r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Sep 18 '14
Week 36 Results: RIP Grail of Speed, Jagged 4 to Group play
No serious maps making straight-up rotation this time around, here are the maps that got extensively tested:
- IRON
- Constriction
- Shine (bombless)
- Texas Shootout!
- Jagged 4
- One Way Ticket 0.6
- Space Temple
- Vigilant
- Yoda v1.1
- Impact
- Six Slick Seals
- Sizzzled's Emporium
as well as a few other maps that I can't remember (sorry!)
Our overall opinion of the maps was that although we at least didn't mind most of the maps being tested, we felt they could either be improved or just wouldn't bring a whole lot or be very fun to public games.
Congratulations to ThePirate for getting Jagged 4 (Preview) into group play! The maptest committee felt that although the map would be slightly too chasy for pubs, it's still overall a fun map that would be decent to play competitively on, and it also gives everybody the chance to test whether or not we're right by playing the map in groups and forming your own opinion from a competitive and public standpoint.
Finally, there will be a brief ceremony across all TagPro servers at 9 PM ET for the highly beloved map Grail of Speed; please hold a 2 minutes silence across all servers as a tribute to the fallen.
The maptest committee played a similar map named Spilled Milk (Preview) to see if it would be a suitable candidate, but we felt the map would not be as widely accepted, and we didn't want the community crying over Spilled Milk.
That's basically it, there might have been a few things forgotten (which will be edited if remembered), a new maptest thread will be up in a while.
Do you want to take a more active role in shaping test maps or want more criticism for your own before they get test-played? Join the growing community at #TagProMaps on IRC! There's a few maptest committee members who are active there, as well as others who are helpful and constructive with feedback.
P.S. does anyone play Twister in groups? does anyone else even know what Twister is?
27
u/MrJoehobo SOHB Sep 18 '14
I think we should give spilled milk a chance. It kind of reminds me of an upside down Grail of Speed.
20
u/kirbyfreako &Berk // Centra Sep 18 '14
who thought of that spilled milk joke
it's fucking genius
18
u/CloudyTuesdays a pumpkin 🎃 Centra Sep 18 '14
I still miss command center...
4
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '14
RIP Iron. Any feedback for Space Station?
4
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '14
I liked that jagged has the gate indicator just like in geo it is a small thing that I think helps the map. Also the sarcasm in this post is delicious.
3
u/SUpirate ThePirate / Unaffiliated Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14
Thanks!. I'm glad Jagged 4 was liked. Hopefully people give it a try and enjoy it in group play.
I agree with the fear that it may be too chasey once people figure it out. I have some ideas that I think will tone down the chasiness while keeping the core of the map in tact with all the fun stuff, so look forward to that next thread.
3
u/Buttersnack Snack Sep 18 '14
I love Twister.
3
u/mintalbes Triple A/ Chord Sep 19 '14 edited Sep 19 '14
If you think several maps are good and you enjoyed playing them then why not add them to the rotation? You could wait for a map to tick all the right boxes but then it receive negative feedback from the community. There will always be uncertainties of how a map is received so i suggest that once the map is "very good but could be improved", you add it to the rotation and see how it plays by PUB players and allow the creator to make slight changes accordingly. If you don't want to push too many changes at once you can set a normal probability for these maps in the first week
5
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '14
Mfw
7
u/quassus crosky Sep 18 '14
The updated Monarch wasn't even tested this time? What gives? ....uh, any feedback, i guess?
4
u/magikarpnotgyrados Magikarp // Pub God Sep 18 '14
that spilled milk map looks really cool!
6
u/BilldaCat10 Sep 18 '14
Well, my work here is done.
(extinguishes torch, slings pitchfork over shoulder)
2
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '14
Jagged looks fun :)
I've played it several times, but it's super chasey and generally awkward and not good.
2
u/Lysozyme_ Lysozyme Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14
Can I have a comment on my update to snatch please? I thought it was so much better
Here's the submission: http://www.reddit.com/r/TagPro/comments/2g63pw/monthly_map_rotation_thread_36_please_read_the/ckj8p82
2
u/EmperorOfNothing Resignation is my virtue; like water I ebb, and flow. Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14
Any more feedback for Scissoring Heads 2? haha daveil pls halp again
I have Scissoring Heads 3 on standby. My current changes from 2 to 3 are as follows; and I can always look again before resubmitting:
I took away the extra yellow boosts on the outside of the base, so only the inner yellow boosts and the team boosts on the outside are left.
