Early in the episode Shawn and Gus reference the Dukes of Hazard remake and talk about the race car driver being 'cartoonish'. The race car driver was played by James Roday.
It's funny, I watched it last night while inebriated and remembered him from The Tao of Gus. I watched it sober today and I was racking my brain to figure out what episode he was in, and I remember him from the suicide hotline. It wasn't until your comment that I realized he played two (well, three-ish now) different characters, and not even cameos.
You just saved my head from a world of pain! It was taking me forever to think of it. I love this episode but it's hard to try and remember what actors were in what episodes.
I attempted to create a list of every recurring guest star and the episode they were in prior to tonight's. Fill in anything I missed or got wrong. I tried.
Dana Ashbrook - Bob Barker - "Dual Spires"
Ray Wise - Father Westley - "Dual Spires"
Ray Wise - Father Westley - "The Devil Is in the Details... And the Upstairs Bedroom"
Ralph Macchio - Nick Conforth - "We'd Like To Thank The Academy"
Michael Weston - Adam Hornstock - "Cloudy With A Chance Of Murder"
Lindsay Sloan - Melinda - "Shawn and the Real Girl"
Alan Ruck - Phil Stubbins - "Gus Walks Into A Bank"
So far no one has mentioned, that Andy Berman, who was the white guy with an Asian Accent from Autotopsy Turvy, was in the courtroom crowd. Noticed him right near the end.
We originally guessed that it might be a double and that she might not have been around for when they shot that scene. But after playing back the scene it really looked like Jules. Anyone else have any idea?
I guess I never noticed that - IMBD trivia apparently claims that Juliet often sneezes during Shawn's psychic episodes. I guess I'm going to have to watch the entire series again
Wasn't it voted on by fans. They got to choose between about 5 different episodes to remake? I mean I guess I don't understand why the show publicists came up with that idea, but when shows have a big cult following like Psych, they do strange things like this to please people.
That . . . was not great. I give them credit for the effort, but I don't think the execution was there - if they're going to do a remake of a prior ep, it should be much improved, and this was decidedly not.
I watched the original season one ep just before this one came on, and that comparison really brought home how much better the first one was. But it also highlighted something that's been bothering me in recent seasons: the Flanderization of Sean. I know I'm not the only one to say this, but it hasn't been something that bothered me enough to mention before. Seeing Season 1 Sean right before seeing current Sean, and in supposedly the same ep, brought home how over the top and borderline obnoxious he has become. In the past, while silly, his behavior served a purpose - he was an astute observer of human behavior and had a truly unparalleled eye for details. This all made him a heck of a detective. These days, however, much of the ep is taken up with Sean blundering around, making an ass of himself, pissing people off, and at the last minute, stumbling onto some absurd bit of information or observation that allows him to save the day. Edit: I seriously expected this episode to turn out to be a dream or something due to how ridiculously over the top all the performances were. . . and that's saying something for this show.
Don't get me wrong, I still like the show. But this episode. . . it made me realize that it's a good thing they're winding it up.
They bash remakes through the entire episode, and this episode "wasn't as good as the first one." How do you not find this hilariously meta, and probably intentional?
I think this episode was kind of designed as a spoof on remakes. I think they let the audience in on the joke at the beginning where they ripped the idea of remakes in general.
I though it was a funny line the first few times, sure. But as the show went on, and wasn't good, the line became less and less funny, and more a sadly true commentary.
I mean, I like meta humor as much as the next guy, but I'm more interested in watching a good show.
Ya, and I get where you're coming from, because s01e12 is much better plot-and-acting-wise (way better). I still thought this one was a good episode because of the meta, quips, nods and spoilers. Two different kinds of good. Still the best of this season, I think. Can't please everyone though.
Sure, don't get me wrong, I still like the series. It's not the same as in the first season (and in my opinion, not as good), but it's still a good show. I'm not usually one to bash a show that has some bad eps. . . but this seemed like a particularly bad misstep. Still, I'm not going to become a hater.
I feel like Shawn has been acting weird this whole season. I realize it's only been a few episodes but what the heck? It's like he's being dumb or stupid. It's not a plus for the show, in my opinion.
I honestly had zero recall, and was annoyed with myself, because I knew it would be funnier if I could remember it. And my DVR had actually recorded Cloudy with a Chance of Murder, as though it was trying to tell me to watch it first.
On the plus side, my rewatch of Psych is, apparently, going to feel like an entirely new show :)
There was a subtle Twin Peaks reference tonight, too. Ray Wise played judge Horace Leland, and he's most famous for his Twin Peaks role, Leland Palmer.
