r/anime • • Sep 19 '25

Discussion I don't agree with the spoiler hype.

Ive watched tons of shows where I knew major plot points going in.

Sometimes that was intentional, sometimes accidental.

I tend to think a good show is not dramatically effected by spoilers. A great show might not be effected at ALL by them.

This is easy to see when you think about how rewatchable a really good show is.

Now, obviously spoilers can ruin a surprise. They can wreck suspense...

In my experience the better the show (aka how immersive and well written it is) the less that is the case.

Here's the point ...

I think a story absolutely requiring the viewer/reader to go in blind to be interesting or enjoyable is a sign that that show is not very good.

If the journey is only worthwhile to get to the end, it's not a good journey.

There are a few huge shows that really count on the viewer being surprised or invested in the mystery/suspense. I think this counts against their quality.

The best mystery shows are interesting because of how the characters solve it, not because of the answer.

0 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

26

u/N7CombatWombat Sep 19 '25

Congrats, you've formed an opinion and discovered how you prefer to consume fiction, but that only applies to you. Some people don't rewatch shows, some people want the surprise and the shock and when it's taken away, they no longer have the desire to watch the show. We're all different, and we have different tastes and standards.

-3

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I never said I like spoilers or that spoilers are good. No one can seem to get the thrust of my assertion. I'm saying if spoilers ruin the story, even though they aren't ideal, that's a sign other aspects of the work are lacking in quality.

The existence of different opinions doesn't contradict the existence of a truth.

I don't find your appeal to reletivism moving. My assertion is true or false, and it was and is true or false despite what you or I believe.

I'd love to discuss that point though, if anyone would like to.

5

u/N7CombatWombat Sep 19 '25

I'm saying if spoilers ruin the story, even though they aren't ideal, that's a sign other aspects of the work are lacking in quality.

The existence of different opinions doesn't contradict the existence of a truth.

And you aren't speaking a truth or a fact, you're stating an opinion, one I don't personally agree with, but a real opinion can be both true and false, it's just how you feel and that's valid for you, no can take that from you, but no one has to agree with it either and others are free to have different opinions that are just as right for them as yours is to you.

When you start making assertations that your opinion is fact is when you've lost the plot, so to speak.

-1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

We don't need to get into epistemology here... But I really don't think it takes a genius to see you are contradicting yourself. Subjectivism/ reletivism just doesn't hold water.

You are saying-

  1. Opinions can be true and false, it's up to the subject's experience.

But is THAT statement of opinion true? If it is... then it isn't, by your own standard.

You see, claiming that there is no objection matter of fact is itself a claim of at least ONE objective matter of fact...

So if one opinion can be true regardless of the subject, why can't other things be?

Opinions are either true or false, or more true and less true... They can't be both. The law of non contradiction states "it is impossible for a proposition and its negation to be true at the same time and in the same sense"...

That's logic 101.

If you disagree with me, give me reasons. Don't deflect by appealing to "people see things differently".

I know they do, and I think they are wrong- that's literally what the post is getting at.

4

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued Sep 19 '25

The statement " Opinions can be true and false, it's up to the subject's experience" is not a statement of opinion, it is a statement of fact about the definition of the word "opinion." And they're correct, an opinion, by definition, is true and false to different people. An opinion, by definition, is a description of someone's personal values based on their subjective experiences. Your criticism holds no water because it's not a contradiction, they are saying "it is a fact that opinions can be true and false at the same time, it's up to the subject's experience if spoilers ruin stories for them" which is a completely coherent statement. It is not their opinion that opinions can be true and false based on the subject's experience, they are just telling you the definition of the word "opinion." If you're using some other strange definition of the word "opinion" that doesn't see common usage, you're talking passed each other. They are not claiming that objective facts don't exist, they are telling you that your statement about spoilers is not an example of an objective fact, it is an example of a personal subjective opinion.