I am also planning on making the top/bottom entrances to the mid box smaller, cause one prominent non-MTC community member said it was too chasey and too islandy, while keeping the spirit of the mid that one MTC said was interesting (small entrances still there as options, but harder to just use it to stall as a fc),
and I took away the two bombs in base and replaced it with a single bomb and the very far left/right of the map and their bases, to give a GeoKoala-like option for offense (another risky strat, since you need a teammate to help out with the gate).
To one person with constructive criticism, i'll say that if I take away the team boosts, then catching up to enemy fcs will be incredibly difficult, and even though I understand it when you say it will make for easy sniping, that is assuming all snipes are created equal and perfect, AND i moved the team boosts in a way so that if a fc is far ahead enough, they can be out of line (either with the square walls, or just getting ahead and moving the boosts out of line behind the mid square walls a little)
Scissoring Heads 2 (I took away the v10 part lol)
Scissoring Heads 3 (not submitted yet)
Fuck yes Grail of Speed is gone! Pls no Spilled Milk pls
Jagged 4 looks pretty interesting; will look to see how it will do in group play, cause I don't know at the moment
What the hell is Twister?
Several thoughts combined together; great idea Nug! >_>
2
u/crblanz Keekly | used to be good sorta Sep 19 '14
Could I get feedback on "Starfish" and/or "Coach 2" please?
2
u/Splanky222 BBQchicken | Retired Sep 19 '14
No Google Doc for the tested maps?
2
u/Napoleann David Stern // Radius // Knights of Cap-A-Lot Sep 19 '14
I know what Twister is, yes.
3
u/2tyrodnazc asdf Sep 18 '14
I personally really like Jagged 4 for shaking up what is imo an increasingly more defensive-oriented (and easier/safer-to-make) submission of maps to test. The chasiness could be a problem, but I'd be more than willing to play the map in pubs if everyone could agree the chasiness wouldn't be as big a deal or if revisions could be added to it to make it less chasy.
3
u/mmartinutk Macho | JuicyJuke Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14
I'm a little shocked Monarch didn't even make the list. I tested it out with some people and I really loved the flow and was very prepared for it to make rotation. And no bias here, I couldn't even tell you who made it.
Edit: I say I was prepared for it to make rotation because it appeared to be the favorite in BBQ's "The Mappening". I figured it would have more support than it apparently did.
2
u/Rapture_On_Occasion Rapture Sep 18 '14
Any feedback for Constriction?
2
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Sep 18 '14
Grats ThePirate! Great map. Have fun with your new flair! Also I got 2 maps into testing? I'm done now (not really though).
On another note, how did Shine and SSS play during testing?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14
R.I.P Grail of Speed. You will always remain one of my favorite maps.
1
u/ButterChurn Butter Sep 18 '14 edited Sep 18 '14
I see it didn't get tested, but any feedback on Marx?
Edit: preview
1
u/Cribbit Curl Sep 18 '14
Please put Bots into consideration for next round.
1
u/matt287 RadiaN // Diameter // The Cap-22's Sep 19 '14
Could I get some feedback on Yoda v1.1?
1
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Sep 19 '14
Also, is there going to be a spreadsheet this time or general feedback on the maps that were tested?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '14
Can I have some feedback for Space Temple, Sizzzled's Emporium, and Platypus 1c (which I modified the bases of thanks to crit from Pigoon)?
0
u/Juz16 Origin | 60° | I've got the D Sep 18 '14
>complaining about maps that are "a little too chasey"
>gamepad still in rotation
uh huh
-8
u/BilldaCat10 Sep 18 '14
After thinking about this, what the hell were you guys thinking?
And by 'this', I mean the passive-aggressive bit about the Spilled Milk map. It comes off as a big 'fuck you, you guys don't know what's good for you' from the MTC, especially after all the drama regarding polls and how they are held in disdain by several members of the MTC. You should have just removed GoS, and left it at that, instead of trying to get in some kind of parting shot.
For you guys to basically antagonize the public here, then wonder why people don't trust the MTC/accuse them of favoritism of maps by MTC members, shows a real lack of foresight.
-2
u/Splanky222 BBQchicken | Retired Sep 19 '14
#GIVEMONARCH
0
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment