r/Sherlock • • Jan 01 '14

Episode Discussion The Empty Hearse: Post-Episode Discussion Thread (SPOILERS)

That was worth the wait!

1.1k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

495

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Why is everyone going on about Moffat? The episode was written by Mark Gatiss.

600

u/GoFlight Jan 01 '14

He doesn't get as much credit as he should, especially given how well he plays Mycroft.

→ More replies (32)

87

u/invinciblesummmer Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 02 '14

Yeah I really don't get that. It's like how /r/breakingbad think the entirety of breaking bad was created by Vince Gilligan alone LOL

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

15

u/OllieRaiden Jan 02 '14

Did anyone else notice that before Sherlock revealed himself, John was walking with his limp again? Thought that was a nice touch.

3

u/GoFlight Jan 02 '14

Good eye, I did not catch that.

62

u/p3rp3tua1m0t10n Jan 01 '14

Eureka! In sight, a snide sleuth returns sketched as scapegoat and scoundrel, having slipped surveillance, whose sore sibling sits sipping in silence, supervising schemes of scales superlative. His sidekick a sharp soldier of sentiment, he stands solid, set towards soliloquies of smarts and sarcasm. His sole stance of justice saves and sins in similar sums. It suffices to say it is a very good pleasure to see him surface and you may call him Sherlock.

4

u/GoFlight Jan 01 '14

Well done!

→ More replies (11)

746

u/ha5hmil Jan 01 '14

Derren Fucking Brown! almost fell for that.

also - i'm a bit confused, did Sherlock actually tell HOW he did it?

241

u/AlderaanRefugee Jan 01 '14

"BOLLOCKS!"

"Wha-"

"Derren Brown?!"

→ More replies (1)

111

u/bacon_pants Jan 01 '14

I saw some screenshots a while back of Derren Brown on the Sherlock set with a hand over Martin's face, but I assumed it was either photoshopped or something to do with a Derren Brown special and not actually being filmed for the show.

560

u/Kemuel Jan 01 '14

The first explanation was a trap, aimed to make fans go wtf and to catch the rest out with details which the people who have pored over it would immediately discount. The second explanation was taking the piss out of the fandom and shippers. The third explanation was a more convincing trap laced with some details of the truth which fans had worked out already, in order to draw us in. The full answer's yet to come.

→ More replies (81)

158

u/fenwaygnome Jan 01 '14

Damn, that looks like one that went over my head here in America. I had to look him up. That's pretty funny though.

→ More replies (9)

60

u/bimonscificon Jan 01 '14 edited Feb 03 '25

full growth many alive mountainous fearless office narrow encouraging squeal

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (95)

558

u/NaePish Jan 01 '14

The gif of the false theories being ripped from the wall is going to be oh so pervasive in weeks to come.

134

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

That one was made for tumblr

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

845

u/AElliot Jan 01 '14

Sherlock's Mary Deductions:

Lib Dem, Only Child, Size 12, Guardian, Bakes Own Bread, Linguist, Part-time Nurse, Short sighted, Clever, Romantic, Cat Lover, Appendix, Scar, Secret Tattoo, Disillusioned and Liar.

409

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Liar? Oh, dear.

→ More replies (68)

42

u/j33 Jan 02 '14

Liar was one of the larger words in that mental word soup thing he does, and I think it may have significance, but time will tell.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (17)

1.2k

u/hotwhovian Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 01 '14

"F..." "Cough" Definitely the best line.

465

u/ha5hmil Jan 01 '14

also the middle finger watson gives when he puts the gloves on.

→ More replies (17)

223

u/BellisBlueday Jan 01 '14

Don't forget pisspot :D

19

u/anilemcee Jan 01 '14

also "age issue"/"ages you" from Mrs Hudson

16

u/suomihobit Jan 02 '14

I enjoyed "Does yours wipe off as well?"

→ More replies (17)

713

u/grania17 Jan 02 '14

Can I just say I love the fact that Mycroft took their parents to see Les Mis and then called Sherlock during the first act complaining! Absolutely brilliant.

577

u/suomihobit Jan 02 '14

I love that they used Cumberbatch's real parents!

→ More replies (11)

95

u/salamander1305 Jan 02 '14

I think that's Act II. Act I starts with "Look Down", not "Do You Hear The People Sing." It seemed like Mycroft thought Sherlock would switch with him after Act I

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

311

u/Ging84 Jan 01 '14

I thought it was a very funny episode, I especially liked how they moved from posh restaurant to I think a café then kebab shop as I imagine they were probably kicked out as the behaviour got more violent. Also the cuts between Sherlock and John at the doctors office were superb, I think its easy to forget how funny Mark Gatiss is and was just see League Of Gentlemen.

→ More replies (1)

473

u/Mahog4ny Jan 01 '14

I think everyone's still missing the point that it's not how he faked it, but why he faked it...for seemingly just John?

217

u/Chapman14 Jan 01 '14

I totally agree, im a little confused as to why he would need to fake his death if the sniper was paid off?

→ More replies (44)

72

u/fenwaygnome Jan 01 '14

Well, if you go back to the source material John Watson is the narrator and the sole source of information we have. Everything we know is through Watson's eyes. In that way "just John" basically means the entire world. It's possible that is what they are going for.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (19)

378

u/ShuuseiKagari Jan 01 '14

The fact that season 3 will be over in 11 days is surreal. It's like being given a bag of Haribo, eating 3 of them and then having them snatched away for another 2 years.

111

u/YeahTacos Jan 02 '14

The season is short but it's still a lot of content (awesome) - think about it, it's like 4.5 hours per season.. That's 270 minutes (same as a 12-ep comedy on hbo or showtime). As for the long pause, I think the next one will be shorter... No hobbit to film!

→ More replies (9)

10

u/thegamels1859 Jan 02 '14

I thought this was the last season? With the last episode being The Last Bow, which is his last case chronologically.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)

202

u/yourmydinner Jan 01 '14

We'll see at least another 20 fan theories before we get the real one won't we?

132

u/bacon_pants Jan 01 '14

I kind of love that they took all the popular theories and squished them together in one big ball of WTF.

149

u/kartak Jan 01 '14

Yes... Some more disturbingly homoerotic than others.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

182

u/JackWilfred Jan 01 '14

As somebody with a large map of the London Underground on their wall, I found the train enthusiast quite funny.

→ More replies (15)

393

u/callumacrae Jan 01 '14

They're not going to tell us, are they? :(

553

u/fenwaygnome Jan 01 '14

They showed all of our theories, and then addressed that anything they came up with wouldn't be as 'good' as whatever our personal favorite theory was, and we'd just be disappointed. I thought it was clever.

→ More replies (54)

110

u/DenryuRocket110 Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 01 '14

It'll be at the end of episode 3 of Series 9

→ More replies (13)

143

u/GibsonGolden Jan 01 '14

he said there were 13 possible ways? I feel like we'll see 13 different versions, which I kind of enjoy.

→ More replies (26)

189

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

The man at the end (can't remember his name) will reveal how Sherlock did it in the season finale to show the viewer how smart he is.

→ More replies (12)

63

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

I feel like Moffat might save it for the season finale... bastard....

→ More replies (32)

11

u/hunglikeafucker Jan 01 '14

I'm gonna kill someone.

→ More replies (11)

171

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Okay, so there's a new Big Bad Villain. And we still don't know how Sherlock jumped. Methinks the finale will involve an exchange between the two, with him (NewBigBad) unravelling and answering it; Sherlock will be amazed and so a little frightened, starts taking him seriously etc. and we'll finally have our answer.

It'll just be a test of this new villain's...worthiness, in replacing Andrew Scott.

128

u/ElectricFriend Jan 02 '14

No-one can do 'the eyes of a psychopath' like Andrew Scott can. In fact, I shall never be able to see Scott in anything else ever again because he fucking terrifies me. Lars has a lot to live up to.

→ More replies (5)

23

u/black_pepper Jan 02 '14

Twist - Moriarty from last season was actually Moriarty Jr. and this season's villain is Papa Moriarty.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

930

u/kartak Jan 01 '14

"Killing me... Oh please, that's so two years ago." That was utterly brilliant. The episode make me laugh out lound several times.

672

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

The best was John & Sherlock's faces when they saw Molly's fiance... cracked me up.

→ More replies (32)

522

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

This episode had a lot of funny moments.

I rather liked the bit where Mrs. Hudson is surprised John is marrying a female.

→ More replies (26)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

my favorite part was sherlock and moriarty giggling on the roof.

→ More replies (4)

590

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

I loved how they mocked all of us with the Anderson going mad at not knowing

248

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Everyone is a critic.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

71

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

So. Much. Fanservice.

→ More replies (4)

582

u/GammaRay_X Jan 01 '14

love the moriarty/sherlock action there

337

u/AlderaanRefugee Jan 01 '14

There's going to be thousands of poor quality tumbr gifs of that.

Also there was a part at the beginning about a quote being on a T-shirt. That quote will soon be on a T-shirt.

→ More replies (11)

222

u/Spawnzer Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 01 '14

Is there a gif already? I'm gonna need that gif

And the one with Molly too

To tumblr I go!

EDIT: :3

EDIT2: This gonna be a good year

EDIT3: I love me some bromance

→ More replies (34)
→ More replies (19)

250

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

In Molly's defense...maybe she just likes that sort of look? Less of "looking like Sherlock" but just that aesthetic in general?

117

u/StaircaseToYou Jan 01 '14

I could have bought this had they not made it look like her heart was breaking in the stairwell scene. She's clearly not over him, so instead she found the next best thing.

→ More replies (11)

278

u/potsofink Jan 01 '14

It's entirely possible, who doesn't like a tall, handsome, high-cheekboned man? I still cringed pretty hard for her though.

→ More replies (3)

151

u/ThefinalTardis Jan 01 '14

Molly is THE fangirl. She represents thousands of girls settling for someone "like" sherlock out there, because they can never have a fictional character. And honestly, they do love those others, but there is just a little bit of their heart which waits.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

186

u/subpubescenthair Jan 01 '14

This episode has made me love Ms.Hudson so much more.

Don't get me wrong, I loved her character, but I never thought she could make me laugh as much as I did this episode.

280

u/Techmical Jan 01 '14

"Oh, that's lovely! What's his name?"

"It's... A woman..."

"A WOMAN! YOU REALLY HAVE MOVED ON!"

→ More replies (1)

62

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Mrs. Hudson was great. I love how she was cleaning Sherlock's dishes when he came back. "Not your housekeeper!"

282

u/george__kaplan Jan 01 '14 edited Jan 02 '14

Anderson has a first name? This episode was crazy-the show finally became self-aware I think.

83

u/GamePhysics Jan 02 '14

That's a clue we might have missed though! Some thought Anderson was trippin', and it might be true.. Because Sherlock wouldn't know/remember his first name, right? He didn't know Lestrade's name was Greg until The Hound of Baskerville, and even when he returned now, he called him Grayham instead of Greg. So what if Anderson was indeed tripping, and Sherlock only knew his name because it was his own dream?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (15)

156

u/Maridiem Jan 01 '14

I'd like to remind you all that this episode was penned by Mark Gatiss. Not Moffat! So uh... all the fanrage/fanjoy can go towards Gatiss instead, eh?