They are absolutely correct that you are not speaking an objective truth. You are stating a value judgement. To you, spoilers do not ruin stories. The wording of your post also strongly implies that you already understand that this is your subjective opinion. The title says you "disagree" with the spoiler hype, implying this is a debatable topic and you're stating your own subjective values. You say "in my experience" the better the show the less that is the case," showing that you already recognize that this is your own subjective experience and not a fact about the world which can be true or false. A person can't be wrong in how they feel, you can say your piece but people are still going to watch shows and feel like the experience was ruined because of spoilers. That's not something you can logic your way into feeling differently, it's not a lack of knowledge that makes people feel that way. There's really no way to debate this beyond saying "people see things differently." Even if someone agreed that how a person solves the mystery is more important than what the answer is, they might still find the tension and the answer itself so important that it ruins the experience for them. There's not some deeply thought our reason for that, they are just explaining how they feel.

And for what it's worth, I agree with you on this and I share your values here, I don't think spoilers ruin stories and I've made extremely similar points in the past. But I don't expect anyone is going to read those points and think "oh, well if you think about it that way, I actually don't care about spoilers anymore." That's not how that works. When we say it, we're explaining our experiences. There's nothing to debate.

0

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

A fact is an opinion (some proposition of truth) that has been proven.

Opinions that haven't been proven yet can still be true or false. That's what argument and discussion is FOR... to take two opinions and whittle away at them until we get fact, or closer to a fact.

I disagree with almost everything about your proposed worldview, and I think it's probably the kind of thinking most destructive to the human race right now.

OF COURSE feelings and experiences can be wrong. We ALL need to know that, and deeply. Experience is prone to all sorts of bias and corruption.

Our experiences probably almost never match up to reality perfectly...

Searching for truth is simply trying to vet personal experience against what you can verify about reality using objective measures, logical or empirical.

If what you are saying is true then it undermines the entire Socratic process from which we derive so much of our bearing as a species.

If opinion is just subjective and cannot be justified or verified through reason then the point of most communication is an illusory goal.

3

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

No, a fact is the opposite of an opinion. A fact is something that can be proven, an opinion is a statement that doesn't have a truth value and is a statement about personal experience and value judgement. Feelings can only exist within and from the perspective of a subject, thus they are subjective. Someone's experience doesn't have a truth value, you can't prove that an experience or a feeling is right or wrong. It's not that it's hard or that it hasn't happened, it's that it literally is not possible, the notion is incoherent and self-contradictory. When someone tells you "I think the color red is prettier than the color blue," that can't be wrong. They're telling you "I personally find the color red to be prettier." That's not something you can argue for or against with facts and logic and there's no objective reality about what color is the prettiest because the concept of "pretty" has no truth value; if you're describing some truth then what you're describing is fundamentally not what the word "pretty" means. "Pretty" is a truth-neutral concept of what personally moves you in a particular way. It makes no sense to say "you were wrong if you found that to be pretty" because there's no way to measure "prettiness" by definition. Likewise, if spoilers ruin a show is also a truth-neutral statement of what personally moves someone in a particular way. There is no reality to match up to here because "feeling that spoilers ruin shows" doesn't exist outside of if people happen to feel that it ruined their experience, the reality described by an opinion is a reality that exists only in each person's mind based on, yes, their biases. The idea of proving which color is prettier than another color is an incoherent, self-contradictory idea for this reason, and the same is true of proving that spoilers do or don't ruin movies. This is separate from an objective reality which we can describe with verifiable facts and measurements which do have truth values. This is all stuff we should have learned in Kindergarten tbh.

Communication is just our ability to make each other understand what we are conveying. We can communicate perfectly fine while disagreeing with each other. When someone says "spoilers ruin movies for me," I understand what they mean perfectly fine even if my experience is different. They have communicated their idea with me, and it has come across coherently. I can then communicate my own idea, and we can go back and forth to have a deeper understanding. Argument and discussion is sometimes for finding a truth or getting closer to a fact, but sometimes it's not. Sometimes argument and discussion is more personal, it's about learning about others, getting closer to understand how other people think and feel, and broadening your worldview to better understand different ways of experiencing the world. Arguing with Flat Earthers about the shape of the planet is the former, debating movies on the internet is the latter. Quite frankly, people's inability to accept that others feel differently from them, and that it is not a bad thing or a problem to solve when others have different values from them, is actually the kind of thinking that is most destructive to the human race right now. Assuming that what you think and feel is a proven fact, or can ever be proven, is the height of arrogance.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

It's insane that you cannot see the self contradiction in this whole thing.

