r/WritingPrompts • u/Maifei2050 • Feb 28 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] Broken China - FebContest
Four families. Four dreams. Four very different paths. The Chinese economy is slowing and businesses are struggling. A dress shop owner worries about paying the mortgage and the private school fees for her daughter while her husband’s factory downsizes. A engineer at the same factory has grand money making ideas but must deal with problems at home. A foreign teacher and his Chinese girlfriend prepare to go overseas and debate when and how to tell her parents. And a wealthy couple scheme to get their son into the city’s best high school, or if they can’t, embark on a radical and wrenching plan B. (9115 words). Link: http://eastwestfuturestories.blogspot.com.au/p/broken-china-novelette.html
1
u/Hatsya Mar 01 '15
Very good job! I really liked it!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '15
The fact that all of the characters but one is speaking in a non-native tongue provides a unique challenge. With that in mind, I thought that the characters all spoke realistically, and the dialogue was a bit stilted as a result. This applies to Malcolm's speech as well, though that can be justified because he's speaking to students who are learning the language. I can appreciate the realism there, but it just made the story difficult for me to read.
Another note I wanted to address about the dialogue is that even when Malcolm wasn't around, the characters were speaking English to one another and the dialogue was still a bit stiff and awkward. I understand that you can't exactly write those parts in Chinese (though I very much liked the inclusion of a few words between Wu Ming and Zheng Long), but maybe a quick note that they're speaking in their native tongue (unless, of course, they're not?), and let the dialogue be a bit more informal? I think it's the lack of contractions that's getting to me, which in some circles is considered a good thing, so I guess it's just my own personal preference.
I liked how the stories were all a little bit intertwined without being contrived. I think it was a nice touch to make Henry one of Malcolm's adult students, for example. Their friendship was touching. I did have a hard time keeping track of all the stories, though, which I think is the greatest weakness of the piece, but it was a well-written entry all in all.
One last thing: I thought the story was brilliantly titled. I did, however, keep waiting for the china pot to break! ;)
1
u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU Mar 11 '15
I really enjoyed this story. I thought the slightly broken English worked well, especially when it came to Malcolm talking to his students. My biggest issue is that I got the stories about most of the families confused. :( Malcolm's was fairly easy to keep track of, since his name sort of sticks out of the bunch, but everyone else felt a bit muddled and I couldn't quite keep track of who owned the properties vs who wanted to put their kid through school... Especially since almost everyone was just worrying about the fact that they didn't have money.
I also think some of the sections felt a bit too much like people were just talking for the sake of the reader. There was at least one bit of dialogue where the people basically just said "The government tried to put these laws in place to keep apartment prices from falling, but it didn't work," which didn't quite feel like natural dialogue to me, but more like you needed me to know the politics in play. I think you could have eased that in a little more, added a bit more of a human element to the conversation.
And one last critique, the bit about Julia's dad dying was a bit sudden. That could have been hinted at a little earlier, and we could have had a few more words about what Malcolm did while she was at the hospital.
Overall though, a very enjoyable story. The ending just gave me a great big smile, and I love the description of the jade dragon. Plus, the title Broken China is just amazing. :) Good story, and congrats on making it to round 2!
Edit: Also, one quick fix for you, one of the earlier sentences is a bit mangled. Something about Henry getting him a gift, and "He grabbed a picked up a red shopping bag..."
1
u/Piconeeks Mar 14 '15
I really liked how you used multiple characters to give a sense of a world from multiple points of view—it was totally engrossing and an extremely great read. Good work!
I have some subjective criticisms, though:
First subjective criticism: when you mention chinese characters like "fu", I can't help but immediately disassociate them from chinese because it's clearly been typed in English, and that in turn kind of alienates that portion of the story. It might just be because I actually am familiar with the characters, but I still think it would be beneficial to have the character, 福, actually in the text.
A second criticism: the dialogue seems somewhat stilted and weak. The characters talk like robots, which again takes the reader out of the story somewhat. For example:
I mean, I understand the language barrier between the two, but even so if these people are discussing the market value of jade pieces then they could at least have a more fulfilling and less one-sided conversation than this one. It just seems out-of-place.
Furthermore, the robotic form of dialogue lends itself to cliches:
It seriously detracts from the meaning and gravity of a scene if you have to resort to a cliche to explain it. Use more detail, add nuance to the situation, or even just reword the passage so that I can actually empathize and believe in these characters.
I mean, sometimes the dialogue is just so objective-based it hurts to hear:
Ultimately, the fact that these characters speak in this way makes it difficult to believe that they exist. The respectful tone that you adopt before a superior is difficult to translate because a lot of the differences are simply using more deferential synonyms rather than changes in sentence structure. I appreciate the effort, but you're going to have to do more to make me believe in these characters.
And this problem leads to a third criticism: a plot-oriented story ultimately ends up with far more telling rather than showing. For example:
Gone are the opportunities of nostalgia and anecdote to make the reader infer the longing for home and the entertainment of the possibility of returning in light of his economic situation. This plot requires a lot of points to occur and I understand the need for them to be communicated effectively, but even so just outright stating what needs to be stated really dumbs down the exposition and makes me feel like as a reader I'm just going through the motions.
Add some to your word count. Show, don't tell.
This brings me finally into criticism number four: exposition.
The brief glimpses I get of setting and description are my favorite parts of this story. Unfortunately, they are few and far between. Immerse the reader in your story, and take a while to lean back and give a sense of space. Some of the sections where two characters conversed were literally four or five paragraphs long, and the reader is hardly given time to catch up before they are being shoved onto the next plot point. Take your time, let the story flow.
This brings me into a final criticism: I left the story feeling rushed and uncertain.
It was a mixture of having underdeveloped characters who all seemed to be the same, very short plot points that had a lot of description and depth to be desired, and an overall lack of a sense of space or setting that just made it difficult to think back to your story and remember a particular moment or description that lies caught in my memory.
All these criticisms are subjective, so don't take them to heart unless you agree with what I'm trying to say. These choices may well have been artistic or stylistic on your part, and so I don't want you to sacrifice that because somebody on the internet told left you a review.
Rather, if you take anything from this comment take the fact that you've created a beautiful world with lots of room to expose and explore the nuances therein. Keep writing!
1
u/ReeCallahan Mar 18 '15
Just thought I'd stop by and bring you a nice basket of feedback!
I applaud your juggling act! I think tackling this many characters was really ambitious and I hope you end up expanding this later into something much larger. I think you have an opportunity here to reflect on a people and culture that doesn't often get the lime light in English.
I liked that characters were all in some way related to the English teacher. This story really reminded of movies like Happiness and Magnolia - narrative mosaics made of characters that intersect unexpectedly around a certain event or place. I think you really tap into this genre effectively.
Though, I did run into trouble as the narrative continued. My only real trouble was that seemed like there were too many characters with similar, money related conflicts in such a short piece; they blended together on me about halfway through. You might want to give them some more idiosyncrasies and better develop their settings to help give them more distinct personalities/situations. Totally up to you, though.
I hope this was useful!