49

u/TentacledTessa Jan 01 '14

No wonder he's so good at playing Mycroft. I can just see the smirk.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/takethesky87 Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14

Some observations after a second viewing:

  • The guy who sets off the bomb is named Lord Moran. Didn't notice the name drop the first time around.
  • The one-word clue we got for this episode forever ago was "rat." Sherlock refers to the people he's tracking (including Lord Moran) as "my rats" when John is in 221B with him.
  • Moffat said there was one thing we were all missing in our theories about Reichenbach, something Sherlock did that was out of character. After watching this, my guess is that it's the fact that Sherlock never went to Mycroft for help during S2E3. When Mycroft is telling John about the assassins moving in next door to 221B, Mycroft says he won't talking directly to Sherlock because of "too much history between us" -- even though that hasn't stopped Mycroft from talking to Sherlock in any other episode. And then when Sherlock and John are handcuffed and running away from the police, John suggests going to Mycroft for help but Sherlock dismisses the idea immediately ("A big family reconciliation? Now’s not really the moment.") -- again referencing something that we've seen no real evidence of in previous episodes. The two brothers avoiding each other always struck me as a little off, but frankly, I just wrote it off as a bit of a cop-out in the script in order to make the elaborate plot work. But now that we know (assuming the explanation to Anderson in The Empty Hearse can be believed) that Sherlock and Mycroft have been working together since before Moriarty even landed in Mycroft's custody, their avoidance of each other in Reichenbach seems like a very deliberate choice.
  • When Mrs. Hudson and Mary are talking in 221B after the bomb is diffused, while everyone's having champagne, Mary mentions she and John are thinking about a May wedding date. Since The Empty Hearse takes place in November, we are looking at a time jump of at least 6 months between now and Sunday.
  • What does everyone make of the stuff in the warehouse (?) at the very end, where Magnussen is? Lots of weird stuff in there.

Edit: clarifying some details

10

u/TheKingOfBadgerHill Jan 02 '14

The rat thing was a very nice touch. One of the more infamous cases that Watson alludes to in the original stories (which he doesn't tell) is that of the Giant Rat of Sumatra, and the disused tube station is called Sumatra Road. Clever.

→ More replies (10)

90

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Did anyone else notice something odd about Mary? When her and Sherlock meet, there's some sort of reaction. I don't know quite what it was, but I've the feeling it'll come into later episodes (and knowing John's luck, it won't be good).

78

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14

Sherlock deduces a bunch of stuff about her. Elsewhere in the thread someone paused in and wrote down all the deductions and apparently "Liar" featured prominently.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

917

u/fenwaygnome Jan 01 '14

This was by far the weakest plot of any episode. There was almost no real plot at all, but it was still enjoyable because of the strength of the actors and the characters.

Mary is fantastic by the way. The chemistry that Martin and Amanada have in real life absolutely shone through on screen. They were wonderful together. I'm glad they didn't go the route of Mary not liking Sherlock, it would just make us not like her character because we're always going to side with Sherlock.

294

u/acecore Jan 01 '14

I agree with you. Loved the chemistry and it surprised me as I was really ready to hate her character. The episode was weak in the sense that there was little of Sherlock actually doing anything other than winding the other characters up. The bomb plot seemed very forced and was solved all too easily and quickly (not just the 'off switch' but the whole subplot). Very self indulgent and a long fan service episode to set up a '2 episode series'. The 'action hero' explanation had me cringing so hard too. Can't wait for the next episode, the sign of the four is one of my favourite stories and am looking forward to seeing how it translates to modern day.

→ More replies (13)

139

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

Agree- I think to Moffatt and Gatiss this episode was first and foremost about indulging themselves a little, giving the fandom a nod and just letting all the actors stretch back into their characters a little. The plot was secondary to the enjoyment of everyone.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

The chemistry for them was good for sure, and I liked that Sherlock was not dismissive of Mary. Maybe because of the adjectives in his brain that he associated with her (such as "clever"), maybe he realizes that John does see a future with her and must acknowledge the change in dynamic.

But when she comes to 221B with the texts about John being missing, he takes her concern absolutely at face value with no hesitation. And he takes her with him, he doesn't pull some "I need to be mysterious and handle this myself" crap. Makes me wonder if he's learned some humility (that rather painful torture scene may've helped him on his way).

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (26)

41

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

I get that Sherlock had to be introduced back to London and meet up with John and all, so that would take up some time, but... Where was the story? The mystery to solve?

11

u/Death_Star_ Jan 02 '14

If they didn't fill it up with the character stuff, it would almost constitute a plot hole. 2 years and he's back from the dead? How would normal people react? Just get back to work? This episode was about strengthening and rebuilding Sherlock's relationship with John, since Sherlock will be playing a huge role in John's life soon.....

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

212

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

My internet cut out at parts so I thought the Moriarty and Sherlock pushing the dummy off part really happened..that was weird.

111

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Same thing happened to me... I was like, "Well this show went to shit." But it didn't.

→ More replies (3)

39

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Brilliant. I think it jumped around at points and the underlying mystery was a little weak, but they had to reintroduce everyone and establish that universe again. I'm not complaining. I'll be watching it again as soon as I can find a copy.

38

u/NiallH22 Jan 01 '14

In defence of Moffat and Gatiss, they said we'd find out, they never said in which episode it would be...

→ More replies (1)

38

u/-Summer-is-Rad- Jan 02 '14

The fact that they used Benedict's IRL parents for Sherlock's parents was a really nice touch.

→ More replies (5)

132

u/Dragonache Jan 01 '14

I take it that the story he told about how he did it wasn't actually true then?

152

u/onetruepurple Jan 01 '14

I thought it was. He told it to Anderson specifically to make sure no one else would believe it.

→ More replies (20)

57

u/cyanide Jan 01 '14

Doesn't look like it. Too obvious.

→ More replies (35)
→ More replies (39)

159

u/Swyfti Jan 01 '14

is there always an off-switch though? I don't think there is...

138

u/Romiress Jan 01 '14

Two possibilities with this. One: The person (glasses guy?) wanted to give Sherlock a fair chance if he figured it out. Two: In a case where there should be no real chance someone could stumble upon the bomb, where the bomb is being brought in from another country, it's probably a lot safer for the bomb to have an actual switch. Like a gun having the safety on.

→ More replies (17)

69

u/not-lenny Jan 01 '14

Would make Counter Strike a hell of a lot easier for the CTs.

51

u/ArcticNano Jan 01 '14

It would make sense, but in another way it wouldn't make sense...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

185

u/Dooflegna Jan 01 '14

I like how they didn't actually reveal how they did it. They just provided one possible explanation for it.

362

u/CydoniaKnight Jan 01 '14

I'm going with the second theory. The mannequin and the kiss.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

35

u/lanidelrey Jan 01 '14

So... who wants a shock blanket?

→ More replies (2)

124

u/Kid0mega Jan 01 '14

I like that they basically took fanfiction by the horns and tackled it; there. Definitely not the strongest episode ever but I think it was a brilliant re-introduction. I'm so happy right now ahhhhhhhhh. Sort of worth the wait. I'm so excited to see what they do with the next bit. Also it was great to see a new sort of relationship between Sherlock and Mycroft. Although the parents bit seemed like something of a throwaway, I hope there's more to it.

TLDR; I LIKED IT VERY EXCITED

→ More replies (6)

62

u/zzpza Jan 01 '14

Teacups turning into eyes

→ More replies (14)

87

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

This was probably the funniest episode yet.

  • The fake theories to poke fun at fans
  • John's mustache and everybody making fun of it
  • Sherlock as a french waiter, with John totally oblivious
  • Sherlock and Mycroft playing Operation
  • The Austin Powers style montage of John and Sherlock completing each other's sentences ("pisspot!") and John flipping off the camera
  • Molly's boyfriend... yeah
  • The off-switch on the bomb

I'm sure I'm missing a few good ones.

12

u/tranquil91 Jan 02 '14

I think the humour was just very different. The funny moments were more obvious and the jokes more pronounced. I have to say I preferred the subtler and more understated comedy of the previous series, although I do understand that the first return episode has to be a bit more flashy.

11

u/AGNKim Jan 02 '14

The entire scene with John and Mrs. Hudson. "I'm not gay."

30

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Terrorists get into all sorts of trouble when there's no off switch.

→ More replies (1)

328

u/Fithboy Jan 01 '14

I think one of the most important things learned in this episode is the extent of Mycroft's intellect. He is on par, if not more clever than Sherlock.

232

u/helmethair1 Jan 02 '14

In ACD's stories he mentions that Mycroft is much smarter than Sherlock.

→ More replies (14)

114

u/dr_pepper_35 Jan 02 '14

In the new episode, Mycroft compares himself to Sherlock as Sherlock compares himself to an average person. Sherlock did not really argue against this.

→ More replies (4)

112

u/FourCubed Jan 02 '14

From Wikipedia:

"...he has no ambition and no energy. He will not even go out of his way to verify his own solutions, and would rather be considered wrong than take the trouble to prove himself right. Again and again I have taken a problem to him, and have received an explanation which has afterwards proved to be the correct one. And yet he was absolutely incapable of working out the practical points..." —Sherlock Holmes, speaking of his brother in "The Adventure of the Greek Interpreter"

"The conclusions of every department are passed to him, and he is the central exchange, the clearinghouse, which makes out the balance. All other men are specialists, but his specialism is omniscience." —"The Bruce-Partington Plans"

Mycroft actually seems like a pretty cool character. He has better deductive skills than Sherlock, but he doesn't have the drive/obsession Sherlock has to confirm his ideas.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/gerald_bostock Jan 02 '14

I thought it was already established that Mycroft was the clever one.

164

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

We already knew that.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (12)

69

u/Tomm_Bradford Jan 01 '14

I personally think the only plausible explanation we've been shown is the Sherlock/Moriarty kiss.

→ More replies (2)

75

u/al5xander Jan 01 '14

when sherlock and moriarity was about to kiss i just laughed so fucking loud

250

u/EmilyGoesMeow Jan 01 '14

"I AM NOT SHAVING FOR SHERLOCK HOLMES." "That would be cool on a tshirt." THIS NEEDS TO HAPPEN.

246

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

I would wear it, but I'm a girl so that might invoke a different thought haha.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

18

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

It was exactly what I expected! All the characters being themselves in an awesome manner!

261

u/Laremere Jan 01 '14

The hat!

When he said "Time to be Sherlock" and started walking to the door only to pause, I yelled out "The hat!" and then when he reached for it, I let out a joyful "Yes, the hat!"

→ More replies (8)

107

u/serenitary Jan 01 '14

Holy crap. I think the Sherlock's character arc this season is going to be learning how to be less of an asshole. Pity.

→ More replies (11)

204

u/TentacledTessa Jan 01 '14

That was the best thing I've seen all year.

→ More replies (9)

353

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

So, did anyone else feel like Moffat was speaking directly to us during that scene with Sherlock and Anderson?

376

u/PallandoTheBlue Jan 01 '14

Yep. "Everyone's a critic."

→ More replies (1)

93

u/TentacledTessa Jan 01 '14

Yep. Anderson became us in the mini-episode, now he's very much us. Except that we don't fake crimes to get Sherlock's attention.

Yet...

→ More replies (2)

36

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

There was a lot of that episode which was speaking to and making fun of the fandom.

41

u/SleepyHarry Jan 01 '14

I'm waiting for the gif with "THE FANDOM" plastered across it.

/request

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (19)

41

u/ZarrowWrites Jan 01 '14

The whole 13 theories possibilities was complete fan service. It's was great AND frustrating.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/SourPotato Jan 02 '14

The best part is the fact that John keeps saying "I'm not gay!" and everyone nods and then laughs when he turns away. It's okay John. The closet is the place to keep skeletons, not your feelings.

14

u/create1ders Jan 02 '14

I like trains.

26

u/yourmydinner Jan 01 '14

Worth the wait indeed!

13

u/Bradboy Jan 01 '14

I was so fucking angry 2 minutes it. I was so fucking angry. When I heard 'Bollocks!' I sighed so bloody hard. I love how Gatiss basically just took the piss out of us all the way through. When Sherlock started laughing I thought we we going in for the whole 'Walt in the crawl space' breaking bad plot point. Bloody amazing. Worth the wait.

12

u/TSpange Jan 02 '14

John kept asking for an indicator, even the smallest sign or hint that Sherlock was alive. Sherlock told Mycroft and Molly and the parents about the fake death, why not John?

He did. Sherlock told him "It's a trick... It's just a magic trick."

11

u/NoGod4MeInNYC Jan 02 '14

Did anyone notice the allusion to the "A Case of Identity" short story with the woman and her stepfather in Sherlock's office (sitting room)?

Were any of those other small cases nods to the short stories? I couldn't recognize any others.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Wow, they really played off the fandom, didn't they? There was the theories, obsessive fans and even shipping. I'm not entirely sure how to feel about that…

→ More replies (1)

116

u/Stach37 Jan 01 '14

Anyone else feel like Anderson was suppose to represent the viewers of the show?

57

u/yourawoman Jan 01 '14

I did thoroughly enjoy all the little fake fan fiction explanations they put in. I did nearly turn it off after the first 5 mins before they told us that explanation was a fake. When do you guys reckon they will actually tell us?

I wasn't really to happy with the whole "there's always a off switch" but on the whole a good return to the series.

77

u/sebzim4500 Jan 01 '14

If I was building a bomb I would sure as hell include an off switch. It would be easy to set it off accidentally, and I'd rather not die.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

10

u/Kalvin95 Jan 01 '14

Absolutely fantastic reintroduction for the new Sherlock series, pretty much perfect in every aspect. I did notice that the first half feels like its been fan-written, and the writing was much faster paced than usual, with many more jokes put in, but I felt this was an episode designed to be a fun (re)introduction for fans old and new.

With also a noticeably larger budget for graphics and effects, it makes it feel even more slick (if that were possible), and just adds to the greatness of the episode.

Loved that the favourite fan-theory was written in there (Anderson's theory) and was just laughing the whole way through the fangirl's theory XD

Slightly nit-picking here, but I was slightly disappointed with the simplistic resolution to the train bomb, although for comedic effect it was bloody hilarious :D

All in all, very glad Sherlock's back, and it was definitely well worth the wait _^

→ More replies (2)

81

u/serenitary Jan 01 '14

basically all the major fandom pairings had their scene

  • sherlolly (sherlock and molly kissing)
  • sheriarty (they were giggling like schoolboys oh god)
  • johnlock (most of it)

MOFFAT:RETURN OF THE TROLL: PART TWO

78

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Sherstrade had a nice embrace too.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/chasethelight Jan 02 '14

I was not satisfied with the Johnlock. Everyone else got a kiss or a hug, and I got a fiancee who I can't hate because she's just too cool. Life is pain.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

26

u/filthysize Jan 01 '14

Haha, I knew they weren't gonna actually tell us. After so long, it's so built up they knew they could only disappoint. I ain't even mad.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Danzibar Jan 01 '14

All in all I really enjoyed this episode but there were two things that really bugged me. Firstly the narrative felt very disconnected and it left me a little confused as to what scenes were relevant to what sub-plot. Secondly, the entire underground bomb plot bugged me. So there was a bomb on the train and there were demolition charges up the tunnel, why did Sherlock turning one bomb off disarm the charges outside the train car? Or was that the detonator for all of them and I'm being an idiot for not immediately assuming this?

13

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

The charges in the tunnel didn't have their own detonators. They would have been set off my the first explosion.

9

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

All of the character development was refreshing, especially between with him and Mycroft.

Sherlock ATE in this episode.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/birtney Jan 02 '14

Did anyone else notice in the news broadcast that says Sherlock's alive that the ticker at the bottom of the screen said something along the lines of "Magnussen being called before Parliament"?

24

u/aaronboardley Jan 02 '14

A die-hard train fanatic just happened to forget about a line between Westminster and St. James Park until Sherlock reminded him? Don't buy it for a second, and it's really bugging me.

There were no through-trains while John and Sherlock were down there so it had to be a whole separate branch. TrainFan said he'd checked and there were NONE. It's annoying that he just happened to miss that massively convenient one because 'it wasn't on the maps'.

Love the fan-trolling stuff. Bugged to hell about that.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/zedsdeadbby Jan 01 '14

Loved Molly's fiance. That and the "F-" "cough" bit were fucking hilarious.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/webgirly Jan 03 '14

I think maybe I asked this question in the wrong context earlier, so I'll try again.

Remember Moffatt saying: "I've been online and looked at all the theories and there's one clue that everyone's missed. It's something that Sherlock did that was very out of character, but which nobody has picked up on." ? http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/9027070/Have-Sherlock-fans-missed-a-big-clue.html

I've been quite distracted by this point and have been trying to figure out what it was (my conclusion was the whole "You repel me" reaction, though that led me nowhere) so I was looking out for the answer on Wednesday - but I didn't see anything.

Did I miss it? Or was it not mentioned/covered? Or is Moffatt just screwing with everyone, again?

27

u/EdoTve Jan 01 '14

Wait a second, I didn't understand something quite completely. We really don't know how he did it do we?

→ More replies (14)

25

u/IAMAchavwhoknocks Jan 01 '14

That was fucking brilliant!

25

u/EpsilonSigma Jan 02 '14

Despite all the various hilarious scenes and dialogue, I'm not a huge fan of this episode all that much, and judging by the next episode's trailer, it's not looking to good.

Over the last 2 years, Moffat, Gatiss, Cumberbatch and Freeman have all become increasingly aware of the fandom and cult following. As I suspected, this has affected the episode in a way that they made it feel a little bit too "fan-service-y". I mean, yes, the mystery of the episode was at least THERE, but it wasn't the most thrilling or original. The show up to this point has been all about the mystery of the episode, and the characters reacting to the mysteries. This episode was all about the characters reacting with each other, and the mystery felt kind of forced into the plot. And judging by how the next episode is about a wedding of two primary characters, I feel like it's going to be more the same. I know there was some big elephants that needed to be taken care of from last series, but I really don't think the entire episode needed to be spent on it.

I still like the show, and I fucking died at how hilarious the scenes were. But I can't help but feel like the show isn't what I started watching it for right now. I liked it because it was Sherlock Holmes, in modern times, solving clever crimes. I hope that this is a one off occurrence, especially given the scarcity of episodes and how long it takes for new ones to come out.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/timliew Jan 02 '14

So much to love about this!

I know some people are complaining about the reference to so many fan theories and the fact the episode focused on the Sherlock/John relationship rather than the case, but I loved it.

One of the weaknesses of Conan Doyle's version is the fact that Holmes is gone for 3 years (versus 2 in the TV episode), Watson faints upon seeing his friend alive and then it's as if nothing ever happened. Watson's shock and rage her is far more real.

And I think people who complain about the fan theories being enacted and the lack of plot are missing the point somewhat. The story is all about the relationship deliberately - even the bomb plot is just a means of forcing John to open up and forgive Sherlock. And, as John himself says, the point is not to explain how Sherlock survives but the repercussions of his act. Like a magician's trick, the truth is always more mundane than the illusion itself. There is nothing that Gatiss could have written which would satisfy all the fans who believe their solutions are better. So why bother?

14

u/Fantismal Jan 02 '14

My favorite exchange in this episode was between Mycroft and Sherlock.

"I'm not lonely."

"How would you know?"

I think that summarizes just about everything in two lines. Sherlock and Mycroft are probably the two most lonely people on the planet, isolated with their massive intellect, but they don't realize it because they've never been not-lonely. It's like how people say "I never realized we were poor until someone else told me." Sherlock got John in his life, and when he lost John for two years, he realized that these feelings he had felt all along were loneliness. That's why he's being so human this episode: he knows how to fix his loneliness, and that's by getting John back.

However, he realized that his big brother probably also feels this loneliness, only Mycroft has never had a John to show him what it feels like to NOT be lonely, and that's why Sherlock is so invested in his relationships right now and playing with him and such. He realized he hadn't known happiness before John, so Mycroft must have never known happiness either.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/thebeatsandreptaur Jan 01 '14

Objectively not the best episode, probably one of the worst. Non objectively. YESSSSSSSSSSSS YES IT WAS SO MUCH FUN I MISSED IT SO MUCH! UGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH MOFFAT! GATTIS! MIND PALACE!

→ More replies (6)

33

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Anderson is just a perfect presentation of us/the internet

13

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

Definitely don't think we got the real story of his survival, which is semi-unfortunate. I liked that this was a lighter episode overall, because of how very, very dark the finale was (which was necessary).

John's escalating aggression toward Sherlock was pretty goddamn hilarious, I thought.

And seeing Sherlock want to lean on Molly more, but having to pull back as her engagement was revealed was hard. He's always had John to lean on, he's sort of lost that, he goes to the person who was always enamored with him and now has lost that too.

And I thought that Mary was a good, solid supporting character. Good chemistry with John (which makes sense because she is Martin Freeman's partner), and it was interesting to see Sherlock not be dismissive of her.

I daresay Sherlock's had to discard some of his petulance that we find endearing but in that world must be infuriating.

13

u/aspmaster Jan 03 '14

Am I the only one who didn't like it?!

The episode was like 80% fanservice and slapstick comedy. Booooo.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/shki Jan 02 '14

Obviously, after all the anticipation, I enjoyed it immensely. That said...

The entire episode talking about the fanbase to the fanbase, it was tiring. If they kept it to a little nod here and there it would've been magical, I think. This way it's like, you'd have complained whatever explanation we offered, so fuck you, everyone's a critic. Well yes, your job is to make the thing, and our job is to react to it, not the other way around.

Obviously they're all geniuses and I'm hopelessly hooked, it's just... I don't need them to talk about us, I need them to talk about Sherlock et al. It drained some of the fun out of it for me.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/InternetIsHard Jan 01 '14

Now that I think about it... for people new to the series this episode wouldn't be anything special, wouldn't it? For someone who missed the fandom going crazy, all the theories, the wait... it could actually be one of the worse Sherlock eps...
I personally loved every second of it but I had the context of the last two years. People who will get into the series later will be either very confused or very put off...

6

u/ForestfortheDraois Jan 02 '14

A few thoughts that went through my head:

On Anderson's (first) theory: "Are we being mocked? We're being mocked."

