r/thescienceofdeduction • u/aaqucnaona [Mod, Founder - on sick leave] • Feb 16 '14
Experiment [Official] Suggestion: Compiling a trigger base for deductions
[Note - Once our science advisors get some free time on their hands, the experiment will move from discussion to planning stage. We will start looking for participants at that time, so PM me if you are interested. Managing this is hard, but participation is very easy, so it won't hog your time or be too much of an effort.]
The first thing to do, I think, is this - As Chris showed here, we need to compile a list of [cues] (http://waypastmybedtime.tumblr.com/post/75622780467)[changed the name from trigger to cue since its more discriptive] for deductions. These will serve the purpose of:
- Telling us where to look.
- Telling us what we observe likely represents.
- What is usually present for each general profile of people/event/etc. so that we may notice if a non-event occurs.
How I propose we do this:
- Each week [or unit time] we decide upon a list of 10 [or n number] of such cues.
- As many of us as possible test this on the widest sample of people/situations in our day to day lives for that unit time.
- We each note how many times we hit or miss.
- Based on the number we get at the end of the week, we give each cue a reliability score.
- This tells us how likely we are to be right if we observe that cue again.
- This allows us to make a database which gives future readers something to refer to and test against.
- If their reliability changes in the future due to social/other conditions, we can resubmit it for testing.
This, IMO, is our current best plan of action to get this thing started.
The data could be tracked like so in a spreadsheet, like so [proposed design].
Then, start compiling a database from the experiments, like so:
Observation A means Deduction B [Or Observation A is likely to mean, in descending order of probability, Deductions B,C,D,etc]
Status: Confirmed/Falsified.
Reliability: 85% =/- 5%
and so on, in a separate google doc.
The experiments will run like so: Discussion -> Planning -> Implementation -> Tracking -> Compiling -> Addition to main database. We are currently in the Discussion phase and its likely the Planning thread will be initiated within 24 hours. Hopefully we can get the experiment running by next week.
Ps. Please submit some triggers to be considered for the first experiment. And example:
Cue - People cross their arms with their dominant hand tucked in. [Clarification]
Observation - Someone crossed their arm with right/left hand underneath.
Deduction - That person is right/left handed [respectively].
We have moved to stage 2 [planning].
5
u/erjulk Feb 18 '14
it might be insightful to separate "testers" by country to filter out differences of location and the local social contract
i.e. in the us you would look for signs of someone playing football or basketball as the two most likely sports to be played by the general population in the eu it would be soccer...
this in turn could provide information of a persons origin by mere details
i.e. someone having "markings" of some sort that show he/she is an active cricket player would make a certain group of countries more likely than others when determining the country of origin (say for tourists)
2
u/aaqucnaona [Mod, Founder - on sick leave] Feb 19 '14 edited Feb 19 '14
Clarification about stages -
2
u/TheOneAnd_Only Feb 16 '14
This is a great Idea. we could sidebar it as well.
2
u/TheOneAnd_Only Feb 17 '14
The design looks great. I can't wait to participate !
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
I don't know if "trigger" is the right word. They're more like "tells" or "cues."
2
u/Starcsha Feb 19 '14 edited Feb 24 '14
Cue: People who are comfortable with each other will adjust their poses when next to each other and/or talking. This goes as far as even the smallest details, such as hands and fingers.
Observation: Two people are talking to each other; person A is sitting with their legs crossed and person B is not. After a few minutes, person B crosses their legs.
Deduction: The people are comfortable with each other, or at least person B is comfortable around person A.
Potential Problems: It is easy to fake this if you know about it.
~
Cue: People who are not comfortable with each other will cross their legs and/or arms when sitting, or their arms when talking. This is a defensive pose and indicates that the person would prefer to distance themselves from their conversational partner. As /u/kaizoku-shinobi said, crossing your legs while standing is not a defensive stance at all and thus is done around people you're comfortable with.
Observation: Two people are sitting down, talking to each other. Person C starts talking about how they hate people who drop out of school. Person D then crosses their legs and arms.
Deduction: Person D is getting uncomfortable around Person C. In this scenario, it is even likely that Person D dropped out of school themselves. I would not deduce that far, though.
Potential Problems: Again, it is easy to fake this if you know about it. Hit and miss conditions: Participants observe person A crossing their arms/legs when talking to person B and assume that person A either doesn't like person B or was offended by something person A said. If they don't know whether this is so, they simply ask person A, or find out about it differently. If the assumption was correct, it's a hit, otherwise, a miss. Alternatively, they already know the affiliation of person A to person B. They observe if they cross their arms/legs when talking to person B. If they do, it's a hit. If they don't, it's a miss.
1
u/aaqucnaona [Mod, Founder - on sick leave] Feb 16 '14
Our rooms and desktops are also obvious submissions to their respective subreddits, as a method of getting engaged with their communities as well as creating a baseline for our own skills at the onset, to see if and over what timeframe they improve.
1
u/aaqucnaona [Mod, Founder - on sick leave] Feb 16 '14
The data could be tracked by a google doc and its crowd-sourced to this sub so everything can keep track of their data. The mods will have backups in case of vandalism and everyone would be requested to have offline backups just in case. If we are to do proper science, those spreadsheets are valuable data.
4
u/Kaizoku_Shinobi Feb 17 '14
Possible cues. Feel free to throw any out.
1
CUE: According to Joe Navarro's book, What Every Body is Saying, people cross their legs while standing only while talking with people they are comfortable with. This is because people are apparently more willing to give up a stance that allows for a quicker escape if they trust the person they are talking with. OBSERVATION: A person crosses their legs while conversing with someone. DEDUCTION: This person trusts the one with whom they are conversing and are possibly rather close friends. POTENTIAL PROBLEM: The person crossing their legs may just really need to pee or whatever, so look for at least a few other signs of relaxed behavior or expressions.
2
CUE: According to a certain study, people who most frequently wear new-looking or meticulously well-maintained shoes are most likely to be generally anxious people (possibly because they are usually concerned with what others think of them and their appearance). OBSERVATION: Someone you interact with or see on a regular basis is almost always wearing shoes that look like new and/or you've seen them tend to their shoes several times (rubbing off scuffs, etc). DEDUCTION: The person could be a generally anxious person and/or concerned with how others see them. POTENTIAL PROBLEM: The person may require nice-looking shoes for their job, but it should be fairly easy to tell apart shoes that are being taken care of on a "normal" level and ones that are taken care of on a more "extreme" level, especially if you see the person with a degree of frequency.
TL;DR Possible cue #1: People cross their legs while standing only when they're talking to someone they're comfortable with (usually close friends). Possible cue #2: People who usually wear new-looking shoes are likely to be generally anxious people.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '14
[removed] — view removed comment