r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Aug 25 '14
Map Thread #34 Results
In thread 34 we recieved a lot of interesting submissions. Especially of note was that the map committee felt that the submission quality of neutral flag maps were of a significantly higher quality than before, and a lot of maps from previous threads was resubmitted with improvements which was also very encouraging.
After initial voting based on personal scores from each committee member, the following maps made it to the main maptesting session:
Of these maps, the committe vote to add Volt to the map rotation because it does neutral flag in a new way and still manages to play balanced. Congratulations to Ball-E for getting it into rotation.
If you want feedback on your map(s) and why they didn't make it to rotation/testing session, you can request that in the comment section.
Aside from that, there's not much happening in terms of map rotation this round. The committee voted to keep all the maps in for now, but we are aware of some of your concerns with some of the less popular maps in rotation, and will monitor the situation in the coming weeks.
On a related note, the current map rotation is getting pretty big, and as so many maps in rotation are in the eyes of the committee of a high standard, it gets harder and harder to justify taking out maps of the rotation to add new ones in. So we want the communitys opinion on this. Do you think the current rotation (21 maps) is too big? Should it be bigger? should we consider alternative solutions like taking maps temporarily out of rotation for a period of time and then put them back into rotation?
8
u/hyponome Hypo // Tagenham & Rektbridge Aug 25 '14
Who made Volt? Congratulations to them!
21
u/Tim-Sanchez tim-sanchez // Chorbit // ex-ex-ELTP Independent Commissioner Aug 25 '14
I'm concerned that some older maps are being left in because everyone is experienced with them and thinks they like them because they know them well, but if they were objectively looked at again now may struggle. Does the maptest committee ever go through rotation maps, particularly older ones, with the same critical eye? Without picking on any specifically (I am), I'd be surprised if a map like The Holy See, which I know a lot of people love, made it in because it is very offense-heavy, with a lot of powerups and is very chasey.
31
u/TPsquirrely Squirrely // The GesTagpro Aug 25 '14
I feel as a experienced player the more maps the better as it extends the life of the game and reduces of getting the same map twice in a row. Personally id be fine with double the number of maps in rotation as I find tagpro maps pretty simple to learn to a reasonable level compared to fps games like cs or battlefield.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14
Just my thoughts - I feel like we should be adding way more than just one map at a time. We need more maps to mix things up, because it kinda blows playing the same couple maps. I also feel like we should be removing some maps rather than none at all.
6
u/quassus crosky Aug 25 '14
Feedback on how Monarch played in the maptesting session pls
9
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '14 edited Sep 07 '14
This is probably already buried because I'm late to the party, but here is my idea.
We take out older maps, and put them into what I'd like to call a "Classics Rotation." Some/all of the maps that would be in this rotation would be:
All of these maps are Map Thread 19 or below. We are now about to start Map Thread 35. I've been playing since January, and to me, these are all (pretty much) classic staple maps of TagPro. But remember, this is just an idea, you don't have to take all of those maps, I think 4-5 would be just fine.
So this is what we do. "The Classics" (or whatever you want to call them) are taken out of rotation. I know, I know, just go with it. So what we do is every week/month/day/(whatever time period you want really) one or more of The Classics is put back into rotation. So you could have a day with The Holy See thrown into the mix, but another day it is Boombox. Or you could have Geokoala & Star week, or whatever combination works best.
Pros: Frees up rotation for newer maps while still giving people the opportunity to play on their favorite old maps.
Cons: People will miss their old maps and want them back in permanently (but depending on the time frame the map they miss could be back by the next day or so).
All in all I think rotation could be bigger. Whether it could double in size is beyond me. Think about the average time a Some Ball 1 plays Tagpro in one sitting. Say and hour maybe (rough estimate). In this hour he could play on a different map every game, which could be hard to get into as a newcomer. There is no real way to tell how big is too big until you are too big.
6
u/TOJO_IS_LIFE TOJO | Pi Rats | OS Aug 25 '14
Monarch is an ass.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '14 edited Aug 26 '14
P.I.G. :'(
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/964
Preview: http://i.imgur.com/QbQZY5i.png
Thoughts? I don't know what to change. It is the 8th map made by me and is my masterpiece.
3
u/randylaheyjr Byfuglien Aug 26 '14
Please just let players vote on a random selection of 2 maps before each game.
9
u/BilldaCat10 Aug 25 '14
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHoNWwhzh3M
2
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14
I was really hoping Volt would get in, it looks like a great map.
Can I have some feedback for Platypus?
2
u/sportmonkey0 sportmonkey//Pi//The Deballishers Aug 25 '14
I actually would like more maps in the rotation. I love having a wide variety of maps to play on, and a lot of the new maps are looking very nice. I don't really want to keep Command center in the rotation anymore though. I find in PUB's at least, that it is a fairly chaotic map where you basically just have to juke out 4 people and then, depending on where you passed them, they could still catch up by just going through their gate. A few of the other maps such as colors, bombing run, smirk, and the holy see (even though I do love the holy see) should be at the very least taken out for a little while. I find that there is a limiting factor in gameplay on those maps now because most people know how to play them. Not many practical and new ways to play the map for O or D are found anymore. There has become almost a set strat to use for your position on those maps now.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14
Volt is the only one of these that I've played (well, an earlier version) and it's really fun.
No, and there are certainly maps in there that I think are really substandard (I could outline my beliefs on this if asked). I think there could be more than 21 maps in rotation without any issues. I'm not really seeing much of a reason to take maps out on a temporary basis.
2
u/Jufda 💎 hitbox.tv/jufda Aug 27 '14
I've been wondering why there are so few maps in rotation. I would consider 40-50 maps a good amount. That should be easy to fill with all current and past maps sent to map rotation threads. I don't see what would be achieved by taking some maps away from rotation for a perioid of time, but it would be nice to have some kind of system that favours different maps each week. Maybe more new maps when they come to rotation so people get used to them, and a bit less the old maps that have been in rotation for months. In addition to that, there could be some kind of map rating system, either with or without it having effect on the maps the player gets to play. Or we could have a few "rotation sets" that would change weekly, each including about 20 of the rotation maps.
3
u/MultiMediaWill Juke King - MVP 90% of the time Aug 26 '14
I also believe that tagpro can handle 40+ maps in rotation at once. My suggestion is to remove the lowest 1 map and add 3 new maps each time until we hit 40 maps then remove 2 and add 2 at a time. Let's keep this game fresh please!
3
u/Str8-Ballin Str8_Ballin (Radius) Aug 26 '14 edited Aug 26 '14
In no particular order:
1
u/throwaway_the_fourth I will not change my name in the sidebar. Aug 25 '14
I'm looking forward to playing on volt! I tried it before by myself on map test and I think it is cool.
1
u/EmperorOfNothing Resignation is my virtue; like water I ebb, and flow. Aug 25 '14
Some thoughts...
-Thanks for your work committee~
-Volt looks fun since I saw the first one, so I'm looking forward to that
-Do you have any feedback or suggestions for my map, Conjoined Heads 10? (If it sucks, at least tell me :,( )
-21 maps in rotation do seem like too much, but the question is now which ones get the boot...
-Ugh Colors is still in, and the old Grail of Speed is so much better and less clunker
1
u/TPsquirrely Squirrely // The GesTagpro Aug 25 '14
Also will we get word on the thoughts on submitted maps.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14
Technically this version wasn't in the thread, but do you mind providing feedback?:
http://maps.jukejuice.com/static/previews/1037.png
Top bomb button boosts you middle while bottom sends you into flag.
Bases are now flipped to make route around map more of a U than a O.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '14
Yes. There should be a dramatic overhaul of the map pool. Cut the fat. Remove all the maps that are older than six months and replace with newer maps. Game gets very stale otherwise.
1
u/gingerdg TPRL 🔴RMTC 🔴NASCAPS Aug 25 '14
solid choice
1
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Aug 26 '14
Could I get feedback on blu-ray?
1
u/411connor caroline :3 Aug 26 '14
Can you guys review my map, Slanted 1.3?
http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/834
Preview: http://i.imgur.com/nU7wqrg.png
1
u/Warlord24 Koba Aug 26 '14
No. I prefer to have more variety (more maps).
1
u/ButterChurn Butter Aug 26 '14
Feedback on Nudge and Looper please!
1
u/Sosen timeboy Aug 27 '14
Can we have Trapdoor available for group play pls?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment