r/anime • u/MasterAyy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Master_A • Mar 09 '15
[WT!] Gosick, a "Tragically Beautiful" Mystery Romance
While watching Gosick I never thought it'd be a series I would strongly recommend to others but by the end of the show it lit a spark in me that truly cared about the characters and their outcome. The show slowly builds up speed and by the end it goes full throttle. Below I'll describe the show a bit and why you should watch it!
Brief Description
The series takes place during the 1920's in the made up European country of Sauville. During this period of time in the show science is trying to take hold and counter the superstitious beliefs that are still popular. Sauville even has a ministry of Occulent which is focused on the supernatural. Since the general populace believes in the supernatural many people believe in all the ghost stories and that the mysteries are caused by supernatural beings.. Using this 1920's setting the show tries to delve into the science/logic vs superstition and that's where one of the main conflicts of the overall story arises.
Our main protagonist, Kujo Kazuya is a Japanese foreign exchange student to Saint Marguerite Academy where he first meets Victorique. The first half of the show is semi episodic with 1-3 episode mysteries that the pair of them solve. The first half is used to build the world and define the characters but then it starts to hit the plot fast during the second half where the overall story comes into play.
To be brief Gosick is beautifully animated. The characters and background are nicely detailed and the show is nice to look at. An example of a scene. The Gothic and Victorian atmosphere really helped set the mood and I thought it was a nice choice. Having the show take place outside Japan lets it break free and try something new. The music was also beautiful and helped set the atmosphere. The OP & ED are full of symbolism and also go with the tone of the show.
Genres:
- Mystery: While the show is mostly known for it's mystery theme it's actually not very strong in this department and you shouldn't expect to much from it. I'm not saying the mysteries are bad but they mostly fall into the average category. There are some clever moments but overall the mysteries are used to build the world and the history/atmosphere of the show. The mysteries later take a back seat to the overall plot.
- Historical: The post World War I setting is pretty cool and I liked how the writers tried to incorporate its themes. While it doesn't follow history exactly its a cool spin on "what if things went differently" and how history went down a different path in this alternate universe.
- Romance & Drama: The true gem of the show is within these two genres. The romance isn't the "professing love going on dates" type but a more natural progression of being together between our two main characters. I'll explain it a bit more below.
Why you should watch it?
Pros:
- Victorique, the main heroine and the star of the show. She's Tsundere-Kuudere hybrid character and carries the first half of the series pretty much on her own. She goes through some pretty major events and her character develops and grows in a great way as a result. I found that her character design and personality are very similar to Kuroneko from OreImo so if you are a big Kuroneko fan like I am you'll find alot to love in Victorique.
- Subtly built romance with no fanservice. The romance in the series is never sexualized nor is Victorique which I found to be pretty nice. The viewer gets to see the sparks develop between Kujo and Victorique and it just feels really genuine. By the end of the series you to will be strongly attached to this pairing as the show takes it's time to pull them together.
- The Ending. Gosick definitely has one of the best anime endings that I've ever seen and it really struck a chord with me. Without spoiling anything the last 3-4 episodes are very intense with the story coming to an end. The ending was beautiful and tragic in its own way. It's one of those endings that hits you hard and leaves an impact.
Cons:
- Kujo is kinda dense during the first half the show and many of the mysteries fly over his head. He is the "Watson" to Victoriques "Sherlock" so he mostly is around for Victorique to advance the plot. He transitions into more of a knight during the later half of the show as he grows closer to Victorique. Don't be put off by him at first, he is a likable character that gets more serious later in the series.
- As I've mentioned above the mysteries are rather weak but they really aren't the main focus of the show in the first place. I think show's like Hyouka had the better mysteries but Gosick uses the mysteries as just a vehicle to define the world and give us the back story that we need. The two best genres are definitely the romance and drama.
Final Thoughts:
I'm very pleased with how Gosick turned out and highly recommend it. Watch the first half for Victorique and later the second half for the plot that goes down. The ending was the type that made me want to bump it up extra points after finishing, it was just that good to me. Watch and let the story grab hold and pull you in to the delicate relationship between the characters.
64
u/Spartan448 Mar 09 '15
In my opinion this show is worth your time if only because "Gothic Lolita Sherlock Holmes" is one of the best character concepts ever. She even has a little toy pipe that I'm surprised didn't make it into OP's gif set.
20
u/icebreakeur :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/icebreakeur Mar 09 '15
Dont forget the ending! god, that ending, I played it so many time at osu! when i started playing.
One of the best if not the best ending i know so far https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MsxyWP0en04
38
u/mmonsterbasher Mar 09 '15
"Viiiiicccccttttttoriquee!!!
11
u/NoVeMoRe Mar 09 '15 edited Mar 09 '15
This show really is visually stunning, has an astounding atmosphere and a memorable musical score with one of the strongest ED's.
Gosick is by far one of my favourites and while it was never an absoluty obscure or underrated show it always seemed to me like it wasn't talked much about for no good reason given its ratings and rankings. So i'm really glad that it's getting a little bit more of attention here.
That said though, i think the biggest mistake one can make going into this show is to expect a case by case solving of thrilling mysteries because of it being tagged as a 'Mystery' show and expecting that to be the actual focus of it. In my eyes the show is actually really all about the obscure, fears of the yet unknown and occult incitement versus reasoned thought and the progression of science of that period of time in its overarching theme and i think that it almost nails it perfectly. Gosick really manages to give you this authentic feel of that period of time, you honestly start to believe that these events are actually taking place there and that this is their world and not just some nicely drawn fassade for staging the characters and moving the plot ahead.
If i had to give a criticism though i'd say that Victorique really steals and needlessly carries that show to the expense of the remaining cast and while i do not mind that most other characters are just "people they now and then talk to but don't have a strong connection with", it sadly also affects the male lead given his disconnect to his new surroundings as a japanese tranfer student. So the time that he gets to advance as his own character are rare and since he's nearly always accompanying Victorique he's getting overshadowed by her pretty much all the time until the second half of the show starts kicking in.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
Gosick is one of the most baffling shows to describe to people. The first half of the show is just on the tolerable side of boring, and if it weren't for Kujo being generally moe I'd probably have dropped it. But then something happened. All of a sudden the mini-arcs had stakes, there was tension, and I legitimately couldn't tell what was gonna happen next.
Gosick's last arc might be rushed, but goddamn if it's not one of the best, and definitely the most complete, endings in LN anime adaptation history.
6
u/TokaBestGirl :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hangedre Mar 09 '15
Started watching it yesterday,i find the MC REALLY annoying. D:
2
u/texxaport Mar 09 '15
Just started this yesterday!
2
u/shard13 Mar 10 '15
Thanks OP for this WT. I remember starting this back when it was airing and I ended up listening to the ragers about how stupid this show is. This thread made me give it a second chance. That and I needed a break from the tragic anime spree I have been on.
2
u/Butterkupp Mar 10 '15
Correct me if I'm wrong but I thought the show ends during WWII, so it's placed in the mid to late 1930s.
2
u/ghoulas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ghoulas Mar 10 '15
My wife loved it and she searched for any similar show, she likes mystery solving with similar art style. Any recommendations?
2
u/rific :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/rific Mar 10 '15
Show is for sure entertaining, but I had a big problem with the deduction of mysteries. Maybe I'm just dumb, but not many of them made much sense to me. It felt like goth loli pulled the answers out of thin air and being correct, not giving us the viewers much of a chance to figure things out.
Also, a good chunk of it can be boring as hell, but those last few eps are pretty spectacular.
2
u/ArianaArmy33 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ArianaArmy33 Mar 11 '15
Started this yesterday I'm like 4 episodes in. Pretty good so far. :)
3
u/samstone13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/samstone Mar 09 '15
Honestly I think the big part of the show is Victorique. If you have a dislike for goth loli then you would not enjoy it as much. I did find the show interesting but was not that excited about it like most of my friends who watched it for Victorique and the romance between her and Kazuya. Also the ending seems...I would not call it rushed but it's definitely not fulfilling to me. Hope that the 2 new LNs (Gosick blue and Gosick red) will be adapted considering the theme and a new environment (NY during prohibition era with serial murder cases) are really interesting to me.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '15
I watched episode 1 of this show and simply forgot about it a long while back. I've intended to return to it, but never really found the motivation.
I was on board with your suggestion until this. I thought Hyouka had pretty terrible mysteries and was mostly about the people and its themes about tradition and whatnot, much like how you describe Gosick. If Gosick's mysteries are even worse than "Why did the homeroom teacher think we had already covered systems of equations when we hadn't" (an actual mystery they spend an episode or two on in Hyouka), I'm not sure I can take it.
I'll still check it out again, since I like good romance and the gothic/Victorian aesthetic a lot, but shit man, how hard is it to find a good mystery thriller in anime.
By the way, since I'm here, this is just a suggestion not just to you, but to all [WT!] writers: What's most persuasive to me if you're trying to convince me to watch a series is the actual series itself. Don't tell me about it, show it to me, make me hear it and experience it a little. Link to scenes, screenshots, soundtracks, something visceral and immersive. You do some of that, but do more of it. A lot more of it!
3
u/ChaseTx Mar 10 '15
Gosick was great. I need to go back and finish it
3
u/hopecanon Mar 10 '15
this was actually among the first anime i ever watched and its remained a favorite since then, it is delightfully funny and tragic at the same time.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '15
Ivve started this twice and only gotten to episode 2 or 3. Now I wanna try again. What episode # would you say the story picks up?
4
u/igloojoe11 Mar 09 '15
I liked this series, but I really would have rather it had kept it's episodic mystery format. Though, when it did break into an overarching plot, it was still fine, I just preferred the first half.
2
u/EDNivek :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EDNivek Mar 09 '15
I think towards the end many characters weren't fleshed out well and the ending felt rather rushed. Not terrible, but not the best.
2
u/war_story_guy Mar 10 '15
This reminds me of the archives of Dantalian.
2
u/MicoJive :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MicoJive Mar 10 '15
I liked this a lot more then I thought I was going to, which is a good thing.
2
u/Solacen :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Solacen Mar 10 '15
Gosick is one of the few shows i have rated 10/10 on MAL because it was so damn good.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 09 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment