r/WritingPrompts • u/Lexilogical /r/Lexilogical | /r/DCFU • Feb 28 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] STOLEN TIME - FebContest
Diane is a young girl living on the streets when she pickpockets a stranger. But instead of cash, what she finds is a warning from a father she's never met. It isn't long before she finds herself trapped in a world where the normal rules of physics just don't seem to apply.
Word count - 13394
And please, leave comments! I plan on continuing this story... Just after the contest. :)
EDIT: This story is now a book! Stolen Time on Amazon! New word count - 29k
5
Upvotes
1
u/TrueKnot Mar 04 '15
Found you. :)
1
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Mar 05 '15
I'm going to start with this: Excellent writing. I wanted to make that clear before the next spot gives you any undo despair.
Off the start you were fighting an uphill battle. I generally can't stand teen fiction. Not sure if that's what you were trying for, but it's how it felt. It's hard to describe the feel between adult fiction written about teens (eg Ender's Game) and Teen Fiction (far too many recent books to count), but I generally know it when I read it. Again this is my opinion, but I refused to let it hold bearing on how I judged your writing.
Well, you fought an uphill battle and won. Your writing skills are well developed and your story had rhythm and flow. It was a tight race, but you were the best in your group.
1
u/jhdierking Mar 07 '15
First off, I'd like to say good editing and proofreading. All I caught was one typo in "the sweet(est) chocolate bar" and comma splices.
I enjoyed the story and was pulled along by it. Since most of the characters are teenagers, the story has a young adult feel to it and I could see it working really well in that genre. There's a lot of plot meat, backstory, and world exploration to do here and I could really see this being fleshed out into an expansive story, even full-length novel.
Some food for thought:
Donovan was brought up twice, but there seemed to be no reason to include him. How does he function in the story? Was he a sort of father figure for Diane, taking her under his wing, teaching her what she needed to know to survive? Or brother? Romantic interest? How does she feel about him leaving her? Does she have any resentment? Since he is a named character, you must make his character count for something and play more of a role.
I needed a bit more explanation of why Diane puts so much stock in the note. She pulls herself back from believing it, only to be drawn in again when she touches the wallet. Why? Can this be explained later, like some telepathic connection from her father or what not?
I really liked the line: "The man’s smile looked about as real as the aluminium Christmas tree that my foster parents used to set up."
I like the thought you've put into the powers and wanted more detail of how these powers work, what the facility is for, how the kids are being trained, why, etc.
The fight and murder scene was not long enough to really get into the right level of emotional depth and this scene really needs to develop. Since Emily has no emotions in the scene and she seems to be running on automatic, you have to feed us more of Rocket's and Diane's emotions to compensate. Can Diane see fear in Rocket's eyes once he realizes what's happening? Does he cry? Does he bcome angry? Describe him in more detail. You mentioned Rocket's last expression, but what was it?
Also, if you expand on this story, spent more time between the MC's arrival at the facility and Rocket's death. Give us a better sense of Rocket's character. He seems cocky, a bit of a jerk in the one scene we see of him. Because of that, I did not much care if he lived or died. A jerk is a fine starting place, but develop him into more of a sympathetic character. Is he just putting on a brave face? Does he miss his family deeply and wish that he could go home? Wish he did not have these powers and have to be at the facility? Make him into a character the reader likes: that would make his death all the more horrific and that scene needs to be one of true horror.
1
u/Piconeeks Mar 16 '15
This story was exceptional. I really liked how you built up this new universe and how well you created the characters.
I did spot one grammar mistake:
But that's about the end of any objective criticism. On the subjective end of the spectrum, however, I think that (at least from my point of view) there are a few things that you could improve on:
First off, there was some inconsistency in the story where the events and the character's actions suffered a sort of mismatch:
I mean, this is the second line to come out of a girl who has been drugged and kidnapped and taken away into a prison cell. While I was reading I was incredibly puzzled over just why she would act this way. Why isn't she panicked? Why does she trust this other girl so much? What is going on?
I feel like this is a general failing of first-person stories in general, but I'll get to that later on. Here's a another example:
Her reaction to death is so nonchalant, it's hard to believe. I would be contorting in incredulity if I ever heard the information that Diane just did, and here she is brushing it off. It's a weird emotional mismatch between the reader and the character, and it alienated me a little from the characters in the story.
Finally, there's that death. Why did that happen? What came over her? how come he didn't feel the same? How come she didn't use any of her powers to aid in the battle while he could? How did she even win? These are questions that were never answered and the whole sequence felt a little bit forced because there was no cause for it.
