r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Apr 23 '15
Map Thread #46 Top Maps Feedback Thread
Welcome one and all to the top map feedback thread for map thread #46! The following maps have made it through to the next stage - 4v4 testing - which will take place on Sunday, April 26th. The goal of this staged testing is to give maps more time to sink in. It also allows the community and committee members to give feedback to promising maps in the same testing cycle.
Maps
Capture the Flag:
War Garden by ooo kill 'em & Rapture
Arcade by Loaha
Crabble by Flail
Draft by Dianna Agron & Aniball
Ultradrive by Aniball
Neutral Flag
Bulldog by Snowball
Blob by Dianna Agron & Aniball
Mapmakers whose maps have advanced have until testing takes place on Sunday to make alterations to their maps. Any edits should be posted as comments responding to the appropriate top-level map comment made from this account.
Group Rotation
In addition to the 4v4 testing, the map 00101010 by Flail will be added to the group rotation.
To the community, feel free to give constructive criticism on these maps as well! YOU could influence the next map in rotation!
9
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15
Draft by Dianna Agron & Aniball
Preview
7
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15
War Garden by ooo kill 'em & Rapture
Preview
3
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15
Ultradrive by Aniball
Preview
2
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15 edited Apr 23 '15
Blob by Dianna Agron & Aniball
Preview
7
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen | Salt Mine Apr 23 '15
Obligatory /r/CountMapula4Rotation
I think I've been seriously overestimating my skills as a mapmaker, because I was really confident in Ghost/Phantom. As often as I've been turned down, it's never not disappointing.
Pretty good crop here though, I suppose. I really liked Draft & Blob by Dianiball and it's nice to see War Garden's revival. Arcade looks pretty cool too. I'll be honest though, compared to the vast majority of maps submitted, Crabble isn't anywhere close. It only advanced because of Chalksy's competition :P Sorry Flail, I usually like your maps, and I'll admit that I'm biased because I've been drowning in asymmetrical maps over at /r/TagProTesting and I'm not a huge fan of giving feedback for things that are inherently imbalanced, but I stand by my statement.
Good luck to all who advanced.
1
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15
Arcade by Loaha
Preview
0
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15
Bulldog by Snowball
Preview
2
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Apr 23 '15
Come join top maps testing tonite at 8:30 EST!
2
u/Dannymod Danny // Official Tagpro Critic // Maker of Threads Apr 24 '15
#Bomberdome4GroupRotation
1
u/manbare Hi, I'm Manbear Apr 24 '15
Did you guys get any submissions with gravity wells?
1
u/gingerdg TPRL 🔴RMTC 🔴NASCAPS Apr 23 '15
I happen to like a few of the maps on this thread, but I have to say that I am really disappointed that Count Mapula did not make it in the top threads. People have been pushing for that map to be in rotation ever since it was created, and I believe that several members of the maptest committee even praised it as well.
As stated in another comment, it might be extremely beneficial and an idea worth delving into to have the spreadsheet with all of the maps ranked again.
As moosen, and butter churn were saying; it gets really frustrating when you submit a map, and you have really positive feedback, yet absolutely nothing comes out of it.
In addition, another idea would be to have a poll once the map submission closes with 10 spaces to write the name of your favorite map for rotation. Then, when the spreadsheet comes out, there will be a column called "public vote" next to the rank.
Hope you like the ideas
/r/CountMapula4Rotation
-1
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 23 '15
Crabble by Flail
Preview
0
u/bdubyageo Saks 5th Ave / Centra Showboat Aficionado Apr 24 '15
Bring back gamepad
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment