r/anime • u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • Jul 31 '26
Meta The Temporary Random Sort for Episode Discussion Comments will be made Permanent Starting August 1, 2026
We are changing the default sort for episode discussion comments to random for the first six hours of an episode thread's posting.
reddit's default "best" comment sorting incentivizes posting early in episode discussions by giving the earliest comments the most exposure and thus chances for upvotes and karma. The feedback loop of exposure time and upvotes would result in early comments, even if low-effort, dominating the top spots in episode discussion, while comments of greater quality that required more time to develop (or indeed even enough time to finish watching the episode) would not get the recognition they deserved.
Thus, we will randomize the comments to give quality a better chance against speed. While early comments will still have an advantage from a longer view time, this will be mitigated by randomization as a higher-effort comment which took longer to write will still have a chance to appear at the top of the sort. Unfortunately, the limitations of Reddit's official mobile app prevent us from applying this change for mobile readers.
This change will go live at 0001 UTC August 1.
The randomization reverts to reddit's normal sorting after six hours to make the episode discussion easier to read and follow, particularly after refreshing the page.
A trial for this ran from February 18 to April 1, 2026. Pre-trial data and user feedback can be found here.
•
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan Jul 31 '26
The statistics:
Data from episode discussion threads spanning 2019 to 2026:
Raw Linearly smeared Normal smeared data (σ=40)
Linear smear takes the karma value of each comment and spreads it across the 60 seconds before and after its posting, allowing for second-level granularity but with more generalized trend lines versus individual spikes. It is the recommended way of analyzing the results.
Normal smear concentrates the smearing effect more closely to the precise time of each comment. Full karma value is not entirely represented due to cutoffs and is somewhat distorted from real world karma values, thus it should not be compared to other graph types.
It was concluded that the trial was highly effective at curbing the first comment effect, with a strong decrease in karma for comments made in the first two to three minutes and moderate decreases in karma up to about the 20 minute mark. Beyond that range, effects on karma dipped back below the noise level.
146
u/ciberrrr Jul 31 '26
Can this make comments with negative karma be on top? Sometimes there are quite a few trolls, ragebaiters or people giving spoilers without spoiler tag on episode discussion threads.
58
u/zairaner https://myanimelist.net/profile/zairaner Jul 31 '26
I always wondered why the discussion thread goes up the moment the episode is available, and not 20 minutes after that when people will have finished it. Seems like that only encourages to comment before having watched the episode (or watching the episode in japanese beforehand, or being a manga reader).
13
u/CuriousBroccolli Jul 31 '26
In short, I grew to like it a lot, even though I was unsure at first.
That being said, I have no clue what I set it to, but I have been noticing comments with more upvotes near the bottom, as well as the opposite.
It's both refreshing and better for discussion in general I'd say.
It depends on the show, but over the years, in most cases, meta shifted towards essays, memes and complaining being on top and driving most of discussions. Now you get a good mix of those and more simple ones like "great episode" , "this moment was really funny", "boobs" etc.
Just normal comments that ease the tension and clutter, which is in my opinion super important for more casual users.
If course, as you have said, commenting later is no longer pointless, which is likely the most important part, but I just wanted to point out things I liked.
27
u/wloff :GJ::GK::GL: Jul 31 '26
I very much like the change, though I would personally increase the duration from 6 hours, probably to 12 hours or so.
Have you considered doing a trial run with a longer duration to see if it has any meaningful effect on the stats? Or are you just happy that the effect of the instant 2-minute random posts is curbed?
8
u/Distinct-Rain-2360 Jul 31 '26
I think this is definitely a good change. I'd like to note just as an avid comment reader, that even if given an exposure buff, there's a sharp drop-off for engagement and upvotes once the comment passes a certain "complexity score" threshold.
On the lower end, let's say we bucket ultra low quality comments as one liners, memes and random drive by bashing, subpar comments being those just post their personal opinions (ex: "I hate this character so much"), short summaries and bulk screenshotters, normal comments as those who point out easy to miss details, and surface level plotline discussions. The normal comments are the ones that are going to be most equalized by this policy.
Everything in the higher tier just tends to get ignored. It could be plotline comments which span more than 5 paragraphs or 800 words. It could be in depth or higher order analysis about character psychology and actions. It could be references and parallels to the real world or other series. It could be opinions that go against the grain that are backed with good justifications. For threads that go beyond 500 comments in popular series, I'm always digging to the end of
load more comments, because these gem comments are always at the end with 1 upvote before the late normal ones with 1 upvote followed by those with negative votes.I don't think this is something that can be fixed, because this sub has long passed critical mass and mainstream awareness, meaning that the sub's behavior will have strong inertia to that of the average dopamine addicted redditor, regardless of measures taken.
That said, I hope to be proven wrong, as I often wait for a season to end before binging and reading the episode comments after watching each episode.
6
u/Syokhan https://myanimelist.net/profile/Syokhan Jul 31 '26
I quite liked this implementation back during its trial run, so I'm happy to see that it's going to be permanent. Thanks mods!
6
u/Nebresto Jul 31 '26
Good. I still think the randomized time should be doubled at the least though
17
u/WeeziMonkey https://myanimelist.net/profile/WeeziMonkey Jul 31 '26
I like the change. I never watch an episode the exact moment it airs, and as a result I usually never saw a point in leaving comments because my comment would already be buried at the bottom by the time of posting it.
5
u/ptd163 Jul 31 '26
I'm in favour of this change. I quite liked the trial. It surfaced comments I might not have otherwise seen or engaged with. I would suggest bumping it up to at least 8 hours though. Maybe even 10 or 12.
The reason I suggest is this is because of shows likes Polar Opposites S2. Because of how time zones work it airs in that
sweetsour spot of 4 am Eastern Time. A large part of NA is not awake at that time so there's a chance that lots of NA viewers will not get to benefit from random sort the way other viewers will be able to.4
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jul 31 '26
Nice!
The difference wasn't as marked as I thought it would be (because as OP said, the early comments still have most exposure), but every bit helps!
8
u/ElectricalCompany260 Jul 31 '26
Can someone tell me why I get in some other subs top instead of best as default?
How can I change ALL subs to best on default?
17
u/Hitman7128 https://anilist.co/user/Hitman7128 Jul 31 '26
Good! It helps mitigate situations where you have something important when an episode discussion thread gets posted, as well as situations where a thread gets hit by bots/users that downvote every comment.
6
u/Jusenkyo_5 Jul 31 '26
Great decision
2
u/tehcharizard https://anilist.co/user/Lv100Pidgeot Jul 31 '26
I sort by oldest to newest regardless so won't make any difference to me.
2
u/MeatballZeitgeist Jul 31 '26
I was a little skeptical myself at first but it definitely made it easier to participate in a discussion without having to set your alarm clock to catch the thread in the first ~20-30 minutes.
2
u/ryecurious Jul 31 '26
I'm really confused why you say this, this is how Top sorting works, not Best.
Best was literally invented to solve this exact problem, giving comments posted later an advantage over earlier ones (as long as they can get a higher ratio).
Not saying Random can't be better in this niche case, but I'm genuinely shocked how many people in this thread are describing problems with Top sorting but saying they're from Best.
2
u/Moxey616 Aug 01 '26
Horrible news for the unemployed
2
u/CIearMind Jul 31 '26
Good choice. Good good.
2
u/Skyreader13 Jul 31 '26
Great change
-2
u/D3k4s Jul 31 '26 edited Jul 31 '26
Solid choice. Would it also be possible to address how the "Though I'm An Inept Villainess" episode discussion is currently being created to match pirated content availability? I think this is an issue IMO.
https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/comments/1v6wj1b/though_i_am_an_inept_villainess_futsutsuka_na/
I included the thread so that you could read the explanation from the mods:
1
u/detarameReddit https://myanimelist.net/profile/qTqTdetarameMAL Aug 01 '26
In theory, this change makes sense for me. I guess we'll see about in practice.
Thanks for all the hard work, r/anime mods! :D
1
u/ilikechess13 Aug 01 '26
So i guess this change does not work for old.reddit?
guess this is why i completely missed this thing earlier this year because it just didnt happen for me
i wonder how small percentage of redditors use the old.reddit
1
u/Epsilon_void Jul 31 '26
What a shame.
1
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Jul 31 '26
Thats an odd choice for a reddit that focuses on live anime disscussions.
If your post gets burried in a hundres others what point is there to watch anime as it aires and disscuss it as it airs with others? This negtively impacts that which was somethign many come here for.
Dont yall have a bests comments thing each year? Wouldnt this negatively impact that too?
The idea that people are farming imaginary internet points is what ever, who cares about those? Karma farmers have many other places to go to do that. But thiis action to try to counter that is an odd movee because it hurts those who wanna discuss anime as it airs with others.
Just my 2 cents from someone who doesnt care about karma and is just here to talk about anime with people. Feels like this will only hurt that in general.
1
u/Aviri Jul 31 '26
Interesting change, will be interested in how it plays out on the full sub for discussions.
1
u/AceSoldia https://anilist.co/user/Acesoldia Jul 31 '26
Ah interesting I always wondered how sometimes the first comment got everything
1
u/LaughingDash https://myanimelist.net/profile/lankyseat Jul 31 '26
Awesome change!
1
u/Agarvorn Jul 31 '26
except for Mushoku Tensei threads which are gonna be sorted by controversial by default
1
u/slicer4ever Aug 01 '26
Would it be worth also hiding comment karma during that 6 hour period as well?
-2
u/Thomas_JCG Jul 31 '26
Statistics also show that more people die from falling off their beds than from plane crashes, yet nobody thinks the solution is make people sleep in planes.
That said, I do understand the decision. In popular threads, there will be too many comments to read so sorting by best makes it so only the comments that got the early start get read, upvoted and continue the cycle. I do not believe that low effort gets to be on top, though, so I see it more as a way for people that watch the episodes later to still be seen.