r/anime • u/FunkSoulBuddha :K:https://kitsu.io/users/josh • Jun 07 '13
I am Josh Fabian, Cofounder of Hummingbird, a social platform to track, share and discover anime, AMA!
If you'd like early access to Hummingbird, we're currently running a promotion with the awesome guys over at Anichart so go ahead and grab the invite code "ANICHARTNET" and pop it into the 'invite code' field after registration to skip the line.
For a preview of where we're heading in the next few weeks, here's a quick look:
New User Homepage, which will be live in a few days:
Character / Voice Actor pages, and yes, you guys will finally be able to add your waifu / husbando once we launch this section. Still a work in progress.
New Anime pages - Still a work in progress.
Okay, let's do this! AMA!
(Oh god... be gentle!)
43
u/nigrea Jun 07 '13
Why Hummingbird and not MAL?
27
u/underdabridge Jun 07 '13
Why did you name it Hummingbird? I google it and, obviously, it's not the top result.
13
u/Twilight_Scko :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Scko Jun 07 '13
13
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13 edited Nov 03 '16
[deleted]
0.9931
6
u/FunkSoulBuddha :K:https://kitsu.io/users/josh Jun 07 '13
Alright guys, I've gotta run for now. I'll pop back in later to grab any questions that haven't been answered yet. It's been fun! :)
21
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
How do you plan to turn a profit? I would imagine you have plans for things like premium accounts or something along those lines. With things like adblock and the like, advertisements can't be your only plan. Even gelbooru has had an issue with getting it to be self-sustaining.
I would also suggest to start marketing yourselves at cons, even if it is just a small booth. I would expect that to bring in quite a few users that haven't heard about you.
Edit: Forgot to finish my thoughts, was getting into the beta.
19
u/MissyPie https://myanimelist.net/profile/HammerSenpai Jun 07 '13
I already really enjoy Hummingbird, so I guess I just wanted to know if, in the future, you'll be keeping the development blog better updated?
You've mentioned features that will be added soon/very soon in forum posts, but they aren't mentioned on the blog :c It would be nice to see previews/hints about what's coming soon :D
9
u/firstgunman Jun 07 '13
What got you into Anime? What was the turning point that made you think: 'hey, I can turn this hobby into a profession?'
17
u/games2007 Jun 07 '13
Are you considering an 'import lists from MAL' method, or a program like MAL has to automatically update your anime progress? Also, MAL tracks Manga and Light Novels, but not visual novels. Would you consider adding trackers to these other mediums. I think visual novels especially are worth including in this kind of list, as MAL has been pretty negligent in not having VNs part of their community for years, and I think it would benefit the medium's popularity in the West.
6
u/lefty40404 Jun 07 '13
This has been a request that has been going on for MAL for awhile, with no avail. Will you consider adding a section for visual novels?
5
u/OavatosDK https://anilist.co/user/58 Jun 07 '13
Is there any plans to change the way the "Top Anime" page works? Using tomatometer-esque system makes it so almost everything is marked as highly positive, which results in things like the Steins;Gate OVA being ranked in the top 30.
4
u/kinyutaka Jun 07 '13
Is there going to be a way to discuss positive and negative reviews?
This one person keeps putting wall-of-text reviews that amount to saying "You're retarded if you have a different opinion of anime that me" and I'd love to give her feedback of why I like these shows.
4
u/xero99 Jun 08 '13
A million people have probably said something like this, but I just wanted to say that I really love Hunmingbird, especially its gorgeous aesthetic value. It also allows me to better find anime I might like because of the great search functions. Best of luck in finishing everything up!
7
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
Can I get my beta account yet?
Seriously now, though. What prompted you to create Hummingbird when other sites (say, MAL) were already available? What do you feel your platform does differently - better - that sets it apart from the alternatives?
EDIT: Oops, it appears that literally everyone else has asked that too. In which case, if you have the time and don't mind me asking too many questions - if you were restricted to watching only one anime series for the rest of your life, what would it be and why?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 09 '13
On one occasion already someone has asked for recommendations on /r/Animesuggest and supplied a Hummingbird link of what they've seen. When people do this with MAL links, I can easily see how much overlap we have and check what I've seen but they haven't. Short of maintaining two accounts, does/could any method exist for me to compare lists cross-platform?
3
u/games2007 Jun 08 '13 edited Jun 08 '13
Is there a way to fix duplicates in your library? I imported my list from MAL twice. I don't think duplicates should be able to exist at all ;x http://i.imgur.com/Fd8kq74.png
Also, I hope that things like sequels, prequels, OVAs, spinoffs, etc. to a series will be displayed. Example: http://myanimelist.net/anime/5081/Bakemonogatari You'll see
Adaptation: Monogatari Series: First Season
Summary: Bakemonogatari Recap
Sequel: Nisemonogatari
Prequel: Nekomonogatari: Kuro
3
u/arch4non Jun 08 '13
It needs a way to import from lists from AnimeNewsNetwork.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '13
This website looks really professional and clean.
Good job guys. Maybe, if this really takes off, it can perhaps clean-up some of the negative opinions about anime.
5
u/NavarrB :K:https://kitsu.io/users/navarr Jun 07 '13
An email I sent you that never got answered:
Hello Josh,
I learned about Hummingbird today (off of a flair on r/anime) and was very interested in it. I have a few questions, some of which are probably answerable if you have an account (I obviously do not yet) and a number of which probably aren't. Some of them would also be major selling points for a MAL competitor (at least where I sit)
As a MAL user and web developer this was one thing I thought it was seriously lacking. I'm sure they have some undocumented backend API that MALU plugs into, but the developer at MAL was very quiet about everything and very complacent since he said that since MAL had been purchased he was the only one authorized to work on it, and then only really for maintenance. I like to aggregate my data, and sometimes I like to make services I use talk to each other.
[2 removed because it's answered elsewhere]
3) Do you have an "auto-updater" or sorts? To be honest, it's the main reason I use MAL, especially it's built in release-tracker.
4) What language is Hummingbird written in? And are there any openings - you know, just out of curiosity .~
Thanks for letting me waste a little bit of your time,
2
u/honkwas Jun 07 '13
Hi, I signed up recently and have been filling out my lists.
I was wondering if you would allow subcategories within lists, eg if I spilt my planned to watch into genres or what I'm more likely to watch?
Also check out my profile, my random choices of pictures for my icon and header work nicely together.
2
u/BetaSoul Jun 07 '13
Just requested an invite. Lets see how you dev.
2
u/modman2 Jun 07 '13
What do you think about sites like herro.co? What sets your site beyond the other sites that will make people jump forward and use yours?
2
u/Junistry Jun 07 '13
I don't really care about reviews and recommendations but I'm more interested in how I can have a website where I can organize "my animelist". I started doing this in MAL but can you tell me about Hummingbird in this regards?
2
u/SolarAquarion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SolarAquarion Jun 07 '13
Will you be having a taiga/malupdater styled app for hummingbird which can have plugins for RSS and stuff?
2
u/Sarahmint :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sarahmint Jun 08 '13
Why does everyone need an invite instead of just joining?
2
u/Planetariophage Jun 08 '13
I like the site. I was actually thinking of making something like this in the past when I did all my machine learning courses. I actually posted a question here to see if it was already done and someone mentioned your site. I never got an invite until now (was like 600-700ish place D: ). Also, by pure coincidence, the logo for the company I work for is almost the same as the logo for your company ;P . Good luck, I hope this takes off!
edit: also can you make the quote bar smaller? It's taking up 25% of my laptop screen D:
3
u/cptn_garlock :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cptngarlock Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
Will you ever be implementing direct links on the show page to sites such as Crunchyroll, Daisuki, or Funimation (e.g. the Sword Art Online page would have two outgoing links, one to the show page on Crunchyroll and the other to the page on Daisuki)?
7
u/underdabridge Jun 07 '13
Hentai?
6
u/lastorder :K:https://kitsu.io/users/lastorder Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
How does your recommendation algorithm work? Albegus is near the top of the second page of recommendations, but I can't imagine many people have seen that and rated it.
6
u/Semblances Jun 07 '13
Why use a 1-5 scale rating system over a 1-10 scale rating system?
6
u/HumanIsDead Jun 07 '13
Hey don't know if y'all are still around but here is a suggestion: If I mark an anime as complete, please don't make me manually in put the episodes watched. I made an account on your site then added around 300 shows that I've watched to my library, most of which I've completed before noticing my time spent watching anime was no where near correct. So now I have to go back through my library typing in episodes watched for all the ones I've completed.
6
u/ClearandSweet :K:https://kitsu.io/users/clearandsweet Jun 08 '13
Hey I've been using the site and have nothing but praise for the idea and the execution. Something as simple as having a tight WYSIWYG editor for writing reviews feels so great. I CAN HAVE A GIF AS MY AVATAR.
But most of all, I really, really, want to thank you for being so open and honest with the community. You earned my loyalty when you answered my question about the English/Romanji titles on the forums a while back, whereas the same post on MAL was part of a six-month old thread with no response.
I do hope you've developed thick skins, though. Anime fans can be entitled and terrible excuses for people with not a thought of politesse.
That said, hearing your plans for the future in this thread just make me happier and happier, specifically the economic and business parts. Maintain this level of enthusiasm and dedication and you will succeed.
Good luck and 頑張って!
6
u/partysmores Jun 08 '13
I noticed the rating system is changing from the MyAnimeList one to the standard American TV ratings system (TV-G, TV-PG, TV-14, TV-MA, etc) in that photo. Do you fear this will confuse international visitors at all?
2
u/purgarus Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
I guess this is more of a question towards Hummingbird and not you, but when do you think it will move past closed beta and be open to share all of its awesomeness with everyone?
Also, how did you get the idea for Hummingbird? Was it a bunch of people collaborating or just you and some friends throwing ideas around?
10
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13
Hummingbird offers a similar service to web sites that are already available. How would you describe the the differences, and what forthcoming features could set it apart further?
8
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13
The one thing that bugs me about MAL is that most of the titles are in romaji, even the ones that have been domestically released. I watched Spice and Wolf, so I always do a doubletake when I see Ookami to Koushinryou there instead. Does Hummmingbird support any kind of language preference for this - either per title or as a site-wide user preference?
4
u/mwlgogo Jun 07 '13
pretty cool site.. but will you fix the server lag?.. since sometimes is kinda slow to load.. or mb im the only one with that problem?
1
u/ivari Jun 08 '13
Will you implement a staff/cast entry comparison feature like in ANN's encyclopedia?
1
u/ivari Jun 08 '13
Please add an option to browse anime per release date. Categorizing anime based on its season is very easy than to pick or search.
1
u/ivari Jun 08 '13
Can I hide the quote header while browsing? It's distracting.
Why when I finished adding a title the page goes back to the top?
It would be fine if the progress meter changes color according to your watching status (dropped = red, watching = orange, finished = green, etc)
1
u/jimtsurugi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jimtsurugi Jun 08 '13
Just finished registering. Am dismayed at the gratuitous display of cats. Don't you know that cats are vile creatures that only exist to prey upon the soles of the innocents?
At least you could have put comic style cats as the default. Would have made the site look like it had something to do with Anime.
1
u/KnivesMillions :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ibob Jun 08 '13
Shit I'm late for the party, I wanted to know these guy's Top 3.
1
u/Musical_life :K:https://kitsu.io/users/4464 Jun 08 '13
Will there be a program for Linux that I can use instead of the site just in case? Or a mobile app?
1
u/MeisterCho :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Cho Jun 08 '13
When I go to my library in Hummingbird, I can click on the row for an anime and see the picture and a summary. I really like this feature, but it's not available when you look at other members' libraries. Is it possible to implement this? Especially the picture... I know the phrase "don't judge a book by it's cover", but the picture really influences my decision D:
Also, for the url of profile/list, is there a way you can remove the id that's attached to the username?
I'm slowly but surely being converted! Keep up the good work!
1
u/Unixsuperhero Aug 09 '13
I hope your team is still responding to this AMA. I have 2 or 3 questions, I think I know the answer to the second, but that might just be cloudflare.
Question #1 Where do you guys get your data from. For example, various data about a series:
of episodes licensed for release
Are there public databases/apis? I'm working on an anime/manga/etc. app myself (for personal use, unrelated to recommendations), I need a working catalog of series info. Without ripping another site, how do you get access to this info and keep it up to date.
Question #2 What languages is the site developed in. It looks like Ruby (on Rails) based on how your assets are minified and named it looks like asset pipeline. Although that could be cloudflare, I'm not sure. I just started working with cloudflare this past week.
Question #3 How do you like cloudflare? Useful?
3
u/sageinventor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sageinventor Jun 07 '13
I you can provide me with a mobile app, I am already switched. The deal is done. (even though I already use it, mobile apps are just great.)
3
u/brokenbentou :K:https://kitsu.io/users/2999 Jun 08 '13
Oh hey bro, saw you at Acen!
3
u/killnight Jun 09 '13
So I've been using Hummingbird for a few days now, here is what I think:
-If you add an anime and sign it as completed you still have to fill in how many episodes you have watched. kind of annoying when you add like 10 or 20 in a row to your list.
-The site itself seems to have some issues, nothing really mayor which affects the browsing but sometimes it times out.
-I reaaaally don't like this follow twitteresque thing. I want an old school friend option :c
And now to the Good points:
-The layout is absolutely amazing. After years of shitty coded WBB forums it is really nice to have something like this. Plain, beautiful and perfect.
-The explore function is fun, even if teh genre list is somewhat frickly.
-The site is designed in a way that makes it hard to get lost and easy to find what you're looking for.
-Many interesting new ideas.
So in short, still teeny tiny flaws but as a whole an awesome site. Nice community and when you take in account that it's still beta then this place can grow.
1
u/demon-nerd Jun 07 '13
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=6EUYBWhVkKg
hi i love this site and the owners always hear us out on ideas a very enjoyable place! -video not related-
4
u/ayogoke Jun 07 '13
Josh, Do you even lift? And if so how much?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13
What is your philosophy behind ratings? In a lot of instances numerical anime ratings seem arbitrary and unhelpful in assessing a series as a show may appeal to a taste of one person but not another. Basically, what is the purpose of rating an anime by a number on your website?
2
u/watonakali Jun 07 '13
feedback:
there is no button that you can click and submit that you watched all episodes
you have to add each episode with 1 click at a time
add a button "have watched all episodes of this anime"
2
u/lobstahfi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lobstahfi Jun 07 '13
I hope you guys are still here. I was excited to hear about hummingbird when it was first mentioned on this subreddit and put my name in for the beta trial. I thought it was weird that I still hadn't heard anything so I checked your site today. It says a confirmation was sent but even when pressing resend, I still see nothing in my email. Anyway for you guys to check, I'd really love to be a member. Thanks for the AMA :)
2
u/tletang :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Terger Jun 07 '13
Thanks for the info and the promo code! Checking out the site now.
2
u/Jonas-sama https://myanimelist.net/profile/Jonas Jun 08 '13
Love the design man. :) Keep up the good work! Can't wait for the new anime page, looks awesome~
2
u/sakkarozglikoz Jun 10 '13
Is there an option to import my anime list from MAL? And when I tried to mark a show as completed this happened. Progress 0/26, I had to fix it manually. And when I fixed it manually, my total watch time doubled itself.
2
u/ThadChat :K:https://kitsu.io/users/tails Jun 12 '13
I'd just like to say that I really like the site and look forward to future updates!
2
u/tommyth3cat :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/tommythecat Jun 07 '13
So I've never used your site, what sets it apart from alternatives and would make me want to use it in your opinion?
1
u/EllaGuru_ Jun 07 '13
Any plans to support visual novels? It's oft requested on MAL, but turned down every time. VNDB is lacking in many regards too, like not listing staff and seiyuu credits.
1
u/toyhammered :K:https://kitsu.io/users/4195 Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
Well i got quite a few questions to ask because I have been part of Mal for just over a year so being able to persuade someone you have to do something better than what mal can offer.
First question: what is your "to do list" of things you are going to add or incorporate into this website (practically a wish list i guess you can say).
Second question: Is it going to be possible to keep track of our progress in manga, obviously this is one of the bigger problems because I could not find anywhere to store data on that and this will almost 100% keep people whom watch anime and read manga from joining this site. So will this be implemented and how soon?AnsweredThird Question/comment: Right now (currently trying to get a degree in web-design) in web design the main thing that makes a website good is user experience (ux). Is it going to be possible to fully customize your anime/manga pages with css like you can do on mal, and also will you offer us even more options than mal has by being able to possible customize javascript/jquery in our mal pages (i dont know if possible thought).
Fourth Question: When looking for an anime under genre you have a nice list but the problem is you have also included demographics as part of genres (shoujo, seinen, josei ect..) Do you plan on separating the demographics and genres or what do you plan on doing about this issue?
Lastly: This will be a simple question for rating an anime are you going to keep it at only being able to do whole numbers as stars or can we do like 3.5 stars because that in itself is very limiting onto rating an anime. Because a rating of 3 stars to 4 stars is a 20% difference and ratings will be very inaccurate this way.AnsweredOk enough questions now time to say all the good with some negative in this website:
Well thanks so much for doing this Ama really appreciate you guys doing this!
1
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '13 edited Jun 07 '13
Requested invite. This better be good.
Edit: since this is an AMA can I ask you guys to let me in early?
1
u/Darkstar1141 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mazui1141 Jun 07 '13
I've just started so it may simply be updating, but does the time spent watching factor in the number of rewatches?
1
u/SparkyRailgun Jun 07 '13
Any chance of user themeing via CSS or similar in the future? One of the things I love about MAL is the ability to pimp my profile, and while Hummingbird already looks quite nice, there are definitely some things that aren't to personal taste that I'd change if I could.
If the above is planned, what are the chances of that extending to site-wide themes? Personal list themes are all good and well, but it can often be quite jarring switching from a dark list to MAL's stark white. Given so man of the Hummingbird interface elements mesh perfectly with each other, it seems like an obvious step if the above is done.
1
u/dungeonsandderp Jun 08 '13
As someone who's never joined an online anime community/site of any kind before r/anime (ok, so maybe a little time on /a/), I'd like to ask:
For a newcomer like me, what features would make Hummingbird easier to get started with than one of the established options?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '13
What is your favorite feature of Hummingbird thus far? When will Hummingbird be out of it's beta stages (approx.)? Besides words of mouth how do you plan on spreading the word of Hummingbird? Ads?
1
u/Rabbiac :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rabbiac Jun 08 '13
A site with karma will never create a good community >.>
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '13 edited Jun 08 '13
Any plan to implement a "Favorites" section like on MAL?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '13
Any way to implement a secondary alphabetical order on any list no matter what the sort is? That's always bothered me about MAL. If I want to see my list in order by rating, I still want them to be in alphabetical order secondarily.
Also, it's weird that the plan to watch list is above the completed list, I think.
1
u/Lirtirra Jun 09 '13
Nor sure i understand, are we going to be able to watch the anime on hummingbird? (like netflix) or is it just to keep track of the anime?
1
u/gravidos Jun 07 '13
Having looked at Hummingbird, it looks no better than MAL. Rather than focusing on ease of use and accessibility, it seems to sacrafice both of these things for social interactions.
Why did you focus on this rather than, say, a minimalist site with only required information?
I have yet to use hummingbird, but from what I have saw, it looks no better than MAL in any aspect bar social integration.