On running around in Serbia: "That's not Sherlock! He doesn't run like Sherlock...Oh, I guess that is him. I won't be majoring in deduction any time soon. (Back to elementary school? badumtss)"

On Sherlock and Molly: "Finally, Sherlock got people. At least Molly. That was very sweet."

On the plot of the episode: "Am I watching V for Vendetta? No? Okay..."

On Anderson: "I feel bad for him, the crazy bugger."

On Lestrade's reunion: "Aw, at least someone's not decking Sherlock out."

On the body double: "I said on this subreddit that we'd probably not find out about the Hansel and Gretel double and we did. I apologize."

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 03 '14

'Surprise me'

'Certainly endeavouring to sir'

6

u/MrXBob Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14

I think this just proves beyond doubt that too much hype and speculation is a bad thing.

No explanation of how he survived will ever be enough to satisfy the people (us) who have wondered and guessed for so long. The expectation for some amazing illusion is now far too high.

I don't believe we'll ever get the real explanation, for this reason.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/ferengi Jan 03 '14

Does this mean that Sherlock and Mycroft aren't the children of Peers? Because Mummy and Daddy did not seem as toffy as both Sherlock and Mycroft did they? I always thought that Mycroft was a lord of some sort even in this universe?

6

u/spacemanxxx Jan 03 '14

The bad guy in the end with the glasses is Sir Alex Ferguson!!

23

u/sars911 Jan 01 '14

Loved it. Everyone is a critic..

18

u/BellisBlueday Jan 01 '14

John in the bonfire

Hedgehogs in bonfires

John = Hedgehog

→ More replies (2)

46

u/Kreindeker Jan 01 '14

I had one major problem with the episode - I felt like the end sequence really heavily borrowed from V For Vendetta, the comic and the film. The whole disused underground station and train as a bomb under Westminster REALLY bugged me. Maybe I'm just reading too much into it, but it felt like it was lifted from Alan Moore.

31

u/[deleted] Jan 01 '14

Both Sherlock and V for Vendetta borrowed from reality.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (19)

10

u/Sepolash Jan 02 '14

One thing that annoyed me was that one of the texts said: "hotting up here", and my grammar nazi rose up in me.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Spawnzer Jan 01 '14

Thank you for the trust issues Moffat

5

u/martens92 Jan 01 '14

Loved every bit of it. Wonderfully done, and now I can't wait for the next one. Loved it when John juat kept going after Sherlock after see each other, really captured the pain he felt.

5

u/AnimatedSnake Jan 02 '14

I'm a pretty new fan to the show, but I'm loving it so far.

The new episode really did go head on, and after a two year wait, it wouldn't have made any sense if they had blown over the character-interactions in a few heartbeats.

So to continue the series I think it was important that there was so much focus on the characters talking about what the hell happened (to a fuller or lesser extent). Imagine if Sherlock came into the restaurant, and John were: "Oh, awesome!" and that was it, and suddenly they are partners again.

From John character I thought of nothing less than the tackle he gave him, and I did actually think he would punch him (like he does before meeting Adler), so I thought it pretty appropriate that he head-butted Sherlock.

Nice interactions between all the characters.

The plot was, not as substantial as plenty have said already. But I do think it is great that they are bringing more focus on the small text-bubbles when they are seeing things hard for us as the viewer. Bringing us more inside, and letting us know what is going on, just a bit under the surface.

Horrible to see John in the Bonfire, I hated everything about that, the thought of burning alive, gruesome, but it moved the plot along.

General in movies and series, I enjoy character development very much. So a scale from 1-to-10, I'm giving it a 8/10. I thoroughly enjoyed it, and was on the tip of my seat the whole episode. Sherlock is back!

5

u/telmah Jan 02 '14

Reference to the original stories: the lady that is crying because her online friend has disappeared is a re-hash / update of A Case of Identity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Case_of_Identity

This episode was so much fun!

→ More replies (1)

5

u/LionDoctor Jan 02 '14

Loved the bit where the fangirl was theorizing about Sherlock/Moriarty action on the rooftop. Great little tribute to all the crazy Sherlock fanfic!

5

u/snazzmasterj Jan 03 '14

Alright, here's my critique of the episode. I get that they wanted to poke some fun at the fans and emphasize the "why" as opposed to the "how", and that's all well and good. But, not actually explaining the how is a huge misstep on their part. By creating the "how" cliffhanger at the end of season 2, they are the ones who made this into a question/mystery, and it then becomes their responsibility to answer it. So, if you think they are never going to answer it, then that is just bad writing on their part; if you create a cliffhanger, not answering it makes all future cliffhangers pointless. If they're just going to reveal it later, then it's simply lazy writing; they could have made this into it's own season, but if they instead decide to draw out that answer, it just defines this season by an event that happened in the previous one. That being said, I did overall enjoy the episode. The acting was great, the editing superb, and it seems they've set up a good future plot. But by making fun of their fans for trying to figure out a mystery which they themselves set up, they devalue any future mysteries they present.

5

u/ginjah_ninjah Jan 03 '14

Here's my main problem with most of the theories, even given they're false. They all operate on the assumption that the point of the farse was to fool JOHN. In context, the only person who had to believe Sherlock had jumped was the sniper and possibly Moriarty (if he hadn't shot himself) the problem for me with all the decoy theories is that in all of them, most of the effort was aimed at convincing JOHN and if that's the case, why?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/onthecrystalship Jan 03 '14

I nearly died of a heart attack during the Sheriarty Fanfiction theory. My dad (who has never seen the show) was just like "WTF?"

5

u/schulace Jan 14 '14

anybody else notice the bomb code?

051113

5 Nov 2013

Really? The fucking date? THAT'S YOUR SUPER SECRET BOMB CODE BRO?

86

u/awsum_possum Jan 01 '14

Not their best work imho, but good.