I also had some reservations about the age of the characters:
I mean, this is about as subjective as it gets, but I find it difficult to empathize with characters that are so willingly oblivious and naïve that they fill the passage with a false sense of contentment. I understand that it was important for her character arc to begin this way, but even so it's difficult to believe a character like that unless they are very, very young.
I mean, cool, but it cheapens the story a little bit (at least from my perspective). Subjective, I know. Feel no need to change this.
A penultimate criticism that I had was that a lot of the worldbuilding was told, not shown.
A large portion of the context came from a simple told conversation rather than any meaningful exposition, and it really felt like the "as you know, Bob..." speculative fiction trope where one character fills in the exposition almost as though it's directly to the reader. It's a little bit jarring and takes the reader out of the experience a bit to be addressed so directly and have their exact questions answered just as they come up.
Finally, I am insufferable when it comes to cliches. For example:
This excerpt, especially at the end of a chapter, is so incredibly cheesy that it really does hurt to read it.
Furthermore, the entire plot and storyline seems to be based off the 'you are an orphan, learn you are superhero, escape oppression' trope. It would be nice if that was changed up a bit because you could predict the entire story from the moment you figure out that she's a time weaver.
That's about all the subjective criticism that I have, because this entire story was incredibly well written and the characters you created were exposed incredibly well.
On my point of writing from a first-person perspective, I've found that a number of writers seem to fall into the trap of failing to justify the actions of their characters simply because the narration is occurring through their eyes. Occasionally we get emotions and other reasons, but a lot of the time the reader is floating in some kind of decontextualized haze and some of the decisions, dialogue and attitudes of the narrator become unclear and their motivations become muddied. It's very important that if you're writing from a first-person perspective you write in a way that is incredibly easy to empathize with, or else you run the risk of alienating your audience slightly.
But, overall, you story was impeccable. I really enjoyed this premise, and I would definitely love to see an expansion!
1
u/Maifei2050 Mar 21 '15
Nice unexpected little twist to start. Convincing character and voice. Good use of flashback to provide some back story. Not sure about her failure to recognise the maroon suit. Given the pivotal role of the wallet she stole from that guy it was slightly odd. Lots of intriguing possibilities for further development.
1
u/ReeCallahan Mar 25 '15
Just a heads up, I’m not trying to be discouraging or anything, but my critique might read kind of harsh. Please know that I’m just trying to let you know what I think could make your story better, and that my opinions should probably come with their own salt shaker for proper seasoning. Toss anything you don’t think helps.
I thought this was an interesting premise! I liked the bizarre Xavier School for Gifted Youngsters – you’ve definitely brought the concept into darker territory.
That being said, I think you talk to yourself too much in this story. Lines like “…chided myself for getting sidetracked.” “…such a simple item shouldn’t freak me out…” “I refused the strangeness of the situation…” “feeling like I’d woken up in a movie.” All seem to me to be you as an author recognizing that something isn’t quite jibing in the story and letting your character make excuses to the reader for it. It wouldn’t bug me if it were once or twice, but you seem to do it a lot. I would suggest, instead, either standing behind your artistic decisions completely or changing the story to make them feel right. Having characters recognize the story in any way like this can bring the reader’s attention to the fact that they’re reading a story, breaking the spell you want to cast.
I think you have a really good understanding of the plot – what it is and where you want it to go – but I didn’t feel grounded in the setting or the characters. For example, I couldn’t give you a description of Aegis other than there is a hall, a cafeteria, some rooms, and it’s in the sky. That’s it – I have no idea what it’s made of or how it’s laid out, whether it’s industrial styled or sterile, or even a little steampunk-y. I think some more descriptors of these places would have been nice.
For the characters, I couldn’t get a sense of the connection between Emily and Diane. The way they first met – and the immediate acquiescence by Diane to Emily’s hair brushing - was puzzling to me. First off, brushing the hair of someone sleeping – no matter how nasty it looks – is totally weird. Second, why would Diane be ok with something that creepy? She’s supposedly got street smarts, but she wakes up in a strange bed with some strange girl brushing her hair and just… lets her continue? I’m sorry, but I just can’t buy that. I need more before development of the character's relationship before I see Diane letting someone do something so intimate.
I hope this is at all helpful! Again, toss what you don't need/like/want.
1
u/robert0543210 Mar 30 '15
RemindMe! 3 months