r/anime • u/NothingFit7091 • Sep 19 '25
Discussion I don't agree with the spoiler hype.
Ive watched tons of shows where I knew major plot points going in.
Sometimes that was intentional, sometimes accidental.
I tend to think a good show is not dramatically effected by spoilers. A great show might not be effected at ALL by them.
This is easy to see when you think about how rewatchable a really good show is.
Now, obviously spoilers can ruin a surprise. They can wreck suspense...
In my experience the better the show (aka how immersive and well written it is) the less that is the case.
Here's the point ...
I think a story absolutely requiring the viewer/reader to go in blind to be interesting or enjoyable is a sign that that show is not very good.
If the journey is only worthwhile to get to the end, it's not a good journey.
There are a few huge shows that really count on the viewer being surprised or invested in the mystery/suspense. I think this counts against their quality.
The best mystery shows are interesting because of how the characters solve it, not because of the answer.
26
u/N7CombatWombat Sep 19 '25
Congrats, you've formed an opinion and discovered how you prefer to consume fiction, but that only applies to you. Some people don't rewatch shows, some people want the surprise and the shock and when it's taken away, they no longer have the desire to watch the show. We're all different, and we have different tastes and standards.
2
u/RedHotChiliCrab https://myanimelist.net/profile/RedHotChiliCrab Sep 19 '25
Depends hugely on the genre of a show.
Some action/adventure show might not be hurt by it as much as a mystery/thriller type of show. Doesn't mean one is better than the other.
3
u/oxlemf10 Sep 19 '25
I think it depends a lot from person to person, there are people who simply don't care at all about spoilers, just as receiving spoilers destroys the overall experience, personally I prefer not to receive spoilers
3
u/Silcaria https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silcaria Sep 19 '25
Spoilers ruin the fun but indeed don't affect the quality of a piece of media. Thing is, the majority of people do consume entertainment purely for the fun factor.
12
u/KenfoxDS Sep 19 '25
You can think whatever you want, but don't spoil anything for others.
1
u/86_Undertaker Sep 19 '25
First I have nothing against spoiler in generel and I get your points, but I can't see myself to agree with you "justifying" and downplaying spoiler.
What about characters which die throughout the anime or what about rly important scenes?
If I already know that this happens or that character dies my mindset is already set. Twists and turns won't have the impact they should and could have. Characters which I know will betray the MC(for example) are viewed different since the start, than if I knew nothing. Where are the suprises or moments where I can say: "Ah shit, now THAT makes sense" and "this is what they teased some episodes ago?!"?
Spoilers mostly take the thinking and excitement, because why should I try to use my brain if I already know what's gonna happen. Doesn't matter how good or how well written something is, the impact scenes and moments can have will not be the same.
"I think a story absolutely requiring the viewer/reader to go in blind to be interesting or enjoyable is a sign that that show is not very good."
Doesn't every show start like that? It's us viewers who decide if something is good or bad and especially when an anime aires all we have is a new product nobody knows how good or bad it will be. You want spoilers already at release? As if an anime studio decides to already upload scenes of ep5 on YT/Twitter when only the first one aired.
"The best mystery shows are interesting because of how the characters solve it, not because of the answer."
I can only agree half. Ofc the way mysteries are solved is fun to watch. But isn't the first thing we ask us what the mystery could be?
-An example is Detectiv Conan. Obviously I want to know HOW the killer did it and how Conan figures it out, but I also wanna know WHO did it.
-Another AoT. "Why are there titans in the walls?" I didn't ask myself first HOW they ended up in there, but WHY they are there. But mainly I don't wanna know beforehand that there actually are titans in the walls in the first place. Doesn't rly matter to know that when I start S1, but it takes the suprise when the anime presents me that fact. I won't be: "Whoa, titans in the walls?!", I'll just think:"Ah ye, that scene."
Maybe I went bit off rails here, it's just that this is how I understood your post.
3
u/CodAdministrative369 Sep 19 '25
this fully depends on the series and the person viewing it. So really no right answer. Spoilers can make you less motivated to finish it quicker or at all. I do think people who get really upset about spoilers when they are at the same time active in social media communities for anime or manga though need to chill. If i want to not be spoiled i legit stay away. You’re taking the risk of being around it
0
u/nuker1501 Sep 19 '25
is this post copium because you got spoiled
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25
I think its funny youre getting blowback when spoiler culture is kind of a problem, some people really think "JUST WATCH THIS WITHOUT KNOWING ANYTHING" merits someone to watch something
Fate fans notoriously still live in a delusion that Fate isnt one of the biggest franchises in the world, that thousands of people know about fate from ways not the Visual novel even though by the nature of multimedia, that just isnt the case, and to shame someone who got into Fate not through Shirous story is some invalidating experience.
Just care about art, you aren't ruined by additional info before you get in, thats not a good way to live
You are right, but also your post kind of isnt that in depth so you wont get thoughtful responses, but I get you
2
u/gcbofficial Sep 19 '25
Spoilers are terrible, no exception or rant will change this
1
u/Janitalia Sep 19 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/Breakdown007 Sep 19 '25
what's even your point? that's such a dumb post. People don't want to hear/read spoilers so respect that.
0
u/headphones_J Sep 19 '25
Bro, just don't spoil stuff for people.