r/anime • • Sep 19 '25

Discussion I Hate The Water Magician With Every Fiber of My Being Spoiler

Spoiler Warnings for the Show!

when I was young I used to really love watching wrestling, but one day I figured something out that completely destroyed my love of it and No, it's not the fact that it's fake that destroyed it for me. It's the fact that one day I realized that nothing substantial was ever going to happen on a non-pay-per-view event. we didn't have a lot of money growing up so there's no way my parents were ever going to Shell out money for a pay-per-view event (this is mostly before the internet) but I could at least watch raw and SmackDown and enjoy that stuff

and then week after week

month after month

things just kept on not... happening...

The Rock was never going to beat Triple H on raw, Stone Cold Steve Austin was never going to do anything other than talk a bunch of trash, and I'll never see a match with Goldberg that lasts more than 2 minutes...

That's when it occurred to me that every single episode of raw and SmackDown was nothing but an ad for the next pay-per-view event and that's when my love of wrestling died.

Enter the water magician: A show that is so clearly intended on doing nothing but directing your attention towards the light novel that I have no idea why they didn't just spend the money on Facebook/YouTube advertisements or something.

The protagonist is quite possibly the lamest overpowered protagonist in the history of the genre, he spent a quarter of the series in a library studying alchemy (and kind of sort of a little bit flirting with an elf girl) while side characters that to this day I don't know their names. we're off fighting epic battles. as of episode 11 they committed an entire episode to a side character that was just introduced a couple of episodes ago.

I totally understand that this is hardly the first anime that has served as a vehicle for a light novel but it's by far the worst and most blatant that I've ever seen try to do it. the creators of this series do understand that they need to craft something compelling for me to even have the desire to buy a light novel, right? why on Earth would I possibly want to further explore this world that is so boring and lame and formulaic? I mean if you're going to make a shameless isekai power fantasy, at least make it gratuitous and entertaining.

Sorry for the stream of consciousness post. I don't normally do long posts at all but I just really hate this show and needed to get this off my chest.

3.9k Upvotes

820 comments sorted by

4

u/Infinite-Ad359 Sep 22 '25

My partner and I have been joking that this is actually a slice of life anime for the main character only.

15

u/IcyAnt9279 Sep 19 '25

I agree with you OP. Unlikeable OP and weird relationships. What is the point of this.

1

u/Western_Promise3063 Sep 19 '25

as far as I can tell it's nothing but a Time Vampire.

2.7k

u/EstablishmentOne3884 Sep 19 '25

I love this. I live for this shit. This is the kind of raw, unfiltered, "funny because it's true" loathing for a show I love to read about.

Well done.

959

u/Padulsky21 Sep 20 '25

I haven’t watched a single episode but I know this shit is genuine when it brings up childhood trauma like that 😭

538

u/Boris-_-Badenov Sep 20 '25

first two episodes were rushed, but pretty good.

then they got to the major town, and mc got sidelined. whole monster stampede outbreak from a dungeon, and MC's best friend that knows he is the strongest guy in town doesn't even mention him... MC's just doing research at the library while the rest of the guild (even the lowest) are fighting.

MC's friend keeps telling his party how great he is, and the amazing spells he can do, but instead of asking for a demonstration it's just "that can't be possible" followed by "you'll see eventually"

360

u/GigaVanguard Sep 20 '25

He’s getting Potential Man’d in his own show?????? That’s too fucking funny man

→ More replies (19)

91

u/Padulsky21 Sep 20 '25

I love me my trash isekai/fantasy anime worlds and I can get through a lot of them but it’s funny how it sounds like it just stalls the entire show. Unfortunately theres at least one like this each season and that formula happens a lot. A lot of them work on me but I didn’t even bother here so I’m glad I didn’t

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/dungfeeder Sep 20 '25

I saw the first episode when it started to air, and i already felt the bs in the air. Was hyped for it after the trailer but they just couldn't pull it off.

→ More replies (1)

132

u/TheBlackViper_Alpha Sep 20 '25

It had potential. It was one of those shows where we have a generic plot OP MC isekai. But if done right it would've been a great show. See 7th prince, its a generic show about an OP MC but man that show's pacing and overall production delivers. I think most power fantasy stories falls into this trap (TBATE *cough *cough). If Frieren or Mushokou Tensei didn't have the production it had it would've also been fallen to obscurity.

106

u/EstablishmentOne3884 Sep 20 '25

I was so surprised by how much I ended up loving 7th Prince. Completely overturned all the negative bias I had when I gave it the smallest chance to impress me.

And impress me it did.

→ More replies (11)

81

u/FlameDragoon933 Sep 20 '25

what's TBATE?

also I disagree on Frieren. Even with less stellar production value it's still very much not a generic isekai, nor it is a powerfantasy. At worst there will be more complaints about "nothing happening" by shonen/powerfantasybros because there's less visual gem to placate them, but the core of the story will still shine through.

70

u/higorga09 Sep 20 '25

There's also the obvious issue that Frieren is not an isekai at all

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

53

u/poislayer342 Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

*Mindlessly upvoted for mentioning 7th Prince to praise it*

The manga got licensed so ppl can't discuss in manga sub anymore, so I am glad that anime sub can appreciate it.

also saying that about Frieren and Mushoku is wild. Sure they may not have the presence they had now without the epic anime adaptation but those 2 were already popular enough. Fallen to obscurity is a crazy take.

→ More replies (6)

42

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

If Frieren or Mushokou Tensei didn't have the production it had it would've also been fallen to obscurity.

Nah, I read Frieren a couple years ago and said it was the first masterpiece manga I've seen made in the last 10 years. The mangaka is a very good writer.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/mucklaenthusiast Sep 20 '25

I don’t actually think 7th prince is that generic.

Or rather, I’d be careful using such words.

Of course, the production value is incredible for that show, but from the set-up (not an isekai), to a lot of the world building (e.g. how dungeons live) to the bigger lore that is implied at points, I really don’t think it’s that generic.

I mean, we just got an absurdist comedy episode about an invincible pig that wants to be eaten.

I think a lot of good shows seem more generic than they are. Water Magician is just that generic.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (2)

403

u/LeVin1986 Sep 19 '25

I'll be honest, the flashback threw for a loop, and I was confused to the point where I thought for good 10 minutes that Oscar was Abel.

46

u/Wild_Card_626 Sep 20 '25

I thought they were gonna reveal that Abel's name was originally Oscar, but something happened that forced him to change it. Turns out it was just the recently introduced fire guy.

10

u/Galinhooo Sep 20 '25

The fire guy has been hinted at since early on, but I guess it could be harder to make the link unless you see his hair changing color in the opening and/or his high affinity for fire.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

59

u/Mysterious-Mud-7862 Sep 20 '25

I’m glad I’m not alone!

56

u/Oh-its-Tuesday Sep 20 '25

There are too many similar looking red headed dudes in this show. 

31

u/allen_antetokounmpo Sep 20 '25

yeah my first thought after watching this sudden backstory "did i miss an episode?", and because oscar is barely introduced, i didnt even know whose backstory is it at first

5

u/Ginger_Tea Sep 20 '25

And the fact he's got shockingly white hair as an adult.

It somehow changed as he was once again running from the destruction of his home.

It's like the first time Witch Watch opened with the Anime her friend and teacher love. I was unsure if I had the wrong file. Second time they did it, I knew what was up.

6

u/Difergion Sep 20 '25

The episode title kinda gave it away but I remembered that the current Oscar looked like Amakusa Shirou from Fate and didn’t have red hair, so I also got confused for a bit.

It doesn’t help much that kid Oscar looked like Abel lol

→ More replies (2)

1.2k

u/Dolomite808 Sep 19 '25

I really wanted to like The Water Magician, and I'm definitely going to finish the season, but man, they aren't making it easy.

The early episodes were really fun for me, and then they got to the town and the MC was basically a side character. I just want a cute fantasy romance between the OP MC and cool elf lady, but NOOOO, we get backstories for every side character, cliffhangers galore, and basically not much water magic.

I think the thing that hurts the most is that it just feels like a lot of squandered potential.

171

u/greatestNothing Sep 19 '25

isn't he basically immortal as well? that's why i thought the elf thing was going to happen. they got a long time together.

216

u/Dolomite808 Sep 19 '25

He has "Eternal Youth" as shown in the first episode. I'd love a version of this story where he and the elf just wander the world as the ages pass them by.

88

u/CuriousMika Sep 19 '25

Yeah, I also am curious how long he was actually at his cottage since he isn’t aware of his eternal youth that I wonder if he was actually there longer than he originally thought

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/saskir21 Sep 20 '25

The elf thing could happen. The first pages of the Manga shows him kissing someone resembling her. Interestingly she did not show up ever since in the Manga and I think I read Volume 3 or 4 (for the life of me I can not recall how far the Englisch translation is).

→ More replies (1)

245

u/PeaceAlien https://myanimelist.net/profile/PeaceAlien Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

I’ve liked it, I joke the MC has become Saitama. Everyone struggles then he shows up and easily defeats them.

145

u/CuriousMika Sep 19 '25

I thought this too but see the water magician doesn’t actually see himself as strong and thinks people are just pulling his leg. Where saitama knows he is OP and struggles with not finding other strong foes.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/psppsppsppspinfinty Sep 19 '25

My bf did bring up if the series was trying to be like OPM.

→ More replies (10)

8

u/54yroldHOTMOM Sep 19 '25

Haha I was going to mention one punch as well. Second season was Saitama doing weird stuff while the world around him crumbled without him seeying it lol. The first time watching it week to week waiting for a new episode was excruciating… the second time watching it with my son was fun. Because we could binge it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/heimdal77 Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

[Water mag regarding the mc and elf. A lot of spoilers.]They do basically become a couple and everyone from the town they live in and knows them know it. He lets her know whenever he will be leaving town for something. They spend time together basically every day for at the very least sparring though usually also spending time together and eating together. They are in another place where a big battle happens and the elf ends up fighting alone vs a big baddie that should been above her weight class but leaves her spent while having others to fight. He realizes she is in danger and just obliterates everything in the way to get to her where he takes her into his arms and hugs her and she relaxes into his arms holding on to him. There is even a princess caryy. A friend of Able develops a sudden crush on Sera and Able immediately tries to warn him off as everyone knows no one should try and get between the two.! Able at one point thought Sera had spent the night with mc when he sees her leaving his place early in the morning. Anime is unlikely to reach any of this and might have skipped some.

69

u/ZaraReid228 Sep 20 '25

Forgive me for saying this but man that sounds absolutely garbage

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Big_Distance2141 Sep 20 '25

"Basically a couple (but not actually)" is one of the worst tropes I know

5

u/Nilah_Joy Sep 20 '25

I’ve heard the LN is better since it’s actually okay and detailed, the anime is just cutting stuff and speeding it up from what it feels like.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/quaketoys Sep 20 '25

I’ve read the books (LN, manga and WN) and was SO looking forward to this! Welp, as often happens, the anime is poorly done. Not that what they showed doesn’t happen (kinda) but they’ve somehow managed to strip out absolutely everything else except only those few things that they happen to show. From whole characters to entire motivations to 98% of everything else, it’s just butchered out and sometimes changed to try to make sense of what’s left that they’re showing.

Compared to The Cleric or The Wrong Way To Use Healing Magic or Heretical Villainess to I May Be The Hidden Boss Level 99 to Bookworm to Campfire Cooking to Black Summoner to Journey Through Another World to Unwanted Undead Adventurer to Neglected Noble to Omnipotent Saint to 80,000 Gold, to Fluffy Paradise to Skeleton Knight to VRMMO life to Tsukimichi to Cautious Hero to My Instant Death Ability to 7th Prince to Slime (ok I watch/read too much anime and there’s more but that’s all I could think of at the moment) to any other decently entertaining isekai. It’s not always enough budget or a good story, it’s also the director hacking away at the books and deciding what stays in and what gets left out.

I just don’t understand any of the decisions made. It’s like someone who read this some time ago remembered the story kinda, told the director what parts they liked, and the director didn’t bother to read any of it. And it’s a shame because it’s a really fun story with great world building and incredible characters. This is only part one too. The whole story shifts/changes/develops and we haven’t even met some of the best people but because of how poorly this was done this will probably never get another season or remade as it deserves.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/froggyc19 Sep 20 '25

Not to mention the disappointment of the animation. The OP looks beautiful but then the show itself is a bit of a mess.

10

u/ChocolateGoggles Sep 19 '25

I enjoyed it from Episode 2 and maybe until Episode 8 or something. The first episode was absolute trash, they rushed through everything and nothing felt impactful. Me and my friend were laughing through the episode and decided to drop it. Many liked it, and that's ok, but I cannot understand why.

However, I read some comments from others and gave it another chance, and while it's been OK it hasn't really been anything special. I've enjoyed those episodes more than I thought I would but the novelty wore off and the writing turned out to really just be maybe 1 level above the worst Isekais from the start of this year. The animation has been decent at times at least.

7

u/celinor_1982 Sep 20 '25

Yea kinda felt the same about "I left My A-Rank Party to Help My Former Students Reach the Dubgeon Depths", it was nice, the first few episodes

I was like, that's cool. The guy gonna just help them level and dungeon crawl... than it got weird with the story, and then the odd tension I guess between all the women with the MC and the weird quote he keeps saying every damn time with the finger flick or whatever. Then, by episode 10, I was like, god, this show sucks.. I managed to slog through to 16 and just dropped it at that point.

Weird on the story cause it went from, I'm just going to help, to bro literally being the guy to save the entire multiverse, like wtf.

The idea is very unique, but I dont think the author knows what they are trying to do really. Cause I liked the idea of parties gaining fame through the weird floating go-cameras.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/charistraz95 Sep 19 '25

SAME i loved the start it was great then it got delayed recap episode. now we r getting flashbacks backstories for every character and we r getting episodes where absolutely nothing happens not even world building im fine if the MC isnt in the episode or 2 and we have actual world building or action but not doing nothing of substance like come on

8

u/FrazzleMind Sep 20 '25

Are you telling me you didn't enjoy 15 minutes of side character backstory that could be distilled down into a few short sentences?

Peasant boy with some fire magic has a happy life, but a certain bandit group slaughters the whole village. MC narrowly escapes and is adopted by a Lord. Just as things were looking up, it turns out the same bandit group has slaughtered the whole Noble household too. Peasant boy manages to escape, now with white hair from the trauma.

Are you saying that this wasn't worth 3/4 of the second to last episode?

5

u/phasmy Sep 20 '25

I like the show and the entire concept of it but the author is not good at writing...

→ More replies (12)

87

u/krunchytacos Sep 19 '25

They changed the MC's personality in the anime. He's kind of an asshole in the light novel.

173

u/Wild_Obligation3265 Sep 20 '25

I think I would prefer an asshole to a blank slate.

25

u/Atharaphelun Sep 21 '25

A blank slate that only appears for a minute or less each episode, if at all.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '25

His anime version is more tame than the jack-ass personality he displays in the novel…practically every dialogue with him is some awkward insult meant to be disguised as a joke

6

u/Anvilrocker Oct 08 '25

He's still kind of an asshole, even if its toned down. Able cops so much flak from him for no real reason. It could be seen as banter, but half the time its out of left field and Able is left trying to smooth it over with others so they don't get offended. Then again, he's perpetually a 17 year old boy from the 21st century, you just know he was a turd online in his previous life lol. I don't know why so many authors think that's a good age to be an OP protag, 17yr old's in general don't normally have nearly enough life experience or emotional maturity to handle the the events and situations they find themselves in with this genre.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

41

u/Iwasseriousface Sep 25 '25

That explains the CRAZY personality swap in today's episode. I was so confused why he wasn't even attempting to like...use his words and just threaten to freeze an unconscious woman to get vengeance.

9

u/alanbtg Sep 20 '25

Could you give an example? I'm curious.

51

u/AlterWanabee Sep 20 '25

He kills people without blinking. His first reaction when he saw someone bullying his party was send ice spears straight into their guts. He experiments with freezing people for fun.

32

u/Succundo Sep 20 '25

Damn, and I thought he came across as a robotic psychopath in the anime, that is significantly worse, but it does give context to how his first reaction upon seeing any new creature is to try to kill it just to see if he can.

→ More replies (7)

40

u/krunchytacos Sep 20 '25

Basically just constant snarky comments or weird jokes, mostly at Abel's expense. It's probably intended to be witty banter. But, it comes off like the friend that doesn't realize his jokes aren't jokes anymore.

25

u/BoBab Sep 20 '25

Oh, that's kind of in the anime still...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

431

u/IIEarlGreyII :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IIEarlGreyII Sep 19 '25

That half the last episode was dedicated to an uninteresting side character WHO ALREADY TOLD US THEIR BACKSTORY had me fuming as well.

This weird low level party Rio is in has no place in this series, I am sorry. They just introduced a lot of interesting new characters, I would rather Rio get more involved with them.

80

u/jawaunw1 Sep 20 '25

Everything about the latest episode is one of the worst story designs I've ever seen in my life. A back story for a character we've only known for two episodes takes up 16 minutes. In this episode the main characters appear only for like a minute and a half in total screen time. And even the person who we got the backstory to has less than 5 minutes of total on screen time if you don't count the backstory.

It's such a glaring waste of an episode even attention at the end isn't there because the drama is fake entirely do we really think that this guy is just going to randomly attack them when he can clearly see two dead assassins like 10 ft away. Or are they just gone now as an excuse for drama so he can fight the main character it's forced ridiculously so.

6

u/Cryten0 Sep 20 '25

You know what? the background isnt even from the same novels volume. At least the one it was currently in and the next (where my brain died of boredom waiting for something good to be written). I think it might be from a spinoff novel following the Inferno Mage.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

30

u/DirectAttorney670 Sep 19 '25

Fr. I think the intend was to make the audience feel Bad for him but personally i was Just enoyed even more after skipping half the Episode waiting to continue the story 

42

u/IIEarlGreyII :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IIEarlGreyII Sep 19 '25

I sat through it assuming there would be a point.

There. Was. Not.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

We didn’t know the backstory of Oscar at all….

Also, the next episode is hopefully going to be the strongest for mage vs the MC (water Mage)… since the cliff hanger is the fire mage about to attack the three low level friends.

26

u/eatnhappens Sep 20 '25

Yeah it was a rather drawn, repetitive backstory though with… maybe I missed it but was there any buildup of the relationship with the princess??!

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/darthvall :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/darth_vall Sep 19 '25

Wait, that guy had already told us his back story? Could you remind me when?

26

u/scratchfury Sep 20 '25

I’m wondering if they have confused Oscar with another character whose hair hasn’t turned from red to white.

→ More replies (1)

218

u/81Ranger Sep 19 '25

My interest in this show has decreased as the season went on.  

There's not much there there for the MC.  He's just a cardboard cutout wandering around with OP powers 

The cute elf girl carried it for a few episodes.  Some of Abel's party look like they might be decent characters but they're barely there.

People seem to be mentioning the world building, but ... dunno.

It's fit into a mindless low stakes junk food show watch if that's what I'm in the mood for.  

Nothing more than that.

54

u/Money_Statement_9861 Sep 20 '25

I just can't connect his motivation of jumping at things because it has fantasy tropes knowing he spent like 100 years doing nothing knowing it was a fantasy world. It feels contrived to make the wet paper bag actually want to do something that involves other people.

He was training with some magical creature all that time and never even thought of looking for anything new until he's with other people for minor things like skeletons?

12

u/NarwhalPrudent6323 Sep 20 '25

No, he wasn't interested in leaving. He was happy with the quiet life he had asked for upon reincarnating. Even when Abel first found him, Ryo still didn't really want to go with him, and only did to help him out. He laments the loss of his quiet life alone several times. Now that he has left, he's enjoying it, because why wouldn't he? 

62

u/TheAllKnowingElf Sep 20 '25

"World building" is cope for anime with shit mc's. Honestly I could tell from the first episode it was going to be bad and I'm mostly skipping through the episodes right now. I don't even know why I still watch it. I hate the main character's personality from the bottom of my heart (still somehow not the worst personality of an isekai mc)

35

u/PrizeStrawberryOil Sep 20 '25

"World building" is cope for anime with shit mc's.

Definitely true, but water magician doesn't even have that.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/JahIthBeer Sep 20 '25

"World building" is cope for anime with shit mc's

I have never heard that to be honest. One of my first go to praises for the likes of HxH, Made in Abyss, Dorohedoro, Moribito (Guardian of the Spirit), Fullmetal Alchemist etc. is the world building and I don't consider those MCs to be bad at all

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/MumrikDK Sep 20 '25

People seem to be mentioning the world building

The world is completely generic game style Isekai setup.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/eatnhappens Sep 20 '25

The animation quality felt smooth and I just really wanted this to work… if they get more seasons I could see this into season but it’s tough for me to picture much success at the current time.

24

u/Lockedontargetshow Sep 20 '25

You don't want more seasons. The strongest part of the novel is the first book. This author does not write very satisfying resolutions and does a lot of things that don't make sense. Lets just say I don't know a single person that is happy with how arc 1 ends and Abel gets a pretty unflattering nickname in the webnovel community for what he does.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Wild_Card_626 Sep 20 '25

Animation was only smooth for the first few episodes, but once they reached civilization it started going down hill. They started taking many short cuts and over using shaky cameras on still images. A technique used to make it seem like action is happening on screen, but not really.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/n080dy123 Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

No idea how you figure it's trying to direct anyone to an LN. Its just not interested in selling you gratuitous which is actually why I like it. There aren't enough straight fantasy anime out there that aren't interesting in being vehicles for a power fantasy just like actual Isekai. This one has that powerful protagonist but isn't interested in him just running about bitch-slapping everything into the ground. He's a bit bland himself but the fact he's more interested in researching more about the plot in the library instead of running headfirst into the problem is actually something I appreciate. And him not needing to be a massive elephant in the room for every major plot beat means the side characters, who are usually afterthoughts in Isekai, get time to be fleshed out.

9

u/Western_Promise3063 Sep 19 '25

If this was the old days and this anime was 26 episodes I would agree with you and all of those points would be fine but the problem is it's a 12-episode anime...

→ More replies (2)

28

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

We get to watch the water magician as he does everything but cast water magic.

23

u/Megakruemel Sep 20 '25

"Water magic? Oh yeah, that's me! Check this out!" *Does Ice Magic

3

u/Saiphaz Sep 19 '25

So... your complaint is that it's trash but not the kind of trash you like?

19

u/tapdancinghellspawn Sep 19 '25

I wonder if the writer had trouble with the Overpowered Protagonist syndrome. If your main character can surmount any problem easily then it becomes uninteresting to develop the character. I think the same happened with ONE who wrote One Punch Man.

29

u/EdibleScissors Sep 20 '25

OP man is funny, though, but its actual strength is that the side characters are interesting. At least Saitama badly wants something and it’s easy for many of us to want Saitama to get an exciting fight no matter how unlikely it is for that to happen.

Water Magician has an issue with meaningful stakes when it is hard to care about why anything is happening. What does he actually care about? Who knows? Does it matter at this point? Who knows!

→ More replies (2)

108

u/gem2niki Sep 19 '25

I only like the opening...wasted potential.

72

u/the_3rdist Sep 20 '25

The MC's journey with Abel was the best part of the show and the OP had more of, and that's why I like the OP.

31

u/gem2niki Sep 20 '25

I was really expecting the show to be about their journey, but that was short-lived.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/EdibleScissors Sep 19 '25

That janky strut that everyone has is pretty funny admittedly.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/81Ranger Sep 19 '25

Funny, I enjoy the ED - skip the OP.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/LordAxalon110 Sep 20 '25

Yeah I really enjoyed the opening song as well, which is rare for me cos I don't tend to even bother with them anymore haha.

→ More replies (2)

36

u/Omeirawana Sep 19 '25

I got bored a few ep in, so I dropped it.

72

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

Its a guilty pleasure watch. Light hearted, chill, predictable. 

With that said, those things certainly make it not stand out, and it will be forgotten by next season.

Really in the first episode, maybe two, I did have my hopes up. It was different. The characters were in a wilderness and really you could have made the entire first season just about their adventure trying to get to the rest of civilization.

18

u/SuspiciousPine Sep 20 '25

I do like how straight-forward the story is. Light-hearted main character mostly having a good time with people he befriends.

Maybe I got burned too hard by the insane negativity of Shield Hero, but Water Magician is really getting me in the "cozy show" vibe

6

u/poislayer342 Sep 20 '25

Shield Hero is basically negativity for the sake of it. I can't ever take it seriously.

Cozy is sleep slop.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

45

u/TheAllKnowingElf Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

The protagonist is quite possibly the lamest overpowered protagonist in the history of the genre

The anime is bad but... there are worse isekais out there.

The funniest thing was last episode they made a character with a great backstory for a fantasy protag... but it's not the mc XD it's like they are showing it to your face "look what could have been if this anime was good and not isekai garbage"

btw OP if you are into wrestling you should watch Kemono Michi or Faraway Palladin. Trust me I know all about anime

18

u/APRengar Sep 20 '25

There was an isekai like last season or the one before that where the Mc was so deathly afraid of talking to women he entered a epileptic state just saying hello. And it happens every time, taking up minutes of episodes of just stuttering.

If were talking about lame protags, it's that guy. And I refuse any other answer.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Nikadaemus Sep 20 '25

Faraway Paladin is epic.  

11

u/Zoulogist Sep 19 '25

Now all the big wrestling stuff happens on tv instead of PPVs

4

u/WorstGanksKR Sep 20 '25

Therapy, you need it badly. God damn.

21

u/SistarsCoser Sep 20 '25

Im more disappointed at it's animation. The OP animation is like a bait plus the first 3 episodes. All bait and then we're fed with slideshows and below avg animation.

15

u/WiqidBritt Sep 19 '25

This is a quality rant.

120

u/excluded Sep 19 '25

I personally like it. I also love the great cleric which a lot of people seem to hate.

World building for me is a big thing (is why I love overlord), but having side characters actually do stuff and not have the main character hog everything (also which I hate about overlord) is just perfect for me.

Though the elf waifu not having screen time despite being prominent in the ending song is kinda weird ngl.

12

u/SuperDabMan Sep 20 '25

Great Cleric is great no jokes but it's very different from Water Magician. I ended up reading all the LNs.

21

u/TheEVILPINGU Sep 19 '25

I don't agree that Ainz does everything. Many side characters in there actually has their own stories and stuff they do.

→ More replies (5)

87

u/bigmean3434 Sep 19 '25

Try clevatess . It is this seasons sleeper

33

u/excluded Sep 19 '25

I love that show and am excited for season 2 since it got announced.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/ShoupyDoo Sep 20 '25

I think most of us are criticizing it because the world building has been very sporadic and not cohesive. Interesting elements but I don’t think any of it has tied together yet. Pretty much same for the side characters. I don’t think people necessarily mind side characters getting lots of screen time, but these side characters are pretty generic and boring. The ones that do have potential are not fleshed out well before the author moves on to yet another. Author has put a whole lot of quantity over quality into the work. Lots of potential but fails terribly on execution.

10

u/Melodic_Twist_1546 Sep 20 '25

I also love the great cleric which a lot of people seem to hate.

I really enjoyed The Great Cleric. That character actually trained and accomplished things. We saw his growth.

This Water Magician show is just baffling.

First two shows were fine. Now it is as though they are going out of their way to NOT talk about him. I wasn't even sure what was happening in the first 10 minutes this week.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Enter_My_Fryhole Sep 19 '25

I love it for the world building too. I think pacing is a bit slow however, so that hurts it for me. Overall, I look forward to the new episode more than other anime im watching. Clevatess, anki, gachiakuta, call of the night are just a few of the bangers this season. Water magician just has legs, its a healthy mix of isekai and slow life animes. Just maybe a little too slow as I mentioned.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/darthvall :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/darth_vall Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

High five dude! Love both Water Magician and the Great Cleric. I think both are wonderful spin of the usual OP isekai protagonist, instead of the usual boring MC.

I also like the focus on side characters in the Water Magician, while people being frustrated by Ryo's lack of appearance (LOL).

Both are my top watch list of the day when there are several anime airing.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/SomeRandomJoe81 Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

I like the Great Cleric and have watched it multiple times. I am currently rewatching Wrong Way to Use Healing Magic for the 3rd time.

I hate this show and just dumped it.

edit:Took a moment to sit and think about where my irrational rage at this show stems from and came up with the following.

I don’t think we’ve got a clear answer on what the Fairy King’s whole deal is or what’s up with the asura. He’s got a smart as hell elf waifu and a trusted seasoned adventurer he could ask. Doesn’t have to tell either of them that he fought one.

I don’t mind having fleshed out side characters but maybe having a veteran party AND a rookie party to follow is a bit much. I honestly don’t care about the rookies and they’re just riding MC’s coat tails anyways.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/OddReason9030 Sep 19 '25

It has pacing problems but it's decent. Wish they'd get back to the water magician water magicianing.

32

u/fun_until_you_lose Sep 20 '25

Saying this show has pacing problems is like saying a double amputee has a leg injury. Technically accurate but really downplays the severity.

5

u/Atharaphelun Sep 21 '25

Don't you worry, the final episode will be a triple flashback for those three noob adventurers that are traveling with Ryo for the mission.

5

u/APRengar Sep 20 '25

Yeah, first like 4 episodes I think were very good and then it fell off a cliff.

MC and the Swordsman had good chemistry and were fun to follow.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/PickledPokute Sep 20 '25

I haven't watched the anime, but LN is an interesting change of pace.

Ryo isn't a perfect charmer that skillfully makes everyone around him into allies. He has a lot of quirks that make many other people guarded around him and his obviously overblown trope expectations make suffering him as a reader a bit difficult. He holds to his weird principles quite well.

While the series has the problem that almost nothing in the world happens without Ryo being somewhere nearby, he isn't always in the center of events and often misses important parts. Ryo also lacks initiative in conversations and investigations, which nerfs him a bit and prevents him to just skipping to the bosses. Instead more often he passively waits for something interesting to happen around him.

Other characters in LN aren't tightly coupled to the MC, which I like. They have their own storylines and goals which directly might not clash at all with those of Ryo. He often though just happens to be in the general area. This clashes quite hard with how long Ryo was the center of storytelling though. The scope of the story grows way too fast. Abel, the Princess, Oscar, the adventuring party from far away, the Rogue and various enemies are refreshingly focused in their own things.

One conflicting thing I don't like is that Ryo eventually ends up embroiled in most catastrophes happening around him, and while he can't prevent what's happening, he eventually stumbles to the event and while not fixing it, he will mitigate it, preventing total destruction. If Ryo wasn't present, most of the locations would've been utterly devastated.

The LN has the problem that Ryo doesn't have a good goal for the reader to follow and cheer him on. "I wonder what he stumbles upon next" only carries so far. The other characters carry more of the burden there, but keeping Ryo with his overpoweredness in the vicinity kinda clashes with it.

33

u/DirectAttorney670 Sep 19 '25

Personally I think it's okay. Not great but also Not the worst.  Ive Heard people say that in the light novel there is way more Action but considering how op the MC is I doubt it.  I still Look foward to new episodes but episode like the last one make me considering dropping it.

5

u/charistraz95 Sep 19 '25

kinda like one piece cause in the manga u dont have the slow camera panning over everyones face and doing a flashback every 5 secs xD

5

u/darthvall :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/darth_vall Sep 19 '25

Not a novel reader, but since some of what Ryo could do is very technical then I imagine by more "action" it's just explaining the detail and mechanism of his magic when he used it. Basically a 7 paragraphs (hyperbole!) Of battle scene that's actually only 1/2 minute of action time if being visualised real time or something like that.

29

u/Shimmitar Sep 19 '25

yeah its very generic and mediocre show, but for some dumb reason i find it somewhat interesting, at least for now. ill probably get bored with it. Idk why they keep producing garbage anime.

6

u/BippityBoppityBooppp Sep 19 '25

It’s one of those shows I’ll put on when I’m folding laundry, just a filler to pass the time. It’s not riveting enough that I have to rewind if I miss a scene but more interesting than like YouTube

→ More replies (3)

12

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

I personally really like the MC, as his personality excuses why he isn’t present when things are going on…

It feels like he is being set up for a personality change as time goes on cause right now he doesn’t seem fully engaged in his second world. I kind of like that about his character.

Personally, if I remembered my current life and was rebooted into a new reality, I don’t think I would immediately make meaningful connections… but I would be interested in the mechanics/lore of my new reality. I’d probably be really distant and noncommittal. In fact, I’d probably debate if it were alright for me to interfere with anything… since it’s not my actual world even though it is my new reality.

He isn’t trying to be a hero, and he only slightly seems to care about the other characters (it’s not clear if he sees people in this world as characters or actual people imo). I kind of hate when isekia characters immediately take on some cause/mission to save the world. This character is just going with the flow (for now), but isn’t committed to anyone or anything. 

It feels like he is just digesting things and slightly scheming in a weird way. Everyone keeps calling this character flat, but I keep thinking this character is hiding a lot just beneath the surface. We are just seeing what all the side characters are seeing (happy go lucky and strong), but the MC is way too focused and observant as a character to actually be that way inside. This character isn’t dumb but he sure likes to play it up for everyone. 

I get he is from another world, however, he has shown to be quick in the uptake… but still outwardly plays REALLY dumb. It feels put on and I personally think it works for the character. It adds depth in my opinion.

He kind of just smiles and jokes things off… which is a great way to maintain good relations without actually getting emotionally attached to anyone. I kind of feel this would be my approach in a new world (at least at first).

He isn’t out right inhumane (as if he was playing a video game), but he doesn’t seem to be treating this new world like it’s reality. He just pursues his interests and enjoys learning the lore/secrets of the world. Kind of like he is reading a book, which he is hinted as doing in his original life.

I get he asked for an easy going life, but that has already come and gone (eternal youth)… either he isn’t fully recognizing this new world as “his” to fully exist in, or he is slowly catching his bearings and start being proactive at some point in the future.

Also, I think the pacing is perfect. It took time to develop technique, it takes time to travel, and it’s taking time for him to learn alchemy. I also think it’s taking time for him to actually truly care about the other characters, as he is lukewarm at best with the side characters.

We get to watch the side characters exist in their world while the MC is slowly exploring interests and really coming to the reality this is also truly “his” world too.

My one wish would be for the side characters to be way more suspicious of his intentions. I mean guy that strong just hanging out as a low level adventurer, reading books on alchemy? At least that one flame adventurer from the other A adventuring group seems to be keeping an eye on him (and others).

By yeah…. That’s just my take on the character and his seeming lack of motivation.

8

u/SunnyBunny525 Sep 20 '25

As a light novel reader, if you haven’t read it and only watched the anime, I can say you are spot on!

The MC is actually very smart and calculating but plays and jokes around when interacting with people, like his banters with Abel. I was disappointed with how little it shows in the anime, they make him seem a little flippant.

He also cares for the people he sees as friends, but in his own way. I also like how he does his own thing instead of running around, shoving his OP power down people’s throats trying to be a hero and saving the world.

I feel, from reading the light novel, his personality is actually a lot crueler than the anime makes him seem. Like you said, he isn’t outright inhumane, but he has no qualms about killing people. You can kind of see hints of it in his little death threats to Abel, Abel is his friend but I’m sure if that friendship ever ended, MC wouldn’t bat an eye about snuffing Abel out.

I feel the anime could’ve done a better job, having read the light novel and loving it, I was excited to see it animated…but I agree with the OP, that the anime is just missing things and isn’t as exciting or captivating as the light novel is.

But it’s still fun to see it animated, seeing the characters and the beautiful scenery I could only imagine, come to life on the screen.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Magical_Savior Sep 20 '25

This is exactly why I dropped the novel, and why I skipped the anime completely. I want Clearing an Isekai With the Zero-Believers Goddess – the Weakest Mage Among the Classmates to get an anime. It has fairly satisfactory arcs, and conclusion, and post-stories. Better water magician by far.

13

u/Arthago Sep 19 '25

I enjoyed how you explained it OP. As a wrestling fan I get it lol. That said there’s good stuff, come on back to wrasslin’ friend.

As for the show you’re not wrong. I watch pretty much every isekai or fantasy show each season and this episode just kept me feeling “well that was nice sure it’s gonna pick up next episode”.

I watched the most recent episode and I was like “ah ok finally here we go”.

Then I realized this is episode 11 lol. It makes me think it’s already got a 2nd season approved, if not the pacing for this one will be terrible lol.

I’ll still watch it, but I get it OP. I’m still watching wrestling so take from that what you will lol.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Vorthod Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

I've seen a couple of clips and I remember laughing at how the guy who just gormlessly stares at people (even in a fight where his opponent is completely open to banter) was supposed to be the main character.

Oh, this elf chick nearly passed by me on the road but stopped so that she could monologue about my outfit? I'm not going to respond to her question, say a single word in the entire scene, or have any reaction in general until she's done and we can just go our separate ways. I won't even bother asking what that was all about once I'm alone.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/MillionMiracles :FK::FL::FM: Sep 20 '25

To be fair, even if you bought the PPV the goldberg matches wouldn't last more than two minutes.

2

u/Western_Promise3063 Sep 20 '25

Looks like his matches have a lot in common with my love life 😭

1

u/Thamor81 Sep 26 '25

You clearly don't like Isekai slop stories, which Water Magician is totally guilty of. If you watch WM knowing for what it is, it's enjoyable watch. But if you go with expectations or thinking it's some Mushoku Tensei level of Isekai story then you will hate it.

1

u/Western_Promise3063 Sep 26 '25

my favorite shows are I'm in love with the villainous, bofuri, kuma kuma kuma Bear, and arifureta so I know what I'm talking about here.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ok-Koala7855 Oct 05 '25

Your post is amazingly ignorant. Every single anime produced is made to bring attention to the written series. That is the goal when the anime’s are made in the first place. The fact that this bothers you is baffling

1

u/SelfIndulgentLunatic Oct 12 '25

You obviously don't have a brain 

1

u/Hammon_Rye Nov 15 '25

Looking for my next watch. Was considering the water magician.
I've learned to google before starting a series, which landed me here.
You guys have convinced me to watch something else instead.

2

u/Western_Promise3063 Nov 15 '25

not gonna lie, pretty fucking crazy to have my thread show up as one of the first results on Google for this anime 💀

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Leaves_Swype_Typos Sep 20 '25

This is a series that will be practically unknown to anyone in a few months. There's hardly any reason to truly "hate" it when there's not going to be any reminders of its existence nor fanboys going on about it and flooding anime-adjacent subreddits with it.

6

u/Fun-Establishment191 Sep 20 '25

Agree 100%, water magician is a big letdown. I wish they would make more season of I’m A Spider, So What instead

8

u/charistraz95 Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

it started off great but it has pissed me off so much on the newest episode like holy shit i do not want a 2nd season if this is wat they r going to do

3

u/Ferovaors Sep 20 '25

Spoiler: I thought the demon fight would be when he was actually challenged. I dropped it afterwards

3

u/Codee33 https://anilist.co/user/Euphplyr33 Sep 20 '25

I’m still really enjoying the Water Magician despite the lackluster adaptation. By episode 2 or 3 we figured out that Ryo was too overpowered to do much given the general tone of the story. This leads to a lot of nice chill moments, and opportunities for a varied cast which I think it does well. Not saying it’s my favorite or anything, but I’m still enjoying it quite a lot.

3

u/EldritchSentry Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

Water Magician would have been good if it stayed the way it was before Episode 3. Just two pals exploring a fantasy world but instead they introduced the most worthless, generic, and uninteresting side characters that take up the screen time. Anime fell off on episode 3 and never recovered imo. The elf romance is ass because Ryo ain't that compelling of a character to have any actual chemistry or relationships with and the elf ain't doing much. Also lamest aura farming episode when we have waaaay better action sequences this season

3

u/Any-Ask-1260 Sep 20 '25

Eh, I think it’s pretty decent

3

u/Blunt_Truth0412 Sep 25 '25

Dang....took me til the intro of the 12th episode to finally snap. It was after he was bumped and drop his food and is left staring at the two running away. Just to give an example, I am pretty sure he came here because truck-kun or a god made a mistake, right? MC lacks any kind of realism and the side characters have more going on than the MC. And how much foreshadowing are we going to use in the first season, just to do nothing with it?

Then you mentioned wrestling (not going to attempt to mention all the old organizations) and I was literally shook to my core. I think you hit the nail on the head and all the hope I had for this anime has emploded in on itself. 2025 season has really dropped the bag. Dont even get me started on the generic rinse and repeat going on in manhwa and manga.

5

u/NaClYarkoz Sep 19 '25

I really like both the show and the protagonist. I was also really disappointed that the anime is ahead of the manga cause reading a light novel now so i can enjoy more of the story, is not something I really want to invest time.

6

u/PackDiscombobulated4 Sep 20 '25

The water magician who uses more ice attacks than water. This anime is trash. Boring side characters and the storyline moves so slow.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/sexwithkoleda_69 Sep 19 '25

Despite the quality having fallen hard, i still like it. 

5

u/thegoodgero Sep 19 '25 edited Sep 19 '25

This may be slightly off topic but it's never been easier to get into non-wwe wrestling than it is right now! They've gotten steadily worse as a product since we were kids but lately there's been PLENTY of other promotions outshining them in pretty much every field that matters. I watch AEW, Ring of Honor, Enjoy, New Japan, Tokyo Joshi and Marigold more days of the month than not and they keep me steadily invested even when I can't fully understand what they're saying (the last 3 are Japanese promotions).

4

u/Arthago Sep 19 '25

This comment right here, OP there’s a wealth of good stuff in wrestling now. Come on back, watch out for tribalism lol.

9

u/abandoned_idol Sep 20 '25

I don't hate Water Magician. I saw what it was in episode 1, confirmed my prediction, and promptly left.

The MC being onboarded by a dragon was a flashing siren light. Let it be a learning exercise.

And I share all your complaints, but they are directed towards the slime isekai (they have him be a slime, but not really, now he's human and the slime is just the thinnest gimmick for yet another nothing-waffle LitRPG that doubles as a chibi-form).

shrug

And there's going to be hundreds more of vapid Lit-RPGs, you're going to have to learn to identify them. Be it slime god, or the water-ball-animation demo.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Carl_Cherry_Hill_NJ Sep 19 '25

I didnt even know there was a light novel. Not like i look for light novels in the first place. If they really intended to use the anime as an ad wouldnt there be something shown to get merch viewed on the episode? I didnt get the whole its an ad vibe. Not saying the anime was good or bad was kinda mid for me its watchable but certainly didnt scream go buy something to me.

2

u/Conscious_Banana537 Sep 20 '25

>I totally understand that this is hardly the first anime that has served as a vehicle for a light novel but it's by far the worst and most blatant that I've ever seen try to do it. the creators of this series do understand that they need to craft something compelling for me to even have the desire to buy a light novel, right? why on Earth would I possibly want to further explore this world that is so boring and lame and formulaic? I mean if you're going to make a shameless isekai power fantasy, at least make it gratuitous and entertaining.

It's funny because... the light novel isn't really that much better. Truly, the rest of the story even in the novel is basically the same. If anything, the anime actually portrayed the MC much better.

The beginning books had the MC actually being fairly intellectual and showing off how his knowledge was helping him adapt to magic and become stronger as a result. But once the author added in new, reoccurring characters, the MC clowns around in an attempt for the author to add in some subtle comedy (not so subtle).

I am not going to lie... I actually don't understand how this got an anime. Maybe Japan liked it to a degree... but I didn't really know much about it until one of the scanlation groups I followed was scanlating it. And the manga isn't that far anyway.

I read the novel to see if the story changes. Nope. There is potential for the story to get serious and the MC potentially meeting his match, but it'll probably end up going the same route as almost every other Isekai does so the entirety of Water Magician is mainly just everyone else existing and having interactions with the MC that may or may not make him take action.

So... yep, you're hitting the nail on the head. This is the type of story it is and... it's kind of just there for no reason.

2

u/GateOfD Sep 20 '25

I jumped to the novel.  It’s a bit better but the MC is really flat.  I don’t mind slice of life powe fantasies.  I have loads of them under my belt.  But all he does is eat. And he encounters some problem and “trains” which amount to “I spent some time training and I did it”

→ More replies (2)

2

u/testthrowawayzz Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

What made you come back weekly?/Why haven't you dropped it?

If something's not catching my attention, I delay watching it so much that sometimes I forget to watch it. Eventually that leads to completely dropping it when I missed too many episodes.

This one I try to come back because I like Ryo's banter with all his buddies but when I check the discussion threads weekly there's less of them in the recent episodes.

(Not intended as a "f off silently if you hate it" comment. Really curious)

2

u/P____M Sep 20 '25

Am I weird to not think this at all, or maybe I am way past the critiquing age I guess, now i just take how it is.

I just find out from the reddit or some posts which will be good and I just watch them.

I am weird, early days were better fr.

2

u/Shadruh Sep 20 '25

This show needs to be like a Naruto thousand episode behemoth. There's way too much story to tell and too slow for only 12 episodes.

2

u/aliasalt Sep 20 '25

The first few episodes were quite entertaining, but yeah it's been pretty bad lately. Still, it's so bland I can't bring myself to hate it. It stands above the competition merely by avoiding having the MC dabble in slavery

2

u/Key_Swimming_8134 Sep 20 '25

Welcome to the anime industry. Capitalism is awesome ain't it?

2

u/Buntalufigus88 Sep 20 '25

As I am current with the translation of the story I can say you are completely right with how they have done the anime. I love it because I know what's going on and going to happen in better detail. I will say not seeing the most recent episode that it will all be about episode 12. That being said the anime itself needs to be more than one season to really start to show Ryo off. He is a hero who wants to be the comedic relief. Mind you he is trying to have an easy simple life or whatever he told the angel. The fight with the akuma was much more dramatic than it was shown.

2

u/Unapologetic_Lunatic Sep 20 '25

Latest episode of Water Magician: "Here's a backstory that's already been told, but now must be shown so you can get more advertisement for buying the LN."

Latest episode of Seventh Prince: man insists that Lloyd is obligated to hear his backstory, and gets smacked for it

Which of these works better?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 20 '25

When a show can pull out a past memory that's how you know it is genuine.

I agree with you about the water magician though, I'll be real.. the anime had me until they reached the town. It was frustrating watching the mc just go to the library while his friends are literally barely surviving or fending off things. The elf did carry the show for two episodes but after that it just grinds to halt. Like some have mentioned already, you encounter an anime like this every season where it is strictly so vague and it is clearly just wanting you to read the source material, you get one every season at least. I'll finish it, because I'm already more than halfway into it.. but once I realized its purpose it makes it hard to keep watching lol.

2

u/DiscountCondom :IJ::IK::IL: Sep 20 '25

ever since he entered town the show has been awful.

2

u/Kalikor1 Sep 20 '25

Downvote all you want but the wife and I love this anime. But I agree it's taking its sweet ass time and I resigned myself within the first, idk, 5-6 episodes, to the fact that they clearly aren't going to progress the story much in one season.

Is it the best anime ever? No. But there's a shit load of other anime to watch and this is just one of them. I love the art, particularly the background and how everything looks like it's on canvas. I like the slow pace even if I wish we'd get some more "meat" more frequently.

Ultimately yes I wish there was more story progression but I also still enjoy my time with it.

2

u/Gistradagis Sep 20 '25

I love how much credit you give this show.

No, it's not some manipulative ad to bring you to the novel. The show simply isn't very good. When people call these kinds of series fast food anime, they mean it.

2

u/raidensnakeezio Sep 20 '25

I think it's a well done junk food isekai, possibly even "elevated" junk food. There's no substantial character stakes/emotional investment. It feels like the narrative can't decide whether it wants to be max-escapism cheat-skill isekai, or hardcore-grounded isekai.

Yet despite this, I find the overall production to be of nuance and to be executed well. It's not the grandest or most creative adventure, but it makes the effort to try and be both. I think this shows in the overall quality. I particularly enjoy the backgrounds.

As an anime-only watcher, I'm fascinated by the narrative's approach. I can understand the general consensus behind why some people might not like the show. The expectation for OP/Cheat isekai is for their to be rapid plot development/power scaling; as if speedrunning through an RPG. It's quite bizzare that a cheat isekai would spend so much time away from the reincarnated protagonist, but I think they do it quite well. It emphasizes the moments when he does (sometimes conveniently) show up (see OPM S1).

I can sympathize with those who feel that the current plot development is stagnant, and that the power scaling is not clear nor being developed clearly. So far, the narration has made it very clear that Ryo is at the level of being a national asset, but the world building has not depicted, or given strata of understandable fidelity to the power levels beyond a B-class adventurer. We've seen dungeon skirmishes but not open-field warfare and siege. Yet despite this, I'm personally fine with seeing the supporting cast struggle with combat encounters in their own way (also see OPM). I think the investment of screentime into the side characters has and will continue to pay off. In RPG-led thinking, OP-cheat reincarnators may be seen as "cheap." Yet by spending this much time with the side characters, Ryo's abilities are now depicted as the opposite of cheap - instead his abilities are valuable.

I think the revalation of the world-building, as well as the character + relationship development is a slow burn, but at the very least it's moving forward consistently. Unlike Kazuya (Rent-a-Girlfriend), where he has no resolve to do anything, or like Re:Zero, where Subaru faces more and more hurdles and setbacks.

2

u/Uminagi Sep 20 '25

I mean, idk you but this anime is above the average in the isekai genre. I'd rather watch this than something like Isekai Smartphone, Wise Man's Granchild or any of that lowtier slop.

Water Magician at least isn't a harem (for now), the protagonist isn't obnoxious, and the animations and backgrounds are very pretty. The fight against the Akuma lady was pretty good and the world building so far is pretty decent (albeit nothing as big as Mushoku Tensei).

I'd say the biggest issue with this anime is the pacing, especially with this episode which honestly frustrated me quite a bit. Previous episode ended on a cliffhanger with the terrorist attack, so then with this episode I expected to see them fight; yet half the episode was dedicated to Oscar backstory (whom I for a sec thought was Abel). I'd really wish that the anime focused more on action rather than the typical nonbiri stuff.

Apart from that, I'd say that the anime has some stuff that makes it distinguish itself from other animes. Like, the fact that so far it isn't a harem, or that side characters actually get spotlight and don't feel like plot devices only to make the MC look cooler (while they do fit that description, especially with the whole Demon Prince thing, they do have some uses to move the story forward). Characters like Abel and Oscar are quite strong and are pretty important to the story (remove Abel and a lot of the story wouldn't have happened).

Obviously the anime isn't a perfect masterpiece, but one can't say it's a piece of garbage, since within all of the isekai slop this one feels like a diamond (or I guess quartz is more fitting lol) in the rough.

I myself give it like a 7.5/10.
For reference, I give Slime Isekai a 8.5/10 and Mushoku Tensei a 9/10.

2

u/Iamnoone2728 https://anilist.co/user/hitathighs Sep 20 '25

This show does the exact same thing the guild receptionist anime did. Lure everyone into watching it by having a highly produced, pretty looking opening while the actual show's animation is just servicable and the story abysmal. Actual bait-and-switch tactics.

Secrets of the Silent Witch also had a beautifully animated opening, but that show at least has likeable characters and a decent story.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Big-Cartographer-758 Sep 20 '25

The pacing is weird. The characters are all a bit flat.

I dont understand the magic of the world. Everyone keeps saying how impressive Ryo is, but in the last episodes there are several spells that seem in the same league. Or at least a lot better than the other casters we’ve met.

Abel’s party mage was shocked that Ryo could summon an ice wall in the air and suddenly there’s a 200 foot pillar of fire erupting from the Earth nowhere near the caster.

2

u/Cryten0 Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

I do not actually mind the anime, it is vastly superior to the light novel. But the light novel, my god is it such bad writing. I felt my brain melting reading it. The main character pays no attention to other characters outside of the current plot point, and otherwise ignores everthing they say in favour of quipping about sterotypes. Combat is not really described, as in no choreography, just ability does x, y responds with z. Any implied story is brushed over in favour of endless entreaties on badly informed science that justifies ability usage. Its all so insufferable bad, all the bad trope writing with none of the spice.

Well I guess that is a lie, I do not mind the first 5 episodes of the anime. Then it gets boring fast.

2

u/TheRealGameDude Sep 20 '25

I got frustrated at the last episode. I didn’t think we needed half an episode on some dudes backstory of how his family was killed and village burned only for it to happen again in the next village. Then the other half wasn’t so bad but i personally don’t care for cliffhangers especially when the anime is ongoing and i gotta wait a week to see the results

→ More replies (2)

2

u/saskir21 Sep 20 '25

Problem is. The LN is not so different. You even get more of him living in the hut before meeting Abel. This is exactly the premise of the show/book.

Except for those damn cliffhangers. I mean take the demon prince. Big windup. MC appearing. And next episode 1-2 minutes to solve it. In the book I can read atleast faster the conclusion.

2

u/merurunrun Sep 20 '25

You know you can just drop shows you don't like, right? You don't have to keep watching them. You can do something worthwhile with your time.

2

u/Kazakami9 Sep 20 '25

I haven't watched the anime, but I have read a few volumes of the light novel. This series has a serious lack of likeable characters. I don't know how it is in the anime, but in the light novel, the protagonist Ryo is constantly insulting his "friend" Abel. The author wrote it as if it was just friendly banter, but those two don't seem friendly enough for that, and the insults are not funny at all - they are just simple badmouthing. He also feels like a huge damn hypocrite to me. The only thing I like about Ryo is his more scientific approach to magic.

There's a ton of side characters, way too much, in fact, considering none of them are particularly interesting. Usually, I can name at least one character I like in any given series, but here, there is none, and the series just doesn't give any character enough spotlight to make you feel closer to them.

The story feels kind of similar to One Punch Man in a way, but is worse in execution in every possible way. In both works, the protagonist is often sidelined and only sometimes shows up to save the day - instead, the actual story is mainly described through the side characters and villains. However, OPM is filled with an incredibly charismatic cast that can easily fill Saitama's boots, perhaps not in deeds or power, but in entertainment, while Water Magician's cast has not a speck of charisma to it's name. I don't think a down to earth cast like Water Magician's is bad necessarily for an isekai story, but then the protagonist should be filling bigger boots, which Ryo is not doing (and he is an unlikeable prick anyway).

2

u/buddascrayon Sep 20 '25

The thing about this that makes me laugh is that fully all of the anime out there adapted from a Light novel is an advertisement for the LN. The thing that makes this suck is most likely that this anime probably follows the LN source very closely.

Good anime adaptations from LN's come from good Light Novel series. Even if the art and animation quality is super sub-par, the content speaks for itself. My own personal example is the adaptation of "My Instant Death Ability..." anime was just the lowest quality art and animation I've seen in a while. But the story was so entertaining and interesting that it made me wanna pick up and read the whole series. (That, and the entire voice cast was so absolutely marvelous in their line delivery that I couldn't help but to love the characters.)

2

u/ozairh18 Sep 20 '25

It took me until the episode where the protagonist ate curry with the elf girl to drop it. The protagonist is too op and his personality is pretty eerie with the way he smiles all the time and accuses the character with red hair of lying to him about things he didn’t even ask him

2

u/Narrheim Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

It's called "Water Magician" and has an isekai premise, so it can be marked as an Isekai, despite not having much to do with the isekai twist besides the science behind MC's usage of water magic.

At the same time, it's trying to appear as some large and story-rich saga, where side characters have their own stories - but each and every one of them is quite shallow and not that much interesting.

The entire story covered in the anime is fully summed up in the opening.

[btw, regarding LN,] it is the same thing.

2

u/Marsman121 Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 20 '25

Even after all this time, I don't understand why I am still watching it. After every episode, I find myself discovering a new depth of hate for a show.

Maybe it is because I have never experienced a story that has no main character. Everyone, I mean everyone, is an NPC. There are no meaningful character arcs, a disjointed and nonsensical plot, and no real antagonist.

The MC is especially bad because he barely seems to interact with the world. He basically does nothing in a story that is supposed to be about him.

"I want to learn alchemy!" Proceeds to do no alchemy.

Random demon attacking him during and eclipse? "Huh, that was weird. Time to forget all about it."

"I want to learn how to use water magic to give myself magic mobility!" Proceeds to practice once, fail, and never again.

Friend's almost die in some sort of freak dungeon event? /shrug

The anime feels like someone took an isekai anime and populated the entire season with filler episodes.

2

u/x28CakeCuts Sep 20 '25

Read the LN! it’s also garbage

2

u/HippiesBeGoneInc Sep 20 '25

What’s funny about this is that the people who had read the LNs were straight saying everything that you wrote and were trying to warn the rest of us.

2

u/bensor74 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pipiruben Sep 20 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

I'm so disappointed with this one. The first episodes are great IMO. Nice vibe and everything. Then, he... simply disappeared? Worst bait & switch ever. It was a 9 at the beginning, it ended up with a 6 on my MAL. I can't rate it lower because I enjoyed the first episodes so much.

2

u/shelpote Sep 20 '25

Let me save you from reading the light novel cause I went to read them. No actually real substancial development happens. They are translated to book 5 and I went and found more online. Still almost no development between elf and main character. MC and ML are a joke. The story line is there but its slow and I dropped it after the time skip.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '25

Some things should stay books 😅

Seriously. I don’t mind an anime that starts slow but this sounds like a snail in winter slow.

On that note, a funny slice of life manga turned anime is a Terrified Teacher at Ghoul School if you want something to wash away the disappointment. It’s sub tho, be warned.

2

u/RioDawn2010 Sep 21 '25

when I opened this post and see Triple H I thought I was I was in the wrong sub for a while lol

2

u/SunnyFlow3rSunday Sep 22 '25

I think the MC is very funny, my issue with is (like you mentioned) he'd never fucking there. Like WHERE IS THE MAIN CHARACTER?!! They do have these big epic battles and only sometimes Ryo shows up to steal the show and get NO CREDIT!!! I don't care he's in the library, I don't care if he's not fighting big battles, BUT DONT SHOW ME EVRYTHING HES MISSING!!!! I wanna see Ryo's weirdness and people's reactions to that, I CRAVE IT. I would care about the side characters, if they weren't acting like the main characters. Like when are they gonna reveal Ryo is eternally youthful and is actually 40 years old or something. We don't know where bro came from, what his life before was, or what his actual purpose is, if he's an anomaly CAN THEY SHOW US WHYYY CAN THEY SHOW US MORE THAN 10 SECOND CLIPS OF HIM????? I am very disappointed because I love mc based shows, which isn't this, but I also adore mc that ACT like side character. But Ryo just IS the side character.

2

u/Firm_Contribution_44 Sep 25 '25

It might as well be a manga/manhwa with how low the budget is
there was an episode they had like 7 straight still images

It's like they went all in on art/character and voice acting but ran out of money for animation lol

2

u/Aggressive_Set4814 Sep 25 '25

The thing that pissed me off the most was how visually pleasing the first 2 episodes were and that it actually felt like a decent watch until I kept watching and just felt cheated

2

u/External_Dog8714 Sep 26 '25

Genuinely had so much hope because it was gonna be an anime with a magic user using solely one element. You rarely see MCs focusing only on one and water is by far my favorite element. But nope it was just completely terrible. Animation subpar, background subpar, MC personality felt all over the place, no depth to background characters, and no direction on where the story is supposed to be going. My biggest issues with these new anime’s is not being realistic. Like why are we walking into adventures club, taverns, walking down main streets, or up early in the morning and not seeing the everyday person. In these times places should be packed with people getting stuff done and yet we rarely see any just regular people. Sorry went off course with that part just had to say. Anyways back to the main point of I was very excited for a water magician mc and it instead ended of being the biggest let down of anime this year.

2

u/Poodicus Sep 26 '25

Enter the water magician: A show that is so clearly intended on doing nothing but directing your attention towards the light novel that I have no idea why they didn't just spend the money on Facebook/YouTube advertisements or something.

Because the anime IS the advertisement.

It may be shocking to some people, but anime like this gets made not to get people interested in the animation, but rather, the source material. Whenever an anime gets a sequel, it's mostly not because the anime did well, but because the source material found a big boost in sales. And so, production throws the money that could be spent making youtube/facebook/yahoo ads is instead invested in 12-episode, 30 minute episodes that may or may not be mediocre as all hell.

2

u/HeLTeRiS Sep 28 '25

For me The Water Magican is like TEMU/WISH version of Frieren: Beyond Journey's End.
When I first saw trailer I was expecting something very similar to Frieren, but..... It is wat it is.

2

u/Snoo-59420 Oct 11 '25

Idk if its just me, and age or generational thing etc, but I enjoyed it. Im wondering if its mis-aligned expectations.

The whole initial premise was that he wanted a slow easy life. He learns to fight and use magic to defend and provide for himself. He stumbles across Abel and leaves to help him as a friend. He takes down the Wyverns out of necessity and convenience. He becomes an adventurer for income, a passport, and lodging. He goes into the deeper dungeon to save his friends.

In short, he's more like Luffy than Naruto. He's not trying to be the best, save the world etc. He's not searching out stronger opponents just to fight them like Goku. He wants to a comfy life to pursue his I Teresa and help his friends. If his friends can handle it, he's not required. If they need his help, he'll be there. Its not meant to just be a battle series. And the implications of his immortality are a soft conflict issue for later on, like Frieren in reverse.

2

u/1amCorbin Nov 05 '25

I'm rewatching The Water Magician rn because i liked it so much😆i love the slice of life nature of the show.

2

u/Real_Ad7480 Dec 26 '25

At least theres no harem

5

u/Frangan_ Sep 19 '25

I really like it for my part. Pretty much for the same reason I like jobless reincarnation.

I like it when anime is going slow, I like it when the mc doesn't get all the spotlight. Feeling the world is alive even when the Mc is not around. Not waiting for the Mc to show up for something to happen in people's life. The Mc can't be everywhere and solve everyone's problem. And we get it here.

3

u/MagicPistol Sep 19 '25

I'm actually watching episode 11 right now. I enjoyed the first few episodes, but the last several episodes were bad. This post made me realize I should probably just stop watching right now lol. Time to catch up on the newest episode of Silent Witch instead.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/l3reezer Sep 19 '25

Y'all are weirdly incendiary about this show. It's obviously a light-hearted story focused on world-building being done by a newer under-manned animation studio, but you act like it murdered your kin.

This series is nowhere near the worst of isekai. Most isekai protagonists are getting Game Master level hacks with access to the console or some shit. Our guy here relatively "just got" water affinity/youth and spent 20 years leveling it up along with his sword skills sparring with the Fairy King.

The protagonist has been absent from one battle in the show. He also had an important fight with an Akuma that no one else was present for, so it evens out.

Episode 11 was probably the worst of the show but the backstory was half not all of the episode and at least had a discernable purpose characterizing the guy who the protagonist is primed to match up against.

18

u/AndroidLaw Sep 19 '25

The writing/directing in this show is just freaking awful and confusing man. Tropey bullshit would make MORE sense and be less awful than whatever the fuck is going on in this show. It's trying to be slow, do world-building, and develop more than just the mc, which is fine - but they're doing a terrible job at it, and it's frustrating.

We get things like the mage girl in Abel's party talk on and on about how Ryo's magic is impossible but she never actually gets to talk to him about it, our OP mc that Abel and the guild master know is op doesn't help out during the calamity great bore event and only shows up last moment during the demon prince event, and now we get that half episode backstory to a new character that I honestly forgot existed and spent a good amount of time confused who tf this kid in the flashback was. People also pointed out how weird Oscar's backstory is with the bandit raid in the last episode discussion so I won't even go into that. Like, if you're going to try to sell yourself on world-building and focusing on side characters, it has to be GOOD writing/directing, otherwise what's the point?

It's frustrating because it promised something different in the first few episodes and was decently interesting, and then things just go to shit, including the animation quality, which can be forgiven with decent writing IF THEY HAD IT. Then there's the AI background with that weird texture on it: https://old.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1mi8m5x/no_the_water_magician_episode_this_week/n73q14h/

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Appropriate-Aside-26 Sep 19 '25

Umm the light novel is the same. This is world building.

33

u/Phaazoid Sep 19 '25

It's a shame the author couldn't both world build and write a story.

7

u/MaskedTwilight Sep 19 '25

I can confirm as a current light novel reader, that it's very slow paced and often times the MC isn't really a main character. The story often dips into the view of other characters and they drive the narrative. Mc is really just along for the ride occasionally.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/charistraz95 Sep 19 '25

the light novel isnt gonna delay, and do a recap, then do flashbacks for a whole episode xD