to distinguish from u/FlaminScribblenaut's own custom flair at flair size (which rules out an episode 9 shot or two that would otherwise be the obvious candidates, lack of Madoka herself or no).11
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jan 21 '24
Congrats to the winners!
5
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jan 21 '24
Not a bad way to go out I suppose.
5
u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jan 21 '24
Doesn't this mean r/anime is now collapsing?
Congrats winners!
4
u/Shocketheth Jan 21 '24
Also I am congratulating and being sorry for u/KendotsX who turned British and won the best Original Content
4
u/Shocketheth Jan 21 '24
Also yaaay, I won.
I thank /u/Shimmering-Sky for writing a wonderful nomination for my Rewatch, and I thank to everyone who voted for Gintama Rewatch.
I have a lot to say about it, but I am leaving it to a final discussion.
7
u/Abysswatcherbel https://myanimelist.net/profile/abyssbel Jan 21 '24
Thanks, Honored to receive an award and to be part of this community! Congratulations to everyone else and thanks for the nomination /u/steven4869 and /u/michhoffman
3
u/ja_noble https://anilist.co/user/halfofmarco Jan 21 '24
Thank you for the nomination /u/Shocketheth
More AMV's coming for sure! :D
3
u/Verzwei Jan 22 '24
Thanks for the award and thanks for nominating me, /u/AniMayor!
Now I've got to settle on an image to use from either Otherside Picnic or Princess Principal.