r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Sep 08 '14
Map thread #35 Results
So we recieved a lot of submissions in thread 35, and the focus seemed to be mainly on CTF this time with a lot of maps exploring unconventional concepts for the traditional gamemode. We would like to thank the authors for making it hard for us to make a choice this week, espeically since we got a lot of submissions where maps have been tweaked for the better from past submissions, which is always encouraging to the committee.
After initial voting based on personal scores from each committee member, the following maps made it to the main maptesting session:
- RocketBalls (Alternative preview)
- IRON
- One Way Ticked 0.5
- Backdoor
- T-rekt V2b
- Pinwheel
- Monarch 0.3
- Snatch
- Monarch (0.2)
- Masquerade
- Freshquipadillion
Of these maps, the committee decided to add RocketBalls (by DaEvil1) and Backdoor (by Bad) into rotation.
If you want feedback on your map(s) and why they didn't make it to rotation/testing session, you can request that in the comment section.
In terms of removing maps from the rotation, the committee decided to vote on if any of the following maps should be taken out of rotation:
- Velocity
- 45
- Command Center
- Grail of Speed
- Colors
With the end result being that Command Center by Bad was voted out of rotation.
This means that the current map rotation will grow by one map for now. This is partly due to the feedback from the community last time that growing the rotation would not be seen as a problem, however, we really appreciate feedback from the community on how the map rotation should look, so please do leave feedback on what you think about the size of the rotation, and what you think of the additions/removals and the current rotation. Because we do listen to it, and try to take it into account when we make the decisions we make.
26
u/Banana_Meat Stewart | Ballnadoes | Probots Muperball Champions! Sep 08 '14
Taking out Command Center while Grail of Speed still remains... :( it's like every map thread that map keeps getting away it
21
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
So now that DaEvil1 has gotten RocketBalls into rotation, can we remove Grail of Speed?pls?
32
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
Why was Velocity voted on to be taken out? It should be untouchable. IMO, it's by far the best map we have in rotation...
I like Command Center, but I don't think it was good in pubs; it's really complicated and bamboozled even moderately decent pub players.
I'm not enamoured with either of the new maps just by looking at the image, but I'm excited to try them out in games :)
27
u/OnlyGray Command Center! :') Sep 08 '14
Wait... What? Command center is tons more fun/better than a number of those maps. It's also a newer map. Shouldn't we be removing older maps, instead of removing maps that players will adapt to?
32
u/BilldaCat10 Sep 08 '14
Hard for me to believe that Colors and Grail of Speed came up for a vote and people deliberately and consciously voted to keep them.
I want names!
18
u/DizzerPilot Sep 08 '14
How in the blithering fuck is Colors still in PUB rotation?
16
u/TerraMaris Scientifically Proven NaCl Sep 08 '14
Goodbye, Command Center, my sweet prince. We had great memories together. <3
8
u/rke12 Ballzilla Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
Can view/test from here:
RocketBalls -> http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/1309
Backdoor-> http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/1326
My opinion doesn't really matter, but I think RocketBalls will be very frustrating in pubs.
Edit: Corrected links according to other comments.
15
u/nubTheGreat nub Sep 08 '14
Very confused as to how command centre was voted out from that group! And why velocity was anywhere near consideration for removal! Grail of speed in particular how on earth is that still in?
15
u/donuts42 donuts42 || Sphere/Origin || Boost Master Sep 08 '14
OH LOOKS LIKE 2 MAPS BY MAPTEST COMMITTEE MEMBERS HAVE BEEN VOTED IN WHAT A SURPRISE THAT THE MAPTESTERS WOULD VOTE FOR THEIR OWN MAPS I BET SOMEONE WILL SAY BUT OH THEY VOTED OUT ONE OF THEIR MAPS BUTS THATS BECAUSE THEY ARE ALMOST ALL ALREADY MADE BY MAPTEST COMMITTEE MEMBERS /s
But seriously I'm sad to see CC voted out over colors or grail of speed, but whatever.
7
u/hobbskm Ballee Lama // The Roll Models // Cappin Planet Sep 08 '14
First time I've been sad about a map being taken out of rotation. Command Center is my favorite map.
17
u/aggietiger Dalek23 | Roll Models Sep 08 '14
Grail is so bad, made the wrong choice imo.
6
u/tamouq Crossover Sep 08 '14
Are you kidding me? Velocity should not even be considered to be removed.
10
u/cddm95ace Iron_Ball // Holdin Gate Warriors Sep 08 '14
I actually really enjoyed Command Center, and never saw many complaints about it in pubs. While it was a bit complicated, I really enjoyed how different it was from other maps.
The fact that it was removed before Grail of Speed amazes me. Not only is it still chasey, but the newer version just has no flow at all.
5
u/quassus crosky Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
RocketBalls and Trapdoor look interesting; I'm looking forward to seeing how they play. And I'm not saying it wasn't the right decision to take Command Center out since it seems to get a lot of hate, but I for one think that map is a masterpiece and I love how it plays :(
Feedback on Monarch pls? Every time I submit it it is pretty well liked and gets tested, but never seems to make the final cut. Is the general design just not gonna be good enough? Or is there something else that, if tweaked, would put it over the top?
9
u/EmperorOfNothing Resignation is my virtue; like water I ebb, and flow. Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
Command Centre y :,(
I don't get how Command Centre is hard/complicated in pubs; people say that you need a lot of teamwork on it, but I find that everyone, even nubs and Some Balls, have a much better grasp on teamwork, direction, and coordination a lot more on this map compared to other maps; I've never had a game on CC which I absolutely hated it at any point...
I hate you Colors. Hate you hate you hate you; even more than Thinking With Portals, Micro, and the new Grail of Speed. Ugh new Grail of Speed is still in...
6
u/NotSomeBall1 NotSomeBall2 // Chord Sep 08 '14
Why's Command Center out?
3
u/TPsquirrely Squirrely // The GesTagpro Sep 08 '14
The most up-to-date version of T-Rekt tested wasn't tested... However I wish to have any relevant Comments on it I guess.
7
u/MultiMediaWill Juke King - MVP 90% of the time Sep 08 '14
COMMAND CENTER WAS REMOVED!?!?!? ... ffs im done.
4
u/BilldaCat10 Sep 08 '14
how about a normal gif of rocketballs and not one with a texture pack
2
u/LEBRONstarJAMES LEBRON*JAMES | MEME*TEAM | Jukes for Jesus 🐇 🐝 Sep 08 '14
Can i have feedback on this: http://www.reddit.com/r/TagPro/comments/2eteko/monthly_map_rotation_thread_35_please_read_the/ck3dlya
Thanks!
2
u/peterpan__ Peter Pan Sep 08 '14
Is there any way to update jukejuice so that the previews with 45 degree walls actually show up correctly?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
Why the F did you guys not vote gamepad out dammit
4
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
YES EAT IT COMMAND CENTER YOU BITCH. TOO LONG HAVE YOU TRICKED PUBBERS INTO THINKING YOU ARE A SEMI-DECENT MAP, WHEN IN REALITY A TEAM WITH 2 DECENT PLAYERS CAN DENY ALL ACCESS OUT OF THE MIDDLE OF THE MAP AND IT FUCKING SUCKS. WOOOOHOOOOOOO FUCK COMMAND CENTER
2
u/Battosay52 Battosay / Chorbit Sep 08 '14
Sad to see CC go, I'd like more neutral flag maps. Disapointed like everyone else about Colors and GoS stayin', but it's not a surprise ^
1
u/NotSomeBall1 NotSomeBall2 // Chord Sep 08 '14
I know the map definitely isn't finished yet, but do you have any feedback about Clay?
1
u/Lysozyme_ Lysozyme Sep 08 '14
Ooh could I have feedback on how snatch played please?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
Just curious as to why my map Platypus was tested last week, modified for the committee's criticism, but then it wasn't tested this week?
1
u/Buttersnack Snack Sep 08 '14
Trapdoor is great and I'm glad he removed a button (which I totally told him to do like a month before he did)
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
Title: PIG
Map: http://maps.jukejuice.com/save/1297
Preview: http://i.imgur.com/zHivqHZ.png
I tried to fix what I got feedback on. Let me know whats wrong, thanks.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
Congratulations to bad for having four maps in rotation, even if it was just for the period between adding Trapdoor and removing Command Center. I know I tested, but was there any additional feedback to Iron?
1
u/Lsky72 Lsky | Centra Sep 08 '14
I enjoy neutral flag way more than regular ctf, why are we moving backwards?
1
u/EmperorOfNothing Resignation is my virtue; like water I ebb, and flow. Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
Any thoughts on Scissoring Heads 1.v10? I'm working on another modified version of it (2.v10) at the moment, so are there any other notes of difference?
First impressions of new maps:
1
u/giga_earthstroyer brrton Sep 08 '14
Thanks for testing my map, Masquerade. Even if it doesn't get in rotation I'm pretty happy for looking at it.
That said, do you have any feedback for it?
1
u/Freshrr Serene x Supreme / Ω Sep 08 '14
Freshly Fresh here, requesting feed back.
1
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Sep 08 '14
Can I get feedback on Pinwheel? Also if I wanted to make a map into rotation, would I be better off restarting, or modifying my current version?
1
u/JungleSpice- Jungle Spice//Radius Sep 08 '14
Cc was great! I also like grail if speed. But colors? I've hated it since the first time I played it. Also, smirk should go.
1
u/sportmonkey0 sportmonkey//Pi//The Deballishers Sep 08 '14
Oh yes! I liked backdoor when I saw it a while ago. I'm glad that was put in along with cc being taken out. Thanks maptest committee!
1
u/crblanz Keekly | used to be good sorta Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
Could I get feedback on Coach?
EDIT: And also is there any way you could quickly look over starfish which I completed just after the deadline and see if there are any glaring issues you see? thanks
1
u/BashIsFun Serf Sep 08 '14 edited Sep 08 '14
I'd like some feedback on Zoo. I'm surprised it got nowhere, since like 90% of people I played it with enjoyed it.
http://www.reddit.com/r/TagPro/comments/2eteko/monthly_map_rotation_thread_35_please_read_the/ck34kis
1
u/kunmeh13 awooooooooga Sep 08 '14
NOOO COMMAND CENTER NOOO
1
u/Rapture_On_Occasion Rapture Sep 08 '14
Any feedback for Cross Shift?
1
u/Freshrr Serene x Supreme / Ω Sep 08 '14
Can I get feedback on my map?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
Velocity is solid af, how could it even have been considered?s
Anyway, thank you. The Map committee is an integral part of the game and I'll let you guys run it how you all see fit.
but Grail of Speed fuckin sucks
0
u/viggetuff Vigge Sep 08 '14
Trapdoor is great and I'm glad he removed a button (which I totally told him to do like a month before he did)
0
u/viggetuff Vigge Sep 08 '14
Trapdoor is great and I'm glad he removed a button (which I totally told him to do like a month before he did)
0
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '14
Take off velocity!
0
u/[deleted] Sep 08 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment