r/TagPro • The Map Test Committee • Feb 19 '15

Map Thread #43 Top Maps Feedback Thread

Welcome one and all to top map feedback thread for map thread #43! The following maps have made it through to the next stage - 4v4 testing - which will take place on Sunday, February 22nd. The goal of this staged testing is to give maps more time to sink in. It also allows the community and committee members to give feedback to promising maps in the same testing cycle.


Maps

Capture the Flag:

Rush by bowtie
Gatekeeper by DaEvil1
Ascension by JuicyJuke
Banzai Bill by Sizzzled


Mapmakers whose maps have advanced have until testing takes place on Sunday to make alterations to their maps. Any edits should be posted as comments responding to the appropriate top-level map comment made from this account.


To the community, feel free to give constructive criticism on these maps as well! YOU could influence the next map in rotation!

8 Upvotes

211 comments sorted by

•

u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Feb 19 '15

RUSH by bowtie

Juke Juice

Preview

→ More replies

•

u/[deleted] Feb 19 '15

Hey, why does the MTC continue to use the maps.jukejuice.com previews when they somehow still don't support the 45 degree tiles? I have to actually enter the map to see the full thing, but then I can't see the full map. unfortunate-maps.jukejuice.com just seems superior to me. Can we not port over the 45 degree tiles or switch to it? It's annoying looking at previews of maps that don't show the full details.

→ More replies

•

u/MJKROX17 Rick Grimes Feb 20 '15

i like the first two, the last 2 not so much

•

u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Feb 19 '15

ASCENSION by JuicyJuke

Juke Juice

Preview

→ More replies

•

u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Feb 19 '15

GATEKEEPER by DaEvil1

Juke Juice

Preview

→ More replies

•

u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Feb 19 '15

BANZAI BILL by Sizzzled

Juke Juice

Preview

→ More replies

•

u/Ballaziken // Radius (rip Origin 2014 - 2016) Feb 21 '15

Banzai Bill looks like fun.

•

u/Blazeth Dianna Agron Feb 19 '15

I think no new rotation maps this thread makes as much sense as it has in a long time.

→ More replies

•

u/Moosemaster21 Moosen | Salt Mine Feb 19 '15 edited Feb 19 '15

Obligatory sigh


Rush

I think I said somewhere before that Rush feels like a less exciting, easier to die version of Velocity. The more I see it and run around in it, the more I learn about it, and I like it more now than when I first saw it, but I'm still not 100% convinced. Sorry bowtie ily.

Gatekeeper

I like this map, I got to test it out 4v4 with DaEvil1 among others and it played pretty well. A little on the defensive side but a solid map overall. With DaEvil being on the MTC it doesn't surprise me that it's here.

Ascension

I love JuicyJuke's maps, I think he does an amazing job. This is a very solid map and in my opinion probably the best of this bunch. Having said that, I don't even think this was the best map he submitted to the thread. I'd like to see this one make the rotation regardless.

Banzai Bill

Hmm. This is probably the best rendition of the map I've seen so far, but it still feels a bit awkward and clunky in some phases. I really don't see the necessity for those portals.


I'm gonna take a risk here - I know this doesn't help me as far as getting my maps considered goes, but whatever, this isn't about me. I think it's really disappointing for a lot of people to see these results. Half of the maps that moved on were from members of the MTC, and the other half were from players who already have maps in rotation. What kind of message does that send to aspiring mapmakers? I think this thread overlooked a lot of solid options. Count Mapula by Dianna Agron & Aniball for example. In the massive maptest that I did, and I believe DaEvil1 was there for it, Count Mapula was probably the only one that received unanimously rave reviews - even Gatekeeper, a map that I like, had a couple comments about recommended tweaks.

I know this is dangerous territory for me to be treading, but it needs to be said and I don't want to hide behind a throwaway. I've seen some serious signs of favoritism fairly consistently from the MTC and it's really disappointing.

→ More replies

•

u/TagProWreckn WreckingBall Feb 20 '15

tbh these all look pretty boring