167

u/fenwaygnome Jan 01 '14

It was like entirely fan-service.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/MrSamster911 Jan 02 '14

i was really waiting for molly to say to (insert bfs name here) that he could take off the stupid coat, and that she was just trying to fuck with sherlocks head

9

u/Martialis1 Jan 02 '14

They used so much time for the reintroduction of Sherlock Holmes that the plot was by far the weakest out of all the episodes.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/mattypemulis Jan 03 '14

Don't want to be a hater, but I was disappointed in this episode.

I feel like Series 1 & 2 were mystery shows with a dash of humor. This felt like a comedy show, with Sherlock acting Wacky with a capital W. Too much time spent mugging for the camera and too little time solving sodding mysteries.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/gamertje Jan 01 '14

OH MY GOD, WE STILL DON'T KNOW!! MOFFAAAT!

But seriously, that was awesome and I can't wait for the next episode!

4

u/helloduckie Jan 01 '14

OH MY GOD! I LOVED IT! Two years waiting was worth it!

4

u/Pendergast221 Jan 01 '14

As soon as I saw the Sherlock mask I was ecstatic because that was the theory I was convinced of all along. Now I just feel like an eejit

4

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

Not going to lie, Molly and Sherlock's interaction really pulled on my heart strings. Did it for anyone else? How he told her that she had always mattered and that she was the most important girl. It was the most sincere I feel that he has ever been to...anyone thus far (in my opinion). I tip my hat off to the director. The very sincere scene between the two of them talking in the corridor was made all the better by the angle of the camera. Because it was at the top of the stairs made us feel like a kid listening in on a secret conversation, which it was. It was magical. Also did anyone notice how in the beginning of the episode Molly was the one who suggested dinner, and just before Sherlock told Molly she was the most important person, he was the one who suggested dinner?

I also squealed in an impossibly high pitch when Sherlock and Lestrade reunited.

It was so worth the wait, the only thing I was disappointed was because they didn't give us an official answer as to how he did it.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

The episode was made to ridicule the fan theories nothing more. Some might believe that it was written well considering the fact that the show was on a hiatus and the episode made it easy for the audience to blend in with the world of sherlock once again but I feel that the whole plot was too 'ordinary' for a sherlock series and a little more background tease of the blackmailer would have been much better than Sherlock doing a Jason Bourne to save John.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/bigboss2014 Jan 02 '14

The code lord north korea used for the bomb was 051113 - the date for those who didn't cop it!

4

u/isris1 Jan 02 '14

The clue for me, that the whole how-he-did-it scene was imagined by Anderson, was how Sherlock keeps referring to him as Phillip. Sherlock never refers to any of the police officers by their first names (we don't even know Anderson's first name until this episode) and he even forgot Lestrade's in this episode itself!

Also, during Sherlock's absence, we've seen how he's become obsessive, bordering on crazy about Sherlock. Sherlock addressing him on first-name basis would be just what Anderson would hope for. In my opinion, just another pointer that the scene wasn't quite real...

4

u/tomothy94 Jan 02 '14 edited Jan 02 '14

Just read this in an interview with Radio Times with Gatiss and Moffat;

So was that last solution [The one Sherlock explained on camera] the correct one?

"That’s presuming, of course, that Sherlock Holmes would bother to tell Anderson the truth,” said Moffat. “We might still not know."

"[But] it’s a very plausible version of how he did it,” Gatiss was quick to add.

Link to article- http://www.radiotimes.com/news/2014-01-01/sherlock-is-back--and-we-still-dont-know-how-he-survived-the-fall

Am I wrong to take this as almost solid evidence that the explanation he gave Anderson was at least not accurate?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

A bit after the fact, but who's the boyfriend at the end? Is everybody shocked to see him just because he looks a lot like Sherlock, or because he's somebody big?

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Danfurbs Jan 03 '14

As a railway engineer, seeing Sherlock walk so close to the 3rd rail after telling John that it was live was painful. Stood between the running rail and the 3rd rail is almost certain death. Still, loved the episode.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 03 '14

How do you think Sherlock got onto to that motorcycle to save John? Mary was there so I can assume it wasn't something too unsavory. Also, it couldn't have been something related to whacking the driver out of consciousness because there were two people on the bike. All that, and he had to do this quickly. Did Mary or Sherlock happen to have large wads of cash on hand? I am sure some sherlock fans would just willingly give up their bike without asking, but what are the changes.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/paddymac64 Jan 03 '14

I was laughing so hard at the GP Doctor's room scenes! Mrs Hudson- "What did he say?" Sherlock- "f..." Watson- "Cough?" And the iconic silhouette before Mrs Hudson screamed! Grinning massively!

4

u/aaronboardley Jan 04 '14

Perhaps we haven't heard the end of the train story?

I think the die-hard train fan was 'put up to' bating Sherlock. It annoyed me how he conveniently 'forgot' that disused station despite being an absolute fanatic (see http://www.reddit.com/r/Sherlock/comments/1u6n7u/the_empty_hearse_postepisode_discussion_thread/cef2z8a?context=3) - but remember, HE approached SHERLOCK. We are all disastisfied with the train bit of the episode I think, it seems sub-Sherlock...so perhaps it's not yet finished? It was all some kind of bait, like the Bonfire bit, too?

12

u/miss_smash Jan 02 '14

I laughed in many, many places, but I think my favourite was Sherlock and Mycroft playing Operation - tears were shed!

And I know it wasn't real, but the hair ruffle after Sherlock went flying through the window... drool

→ More replies (4)

7

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '14

Key piece of dialogue no one's noted yet:

Mary: You died. You jumped off a roof.
Sherlock: No.

→ More replies (2)