Contrary to what everyone else is saying. I think I liked the remake more than the original. That said however they tried to make the plot a lot more convoluted in this one. With more twists and turns and it just turns out confusing. They never explain why the lenard was killed.
If they stay with the original episode, it will probably be the girl from the modeling episode killing him because he wouldn't sleep with her. Which he'd be fucking crazy for, because she's super hot
I like how they made Shawn go back to his crazy old self in this episode. They acknowledged the fact that he used to act crazy when he had visions back then whereas now he just puts his fingers to the sides of his forehead.
I had no idea what was going on. I was watching the episode like "Wait a minute, I've seen this episode before, it's from the first season, but why don't the actors look younger"
My first suspicion was that the shadow on the screen in the first version was circumstantial and hard to notice during the speed of the episode... But this evidence was pretty crappy, too.
I liked the new evidence on film since it shows a real finger and ring unlike the originals "shadow", which in all fairness would have required a "psychic" or hyper-observant person to notice.
Phone edit: to be fair, I DID enjoy all the character cameos but it kindof distracted me since I sat there trying to figure out where everyone was from
And the dad/murderer from the pilot episode and 'Cameron French' (I don't remember his real name or character name) from the Gus Walks Into A Bank episode...
Still holds up as a pretty good episode (but then, so was the original), and the references made it even better.
That said, it still seems a bit random to just remake an old episode... So I think the fact that they left most of the episode the same was a poor choice.
EDIT: By which I mean remaking an episode is itself a poor choice. You can have a new story filled with references and very similar to an old one, but just taking the same plot framework, filling it with guest stars and in-jokes/references, and calling it a new episode doesn't really work.
I love Psych, but this episode felt unnecessary. The screen freezes to remind us it was 2006 felt incredibly awkward, as did the entire episode actually. I don't really know why they did it, the original might not have been a gem but it wasn't that bad.
I think they could have just stood in front of a blank wall and said a few references and would have gotten the same point across.
Funny episode but I am really sad that they chose to remake this one. This was easily one of my favorite episodes in Season 1 and I feel like there were plenty of other episodes they could have played with.
Really disappointed by this episode =( If this really is Psych's final season, I think they should have focused more on new material and tying up all loose ends before it's over. This season really has been a let down =(
I prefer it when the final season of a show goes totally off the rails and becomes a cartoon. At least, I do when it's a comedy like Psych, which really doesn't have any loose ends to tie up.
Why do you say that? In terms of advancing plot it was pretty pointless, but it had some funny parts that I really enjoyed. And having a ton of returning guest actors was pretty cool too.
Precisely. At least the previous 2 episodes had their own mostly self-contained plot, even if it doesn't continue the storyline from the previous season finale. This one, while funny at times, wasn't as great as the original (which they said mid-episode it wouldn't be, but that's not an excuse).
67
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
Oh, fuck yes! Woody!
65
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14
Ralph Machio just said that My Cousin Vinny was just okay.
Love it!
55
u/juseipel43 Jan 23 '14
Bonerfied defense team...
53
u/lemontie Jan 23 '14
DR. JEKYLL AND MR. HY-TIDE!!!!!
48
u/borticus Jan 23 '14
Don't you "C'mon, son," me!
42
u/sbdwiggi Gee Buttersnaps Jan 22 '14
In the trailer I saw:
Father Westley (Wesley?) [Ray Wise]
Nick (The Police Acadamy Trainer) [Ralph Macchio]
The girl from the dating reality show [Lindsay Sloane]
The original Hornstock [Michael Weston (not that one)]
Am I missing any other guest stars?
41
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
I'm confused...
80
u/crashed9 Jan 23 '14
I wonder why they changed how Shawn got onto the defense team. I think the original was better than now, when they just pushed their way in.
LOVE the "It's 2006, remember?!" notices, haha.
21
u/AdamKennethHandleman Jan 23 '14
that was the best "c'mon son" ever
60
u/lemontie Jan 23 '14
hahah, that jab at Suits..."that would make a hell of a TV show"
40
u/MulciberTenebras Jan 23 '14
No else noticed the female news anchor was Janet Varney.... aka KORRA!?
19
u/kbv510 Jan 22 '14
Why is this up so early?
38
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
I attempted to create a list of every recurring guest star and the episode they were in prior to tonight's. Fill in anything I missed or got wrong. I tried.
Thank you /u/Dirty_MikeAndTheBoyz, /u/llionell, /u/mochacheesecake915, and /u/WFUTunnelAuthority
Updated.
http://www.reddit.com/r/psych/comments/1vwv5d/guest_star_list_from_tonights_episode_possible/
35
u/Incara1010 Jan 23 '14
This episode is gonna be so meta
17
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
It's gotta be the female news anchor, the weather guy wouldn't sleep with her, she was having a rough time with her husband, and she seems crazy
Edit: I stand corrected
28
u/Cryx-Hat Jan 23 '14
a flashback? cool its been a long time since we had one.
