r/WritingPrompts • u/jhdierking • Feb 28 '15
Prompt Inspired [PI] Two in the Bush - FebContest
Here is my submission, Two in the Bush, for the novelette contest. Synopsis:
A down on his luck scavenger walks into a pawn shop, hoping to score with his latest haul. When the shop owner offers him a hefty amount for his goods, he realizes he might have scored the big one. He soon finds out he's in for more than he bargained.
Word count: 10,400
Hosted here on my website. PDF also available at the top of the page.
Also, first post here to WritingPrompts. Hello all!
2
Upvotes
5
u/QuinineGlow Mar 01 '15
A little criticism in the hand is worth two in... well, y'know. Just wanted to offer my two-cents on the plot and story development. Don't worry: I don't comment on things that I don't like.
I don't comment very often, in fact.
I'm not gonna discuss grammar or dialogue because I don't want to; there's no major problems, there, anyway, so don't worry about it too much. All I'd really have is nitpicks that aren't worth much to speak of. There's no major problems with the plot and story development either; I enjoyed it and thought it was mostly well-done, but there are a few things I'd humbly suggest:
The discussion of the cult was a lot of telling, and it should've been showing. I'd suggest that the main character either reminisces a lot more about the circumstances behind finding that salvage (with much more vivid detail), or the story should begin with him actually going through the ship itself. This plot point needs more detailed fleshing-out than it's given, and it could allow you to throw in oodles more foreshadowing about the climax.
Mischa is pretty well described by the main character as being inherently duplicitous and untrustworthy outside of her partnerships, and so the MC's decision to sit and 'reminisce' with her while waiting for his next meeting (not to mention leaving his bag unattended) doesn't ring true. I'm aware that you imply she may have done something to his drink, but even if that's the case, why didn't he feel the effects later on in the story (it's never hinted at, again)? I would think that the MC would be more liable to sit with her if, instead, she piqued his interest about a big score going down that he could possibly be a part of (the score being those rocks, naturally, but she never reveals it as such). That way it'd make sense for him to stay and share a drink with her, at the very least, and give her time to ply her feminine wiles with him and wait for him to drop his guard.
The MC's meeting with Erik needs to be punched-up a bit. It makes absolutely zero sense for him to agree to any kind of 'reading' while he's trying to get to a meeting that could possibly get him out of being totally broke (and I don't think that common 'politeness' cuts it). One way to make it more believable would be for the MC to have been feeling psychologically 'odd' with those rocks sitting in his pockets for all this time. He could be feeling very ill at ease as whatever 'process' is going on, exactly, works its magic on him. That might actually make the MC interested in getting a reading on the spot. And this gets to another important point: you talk at length about all the physical effects the rocks exert on him, but maybe if there's a psychological component (of some kind) then the reveal could be far more significant.
Most importantly, I think, is that Erik shouldn't expressly explain the eventual twist to the MC during the reading. His off-the-cuff remark about the cult's defensive strategy absolutely spoiled the surprise (for me, at least). I suggest that Erik's description of the twist should be more vague and uncertain, not explicit (you did a very good job with the 'air' and 'stone' stuff, try expanding on that). The twist should be described enough that the reader completely understands what Erik was talking about later on in the story when it actually happens, but not just dropped in the middle of their talk, where it's made far too obvious in my opinion.
The ending is ambivalent, which is fine, but I wonder if it could be even more so. Leaving Shims locked in the bedroom certainly adds a 'what now?' component to the story, but maybe you should go farther: I'd have liked to see her come out, thinking the coast is clear, only to be tackled to the ground by the MC's new 'friends', held in place as they look to the MC with questioning eyes, wondering what to do next. The MC's musings on whether he can adequately control them would be far more effective, realizing that the next few (unseen) seconds would literally be life-and-death for Shims.
Again, these are merely my humble musings, so take of them what you will :)
3
u/Nate_Parker /r/Nate_Parker_Books Mar 05 '15
Now that I've finished our review group, I've turned my sights inward. I liked this piece very much and would only add one item to QuinineGlow's comments, which I largely agree with. The MC feels like a genuine "Good Scoundrel" and having two murder-birds will probably be a struggle. Maybe enough to take him down a dark path.
Overall, you're a great writer. Ever considered going pro? That said, if you beat me out of this round, it won't bother me in the slightest. Going against this story is a tough challenge. Good job.
Also… bonus point for using façade. I find it ironic the word keeps popping up.
2
u/Piconeeks Mar 15 '15
I really enjoyed this story, and I was actually really disappointed when I got to the end and found out that it was over. It had flowed so naturally that I had no idea that I had gotten to the end so quickly.
I feel like that is the piece's greatest strength but also its biggest weakness. You drew me in really quickly with the world that you described but I was left with all sorts of questions at the end of it, loose ends that left me with the feeling that the piece was unfinished.
I still really don't know what it's like to be a scavenger, and what kind of jobs you usually do, or how he met Mischa, or who Shims is, or really how the protagonist got into this situation. From a worldbuilding perspective, I got the impression that this was mildly futuristic, but I never got a good picture of what the area looked like or the context and setting of the world and economy that your characters live in.
And the story just starts to get interesting near the end, but when the climactic scene of your story is essentially a deus ex machina, you can't fault the reader for wanting more.
But all these (subjective) criticisms hint at the fact that this dissatisfaction was caused by how engrossing and interesting your world and your characters were. I was incredibly interested and invested in these contextless characters from the beginning and your writing made them incredibly interesting. Good work! I'd advise you to expand on it and see where it goes.
2
u/Maifei2050 Mar 21 '15
Well described world and interesting character. I felt the strange creatures didn’t have much build-up or tension. One minute they’re rocks and the next they’re biting someone’s face off. Great potential for more to follow.
2
u/ReeCallahan Mar 26 '15
Hullo! Welcome to WritingPrompts!
I just wanted to drop a little critique here for you before disappearing into the ether! Usual caveat: I'm just a human with opinions and you can totally toss anything in this critique you find unuseful or offensive.
First and foremost, you have a tight style here! I love it when the wording just runs smoothly and I'm not constantly distracted by plodding prose mired in past perfect and pools of adverbs. Though, at the start, I felt like you might have been overloading a bit on adjectives, I was happy to see that tendency fade a bit as the story progressed.
My main trouble at the beginning was that you seemed to have two contradicting descriptions of Brand. The first was as a shop woman who didn't seem to know Lee, and the other was as a grittier version of the same shop woman who was familiar with Lee. I think this was exemplified in the two different descriptions of her smile:
Also, I didn't get why someone who was willing to settle for ten credits from Brand for a knife, would turn down a thousand for a couple of rocks. It just seemed out of place for the character you'd built up to that point. These characters are haggling, only to have Lee walk away completely from what seems like a sweet deal with the context we have in that moment. It doesn't quite add up to me as it is, so you might want to clarify his intention a little there.
I think your characters are all really well drawn personality-wise, but some of their interactions seemed a bit off. As QuinineGlow said, I didn't buy that Lee would be OK being side-tracked by Erik for an aural reading. If the appointment with Shims was put off for a while I think it would help; like, maybe she mentions she's not available for a few hours 'cause her time is valuable and she has other shit to do.
I also had trouble believing that Lee would spend so much time with Mischa when he clearly held a lot of disdain for her. If Mischa was painted as conniving, but maybe also sweet and attractive (and not just when Lee has something valuable) it might give her depth and make it clearer why Lee would waste his time.
Two other things that could fix each other, if addressed: 1. There were a lot of characters and it was sometimes hard to keep track, particularly at the beginning, 2. The story felt like the first act of a longer work, as opposed to a self-contained piece. If you expanded this story out to a whole novel - which doesn't seem like it would be difficult, as you've given yourself a lot of material to work with - then the number of characters wouldn't matter and the story could have a chance to conclude all of the side-stories you've already seeded.
Overall, this was a really well written story, with few issues I could find. By any chance, have you read any of the Dresden Files? There's something about this that reminded me of the first book. Anyway, I hope this was useful! Good luck on your future drafts. :)