r/HFY • u/Krazywolve • Mar 17 '24
Misc YouTube channel stealing stories.
This is not a story, it is a PSA for the subreddit.
Another redditor gave me a heads-up about a YouTube video that appeared to have stolen one of my stories; altered, but at its core, the same. I had previously given permission for SciFi Stories to narrate the story, which they respectfully asked permission for ahead of time.
The channel: Starbound HFY, did not ask me for permission and had the audacity to claim in their video description that the story was their original idea.
You can view them both and see for yourself:
SciFi Stories authorized narration of my story https://youtu.be/SDan4gmRQh8?si=OE8-8sdGhur9QJkD
The Starbound HFY story in question https://youtu.be/2Q4ilr1fLaM?si=GH4F9so6TLYAJ4S6
I put this warning out to the other writers on this subreddit to keep an eye out for things like this and help protect yourselves and your fellow writers.
I also request that we, as creators, band together and censure thieves like this wherever and whenever they pop up. I am unfamiliar with copyright and the law so if anyone knows what can be done about people like this then please, for the good of the community, share your knowledge. The only reason I didn't bring this to the mods first is because I want the entire community to be aware so that they can protect their work. I will be messaging the mods separately.
And if the thief happens to read this: not cool dude. If you wanted to narrate my story, just ask. If you did ask, then at least have the courtesy of crediting it to the original creator.
21
u/Righteous_Fury224 Human Mar 17 '24
Just had a look at the community page on Starbound HFY and the thieving bugger is announcing that they want to publish the stories that they have plagiarized as their own original work on Kindle.
This bugger needs to be taken down.
5
u/Lower-Ad6435 Mar 17 '24
I listened to that story on the authorized channel. I enjoyed it. BTW, what do you prefer your followers do, read the stories here or listen to them on authorized channels, or does it even matter?
Also, the video on starbound hfy went private. Fyi, I'm not going to listen to anything on that channel as a result of this post. Are there any legit channels? I'm assuming Agro Squirrel Narrates is one of them.
3
u/SwiftHound Android Mar 17 '24
The video has gone private, I assume that this post did the trick, very nice and good job spotting this!
410
u/repulsive-ardor Mar 17 '24
Hi so I have had this issue, and you need to sign in to your youtube channel and go to the youtube studio of your channel. There you will see the option of submitting a copyright claim and you will copy and paste the offending video link and fill out the form. Put that your relationship to the copyright as original author and your info and submit.
I also found that it helped to change my youtube channel name to my reddit name as well before issuing the strike.
This is why they add a bunch of different words and try to change the narration just slightly enough to try to slip past the copyright scan that youtube does of the content.
I would also blast them in the comments for stealing your work, it causes them to lose subscribers.
2
u/ugot8 Mar 18 '24
Wow, I'm about to start a narration youtube channel and this is the first post I see.
I personally am still trying to figure out how to get permission from writers to use their stories and what links I need to let viewers know where to go to see the OP.
But I have seen people do this on their A.I. channels. Where they take a story and change a few aspects of it and then post it. Incredible #$^%*# disrespectful to the writer , I believe.
Is there a process for asking permission to use yours, or someone elses story for youtube?
Or is it just posting a comment asking or a sending a dm?
The process, for me at least, is very confusing and kinda scary, lol, I'm brand spanking new to this, but I want to do it without using that bland, emotionless, A.I. voices.
Oh, and is there a way to get a written email saying that it is ok to use the story, or should I make a sheet for the writer to fill out. What would you (The writers community) like from me(Youtube narrartors) to do when seeking honest approval to use the story.
89
u/Cortanis Mar 17 '24
A lot of this has been happening as of late. Particularly I've seen this out of this rise of YouTube channels using AI voice narration to do it instead of an actual person. I already didn't like the AI voice use in the first place but I noticed that most of them I'm seeing don't properly credit authors if attempts are made at all.
35
u/die_cegoblins Mar 17 '24 edited Mar 17 '24
I could swear there have been Meta posts about content thieves on YouTube and other video platforms like TikTok before. Would be nice if we could get a warning like this pinned somewhere, instead of a Monthly Writing Contest update that was posted 190 days ago for a contest that still has not announced the winners. I loved the MWCs but it's clearly not being maintained anymore. Just drop it and put on something useful for authors.
35
u/arabcowboy Mar 17 '24
Wouldnāt it be funny if a bot scraped this and put it on YouTube as a short story.
37
u/VagrantScrub Human Mar 17 '24
I dont think we can stop this unfortunately. Bots scrape the this subreddit endlessly as I understand it. My only defense is my stories aren't very good.
18
u/Johannsss Android Mar 17 '24
Starbound video just went private, I mark this a a win for us
13
u/bulldzd Mar 17 '24
Can I just add my thanks for all you creators who somehow manage to make such incredible stories... I much prefer the several You-Tube narrated channels (Agro Squerril/Net Narrator/Sci Fi Stories etc who ALWAYS give credit to the authors) when driving or working... I really wish you guys could make these stories into an audio book and allow us to purchase them, of course in hopes of you making many many more... Again, my sincere thanks for all your hard work and talent....
25
u/biogear13 Mar 17 '24
Your post led me to a rabbit hole of YouTube hfy narration. So I searched for youtube and here are the channels that have videos entitled 'We don't kill humans'.
Although, I was not able to compare the stories uploaded to these channels to the original. Moving forward, I'll try to create a spreadsheet to list down and try to identify youtube channels that narrate hfy stories without attribution.
12
u/Unable_Ad_1260 Mar 17 '24
There's been an explosion of crappy AI voiced channels lately. I don't want to report them in case YouTube does the YouTube thing and sweeps up the good creators with the bad as well in some blanket bash. Is it safe to hammer the bad actor channels?
7
u/Solid-Childhood-4876 Mar 17 '24
YouTube, at least, might do something. Tiktok didn't for me.
7
u/BasicPen709 Mar 17 '24
Thank you for letting us know so now we can go un follow that Chanel cuse they are not doing stuff right .
5
u/the_clash_is_back Mar 17 '24
I prefer audio books so tend to use channels like this. Recently there has just been a bunch of crap ai generated and altered stories, totally ruined the medium. Channels like the one you mentioned are guilty of this.
Started to just use this sub and a voice to text now, as a bonus I can comment and upvote the original creators work.
4
u/humanity_999 Human Mar 17 '24
Looks like he's already made it a private video.
4
u/VexTrooper Human Mar 17 '24
Good to know, I also went with SciFi Stories when he came to me, shame to see that this is a thing
4
u/JerusalemCats Mar 18 '24
SciFi Stories has a link to the original reddit story which is great. Anyone else that steals, report and give a thumbs down. The concept of Audio Books is Book for the Blind. Volunteers would tape record books and the Blind would get them in local special Libraries. They are great.
1
u/OnTheHill7 Mar 18 '24
So, this is claimed to be written by the poster?
https://youtu.be/DSkaonQjD6M?si=uHASDDtSJQpa4t5T
Is it?
3
u/MeHereThereThenNow Mar 17 '24
Oh man, Iāve listened to Scifi stories telling of this a half dozen times and had no idea there was another one.
3
u/SeaYogurtcloset6262 Mar 17 '24
Hey op, it seems that the video is privated when i checked again.
3
u/Omega359 Mar 17 '24
Blocked channel, thx
3
u/LordCoale Mar 18 '24
In the US and most countries, the act of publishing something, even self publishing online, gives you the immediate copywrite. Anybody who steals it is liable. Most of those TikTok and YouTube people are untouchable by US laws. They are in China or other countries that might have legal treaties with the US about this kind of thing, they ignore the little people. TikTok and YouTube will pull material that is stolen. I did the TikTok form for one of mine and it got taken down. I posted about it here and got a lot of hate for it. I liked the comments that people gave on that post, but it pissed me off royally. I posted in the thread that it was mine and stolen. I thought about leaving it alone, but the longer I sat, the angrier I got. It is not free advertising or exposing other people to our stories if it is not attributed to us. I might have left it alone if it had linked back to my original post. But it didn't and the poster wouldn't give me credit. So I axed it.
1
u/StarboundHFY Mar 19 '24
I reached out to OP several days ago to see what we can do to make things right, but he has decided to not respond.
2
u/reality_aholes Mar 18 '24
Here's a helpful link to Google's own process for filing a copyright claim: https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6005900?sjid=2047521784862031365-NC.
Long story short. Email their copyright mailbox, not their online form. Reason being, you have a copy of the message and timestamp of the email you sent to them. You won't get arguments from Google, they will remove it (that's the law with DMCA).
4
u/Moff_Tigriss Mar 17 '24 edited Mar 17 '24
Honestly, from an outside POV, if it's posted online, there isn't a lot you can do. Youtube, or mainly the robot managing the claims, can eventually work, but for TikTok or Twitter, yelling at the sky is probably more successful.
But there is a way to improve the situation : few channels do ask for permission. Few channels even have a human narrator. I absolutely despise those artificial channels, so when a good one pop, it's always a good time.
Since r/HFY is the center point when someone new search for that style of stories, every channels list them as "HFY", maybe use that to push respectful channels. Promote those who use a real narrator. Make temporary exclusives, follow ups, etc.
I've seen a lot of creator communities losing their mind since i'm online (~1999), talking about "X stealing their content/idea/music/pattern/sprites". Well, every single time, everybody descended into bitterness and hostility. Nobody win, creators loses and exploiters moves on. Newcomers are driven away by the grumpy peoples, and the thing die.
The ONLY way to move positively is to make a synergy with who respond to a public demand. I've seen it. It works. You can do it yourself too, clearly there IS a market. Feed the ecosystem, instead of leaving it available.
And again, if it's online and public it will be exploited. No way around it. Music majors try to kill anything derivative/copied since the dawn of internet, and before, the actual result talk for itself.
EDIT : at least 3 downvotes, with no answers or counterarguments to go with. Great.
1
u/karenvideoeditor Mar 17 '24
Oh yeah, there are a handful out there that took stuff from mine, that I know of. I know of them because I searched my screen name, though, they did properly cite back to the original post. Not sure how to find any that haven't. The fact that they're assholes for not getting permission is relevant, but I don't really have the energy to care. Though this post did nudge me to at least leave a comment on the ones that have a few thousand hits.
I've reached a point where I get regular asks and so I put in my subreddit's pinned post that I've already got someone who does mine, and the next day I got another message asking. Ignored it. That's what I'll be doing going forward.
1
u/radfordra1 Mar 18 '24
Starbound made the video private
1
u/Expendable_cashier Mar 18 '24
Shit like this is ehy if theres no link, I dont leave a like.
1
u/MechisX Mar 18 '24
I have noticed that they will not respond to requests for text versions of the stories (I prefer to read over listen) and never give a source for the stories.
Just as an additional kick to make them do the right thing add a link to the original story here on Reddit in your comments on their channel.
1
u/ScorpioZA Mar 18 '24
Looks like the second channel did read this - that video has now been privated.
I actually foudn your story SciFi Stories did that narrating. Very cool. I enjoyed it.
1
u/Kenbo111 Mar 18 '24
It's set to private now!
1
u/NoahKleugh Mar 18 '24
It appears to me, that some idjiots will spend more time and effort to plagiarize a story rather than following the correct and honorable vector. I pray that Karma will "bless" their day as soon as possible.
1
u/dragonson04 Mar 18 '24
Seems that they've killed that second link already.
1
u/OnTheHill7 Mar 18 '24
This absolutely needs to be pinned. It would also be great to keep a list of authorized sites and sites that are stealing. I like to listen as I drive, but I donāt want to reward thieves. As a community we should make it easier for fans to figure out which is which.
1
u/jamessavik Mar 19 '24
This is annoying. I write on different platforms around the web and have had my stuff pirated. It's just so... middle school, if you know what I mean.
1
u/Philbo100 Mar 19 '24
Although I was on reddit already, I did not know of HFY.
Once I did though, I found I really liked the sub.
So I had a go at a short story.
I agree, not cool to steal without giving credit, The flip side is that more people get to enjoy the stories written here.
The other thing is you could potentially make some money via YouTube if you set up a channel?
1
u/MeHereThereThenNow Mar 20 '24
I haven't seen anywhere else to ask this so Iāll ask hereā¦
anyone know where or how they come up with the images used for YouTube narration?
1
u/DerthOFdata Mar 21 '24
Wait until you learn what Tiktok channels do.
1
u/MySpirtAnimalIsADuck Mar 22 '24
Iāve noticed a few AI driven channels doing the same. I will post names as they pop up on my YouTube feed
1
u/ShneekeyTheLost Mar 24 '24 edited Mar 24 '24
Yea, they did mine as well: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JSl12gBIkjE
Not only that, but had the gall to try and claim credit
1
u/Top-End-Terror Mar 26 '24
There's another page called "HFYStiry" which is pulling the same stunt, with the same cheesey "Fair Use" copyright disclaimer. It might even be the same person using a different name.I've called both pages out for piracy in the Youtube comments a couple of times where I've able to identify the original story and author, but there are a lot of stories here that I haven't read, or I remember the story but not its name or the author, and I haven't been the only one doing so.
I'll keep fighting the good fight.....
1
u/Agil70 Mar 28 '24
In this video the Delpan Empire is mentioned, so i dont know if this story is yours or the take the name or was a coincidence, so i put it here and you say https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0l12uljQHck
1
u/Aeeek May 07 '24
I had a deluge of HFY thumbnails in my youtube feed. Out of place with what I was watching. Never clicked. Just watched some EVE videos for old times and another turned up. Starbound HFY. Made a little more sense. Youtube has been serving some absolute turds lately, some obvious, some maybes that I don't feel like rewarding with a click without googling first.. Which is how I find this reddit post
1
u/Zealousideal_Sir_264 Aug 05 '24 edited Aug 05 '24
https://youtube.com/@sci-firealm?si=gCu2KRhfvuqV8fKD
This is one of many that have stolen my content. Actually just had a successful claim against them. Might want to scan it over, none of the stories credit the author.
Edit: is there a better place to post this link?
1
u/DovaDealer Jan 17 '25
Starbound hfy is no longer on youtube, its a shame to read this as i had liked their narration style. But stealing anothers content and claiming it as your own is just plain wrong and lazy. They should be ashamed of themselves. On another not if anyone knows another channel with great stories i would like to know as I like to listen while i drive.
1
u/Holiday_Law9982 May 14 '25
https://m.youtube.com/shorts/EtWVRuhXQF0
0
u/Skitteringscamper Mar 18 '24
We need a stick here to brigade the comments sections of stolen stories.Ā
Also we should probs get the mods here to make a proper hfy YouTube channel we keep emptyĀ
Then we copyright strike on behalf of the hfy authors, so any redirected money off of those stolen story videos can then be sent over to the author after its Gaines it's views etc.Ā
Sure we should allow them to make their stolen videos, but we should be redirecting their profits to the authors through copystriking their channels and videosĀ
0
u/ALLGAMER88 Nov 07 '24 edited Nov 10 '24
i had every one of my youtube videos stolen word for word and they claimed it as their own there were 2 channels that were only my HFY stories
-17
u/sectoredits Mar 17 '24
While the stories are obviously similar, itās not like you āownā every story of 2 aliens talking to each other about humans. If it was copied word for word it would ofcourse be a different situation..
0
u/[deleted] Mar 18 '24
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '24
[deleted] ā view deleted comment