r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Oct 09 '15
Map Thread #54 Top Maps Feedback Thread
Welcome one and all to the top map feedback thread for Map Thread 54! The following maps have made it through to the next stage - 4v4 testing - which will take place this Sunday. The goal of this staged testing is to give maps more time to sink in. It also allows the community and committee members to give feedback to promising maps in the same testing cycle.
Maps
Capture the Flag:
Birch - Sizzzled (we all still think this is hilarious by the way)
Mapmakers whose maps have advanced have until testing takes place on Saturday to make alterations to their maps. Any edits should be posted as comments responding to the appropriate top-level map comment made from this account.
To the community, feel free to give constructive criticism on these maps as well! YOU could influence the next map in rotation!
5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 09 '15
Aerodent - Grapefruit
16
u/Moosemaster21 Moosen | Salt Mine Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15
Citadel is literally the only one of these maps that I like a lot. Aerodent is pretty good.
Also,
Then please take the process seriously and stop voting for it :/
Post-Salt Edit: I apologize if anything I said in this thread offended anyone. I firmly believe the MTC is doing the best they can, and while we have some disagreements on which maps are most deserving of making appearances in these threads, I commend them for the time and effort they consistently put into it.
2
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 09 '15
Citadel - Canvas
11
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Oct 09 '15
I'm disappointed in this thread. There were some really cool maps submitted, especially NF, but I don't think I like any of the choices here. I think Birch should be given up on honestly, Rham den Swede is probably one of my least favourite maps from the thread. Sediment does not flow well, and has weird bases in a bad way, and Citadel is just too awkward and plain. Aerodent looks like a decent map, but that's about it.
Really not that happy right now, and it's only 50% because my maps weren't chosen.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '15
4
u/mmartinutk Macho | JuicyJuke Oct 09 '15 edited Oct 09 '15
ITT:
Every. Fucking. Thread. We. Post.
And it's from mapmakers who missed out on top maps and are too blind too see their opinions on maps are arbitrary and somewhat biased.
But hey, let's upvote them because watching the world burn is much more interesting.
Why do I do this again?
2
u/kstarr12 nipplefart Oct 09 '15
There's always going to be people that disagree with the maps chosen. Why not have one map chosen by the MTC and one chosen by a community vote?
2
u/TeHokioi Pouakai | Diameter Oct 09 '15
I'm starting to wonder whether we should have the community vote for some maps to enter a trial rotation or whatever. I'm not sure whether the MTC is just out of touch with what sort of maps are liked or whether they don't give a shit / take their job seriously, but the last four or so threads have had such disappointing results and have added pretty average maps compared to some of the ones which were on the list.
In the past four threads, only three maps have been added, two of which went straight to the bottom of the ratings and have consistently stayed there while getting huge negative feedback. In the same length of time four maps have been removed, all but one of which rate higher than every single map added since.
Now, in this map thread so far there's only one map with a positive vote count, out of the dozens of maps which were submitted - not saying all of them were decent (mine was pretty rubbish) - but regardless, there were many more maps which scored higher on the community vote and were better maps than what has made it through - Birch was negative even during the first map phase, yet because the MTC thought it was funny it made it through instead of a better map. None of these maps scored higher than 5 in the first thread, while at least ten other maps scored higher than them and had more positive feedback from the community.
One or two bad threads I can overlook. But as of late it seems as though good threads are the exception, not the norm. As I said, I'm not sure what the reason is, but it's definitely something which needs addressing if the MTC still wants the community to have faith in it.
1
u/JJSpice JJ Spice Oct 11 '15
I wish there was a way to not make downvoted Maps disappear (minimize). In a thread like this I feel like all of the top maps should stay visible. I've received more positive than negative feedback about mine, and have made a ton of changes that no one seems to see since it is hidden.
I'm not trying to complain, just pointing out that it is strange in a thread thats only about 5 maps.
-5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 09 '15
Sediment - DaEvil1
-5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 09 '15
Rham Den Swede - JJ Spice
-12
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Oct 09 '15
Birch - Sizzzled