26
u/Jewrunner Jan 23 '14
Love that dukes of hazard joke about the race-car driver!
26
u/gr0c3ry Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
Blonde reporter (I believe) was the girl that Lassiter brings to Shawn and Gus' 13-year high school reunion.
64
u/lawltech Jan 22 '14
This is to my friend who has to miss tonight's episode. http://i.imgur.com/JvZHRaV.gif
10
u/thebedshow Jan 23 '14
The Aaron Eckhart lines were so good.
19
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14
How long does it take someone to obtain a Masters in Grab Ass?
18
u/mikeycai Jan 23 '14
Anyone else find the scene where Jules sneezes a little strange?
16
u/Incara1010 Jan 23 '14
Sweeeet flashback intro! Suuuuper flashback intro
13
u/juseipel43 Jan 23 '14
Interesting concept...not sure how to feel about it
18
u/Todemax Jan 23 '14
So this is literally a remake of cloudy with a chance of murder?
31
u/ThisDerpForSale Jan 23 '14
That . . . was not great. I give them credit for the effort, but I don't think the execution was there - if they're going to do a remake of a prior ep, it should be much improved, and this was decidedly not.
I watched the original season one ep just before this one came on, and that comparison really brought home how much better the first one was. But it also highlighted something that's been bothering me in recent seasons: the Flanderization of Sean. I know I'm not the only one to say this, but it hasn't been something that bothered me enough to mention before. Seeing Season 1 Sean right before seeing current Sean, and in supposedly the same ep, brought home how over the top and borderline obnoxious he has become. In the past, while silly, his behavior served a purpose - he was an astute observer of human behavior and had a truly unparalleled eye for details. This all made him a heck of a detective. These days, however, much of the ep is taken up with Sean blundering around, making an ass of himself, pissing people off, and at the last minute, stumbling onto some absurd bit of information or observation that allows him to save the day. Edit: I seriously expected this episode to turn out to be a dream or something due to how ridiculously over the top all the performances were. . . and that's saying something for this show.
Don't get me wrong, I still like the show. But this episode. . . it made me realize that it's a good thing they're winding it up.
11
u/ilwolf Jan 23 '14
Am I the only person who has next to no memory of the original episode? I feel like I didn't do my homework.
15
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14
Jackson Hale looks oddly familiar...
Bob Barker from Dual Spires
14
u/lalie Jan 23 '14
I miss Silver Fox Lassie already.
10
u/CeltPats1234 Jan 23 '14
Lmao to the Dukes of Hazzard reference
5
u/tgdm Jan 23 '14
catholic priest is a judge i what
5
u/ppsh41 Jan 23 '14
Contrary to what everyone else is saying. I think I liked the remake more than the original. That said however they tried to make the plot a lot more convoluted in this one. With more twists and turns and it just turns out confusing. They never explain why the lenard was killed.
8
u/MulciberTenebras Jan 23 '14
I knew the murder was being wrapped up too fast... but now, WTF is going on!?
4
u/Me_talking Jan 24 '14
I am really surprised they didn't make a comment about the Karate Kid remake. It was just so fitting!
7
u/vpookie Jan 22 '14
Since the episode hasn't aired yet, another question: Why are there so little dates on IMDb about the air dates of this season's episodes?
7
u/MulciberTenebras Jan 23 '14
There's gonna be a twist, or explanation for this remake.... cause all we've seen is a shorter rehash of the original episode with new guest stars
9
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
lol, nice little shout out to Suits
6
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
Flashback!
6
u/baconator41 Jan 23 '14
Father Peter Westley!
6
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
That whole scene was so awesome
6
u/Incara1010 Jan 23 '14
So wait, they changed the case to remake the story? This isn't how it played out, right?
3
u/garymich Jan 23 '14
I recognized a few others in the courtroom from past episodes as well...great episode!
3
u/blueballzzzz Jan 23 '14
So...who was juror #5?
3
u/MichaeltheMagician Jan 24 '14
I like how they made Shawn go back to his crazy old self in this episode. They acknowledged the fact that he used to act crazy when he had visions back then whereas now he just puts his fingers to the sides of his forehead.
3
u/Polite_Werewolf Jan 24 '14
With the limited number of episodes in this season, this one felt a little redundant.
3
u/bonjourlepeen Jan 25 '14
Pineapple, anyone? Totally missed it this time :(
19
u/MulciberTenebras Jan 23 '14
So yeah.... that was totally pointless
5
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
I was watching season 3 today, and during the football episode, Shawn says Gus got super excited meeting Ralph Macchio.
5
u/krissyjump Jan 23 '14
I'm really not a fan of the directing in this episode so far. The camera work has been really odd.
5
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
does this episode have every guest star ever? i love it
5
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
I kind of hope the girl is guilty this time around
10
u/junglegymion Jan 23 '14
What is the point of this episode?
4
u/lalie Jan 23 '14
This defense lawyer is what would happen if Shawn and Charlie Kelly had a child.
4
u/Jewrunner Jan 23 '14
greatest psych moment ever!
5
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14
That stage guy's beard! I'm jeally.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
I had no idea what was going on. I was watching the episode like "Wait a minute, I've seen this episode before, it's from the first season, but why don't the actors look younger"
2
u/EndersBuggers Jan 25 '14
"Cuz rain.... Is coming"
5
u/TasticString Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
Are they actively avoiding moving the plot along?
It wasn't a bad episode and had some great parts but just seemed unnecessary with other story lines being ignored.
4
u/WFUTunnelAuthority Galileo Humpkins Jan 23 '14
My first suspicion was that the shadow on the screen in the first version was circumstantial and hard to notice during the speed of the episode... But this evidence was pretty crappy, too.
Not sure what the whole point of that was
4
u/xMWJ Jan 23 '14
I still don't understand why they did that.
3
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14
Why can't Gus find a real lady friend?
3
u/lalie Jan 23 '14
I should have rewatched the original first. Was that Twin Peaks joke there in the original?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
I can never watch Katherine Isabelle in anything ever again without seeing Woody's mustache.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Are they doing the shadow-on-the-screen again?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Did I miss when Gus' tie was handed over?
3
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14 edited Jan 23 '14
Is the reason this is a flash back because they stocked it with past actors?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Love the Suits reference in this
4
u/fuzzy_dunnlop Jan 23 '14
This episode is just lazy.
2
u/WFUTunnelAuthority Galileo Humpkins Jan 23 '14
And the dad/murderer from the pilot episode and 'Cameron French' (I don't remember his real name or character name) from the Gus Walks Into A Bank episode...
2
u/juseipel43 Jan 23 '14
Who is playing Priscilla this time? It's driving me crazy that I can't recognize her
1
u/I_Are_Brown_Bear I Are Jan 23 '14
So someone is just down voting every single post? Maturity runs strong here.
1
u/not4urbrains Magic Head Jan 23 '14
Did Leonard die in the original? Also, I had all but forgotten how much more I liked Jules with longer hair.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
Aurora Borealis!
1
u/Googleflax MC Clap Yo Handz Jan 23 '14
Can anyone make a list of all the meterologist names that Hornstock listed?
1
u/V2Blast Benedict Arnold Jackson Jan 25 '14 edited Jan 25 '14
Still holds up as a pretty good episode (but then, so was the original), and the references made it even better.
That said, it still seems a bit random to just remake an old episode... So I think the fact that they left most of the episode the same was a poor choice.
EDIT: By which I mean remaking an episode is itself a poor choice. You can have a new story filled with references and very similar to an old one, but just taking the same plot framework, filling it with guest stars and in-jokes/references, and calling it a new episode doesn't really work.
1
u/Blaizeranger Jan 25 '14
I love Psych, but this episode felt unnecessary. The screen freezes to remind us it was 2006 felt incredibly awkward, as did the entire episode actually. I don't really know why they did it, the original might not have been a gem but it wasn't that bad.
I think they could have just stood in front of a blank wall and said a few references and would have gotten the same point across.
1
u/BigChinkyEyes Jan 29 '14
Funny episode but I am really sad that they chose to remake this one. This was easily one of my favorite episodes in Season 1 and I feel like there were plenty of other episodes they could have played with.
1
u/jmarquiso Jan 30 '14
"It's okay, decent at best."
Also -
Was Dule Hill doing A Feww Good Men a Sorkin/West Wing reference?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
One of the best episodes thus far in my opinion. Such a cool thing to do.
1
u/peeinherbutt Jan 23 '14
Maybe I just want it to be, but is that place in the video Michael Westen's (Burn Notice) place?
1
u/Wendi1018 Jan 23 '14
Really disappointed by this episode =( If this really is Psych's final season, I think they should have focused more on new material and tying up all loose ends before it's over. This season really has been a let down =(
0
u/ILoveDirtyMuff Jan 23 '14
I haven't started my search yet, is there a place to stream this episode yet? It would be greatly appreciated.
-5
u/midwestredditor Jan 23 '14
My god, that was absolutely awful.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment