r/anime • u/cdsboy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cdsboy • Feb 23 '16
Updates and Clarifications to the Spoiler Rules
New Non-Anime Spoiler Tag
We are following the lead of other subreddits (like /r/gameofthrones and /r/thewalkingdead) and adding a new kind of spoiler tag. This tag will be used for any spoiler from a Non-Anime source including manga, visual novels, and other spoilers that do not have an anime adaption.. We're hoping this will add extra clarity to discussion. The new code for the tag is:
[Non-Anime Spoiler](/n "Spoiler goes here.")and show up like:
This new spoiler tag must be used for any non-anime spoilers going forward.
Spoiler Title Clarification
We've noticed an ever increasing amount of spoilers without a title for the tag. This has always been against the rules. However, we've been very bad enforcing this in the past. Moving forward we will be cracking down on spoilers without a title.
A short word on while we're going to be enforcing this rule more strictly:
Currently, a lot of people omit the title of a spoiler when they feel the context of the spoiler is clear. This presents a problem in deep comment chains, permanent links to comments, and large threads that someone is skimming over. While adding a title to every spoiler can be annoying, we believe the added seconds it takes to add the title greatly increases clarity to the comment.
A Final Word
We will be enforcing these now rules gently over the next couple of weeks. However, to be able to do our job properly we're going to need a bit of help from the subreddit. Please report any improperly tagged spoilers you see.
165
u/UnavailableUsername_ Feb 23 '16
Eh...does it need to have such a vibrant, flashy, color?
Read a white-font red-backgorund red wall-of-text seems like making the eyes hurt.
Example:
Non-Anime Spoiler
I find it straining to the eyes.
Can't it be eh...black-font and sky-blue background or black-font and brown-background? ......something less flashy?
48
u/FateSteelTaylor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FateSteelTaylor Feb 23 '16
Is this going to be a place where we can talk about these things, or are you going to leave us an update and tell us to wait a month for the meta thread to discuss them?
If we can talk about them, a few thoughts:
No major problem with this, though I don't know if it should be harshly punished. Idk how you guys do it, but at least when there's a spoiler tag minus a title, the attempt was made there.
Also, how are you guys planning to enforce this? I mean, just by the very nature of the medium, there's no way that all the mods have seen each and every anime (though I'd love to be proven wrong). This has led to mistakes previously. So now that we add manga and other source material to the mix, how do you hope to enforce that? Like, if we properly mark something as a Nisekoi anime spoiler but it turns out to be a Nisekoi manga spoiler, what happens then? Like, for those of us who have read and watched a fair share, are we supposed to remember each minute detail that is distinguished between the two? I don't know how you mods determine the strikes against users (and it seems to vary between mods), but will a spoiler of a manga detail that was skipped in the anime but tagged with /s be the same as not tagging the spoiler at all?
I understand it in the greater scheme of things especially in discussion threads of airing anime that have source material that's ahead of the anime, but I foresee a lot of mishandlings with this and I would like some transparency on how you're going to "crack down" on this.
14
u/BP_Ray :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Maleel Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
I like the idea of this since it can be a bit difficult to sort through spoiler tags on discussion threads or posts about certain shows i'm watching because i'm unsure if what i'm going to be hovering over is a source material spoiler or if I can see it having only watched the anime to completion.
The problem is that it only works as a nice idea or at the very least the rule needs a lot of refining. To use /u/SmurfRockRune's example of Jojo's:
Based on the mod teams responses in this thread, that comment even if 6 comments into a specific comment thread about Jojo's in a Jojo's thread would get removed firstly for not specifying that he's spoiling Jojo's (Even if the context and spoiler title makes it clear) and if he were to accidentally not use the red spoiler tag when speaking about part 5 it would get removed + a warning. This isn't even me reaching here, /u/cdsboy said it himself no exceptions:
And if this accident is repeated several times by one user, you will be banned, as the precedent set with P.Ironman would dictate plus the comment once again made by /u/cdsboy:
Don't you at least find that a little unreasonable? It's not very hard to accidentally spoiler tag a source material spoiler with a black spoiler tag (Especially given habits formed by literally every other subreddit) so are repeated offenses for something like that really fair to be bannable? Also, isn't it completely unreasonable to say "context doesn't matter" for spoilers in discussions? If I am 30 comments deep into a back and forth comment thread, naturally i'll get a little more lenient with my spoilers, but by the rules set by you I can get banned for that. Also, can we discuss how many warnings is "too much"? For example I believe I have 2 warnings on this subreddit right now (Not 100% sure on that) both of which are at least 9-10 months old. Will 3 accidents get me banned like P.Ironman?
I understand why you guys are doing this, it makes perfect sense considering discussion threads are difficult to go through as it currently is. But I feel like you're being too stiff with the rules here, and trying to fix something that I personally believe to be irreparable. You can't make it absolutely impossible for people to run into spoilers to the point where they're only spoiled willingly no matter how hard you try, this is the internet after all. For example say I link Digibro's video on Gurren Lagann vs Kill la Kill and he mentions how Gurren Lagann is a homage to Ashita no Joe 2, there was no way for someone on /r/anime watching the video to know he was going to spoil that (Although it is basically the Darth Vader spoiler of anime) yet they got spoiled anyways. Yet at the same time you can't possibly enforce a spoiler rule for that, you would starve this subreddit of content from basically any and every youtuber video if you were to delete videos like that. Also, there's the problem of linking to spoilers. Like lets say I link to a series of images that are spoilers, but the context you should know that those images are going to be spoilers. It would be impractical and messy if I had to clarify that those spoil a certain series, despite me having a spoiler tag before them, but if we're using the logic you're using here that spoiler warning need to be where ever there is a spoiler regardless of context then I should have to give a warning. That's what I mean by you guys being too stiff about your rule enforcing.
I know you're currently denying this isn't as a result of P.Ironman's ban, only that it prompted discussion about it, but I find it really hard to believe that the way you're enforcing this isn't just to stick by his ban. If you guys allow for context to matter for example, then P.Ironmans ban would have to be lifted because every single one of his spoiler tags (Especially the one he got banned for) had a reasonable amount of context already established in the comment chain. If you guys don't ban for repeated incidents of accidental spoilers (Like the example I gave earlier) then that invalidates your reasoning for banning P.Ironman considering every single one of his spoilers at least made an attempt at spoiler tagging or were complete accidents he was unaware could be considered spoilers Fate/Stay Night: Heavens Feel This new rule really only makes the argument for P.Ironman's ban to be lifted that much more stronger.
7
u/snowywish :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/snowy801 Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
Not working on mobile.
Proof, and Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince spoilers
5
u/DerpyMcFrakles https://myanimelist.net/profile/KakkaKarrotCake Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
I'm had a look at this on my phone with the Alien Blue app (iOS) and it's a bit weird.
In this image using the non-anime spoiler tag, the bible spoiler works as it should, just like the anime spoiler works on mobile.
But in this image using the non-anime spoiler tag, the part 5 Jojo spoiler is isn't displaying properly, yet the part 2 spoiler which uses the anime spoiler tag is working just fine.
And in this image using the non-anime spoiler tag, the Rome 44 BC and Romeo and Juliet spoilers are displaying as articles that lead nowhere when clicked on.
They all look the same and function properly on my computer, so it's strange how it displays in 3 different ways on mobile.
Also the non-anime spoiler in the post description works as it should on mobile, I just didn't screenshot it.
89
u/JTricks :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JTricks Feb 23 '16
Testing Bible Spoiler
10
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
So for non-anime, does this also include manga?
So if I'm having a conversation about JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, do I need to have a rainbow of spoiler tags in my comment?
(No actual spoilers in the tags) Man that time when Part 2 was amazing. It reminded me a lot of the time that Part 5 To be honest, I'm a little bit tired, and I have no idea what I'm talking about, but I think my point is clear.
EDIT: So, it just clicked in my head. I assume the purpose of the red tag is so that people instinctively stay away from it?
3
u/zhongzhen93 Feb 23 '16
I am unsure of the Spoiler title clarification rule, so I'll use Kyon as a case example to ask a question.
Clearly, my statement and context in this post and comment about is the Kyonness of Kyon in the world of Kyon. Assuming that Kyon is the subject we are talking about here:
9
u/Painn23 Feb 23 '16
Nah man this is too much. Y'all blowing my day already. And the CL is about to be in but now I see this. Y'all doing too much now a days.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '16
Can we abbreviate titles of well known shows? Like TTGL and PMMM. Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works is a pain to write out.
Edit: Also, people often include "spoiler" in the spoiler tag title, but is this actually necessary?
34
u/Tank_Kassadin Feb 23 '16
Count me a fan.
21
u/ss_lmtd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ss_lmtd Feb 23 '16
My main concern: people are going to start getting reported/banned for incorrectly using the spoiler tag. Are you going to warn people if they keep incorrectly using the right tag? Are you going to ban them if they continue even after that? Even if they're actually trying to not spoil other people?
More than that, are we going to have to keep pointing people out who don't see this announcement and then end up using the wrong spoiler tag?
7
u/KrysWasTaken :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Xorezekatu Feb 23 '16
Wouldn't it be easier to force people to use spoiler tag titles properly? You're already going to focus on it more, having a second spoiler tag seems useless.
It looks the same on reddit is fun and tapping a comment reveals all the spoilers at once, so it sucks anyways.
7
u/Totenkopfgitarrist Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 24 '16
I don't have a problem with using two spoilers, but I have to say, that I don't really see the use of them. 99% of the spoilers in the episode-threads are about the source material, as everything in the anime isn't a spoiler anymore and the rest is from the source material until it actually airs. Same with all the "what is your favourite anime XY?" threads, where it's 99% about anime as one should expect by this sub.
The only real thing could be same more detailed discussions about themes/series or WT!s and never saw a problem there, as most of the people already write Spoiler S2 or From the manga. And tbh I don't think any user who doesn't do this right now, will bother with two different codes. Instead I see more potential for discussions and errors, when we are talking about old or big titles where source material and anime differs. Going back to reread/rewatch the source/anime just to look up which spoiler tag to use is simply a nuisance... people who already use spoilers with good intentions will have to be more careful as making errors is easier and people who don't use them correctly won't start now.
Furthermore this is also redundant with the enforced spoiler title. The obligation to use the name of the show already warns every person who don't want to read spoilers. And as they are mostly used for discussions/answers to questions, people who'll read them are prepared for. I don't really see the case of "I wanted to know, if they die but please only anime spoilers, no manga spoilers!".
I can understand the need for better spoilers, but in my case, using multiple spoilers with more failure states will just lead to less activity, as I don't want to look up every scene in the source/anime I might not remember correctly. So better just don't answer anymore instead of using the wrong spoiler to get a new warning or other punishments... I can see the cut between anime and non-anime-related source materials but between anime and the source of the anime?
6
u/Zigman369 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zigman Feb 24 '16 edited Feb 24 '16
Question: would I/someone get a warning for doing this past the point of launch period? (instead of using the new tagging system, writing specifically [manga]/[VN]/[etc] within the traditional spoiler tag structure):
I ask this because this new method of spoiler tags is most certainly not standard across subreddits, and can/will cause issue with new [reddit] users/returning ones that don't happen to notice a new thing in the sidebar. Now, obviously the best case with new members to a subreddit is for them to fully read the sidebar, but the fact of the matter is that that just doesn't happen. Some mobile clients are notoriously bad at making it easy to read the sidebar and not only that, most of them don't even show the different [colors of] spoiler tags so a very large portion of the sub's population is either:
Because of these reasons, it seems like this new rule only makes more instances of "(un)necessary moderation" for you guys on the mod-team because there's no doubt that there will be a hell of a lot of people not following this tagging structure right off the bat/into the near future. I agree with you guys that it's not particularly difficult to do (and the fact that it could potentially become a helpful thing with how different kinds of spoilers are handled), but the fact of the matter is that this isn't a standard practice across reddit (the first time I've personally seen this), and it's a lot of hassle on everyone's end to uphold this change with a special focus towards mobile/new users that this new rule either barely effects or could potentially confuse/alienate.
Now maybe this is just the wording, but when I read this it sounds like you guys want [us] to hunt down anyone (again, possibly new/unaware users) who are not following the frankly non-standard practice. I don't like the way this comes off. I've been browsing/occassionally commenting on this subreddit for over two years now and have never/rarely run into issues where people have "improperly tagged" their manga/VN/LN/etc spoilers. IMO the new system is fine but should be optional if making obvious note that the spoiler being tagged is from another non-anime source.
Example:
Where obviously the "traditional" style of the tagging makes obvious note of the fact that we're talking about the VN, and the "new" style denotes that we're talking about the VN because that I used the new system. There should be a bit of give-and-take here, rather than a total crackdown. I don't see why both can't co-exist.
5
u/appu1232 https://anilist.co/user/appu1232 Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
Hmm, I'm not sure how necessary this really is though. Sure it can be used to tag non-anime stuff but usually, I just warn about the contents of the spoiler in the spoiler title even if it isn't anime related.
I guess it would make it easier to distinguish but I feel like people will eventually forget this exists and just go back to spoiler-tagging non-anime content using the normal tag with a warning that it's non-anime related in the spoiler title. I mean I guess you could just enforce it if it dies down but would you be deleting comments that still warned beforehand that it was non-anime related but used the normal spoiler tags?
5
u/oblivionraptor Feb 23 '16
Interesting feature. Would be useful for discussions of the contents of The Holy Bibles of /r/OneTrueTatsuya in this subreddit. Just gotta remember the /n.
Then again, why the need for another tag when, for the black one, you could just indicate what you're spoiling?
Example, no actual spoilers: [LN Mahouka] (/s "Tatsuya is awesome")
instead of Mahouka
Anyway, thanks for the new feature, will definitely use them.
5
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Feb 23 '16
Another question I just thought of. How should this be used in regards to an episode discussion thread for either an airing or a rewatch?
Let's say I'm looking through the comments of my JoJo rewatch, and I have something relevant to say regarding the manga. Do I have to do JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 4 or would Part 4 be fine?
5
u/thisisnotathrowa https://myanimelist.net/profile/gmicha4 Feb 23 '16
considering we have to title the spoilers anyway isn't adding a new color a bit redundant?
5
u/Th1Alchemyst :K:https://kitsu.io/users/1482 Feb 23 '16
This seems like an unnecessary extra step which could be entirely resolved by enforcing spoiler titles in the existing spoiler tag. The situation you're describing is already an edge case, frankly, and doesn't really warrant an extra tag.
5
u/porpoiseoflife https://myanimelist.net/profile/OffColfax Feb 24 '16
So I think I'm going back to my original policy of just flat-out not discussing spoilers in the first place unless absolutely fucking necessary. These rules are unnecessarily complex and unwieldy from my point of view, and it would be better for me to simply dodge the issue altogether. And this will be even harsher for the newcomers to the subreddit (and, in my view, a reversal of the trend to make this subreddit more newbie-friendly) who rarely understand how to do the old spoiler tags in the first place. And having to add in the full and complete names of the anime make them even more awkward.
I'll follow the rule when needed, but I'm going to stand in dissent on this one.
4
u/VincentBlack96 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vincent Feb 23 '16
Testing
4
u/Crossadder Feb 23 '16
[Testing] (/n "this ain't that pleasant to read, IMO.")
Can't say I like the color of the /n spoilers.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '16
A spoiler is a spoiler regardless of the medium, right?
It's going to spoil the story regardless.
Like remember that one time in the Bible but then in the Passion of the Christ
10
u/Kafukator Feb 23 '16
So basically a spoiler tag for source material spoilers? Sweet!
3
u/Warguyyyy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Warguy Feb 23 '16
Theres a typo on the sidebar with it:
But in the spoiler stands Non-Anime Source Anime
3
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Feb 23 '16
Well, here's hoping any and all mobile apps support it in a reasonable timeframe.
3
u/PrinceRazor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PrinceRazor Feb 23 '16
Now I feel like someone might make art with the 2 colored bars.......
3
u/Sunscreeen :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sunscreeen Feb 24 '16
Test comment, please ignore.
Non-Anime Spoiler
3
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '16
Non-Anime Spoiler
3
u/RDOoM Feb 25 '16
So, uhm... am I allowed to use an untitled spoiler tag without actually spoiling anything.
5
u/EpikMemeage :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/epikmemeage Feb 23 '16
This should be extremely helpful in Discussion threads as I've gotten into an awful habit on hovering over the standard spoiler tags.
I'm glad that there is additional clarity now on the "spoiler" procedure as there was lots of inconsistency with how spoilers were being handled in the past. Hopefully most spoiler infractions will be dealt with in a similar manner now.
1
u/ChuckCarmichael Feb 23 '16
Where's the line? Would I have to mark Empire Strikes Back spoilers? What about The Sixth Sense? Or Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince?
2
u/ShaKing807 x3myanimelist.net/profile/Shaking807 Feb 23 '16
Follow up, how will this work on mobile?
2
u/ilkei Feb 23 '16
Feel the new spoiler tag is a bit pointless as long as tagging is more vigorously enforced, accurate tagging, by itself should fix any issues without the need to remember and switch between two different spoiler codes depending on the context.
2
u/Kaffarov Feb 23 '16
Red kinda sticks out a lot to me, maybe change it to grey or something ¯_(ツ)_/¯
2
u/Deskup Feb 25 '16
Is there a way to force spoilers into not being <a> elements? Makes reading them from mobile browsers really annoying. :(
2
u/nick012000 Feb 26 '16
These spoiler rules are retarded, frankly. The original spoiler rules you made were bad enough, and then you just had to go and make them even worse.
2
u/XtoraX :GJ::GK::GL: Feb 27 '16
does sadly not, /n is a link and is annoying when accidentally clicked
3
u/Recyth Feb 23 '16
I don't see how the different non-anime spoiler tagging system is even necessary but ok.
3
u/brothertaddeus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/brothertaddeus Feb 23 '16
God, I hate those. Any are completely impossible to read on AlienBlue. Give me something in the brackets that I can click on, please!
3
u/SturgeonExplainer Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 24 '16
This adds nothing. You could always indicate which material your spoiler was coming from if you needed to.
"Moving forward we will be cracking down on spoilers without a title."
Don't be stupid. Most of the time titles are not necessary for the spoiler.
Also good lord is that garish.
4
u/Enigmaboob :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KURISUTINAA Feb 23 '16
Now this is a cool update. Definitely going to improve discussion.
1
u/Stacia_Asuna Feb 23 '16
What is considered a non anime spoiler?
1:
A: Something from manga
B: Something from manga
2:
A: Something from Light Novel
B: Something from Light Novel
3:
A: Something from a fan-made anime adaptation of above
B: Something from fan anime from manga/LN
4:
Something new in anime, old in LN/manga
New in anime, old in manga
1
u/alranican Feb 24 '16 edited Feb 28 '16
Spoiler test, and then another one
1
u/dralcax :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Dralcax Feb 24 '16
1
u/scorcher117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/scorcher117 Feb 24 '16
I'm glad spoilers will have to say what they are for as people like to use them for jokes so I'll sometimes see a black bar with not text before and check it assuming it's some joke and possibly get spoiled.
Example of joke: Why I hate my favourite anime
1
u/porpoiseoflife https://myanimelist.net/profile/OffColfax Feb 24 '16
Request for clarification from the mod staff: As it is impossible to add spoiler tags for the titles of posts, is there an accepted format for proper notification of spoilers within? For example, there is this one that got removed due to improperly tagged spoilers, yet I can't see what is wrong with the actual title of the post. It includes the [Spoilers] notification as well as the full name of the anime within the title itself.
1
u/montas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/montas Feb 24 '16
So in episode discussion threads, only red spoilers should be used right? Since we don't have to mark spoilers up to aired episode and everything else that might be spoiler, will be from source so it will be red.
1
u/awerture :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/awerture Feb 24 '16
I need a clarification
Are these comments ok according to you?
1
u/polaris6933 :K:https://kitsu.io/users/polaris Feb 24 '16
So what would happen if I forget about this while it's still a new thing (there is stuff in this thread that makes me think I wont, but still) and spoiler tag the old fashioned way (for example visual novel. Would it be a major issue?
1
u/coffeeblossom Feb 25 '16
Non-Anime Spoiler
1
u/vaelroth Feb 25 '16
So does that mean no more invisible spoilers? 'Cause if so, that would be great.
1
u/Pykra Feb 25 '16
what if an anime is airing and i want to spoiler tag a spoiler. Do i have to use it or not?
1
u/Atario myanimelist.net/profile/TheGreatAtario Feb 26 '16
This rule requiring titles seems to force some things to become exposed spoilers. Example:
Dude just spoiled Wibble, and the rules forced him to.
1
u/DangerElk Feb 29 '16 edited Feb 29 '16
I think it's a pretty big problem that the new tag doesn't work properly on Alien Blue. I don't personally use it, but it is one of the bigger ones and I've already seen multiple disappointed comments from users getting spoiled.
It specifically work with
and
From what I remember from similar discussions about other subs in the past the dev does not seem to be that interested in implementing any other subreddit specific tags.
0
u/Slifer13xx https://myanimelist.net/profile/SliferXIII Feb 23 '16 edited Feb 23 '16
Jesus christ, I clearly said that it was a big spoiler and now people are crying because they got spoiled.
1
u/Flyin-Brian Feb 24 '16 edited Feb 24 '16
Will the mods provide someone to hold our hands while we check the subreddit now, to save everyone from all the scary spoilers out there?
1
u/Rinarin Feb 23 '16
Test,test,test.
About the title part, I do omit titles occasionally but that's when I'm not hiding spoilers to anything, so I can't add a title (just hiding a part of the sentence from view while discussing things...kinda like making it tiny). Do I need to tag those as "not actually a spoiler to anything" for example, too? Just curious.
-1
u/Battlepidia https://myanimelist.net/profile/LazierLily Feb 23 '16
Just to clarify is this intended only to be for works that are anime related (often as source material) like LNs, VNs, and manga or is it also for other western books, movies, games, and TV shows?
For example if I were to say that Fate/zero reminded me of Fate/stay night VN Heaven's Feel and Harry Potter, would I need to spoiler tag that Harry Potter spoiler?