r/anime • u/ModieOfTheEast • May 20 '24
Watch This! "The Executioner and her way of life" - The Isekai that was hold back by its genre
Short summary: "The Executioner and her way of life" had a hard time getting recognized. Since it is part of the Isekai genre, a lot of people might have not even given it a proper chance (especially with the first half of the first episode) and those who did, expecting it to be an Isekai, quickly realized that this story would not follow the usual points and dropped it in one of the early episodes. Despite this, it is an interesting take on the genre, especially because it does not feel like a just a cheap copy you have seen 100 times already and the two main characters have a good chemistry while also being interesting enough that you might want to follow them. It is not without fault, the main issue being that you can feel that this first season was just an introduction to what might still come, but it is definitely worth a watch if you can accept the fact that it will not be like most Isekai.
Content:
- Its place in the Isekai genre (Story)
- Reception
- Characters
- Fights and World
- Ending
- Spoiler section
1. Its place in the Isekai Genre (Story)
As I already adressed in the short summary, "The Executioner and her way of life" is an Isekai anime without being your typical Isekai anime. And I know what some of you might think. It's probably just some Isekai with a gimmick and maybe some better than average moments that makes me recommend this show. And the first half of the first episode seems to back this up as we have a generic male protagonist being transported to another world. There, people check is power, determine it's useless, so he is thrown out the castle where a cute girl picks him up, explains a bit about their world and they go figure out that his power is actually really overpowered. But this is where the show takes a turn, because the actual MC is the girl he met, called Menou as she kills him on the spot.
The reason for this is that this world has been a lot of experience with people coming from other worlds. For a while, they summoned a lot of people who all had strong powers and because they lived there, also influenced the culture (as you'd expect from Isekai). However, at some point in time, powers from these summoned people started to go out of control, destroying large parts of the world, making them uninhabitable. Since then, summoning of new people is forbidden by law, but aristocrats still do it every now and then to use these special abilities to gain power. In order for these powers to not go out of control again and since there is no way of sending the summoned people back to where they came from, the church trained assassins like Menou, who will seek out these people and then kill them without anyone getting involved (since the powers go out of control during their death as well, just not as much).
With that being said, is the gimmick just that Menou goes around killing people being summoned to this world "Talentless Nana" style? No, this is not the case either. Her next target, a girl named Akari, seemingly has the power to heal people, but once Menou kills her, she discovered that this is not true, she actually has time manipulation powers. And since the powers activate themselves on death, it is impossible for her to kill Akari. And therefore, she has to go on a journey trying to find a method to kill her before her power goes out of control. On this journey, the story is obviously about them becoming closer friends making Menou doubt her mission and the church, it's about hidden agendas by all the different insitutions and about how the life of people getting summoned into this world was and is now. Because yes, some of these slip through the cracks, since the aristocrats have learned and use one ritual to summon several people at the same time for example.
2. Reception
As you can see from the story summary, the show had a hard time getting recognized. These people who might have enjoyed this road trip like story as a fresh idea in the Isekai genre probably already ignored it during the introduction of the first episode and those who wanted an Isekai, didn't like that this was something completely different from what you have to expect. A lot of the bad reviews are therefore people who dropped the show in earlier episodes reducing its score. Those who stuck with the show until the end, enjoyed it for the different take, but obviously also mentioned that the show was not perfect by any means. Some of the reasons why, we will discuss in later sections. However, one thing that was often mentioned in these negative reviews was the fact that the characters are bland, uninteresting or just not likeable, especially the main character Menou as her job is to kill people while claiming that she is just, noble and strong. And I think this is a good excuse to talk about the characters.
3. Characters
As already mentioned, the show mainly focuses around the two characters Menou and Akari and their relationship. However, the main focus of the show is Menou, so I'll start with her. Her story is basically that she witnessed one of these special abilities going out of control, killing everything around her, only she surviving and she was then rescued by the church and trained by one of their greatest priests, Flare, so she could make sure that tragedies like these don't repeat themselves. And here, we come to the part that I mentioned above as she usually introduces herself as a priest that is strong, noble and just. However, that is just a front she puts up, because she knows herself that what she does is not necessarily just, but an evil she has to do. She even says so about the first person she kills in the show as she knows this person didn't do something wrong. They didn't even choose to be summoned into this world and getting a huge power. And maybe, these powers might have not even gone out of control. She knows that killing these people might not be the just way, but it is what she thinks she has to do.
However, since she is our main character, of course she isn't stagnating in this constant belief. As I already mentioned, a big part of the show is Akari and Menou traveling together and of course, during this time, Menou becomes more and more attached to Akari, so killing her becomes more and more difficult for her. Furthermore, as also mentioned, there comes a point where Menou gets betrayed by the people she trusted, making her questioning her task even more. That being said, it's not like Menou will be a completely different person after these 12 episodes as the story is still very much on going, but you can feel the gradual changes that her character goes through.
As for our other main character, Akari, I can't say too much about her without spoiling. On the surface, she appears to be the naive, cute girl that is just strangely attached to Menou from the get-go, not doubting her once and since she doesn't have memories of the moment she got killed by Menou, this doesn't change over the course of the show. However, there is a bit more to her character, but this will be talked about in the spoiler section of this post.
As for other supporting characters, we have Momo, a disciple of Menou who also usually gushes over her superior and Ashuna, a princess who isn't interested in just following her countrie's politics and wants to search for answers for herself. While these two have their own back and forth every now and then and Ashuna is a fun character to watch, it's mostly Momo that stands out. Because while her love for Menou is mostly used in gags, it's also made clear that she is not just jealous over Menou and Akari slowly bonding, but that she is afraid that Menou might get too attached to her target and when the point comes that she needs to kill her, it will have a strong emotional effect on her psyche. Still, like with Menou, there are signs of interesting moments coming up, but since the show has only 12 episodes for now, you can feel that we haven't seen everything from these characters.
In general, I think the characters are interesting and have their own depth to them. Of course, with only 12 episodes and the story's main focus being the characters, it's clear that there is still a lot more to come.
4. Fights and World
What's left to talk about here are the fights and the world itself. I will be starting with the world as I already explained a good bunch of it in the story section, so I can make this short. As mentioned, this world is heavily influenced by the fact that people who have been summoned influenced the culture and destroyed some regions. While this is mostly in the background, I want to at least mention one moment that I found surprisingly well done. Because this story is not just telling you about the destruction these powers have, but it shows them to you. Once in Menou's flashback but also later in the present when Akari and Menou reach the border of one of these regions and Menou tries to kill Akari using that region.
Part of the world but also the fights is the magic system. Now, I think the magic system is one of the weakest aspects of the show as it is never really explained. There are some things you can interpret for yourself, but it's left rather vague. For example, the idea is that they all have ether (essentially Mana) to use their magic and they conjur it through words (formulas). It's interesting that they conjur this magic onto objects, but it's often not made clear what the boundaries are. For example, Menou has some sort of scripture that allows her to use all kinds of different techniques, even so much as summoning a big translucent church which uses its bell to kill people. This means that the fights can feel a bit random. Because while they still use some strategy depending on the situation, since there are a lot of question marks regarding the rules, it can feel a bit cheap every now and then. There are still moments that show the intelligence and abilities of the characters, it's not like they pull out a new ability in every fight, but I think it's not too strange to say that while the fights look visually interesting, they are probably the weakest part of the show. At least in terms of the actual battle. The emotional aspect of the fights is well done and if that is what you are mostly interested in, this combined with the visuals can carry these scenes.
And since I brought this up here, in general I would say, both world and characters look good. The designs are not too special, but they are unique enough that I can recognize it and the animations are on a level you would expect from a show like this. Pretty average, so not too bad that it affects your enjoyment of the show or certain scenes but also not so good that you remember the series for its animation.
5. Ending
Don't worry, no spoilers here. Those come in the next section. I just want to mention something regarding the ending of the show. As mentioned, you notice that this is an adaptation of a story that is still on going. Meaning that while you can feel that the characters evolve, you also notice that there is a lot of the story still missing and it's not clear if it will ever get a 2nd season. A lot of the questions are unanswered as well and the story also leaves you with a pretty big cliffhanger (though it's one that one could expect the way the story went). The point I want to make here is that the ending can let feel a bit unsatisfied because you notice that there is way more and probably more interesting moments to come and if you have a problem with that (and you don't want to pick up the source afterwards), you might not want to start it until there is a continuation announced. If that is not a big issue for you, feel free to check it out.
6. Spoiler section
I added this section for those who might want to know if there is anything more to Akari or the story than what has already been written. So from here on out, heavy spoilers for [The Show]As it turns out, Akari's ability is way stronger than it is initially shown. In fact, she already traveled with Menou several times beforehand, but Menou is never able to kill her, so when her powers go out of control, the whole story is reset to the beginning when she is summoned. She deletes her own memories every time just leaving behind the feeling that she can trust Menou and likes her (the reason for this being that she wants to experience this journey every time). There are moments in between where this Akari comes back up, usually when she is in trouble and might die. In these times, you can see that she can has quite the skill over her abilities and even manipulates the people around her to get to the outcome she wants. However, these repeats are not always the same. For example, she does not get a present from Menou every time and later on in the show, Akari notices that certain events have been happening different to any other repeat. However, with like most of this, we only get a glimpse as to what the reason for this might be and it's mostly left as a mystery.
80
u/filthy_casual_42 May 20 '24
This show was a great imo. Admittedly I’m a sucker for time loops, but I thought the show was excellent. Good plot and female MC, unique and fun power system with the MC being good in finesse, and a banger OST. Would love a season 2
22
u/TriadHero117 May 21 '24
I’m one of those people who gave up on the show, and I’m willing to admit it may have been due in part to the first episode, but for just about the opposite reason you’re probably thinking. I held on long enough to reach the second twist (and then skimmed the rest), so it’s not that the fake-out in the first episode scared me off; in fact, hearing about the twist was what drew me to check the show out in the first place.
If anything, the hook is too compelling, and when the premise settles in such a manner that makes it clear that we’re not going to see Menou do anything like that again, it took a lot of the wind out of my sails. The twist certainly had the potential to fix that by offering a new hook for the show to recenter itself around, but when it only really comes up as monologue fuel and a “get out of jail free” card, that reignited faith starts to dwindle all over again.
This didn’t have to be a death sentence for Executioner, but without a solid draw to hook you on, you start to realize how little this “subversive” Isekai is actually subverting. Dragon-Quesque setting with light rpg mechanics, an obligatory evil nobility with the exception of an idealistic princess, protagonist with multiple women fawning over them, protagonist with seemingly weak unique magic that’s actually batshit OP(twice), etc.; Oh, and you can practically track when a character is being set up to oppose Menou by how much of a sociopath they start acting like, which smells of a severe lack of confidence in the whole “necessary evil” aspect of the premise.
Oh, and the lead pipe that broke the camel’s back is Momo. Every time she opens her mouth, some of my ability to take this show seriously died inside. She’s exactly the kind of indulgent fan-serving nonsense the show just spent the first episode making a display out of putting in the dirt. And before you mention it, yes, I’m aware of her tragic backstory and why she idolizes Menou, and no, that doesn’t save my opinion of her in the slightest.
At the end of the day, Executioner managed to pull off an excellent hook that was exactly the kind of gets-people-talking controversial you want for the right reasons, too, but failed to properly reel me in afterwards. Oh, and a screaming pink-haired toddler fell into the water and scared the metaphorical fish off.
44
u/Longjumpi319 May 20 '24
Saying that an isekai was "held back by it's genre" is a very hard sell lmao.
If anything the fact that it was an isekai yet still failed is more noteworthy because there are loads of forgettable generic isekai anime that did well
11
u/KRChaserReturns :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GalacticMagna May 20 '24
Oh boy...This series right here... It just wasn't good. And no it's not because of the first episode were the ahem self insert was killed by Menou. But the thing is everything else is just boring. It took 5 episodes for me to get me intrigued to the world building cause imo it was pretty confusing to me. Also, the main characters are so boring. I feel like the only good thing about I can say is that the visuals are pretty good. But.... that's it.
If you like it fine, but I hate it when fans falsely accuse people not liking it because they didn't like the first episode and it's bait and switch (Frankly I didn't like it either).
64
u/BosuW May 20 '24
"but is is definitely worth a watch if you can accept that fact that it will not be like most Isekai."
Usually, you would frame this as an incentive not a warning lol
135
u/sabellini May 20 '24
This show was pretty good and had a banger op
62
u/zairaner https://myanimelist.net/profile/zairaner May 20 '24
Yep, actually turned into my second favourite isekai. Starting with episode 6 especially, I got super into it. I appreciate that the mc was actually the weakest in the group from a pure powerlevel point of view, and that the author put in quite a effort to make her win with skill instead.
Overall I enjoyed basically everything about this, the premise, the production values, the magic system, the fights, the twists, the villains (well, the second villain at least), the different relations between the characters, the yuri.
6
u/felidhino May 20 '24
I was one of those folks, who tried giving it a chance. But it failed to make me want to watch beyond the first episode. It wasn't my cup of tea, and it failed to hook me in, and it's MAL score didn't help.
I understand that you are trying to promote the show, and it's unique premise, but it wasn't very good. Hence it's terrible ratings, I love Isekai trash, but I couldn't stomach the female mc and her obsessed deuteragonist.
4
u/Dog_in_human_costume May 20 '24
I didn't like it and I love anything nearly close to isekai.
The plot was weird as fuck and, outside the FMC, the characters were super boring
6
u/Ratix0 May 21 '24 edited May 21 '24
The light novel went on to be pretty good tbh. First 2 volumes (adapted in season 1) are really the slow slog of the story, especially the first volume. The anime adapted the least interesting parts.
Not to mention the most interesting parts being the world building and magic system, was pretty much butchered in the adaptation due to time constraints.
Outside of it, the supporting casts are ok, I do like to see the 2 main character but the other 2 supporting characters never really got too interesting for me and were more annoying than I liked when I read the novel.
Still, overall I like the novel, but can't say the anime was great because of the lacklustre adaptation + adapting the least interesting parts of the novel
38
u/TwiggyPom May 20 '24
I thought as a whole it was average. If people find the synopsis interesting give it a go I say. If we get more seasons I'll watch them.
18
u/kyon_kun_denwa https://myanimelist.net/profile/kyon-kun-denwa May 20 '24
I really need to watch this. My friend showed me ep 1 and I forgot to watch the rest of the season. I really liked the first episode too!
12
u/MosskeepForest May 20 '24
Seems like a good one to add to the list of stuff to watch, thanks for the review
8
u/FrostyWheelPZ May 20 '24
Akari lookin like Dagger from FF9 was pretty cool
32
u/ExLuckMaster May 20 '24 edited May 20 '24
It’s fucking funny how big a contrast the reactions between Japanese fans and the MAL crowds in the first episode. On MAL or any social media platform, it was unhinged while the JP fans liked it.
Going back there were and still are some pathetic takes. I low key saw some mofos compared Menou killing the self insert to the Floyd thing and called it a feminist move. You can contribute the low score on MAL for review bombing because of this reason.
Which is even a bigger contrast because its score and reviews on ANN far much better.
As for the anime, it was pretty good enough to get me checking out the LNs and you know what. The anime didn’t even cover the real meat of the story, the upcoming volume is phenomenal.
27
u/BigFatKAC https://anilist.co/user/AnimeRichard May 20 '24
I personally didnt like the show. The time loop stuff was interesting but the characters are bland and tropey, and i found myself rooting for the bad guys simply because the main characters are so unlikable. The sound design and op are great though.
1
u/Slyceandice13240 May 20 '24
I have all the manga that’s in English currently. I don’t think it will get a second season sadly
7
u/MrWildstar May 20 '24
I just watched this last week and loved it. Binged the whole season and bought the next couple of books!
5
u/Accidentallygolden May 20 '24
I really liked the MC Chara design
14
u/Entmaan May 20 '24
The show wasn't bad at all, but one important note to everyone considering watching this - do NOT watch the OP, always skip - it contains ridiculously heavy spoilers for things that actually happen beyond S1
7
u/QYXB12 May 20 '24
This is the only anime I've watched that convinced me to actually go buy the light novels, which I've read all of so far. I love the way the world is built, the magic system (which is explained way more in depth in the novels.) and I really like the ethical dilemma of the other worlders. I can't say it's the best written series out there, but it will always be one of my favorites.
5
u/ARES_GOD https://anilist.co/user/ARESxGOD May 20 '24
I agree more people should be watching this series, it had a very interesting concept on the isekai genre which gets a lot of hate in general and people probably just dodged it because isekai bad.
I have it as a recommandation in a video i did of the best isekai series.
2
u/DesignHead9206 Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 03 '24
That's too many words to defend one of the shittiest anime ever made.
Not because of the FL (I read and watch Otome Isekai with no issue).
Not because "it's not a typical Isekai" (I have watched and read almost all Isekai ever made, and there is no such a thing as a "typical" isekai).
But because the story sucks and the characters suck.
And because a story that starts with a nice cheerful person (regardless of gender) being forcibly summoned, feeling all excited and hopeful, being kicked out with not even a sorry just for a misunderstanding, stuck in a foreign world with no money, no friends, no family, no job, no house, no citizen rights, and being killed for nofuckingreason as soon as he had become hopeful again, while the killer goes on being the fucking hero and the killer's lover has the power to rewind time but doesn't even give a shit about saving that unfairly killed person's life, it's not a story at all. It's pure horseshit.
There is nothing special in it, but it tries to sell itself as "oh so fucking special" by being provocative: a "girl love" story where the FL is a pos psycho who kills a nice guy for no other reason than her prejudices and fears, and an isekai that pisses on the isekai genre.
If you bite the hand that feeds you, at least be able to stand on your own.
But this story has no redeeming qualities whatsoever.
I bet my left testicle that the only two kind of people who like it are LGTBQ, and pseudo-intellectual otaku who think that by liking something that pisses on an entire (hugely misunderstood) genre they're so cool and special.
Indeed, 99% of the verbal-diarrhea rants in defense of it are heavily centered on celebrating the death of an allegedly "generic" male MC, trashing isekai as a genre, and talking big shit of the alleged awesome plot twist and other similar random bullshit.
At the end of the day it's just a generic FL shounen like thousand others.
Trying to be special by pissing on others instead of by actually having something special to offer, what a lame lame thing to do.
1
u/Abyranss May 21 '24
I feel like the twist in the first episode worked to its detriment and the show ended up with a lot fewer people watching it than it would have otherwise.
If you open the show claiming that the bland generic isekai boy is the protagonist and then kill him you end up in a situation where the people who like shows with the generic isekai boy will start watching and then drop the show early on and the people who find that kind of character annoying and want to see something more interesting won't give it a chance and won't see the actual show that takes place after that.
Same thing happened with Talentless Nana. I remember I kept hearing about that show, I'd start watching the first episode and then drop it because it looks like it's actually about this boring Nanao guy claiming his superpower is lame. It took until I saw an explanation of the first two or three episodes from someone else before I watched past that
1
u/Averath May 21 '24
I was fine watching this series until the episode where they repeated the exact same animation like three times in a row. I started questioning if I was watching an anime, or a bunch of reaction gifs on a Discord server.
Reusing animation is fine. Shoving the fact that you're doing it in the viewers face is not.
1
u/oddmonkeyear Jul 03 '24
PROJECT MOON MENTIONED! I AM HERE. I LOVE MILI! (help with reverberation ensemble)
1
u/MyAccountWasBanned7 May 21 '24 edited May 21 '24
General rule of isekai: if it has a female MC then it's good.
The Executuoner, Kuma Bear, So I'm a Spider, Bofuri, The Weakest Tamer, Saving 80k, and of course, Spirited Away. Not to mention one of the OGs of the genre; Alice in Wonderland.
Female-led isekais get interesting character arcs, creative stories, actual conversations and growth between characters, and just general attention and care to the writing and pacing. Male-led isekais get an instantly OP MC, a harem that becomes infatuated to the point of obsession, and awkward virgin energy, complete with infinite nosebleeds, any time there is cleavage or even a hint of sexual tension. Even in one like Arifureta where the MC is supposed to be uncaring and a bit of a badass, you still get him getting shy and awkward and trying to look away or change the subject when his harem starts getting too randy.
Why am I getting downvoted?
1
u/iwoply May 20 '24
this is the anime with the iron maiden right? if so the start kind of messes with you going in blind but as the series progresses it gets really interesting especially when they showcase the reasoning behind the actions in the first episode.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '24
Don't remember much about it to be honest, even though I finished it. For a show that pushed against standard isekai conventions, I found it pretty forgettable.
-8
u/Yarmungar May 20 '24
Ah yes, weekly r/anime look at this garbage show, why it is so underrated. Next week its gonna be some cute girl idol show. Its always either some pretentious shit like revue starlight or just bad anime all around like symphogear(it gets better in season 12 trust me bro).
-3
u/Jumper2002 May 20 '24
I'm not reading all that, tldr?
0
u/ArvingNightwalker May 21 '24
I dropped the series in ep 1. The twist was neither surprising nor was it done in a very interesting way. To actually get me interested in the series it sounded like it should have introduced the time rewind girl within the first episode somehow.
-2
u/FantasticKick7954 May 21 '24
Watch talentless nana instead
-17
u/Salaryman42069 May 20 '24
It was westerner bait subversion slop. It's got a moderately interesting premise that was very poorly executed in the anime. The E1 twist came off like a "Haha, take THAT Isekai self insert characters!" rather than "Oh shit something about these powers turns normal people into psychopaths"... which was important to establish for the greater story.
Also the only characters with any chemistry were the Tomboy Princess and the Kouhai. The MC and the looper girl were blander than the blandest self insert.
Ultimately, it's held back not by the genre, but the fact that the Author does not love the genre and wants to "correct" it.
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 20 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '24
[removed] — view removed comment