Are your words here TRUE or NOT TRUE?

It seems like you're saying they are both... Which is a logical contradiction.

Or is every opinion YOU have FACT, but everything I've said is just subjective?

It's not that complicated. Either things we say can be true, or they can't. You cannot logically have it both ways.

2

u/Gamerunglued :Hx::Hy::Hz:myanimelist.net/profile/GamerUnglued Sep 19 '25

No. This is really simple, like Kindergarten level stuff. Some statements can be true or false, and some don't fall in that dichotomy. The statement "the color red is prettier than the color blue" is neither true nor false because it's an opinion, while the statement "the earth is round" is true and a measurable, verifiable fact. The former is an opinion while the latter is a fact, the former is a statement about how the person feels while the latter is one about the reality of the world. My words in the previous comment were true, they were not my opinion. The fact that I don't think spoilers ruin movies is my opinion, it has no truth value. Not everything is true or false, it is a true statement that some statements are true or false and some are opinions that don't fit into either category. Some things we say are true or false and some things we say are a different category of language. You can indeed have both. "It's objectively true that red is prettier than blue" does not make sense as an idea, it's incoherent due to what the word "pretty" means, while "there are objectively 16 ounces in a pound" does make sense and is perfectly coherent.

When I was in kindergarten, the teacher gave us a paper that has a bunch of statements on it and we had to circle "F" or "O" depending if it was a fact or an opinion, defined as "if it could be true/false or not." The fact that you either haven't had to do that or have completely forgotten or unlearned it is rather sad. Opinions are not facts that haven't been proven yet, opinions are an entirely different category of language from facts.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

The fact you learned a basic conceptual distinction in Kindergarten and have not developed it since is why I'm beating my head against the wall now.

Let me read this here ... "It's objectively true that red is prettier than blue does not make sense as an idea, it's incoherent due to what the word "pretty" means"

Ah so you're saying that statement is false because it's about subjective taste.

So opinions can be false. Gotcha.

Listen, if I say John bonham sucks at drums that's an opinion. It's objectively untrue.

If I say he's the best drummer of all time it's an opinion, but we could rationalize and argue about it.

It's absolutely possible that through reason we could come to validate or invalidate that statement.

If you went to any drum clinic and said "John bonham is overrated" no one there would be ok with you saying "that's just my opinion.". They would rightly expect you to back that up with reasons.

Do you think empirical knowledge is all there is? What about deduction? What about the abstract processes necessary to turn sense data into perception? None of that is itself empirically verifiable, but we can be self assured it is real and reliable.

What about logic and our faculty of reason?

I would say you are the person not making the proper categorical distinctions here. There are truths that we can know that are NOT facts in a strict empirical sense. Truth and fact are distinct concepts.

It's a whole other discussion, but there are wonderful arguments defending objective beauty. I don't think statements like, "one thing is prettier than another" are as indefensible as you think - depending on the context.

→ More replies

2

u/N7CombatWombat Sep 19 '25

Because what an opinion is has a definition, they are a defined thing, they are all about personal experience and personal preference. That's why real opinions can be both, because they're conclusions brought about by someone's life experiences and preferences.

Not everything is an opinion though, facts are provable, if you make a statement and assert it as a fact, that can be checked, and you can be wrong in that case.

I disagree with you because I don't think shows that rely on twists or surprises for aspects of the story are automatically poorly written, you're assuming that someone who doesn't like spoilers, someone who really enjoys those twists and surprises, doesn't see any other value in the show. Being surprised is like the cherry on top of the sundae for some people and having them spoiled will negatively impact their enjoyment of the show, and that does not mean the show is bad, and that does not mean the show is nothing without them. It simply means those aspects are a core part of another persons overall enjoyment.

And both of those things can be true, some people really enjoy twists and surprises and lose interest in a story when they're spoiled AND you can feel spoilers aren't a big deal and don't effect your enjoyment of a story. You're trying to have a debate about legitimate, individual taste and enjoyment, and you can't, because that process is personal and looks a little different (to a lot different) for everyone.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I'm not trying to debate the subjective. I'm making an assertion that I believe is true, and if you disagree then you are making an assertion that you believe is true. Both of us are posting "facts" for better or worse, otherwise we wouldn't be convicted of our beliefs.

You are disagreeing and saying that my assertion isn't true because everyone is different.

I'm saying you, and those other people, are incorrect.

You cannot disagree with me without making a positive assertion, and a positive assertion implies a statement of fact.

You are trying to negate my argument by claiming it's just subjective while holding that your own assertion corresponds to reality (aka "is true")...

As I pointed out before, I think that you are being self contradictory. You cannot simultaneously undermine that rational process of making a claim and defending it with reasons AND make a claim defended with reasons.

We're both speaking from personal experience... Neither one of us has a leg up here. Just address the core of my argument rather than trying to undercut it.

3

u/N7CombatWombat Sep 19 '25

You're applying the Socratic method to a subject that is subjective because your statement combines an objective aspect and a subjective aspect. The impact a spoiler has on someone is completely subjective, the quality of the story is objective (not that many people actually know how to critique that sort of thing anymore). A persons enjoyment of a story can be negatively impacted by spoilers AND the quality of the story can still be good. Those are two different statements that can both be true, because one is a subjective view and the other is an objective view that are related, but not correlated.

You need to separate them out and figure out which aspect you want to talk about instead of mixing them together and getting frustrated on some level when the rest of us say spoilers can ruin the enjoyment of a story for some people because you're laying the objective aspect (quality of the writing) over the subjective aspect (how someone enjoys a story). Just because it's well written doesn't mean everyone will automatically enjoy it. That's what personal taste is all about.

I really don't know how to break it down any simpler.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

We can absolutely talk about subjective experience as being valid or invalid, less true or more true. We do it all the time. That's what reviews are. It's what critics do. It's what philosophers do at times. There is a reality (what we perceive) and then there is our experience of that perception. That experience can be more or less accurate depending on a million factors.

All that said, my OP isn't really saying anything about personal experience. I'm not saying that people are wrong for letting spoilers ruin a great show for them...

Instead I'm saying that IF a spoiler can ruin an entire piece of art, then it must not have been that interesting a piece of art.

Everything about that statement is a judgment on the creative work- not the person seeing it.

Not that it matters, because we CAN rationally investigate the accuracy of claims that are rooted in subjective experience.

Denying someone's experience as accurate is NOT the same as denying that they had it.

If someone says "I didn't think ANY of the louvre's paintings were good." I can simultaneously know that that was their experience, and also tell them they are foolish for thinking so because OBJECTIVELY the louvre contains some of the greatest examples of human artistry...

That person's experience would be "out of touch" for some reason or another, and we can even explore why.

Maybe they don't understand painting, maybe they didn't know what to look for, maybe they have never tried painting themselves to understand the gap and quality between the average and the wonderful... Maybe they were rushed by the people they went with,.. who knows. We only KNOW that their existence was their experience, but it was also not reasonable.

Another example is with my toddler age kids.

Often they have explosive fits of emotion. I have to temper that emotion and teach them to do so. Why? Because their emotions (experience) isn't always valid. Sometimes they are reacting to what's going on around them inappropriately, and they need to recalibrate that perception.

6

u/Zeallfnonex https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neverlocke Sep 19 '25

I mean, would you argue that spoiling the end of an Agatha Christie murder mystery doesn't ruin the experience? Does it make her mysteries any worse that knowing the outcome makes it not as fun to read because at least half the point of good detective fiction is trying to fit together the clues before the detective gives an ultimate reveal?

Same way with some anime: it's designed so that the audience is actively trying to solve whatever mystery is going on, and hints and crumbs are sprinkled throughout so that they speculate on what's going on, what's going to happen next. Knowing the spoiler kills that discussion.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

At what point in time are you getting spoiled by Agatha Cristie, meanwhile in real life, you can get spoiled about the ending of Xenoblade 3 pretty hard. What do we do and feel about it.

1

u/Neat-Claim-6892 Sep 19 '25

I strongly suspect you like predictable formulatic shows like slice of life or mainstream action. It is pretty sad if you never branch out to shows that suprise you or enjoy that kind of thing. Shows and movies that break the mold are the whole reason I started watching anime. I avoided this sub for years because of the people that gleefully spoil new shows.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

What are examples of shows that are great that cease to be good if you know what happens? If you have an example I would love to know. It would stand as a contradiction to my assertion.

Id also love to know what shows you consider "predictable and formulaic"... It would be interesting if they were in my top 5.

1

u/Neat-Claim-6892 Sep 19 '25

Medoka Magica, Evangelion, Overlord and Kill La Kill. It is absolultly amazing when you find out all your assumptions were wrong. Overlord took 4 seasons for the review that was planned from the very beginning. They spent a lot of effort to make that happen The clues were there you just did not have the context to put them together.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

And now that you've seen these shows you don't think they have anything to offer?

I've only seen evangelion, but I think it would be worth rewatching, even knowing what happens. It's very thoughtful. If anything THAT show is better the second or third time through because of all the subtext you can miss.

To me, you saying I'd need to watch four whole seasons of a show and be surprised by a critical moment to experience what it has to offer is a really convincing argument against watching that show... If that is what you're saying.

1

u/Neat-Claim-6892 Sep 23 '25

I could absolutely pass on the big reveal in overlord and still love it. The thought that went into it is just a nice bonus. It doesn’t make or break anything. I have watched it multiple times it is just fun and has interesting story and characters.
Medoka on the other hand Is an instant classic but It doesn’t have the same rewatch value. It is all about the surprises. It takes a while to get there for me even though it is shorter.

I have watched Evangelion, Ghost in the Shell and Lain many times they are absolutely better on the second view there is so much you don’t get the first time.

1

u/saga999 Sep 19 '25

I'm saying if spoilers ruin the story, even though they aren't ideal, that's a sign other aspects of the work are lacking in quality.

What you are saying is irrelevant in regards to people's opinion on spoilers. When people say the show is ruined by spoiler, they aren't actually saying the quality of the show dropped. What they are saying is their experience of watching the show dropped. So talking about the aspects of a show that is lacking is completely misunderstanding the point of the discussion people have about spoilers.

The existence of different opinions doesn't contradict the existence of a truth.

If you think your opinion is the ultimate truth that cannot be argued against, then you think too highly of yourself.

My assertion is true or false

No, your assertion is merely your opinion.

0

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

We can absolutely talk about subjective experience as being valid or invalid, less true or more true. We do it all the time. That's what reviews are. It's what critics do. It's what philosophers do at times. There is a reality (what we perceive) and then there is our experience of that perception. That experience can be more or less accurate depending on a million factors.

All that said, my OP isn't really saying anything about personal experience. I'm not saying that people are wrong for letting spoilers ruin a great show for them...

Instead I'm saying that IF a spoiler can ruin an entire piece of art, then it must not have been that interesting a piece of art.

Everything about that statement is a judgment on the creative work- not the person seeing it.

Not that it matters, because we CAN rationally investigate the accuracy of claims that are rooted in subjective experience.

Denying someone's experience as accurate is NOT the same as denying that they had it.

If someone says "I didn't think ANY of the louvre's paintings were good." I can simultaneously know that that was their experience, and also tell them they are foolish for thinking so because OBJECTIVELY the louvre contains some of the greatest examples of human artistry...

That person's experience would be "out of touch" for some reason or another, and we can even explore why.

Maybe they don't understand painting, maybe they didn't know what to look for, maybe they have never tried painting themselves to understand the gap and quality between the average and the wonderful... Maybe they were rushed by the people they went with,.. who knows. We only KNOW that their existence was their experience, but it was also not reasonable.

Another example is with my toddler age kids.

Often they have explosive fits of emotion. I have to temper that emotion and teach them to do so. Why? Because their emotions (experience) isn't always valid. Sometimes they are reacting to what's going on around them inappropriately, and they need to recalibrate that perception.

1

u/saga999 Sep 19 '25

We can absolutely talk about subjective experience as being valid or invalid, less true or more true. We do it all the time.

Yes, people make this mistake all the time.

0

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

Nice removal of context lol. Respond to my examples.

1

u/saga999 Sep 19 '25

It's what critics do.

It's just their opinions. They disagree with each other all the time.

It's what philosophers do at times.

It's just their opinions. They disagree with each other all the time.

There is a reality (what we perceive) and then there is our experience of that perception.

People experience the same thing differently. For example, 2 people watch the same movie. They will have different opinions of it.

0

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

The fact people disagree doesn't mean there isn't a fact to disagree about.

You could even say "disagree ABOUT WHAT?"... the truth.

2

u/RedHotChiliCrab https://myanimelist.net/profile/RedHotChiliCrab Sep 19 '25

Depends hugely on the genre of a show.

Some action/adventure show might not be hurt by it as much as a mystery/thriller type of show. Doesn't mean one is better than the other.

2

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I agree, although I do think great mystery shows tend to be good because of a magnetic protagonist or villain, not necessarily because of the mystery itself. Take BBC Sherlock. Steller performances, insane pacing, amazing writing for the characters.

I watch it every year. Hasnt lost a bit of greatness now that I know what's going on. It's great because it's great. Period.

2

u/RedHotChiliCrab https://myanimelist.net/profile/RedHotChiliCrab Sep 19 '25

On rewatches you're getting something else out of it than you do on a first watch when the mystery plot itself is center stage.

It's what makes good mysteries so rewatchable. When you know the answers you can pay more attention to the characters and plot and see them in a new light.

When you get spoiled it doesn't just ruin the first watch experience, but also takes away from the experience of a rewatch where you can notice things you missed the first time.

2

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I love the knives out movies (new one coming out later this year already has a 100% on rotten tomatoes).

When I watched glass onion I was taken back by the twist and surprises toward the end.

However, if I had known what was going on, I still would've loved watching the detective- because he's objectively a wonderfully written character with wonderful dialogue. Every actor is amazing in their performance.

That mystery movie does have a good mystery, but that's certainly not the only reason to watch it.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I agree with all that.

3

u/oxlemf10 Sep 19 '25

I think it depends a lot from person to person, there are people who simply don't care at all about spoilers, just as receiving spoilers destroys the overall experience, personally I prefer not to receive spoilers

2

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I prefer not to. However, If I do and the show loses all merit because I know what will happen I would say that it was a bad show to begin with.

1

u/mrt90 Sep 19 '25

There's a massive gulf between "enjoyment is unaffected" and "show loses all merit". Most people would ideally like to get 100% of the enjoyment a show can offer them, not 70% or whatever.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I agree with that .. if that's the case then the show was probably pretty damn good.

If knowing spoilers does kill a show though, I think it wasn't well done to begin with.

3

u/Silcaria https://myanimelist.net/profile/Silcaria Sep 19 '25

Spoilers ruin the fun but indeed don't affect the quality of a piece of media. Thing is, the majority of people do consume entertainment purely for the fun factor.

-1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I can agree with that. I do think a shallow interpretation or exploration of a piece of art will make spoilers a bigger issue.

If you're really taking the time to appreciate the art in it's full expression, and it's great/well done, then spoilers will be far less of an issue.

Take something like spirited away...

I'll be able to watch that movie till I die. It destroys me every time.... Yet, I know the story.

It destroys me anyway, because the story is good- even though I know it. It destroys me because it's beautiful and deep, thoughtful and poetic...

I don't need shock and awe, although I appreciated it when I first watched it.

12

u/KenfoxDS Sep 19 '25

You can think whatever you want, but don't spoil anything for others.

1

u/86_Undertaker Sep 19 '25

First I have nothing against spoiler in generel and I get your points, but I can't see myself to agree with you "justifying" and downplaying spoiler.

What about characters which die throughout the anime or what about rly important scenes?
If I already know that this happens or that character dies my mindset is already set. Twists and turns won't have the impact they should and could have. Characters which I know will betray the MC(for example) are viewed different since the start, than if I knew nothing. Where are the suprises or moments where I can say: "Ah shit, now THAT makes sense" and "this is what they teased some episodes ago?!"?
Spoilers mostly take the thinking and excitement, because why should I try to use my brain if I already know what's gonna happen. Doesn't matter how good or how well written something is, the impact scenes and moments can have will not be the same.

"I think a story absolutely requiring the viewer/reader to go in blind to be interesting or enjoyable is a sign that that show is not very good."
Doesn't every show start like that? It's us viewers who decide if something is good or bad and especially when an anime aires all we have is a new product nobody knows how good or bad it will be. You want spoilers already at release? As if an anime studio decides to already upload scenes of ep5 on YT/Twitter when only the first one aired.

"The best mystery shows are interesting because of how the characters solve it, not because of the answer."
I can only agree half. Ofc the way mysteries are solved is fun to watch. But isn't the first thing we ask us what the mystery could be?
-An example is Detectiv Conan. Obviously I want to know HOW the killer did it and how Conan figures it out, but I also wanna know WHO did it.
-Another AoT. "Why are there titans in the walls?" I didn't ask myself first HOW they ended up in there, but WHY they are there. But mainly I don't wanna know beforehand that there actually are titans in the walls in the first place. Doesn't rly matter to know that when I start S1, but it takes the suprise when the anime presents me that fact. I won't be: "Whoa, titans in the walls?!", I'll just think:"Ah ye, that scene."

Maybe I went bit off rails here, it's just that this is how I understood your post.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

Good points all. Once again, not advocating for spoilers. Just saying that great shows don't lose value once you know the story. If something gets spoiled and everything else about a show is well done, it really shouldn't ruin the other things that are good. If it does, then they probably aren't actually good- but the intrigue was disguising that lack of quality. That's my assertion and I'm sticking to it lol.

I went into some of the "subject dependent" stuff on another post.

AOT actually spawned this whole idea so the example fits.

I'm not saying AOT isn't great... But I am saying that if knowing the answers to those questions takes that much away from the quality of the show... To me that's a sign that other factors are lacking.

People often say AOT is great on a rewatch, so I'm assuming there are other things that make it worth watching besides the questions you want answered.

3

u/CodAdministrative369 Sep 19 '25

this fully depends on the series and the person viewing it. So really no right answer. Spoilers can make you less motivated to finish it quicker or at all. I do think people who get really upset about spoilers when they are at the same time active in social media communities for anime or manga though need to chill. If i want to not be spoiled i legit stay away. You’re taking the risk of being around it

0

u/nuker1501 Sep 19 '25

is this post copium because you got spoiled

4

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

This post is in reaction to another post about AOT. That show in particular seems to get a lot of people who quit the show because of spoilers.

I have not finished AOT. I plan to. However, I think if the show is good it will stand on character development, good action, good dialogue, good philosophy, good depth, etc.

If knowing about Eren (which I do) ruins the show it is only because it doesn't have enough of the above.

This is coming from someone who has over a dozen movies and shows I rewatch a few times a year.

Knowing their endings doesn't matter if everything else is pitch perfect.

3

u/nuker1501 Sep 19 '25

I don't entirely disagree. naruto and aot were both spoiled to hell and back for me but I still thoroughly enjoyed them. that being said, I'd be lying if I pretended that knowing things in advance didn't ruin it a bit. when good writing is involved, spoilers go beyond just removing shock factor - it also strips away some enjoyment of the payoff that a built-up story offers. if it doesn't bother you that's great, wish I could say the same.

2

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

It's definitely great to get that shock value. I'm merely saying that a great story is great even after you've seen it. If it isn't, then IT wasn't great to begin with. It's the scary movie phenomenon... Scary movies are exhilarating because of how they are filmed... It's simple mechanics.

However, the fact that most horror films are literal garbage in terms of originality, acting, often special effects, writing, etc is literally so well attested it is kind of a running joke in pop culture.

Those movies are great examples of "one and done" because once you know the plot the movie has nothing to offer.

I'm just saying that great pieces of art keep giving far after you know what's going to happen.

1

u/nuker1501 Sep 19 '25

I'm merely saying that a great story is great even after you've seen it. If it isn't, then IT wasn't great to begin with.

I mean yea, our personal experiences e.g. getting spoiled will not affect the work and its objective value nor its subjective consensus, but it does affect how we perceive that work. so I'm not saying being spoiled makes the work worse, but it can, and often does, make our personal experience with it worse.

I also don't think spoilers are exactly analogous to the gimmicky nature you're alluding to with trashy horror, and the rewatchability factor is also something else entirely imo.

I do agree that good media should still be enjoyable after being spoiled though, like I said earlier.

1

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I can get behind all that.

I should have been more clear in saying that I'm talking about these shows that even their own fans seem to admit are just not watchable if you find out the ending or the twist beforehand.

I'm not saying that any loss from spoilers indicates a show isn't any good.

I'm talking about a show being ruined by spoilers, so that it's difficult to figure out what the point of watching it was to begin with.

1

u/nuker1501 Sep 19 '25

even their own fans seem to admit are just not watchable if you find out the ending or the twist

yea i see that as well and think it's stupid. if you're a fan of something, you shouldn't reduce its value to simply knowing how the plot progresses.

I'm talking about a show being ruined by spoilers, so that it's difficult to figure out what the point of watching it was to begin with.

gotcha. well I think you should also consider that people watch things for different reasons. I'm with you in that the point of watching something for me is to enjoy its artistic value, so spoilers isn't enough of a deterrent for me. but the thing is, most people really just watch something for entertainment. for those people, a plot twist or a great ending can be the crux of the experience, so being spoiled on it will remove reason to watch it for them.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

I think its funny youre getting blowback when spoiler culture is kind of a problem, some people really think "JUST WATCH THIS WITHOUT KNOWING ANYTHING" merits someone to watch something

Fate fans notoriously still live in a delusion that Fate isnt one of the biggest franchises in the world, that thousands of people know about fate from ways not the Visual novel even though by the nature of multimedia, that just isnt the case, and to shame someone who got into Fate not through Shirous story is some invalidating experience.

Just care about art, you aren't ruined by additional info before you get in, thats not a good way to live

You are right, but also your post kind of isnt that in depth so you wont get thoughtful responses, but I get you

2

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

Thank you. Like I said, I'm not celebrating spoilers... I just don't think knowing info about the show will ruin a good show.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

Its crazy we just can't talk about it, when youre online and in fandom or not, with your youtubes and instas and anything else, even if you just have a friend who likes talking about their love, you will learn about something whether you wanted to or not. The rising idea of a "pure" experience is more harmful than just being "ok, are you still gonna engage the show though"

2

u/gcbofficial Sep 19 '25

Spoilers are terrible, no exception or rant will change this

1

u/Janitalia Sep 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

crazy how the post isnt about getting spoiled by assholes

-1

u/Breakdown007 Sep 19 '25

what's even your point? that's such a dumb post. People don't want to hear/read spoilers so respect that.

5

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I was clear about my point lol. I think if spoilers ruin a show, or if a show isn't as good on further viewings because you know the story, that is a sign that the show isn't very good.

I think some writers leverage shock and awe to make up for shallow characters, bad dialogue, or a bad narrative.

That's my point. Thanks for your contribution.

Also, I never said we should go around spoiling great twists and turns for people. I only said a really great story is great for a bunch of reasons, not just because it presents a black box and says "don't you want to see what's inside this?"

0

u/Breakdown007 Sep 19 '25

why are you writing this? are you trying to justify spoiling because "a show isn't good if a spoiler ruins it"?

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

Did he say to spoil people? I think its pretty clear what was said, and the fact something mundade as this is getting the reaction it is says a lot mroe about you than them.

Meanwhile the nature of spoilers in the online world and how fandoms choose to react around them is pretty important

0

u/Breakdown007 Sep 19 '25

So what's OP trying to say then? Ever thought about why it's called "spoiling"?

3

u/NothingFit7091 Sep 19 '25

I just reiterated it. Why don't you get it?

I'm saying that I think great shows are inherently "spoiler proof" because the voice acting, the dialogue, the animation, the lessons, the experience of seeing that expression of art displayed... Because if all of those things are well done the show will be wonderful on its 10th watch through.

If hearing some banter about a show online just ruins the show, or if seeing the show once ruins it for further viewings, then I don't think the show is likely to have done all the things I just listed well.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

oh sorry, I can't spoil it

0

u/headphones_J Sep 19 '25

Bro, just don't spoil stuff for people.