r/TagPro • u/Kintaro08 Pigoon // Centra • Jul 10 '14
Map Thread 31 Results: SuperDuperStamp in, Hyper Reactor out, Diamond Faces in group.
We had some great submissions in week 31. We're happy to see that we're getting a lot of first time submissions from new mapmakers. There were many maps that were solid and offered good gameplay. It's great to see the mapmaker community grow.
After 5+ hours of testing, in the end it just came down to a select few. SuperDuperStamp by BBQchicken will be replacing Hyper Reactor. Congratulations BBQ!
Added to the group page is Diamond Faces by Antero_Rin. We had a lot of fun with this map and had put it through a number of tests. Our final decision was to put it in the group page for everybody to play and enjoy.
The Maptest Committee wants to hear from you! What do you guys think of the current pub rotation? Has the recent push changed your opinion of any maps? If you just got here from the recent push, what are you initial impressions of the maps? Let us know your thoughts.
We've also noticed the demand for more neutral flag maps. Help us out by creating and submitting the neutral map that you have always wanted in rotation.
If this is the first time you've heard of map making and are interested, head over to the wiki! You'll find all the information you need over there. When you think you have a good thing going, be sure to test test test. Hop on mumble or IRC and get a couple of buddies to take a look. Happy Map Making!
21
u/nubTheGreat nub Jul 10 '14
That new map looks questionable, at first glance looks worse than Hyper
49
u/Buttersnack Snack Jul 10 '14
Why is hyper reactor out? That was one of my favorite maps. :(
Also, was my map considered? I know you guys played it and I'd like to know if it was "close" and I can fix it or if I should just start over. My feelings won't be hurt if it wasn't a favorite.
32
u/CieloAzor QBreezy | Pi Jul 10 '14
Hyper Reactor was easily one of my favs. looks upon Colors with scorn It should have been you.
34
u/DizzerPilot Jul 10 '14
Hyper Reactor out? I can't believe the day has come where I see one of my favorite maps go. And Colors or Grail of Shit stayed. No offense DaEvil1 :(
17
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
Nawww...I love Hyper Reactor :(
Also, pls, GamePad is still in?!
Still not a huge fan of SuperDuperStamp from the outset--it still looks really chasey and lacking flow--but it's pleasing that BBQ has modified it for the better since I first saw it. We'll just have to see how it plays out!
23
u/BilldaCat10 Jul 10 '14
get rid of grail of speed NOW
can i donate more to make this happen
8
u/spacecadetjer Dennit | Boostin Jul 10 '14
Nooooo Hyper is fun, colors is so difficult in pubs.
4
u/DrMcDonald ELTP S1 Champ // Commentator Jul 10 '14
Will my penalty shootout map be added for selection in groups so we can test it for competitive play when these new maps are added? :)
4
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
i swear these are the same map
4
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Jul 10 '14
That was a quick map thread, I'm glad Hyper reactor is out mainly because of how long each game would last.
Also, is there a feedback list on each map like week 30 or a list of maps that came close? Thanks
10
u/NotSomeBall1 NotSomeBall2 // Chord Jul 10 '14
Bring back Whirlwind pls.
3
u/catalyst518 Catalyst - TPFG Dev Jul 10 '14
Colors needs to go next. It's impossible to play as a team in pubs, especially with the newer players who have never seen it played competitively.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
Hyper Reactor out? Who do I have to bribe to get it back in. That map is a return factory.
5
u/crblanz Keekly | used to be good sorta Jul 10 '14
Hey, I was wondering how those of us who didn't get out map accepted could get some feedback on what to change on our maps (I'm new to mapmaking, so I'm not sure how this all works). I made the map Bowtie! from the map thread and I was wondering if you guys tested it, if there was any feedback, etc. I didn't expect it to make rotation in its current form, but was wondering what you guys thought about it and what you would want to change. Also, I want to know if you got it to work at all, since there was another map by the name Bowtie that was already in some bot's brain, so I had to add the ! to the end late last night and I want to make sure you guys didn't mix the two maps up.
Also, SuperDuperStamp looks pretty cool, but imo the wall between the two powerups should be a green gate. Looks very similar to hyper reactor in style though, I guess thats why it was taken out
13
u/raven513 The Nevermores // CAW CAW Jul 10 '14
No offense to BBQ, I love him, but that map looks like a piece of shit.
With the addition of Command Center and now this map, I'm starting to question the Map Testing Committee.
4
u/Inimloom Melon // Chord // ELTP S2 winner Jul 10 '14
Noooo, not hyper reactor :(. It was one of my favorite maps.
4
u/PACJ_Ltd Bluey! Jul 10 '14
No one complains about Hyper Reactor
Everyone complains about Colors and Grail Of Speed
Takes Hyper Reactor out
2
u/aggietiger Dalek23 | Roll Models Jul 10 '14
Reminds me of glory hole :/ Diamond looks fun though.
2
u/Lionhearted09 LionHearted Jul 10 '14
I am very glad Hyper Reactor is out. I have had so many games end in a tie or go the full time. I never much cared for it because it was easy for that to happen.
2
u/tagpro4piR 4piR^2 | C-Team Warriors | Balls on Parade Jul 10 '14
Congrats to BBQ and antero can't believe I played these maps when they were just babys
2
u/411connor caroline :3 Jul 10 '14
Four things:
2
u/mmartinutk Macho | JuicyJuke Jul 11 '14
I heard someone say once that there was a Google doc that showed feedback on all maps that were tested. I thought I really had something with my map, but with no mentioning of it, I doubt it will be mentioned on Cap Talk and I probably won't ever know what was wrong with it.
Is there somewhere you guys leave feedback? Other than having to ask the map committee and hoping for a response.
2
u/TagProWreckn WreckingBall Jul 11 '14
I like the horseshoe shape of Stamp and Hyper Reactor because it doesn't give the regrab an easy getaway route which you might see on a map like Colors, Holy See, 45, or any other loopy chasecapade. If your team is forced to make the return with three chasers, you can always regroup and make a line across center. Though I feel that it was accidental, good job by the map committee to remove one similar design and to replace it with another, which is what should happen when maps are swapped.
Other nice points:
4
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
i can't tell you how relieved i am hyper reactor is out. however, i feel like there were much better maps that were submitted that should have been put in. don't get me wrong, i think superduperstamp is a cool map, but i feel like there were other maps that had potential to be put in. thanks for the post, anyway!
can you tell us what the "select few" maps were?
3
u/Aaron215 Aaron215 / Sphere Jul 10 '14
Wow, great work map committee and BBQ/Antero_Rin.
These two new maps have been through SO MANY iterations. It's obvious you guys put a ton of work into these two maps and you did a great job :-) Can't wait to play the final versions on a pub!
2
u/sportmonkey0 sportmonkey//Pi//The Deballishers Jul 10 '14
I don't understand. Why does everyone hate Grail of Speed so much? I think that it's fine. I do agree with colors needing to go. That map is a nightmare in pubs. Not sure what to think about hyper reactor getting removed. That map is a lot of fun, especially if you want to play a longer game. At the same time though, it was really frustrating to find the file on if you didn't know where he was. Superduperstamp looks really cool! I'm excited to play that. I think diamond face looks really fun too, but I haven't played that.
2
u/adhi- DRG Jul 10 '14
THANK THE FUCKING LORD HYPER REACTOR IS OUT. HALLELIUHDKLKSJLUA=IA
2
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
Has it occurred to anyone that just because Hyper Reactor made for high hold times, that doesn't make it bad? A map like wormy almost guarantees low hold, but you don't hear people who mainly play FC offence complaining. Not all maps are perfectly balanced. And it's better that way.
2
u/mocl4 Jul 10 '14
NO NOT HYPER REACTOR D:
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
Could y'all check out those smaller maps made for 3v3/2v2 that a player posted? I can provide the link to the thread if y'all didn't see it, I think those would be fun in groups
1
u/Zankman Zankman // Chord // ex-ELTP Superstar Jul 10 '14
Yay, Hyper Reactor out!
Nay, SuperDuperStamp makes my puny defensive soul weep!
Ynay?!?, Diamond Faces looks fun! Should be in rotation too. P:
1
u/Sosen timeboy Jul 10 '14
I once promised that the day Colors is taken out of rotation is the day I finally donate. y u no want my money, Tagpro?!?!
1
u/B3rcok KlKI // NLTP S2 JUI - S3 NVM - S4 INC Jul 10 '14
RIP in peace hippy, you'll be missed <3
1
u/TheGoldenNewtRobber Fronj, MTC Senior Consultant Jul 10 '14
Um, can I hear some feedback for my maps? Particularly NGC, because I want to know if I should continue working on it or just move on...
1
u/donny_darkloaf loaf / racoicion at heart Jul 10 '14
for some reason diamond faces reminds me of a cheery Asian dude
1
u/PACJ_Ltd Bluey! Jul 10 '14
HYPER REACTOR OUT?
WTF, THAT MAP IS WORSE
ALSO "Lots of good maps this week, but we chose a map from last week"
1
u/OnlyGray Command Center! :') Jul 11 '14
Honestly? The new map looks absolutely ginormous. I'm interested to see how it plays. Perhaps it'll grow on me. Maps that I'd like to see out- boombox (such a boring map. No features whatsoever), colors (can get chasey, buttons rarely used, has been in rotation for a long time and it's gotten boring), and bombing run if it's still in. Maybe star too. I didn't like CFD when it was first added but now it's like my favorite map to play d on. I'd like to see it stay for a while. I also happen to love game pad although I seem to be the minority here.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '14
Holy shit!
It's not rotation but its the next best thing!
1
u/TPsquirrely Squirrely // The GesTagpro Jul 10 '14
\o/ No More Hyper Reactor \o/
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
Wormy is a terrible map, in my mind, for two reasons.
I don't think HR should have been taken out over Wormy or even Gamepad.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '14
Wait, am I understanding OP correct that you only test for 5 hours before deciding which map goes in?
No wonder you make shitty choices all the time and then need to backtrack and pull them out of rotation after a month.
1
u/Tim-Sanchez tim-sanchez // Chorbit // ex-ex-ELTP Independent Commissioner Jul 10 '14
SuperDuperStamp looks excellent! I can't wait to try it out.
My stats are upset that Hyper Reactor is gone, it was great for boosting prevent. Not a very well liked map so I understand the decision, but I still feel it is the first map to have used portals well.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
OH EM GEE YISS
1
u/tagpro4piR 4piR^2 | C-Team Warriors | Balls on Parade Jul 10 '14
I really can't believe hyper is out like not ok
-1
u/DadTheFather dad // ALL co-CAPStain // Pi Jul 10 '14
Let me on the maptest committee.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment