Moon prison. Trippy as fuck. This show is so similar to The Leftovers in that disoriented post-cataclysmic sense it makes me think the premise was shown to producers as "It's like The Leftovers, but with aliens!"
I don't recall if they ever specified where the Factory was, but I always assumed wherever it is it's off-world, so that's gotta be it. Calling it the "Factory" makes perfect sense when you consider all the stuff you mentioned. Now I can't really see the Factory being anything else but that moon base.
The episode had potential, but I really hate the fact that even though Will knows Katie's secret and Katie rightly thinks Will suspects her, they're just pretending everything's normal. The only reason for this is so the show can bring it up again in the season finale or something.
The revelation that the Factory is a moonbase was pretty cool. Hopefully we'll see more of it again soon.
The secrets between Will and Katie have bugged me from about episode 2. I don't think it's sustainable as a plot device. Watching a married couple freeze each other out over the breakfast table isn't very compelling, and realistically, Katie would have told Will what she was doing ages ago. There was no good reason, originally, to keep it from him. Their ultimate objective is the same. It would be smarter just to sit down at the breakfast table, talk it over, and work out a strategy.
Exactly. That's what I've wished they did since the start. Especially given that Will has been honest with her up until the moment he (correctly) suspected her of working for the Resistance. It just sets her up as the "bad guy" in the conflict.
That's how I see her, really. As the "bad guy" in this situation. And I don't think I'm supposed to see her that way, I think she's meant to be a heroine of the resistance. But she does behave deceptively, she's cold and aloof, and she's taking part in activities that regularly result in the deaths of innocent people. She's distressed by it, but she never really questions it. Will, despite being a virtual collaborator, has more of a moral center.
Maybe. But you're supposed to like interesting villains. Like Benjamin Linus in LOST. He was unquestionably a bad egg, but he was a joy to watch. He was complex. Katie, on the other hand, just seems a little blank; one-dimensional.
I think he knows deep down his current boss will never manage to bring back his son anyway.
Yeah, that's the worst part of it: Every time they bring up his son I get that same feeling like no matter what they say it's always a lie to further their own ends. He's just playing whatever shitty hand he's given trying to make something out of it any way he can.
Yeah, I'm actually really interested in the B plotline this episode. I love the idea of the Moon being a forward base in sci-fi, so it being a prison for the occupying force is just great for me.
Oh yeah, it seems like every episode they throw out some new rank and you just wonder how far up it's supposed to go. I'm pretty sure they're doing that on purpose.
That shaved head Occupation officer/soldier bears watching. That street head shot was sure expedient -- if denying the possibility of interrogation was your goal.
Yeah, I was going to make a whole thread about Lagarza's actions here. He allowed Broussard to escape. In this screenshot, Broussard is not far from Lagarza (back by the fence, with the baseball cap). Lagarza had one job: protect the perimeter! He should have turned the other way upon exiting and prevented the escape of the three people behind him, including Broussard. Then he could have moved the perimeter inwards.
Instead, Lagarza charged in and gunned down Rachel. The only description he received over the radio was "white female, short brown hair, blue shirt", and he gunned her down, hitting a couple of others accidentally, and then moved in for a head kill shot on her only, apparently. The Transitional Authority presumably would have preferred to interrogate her. So, it seems like Lagarza is not truly on the side of the local government. He's either resistance or some third party, like CIA or a higher or rival government.
They show Broussard in the market running, running through the entrance and turning towards where Lagarza will appear, running along the street, Lagarza comes out, and then there's the screenshot I showed. Absence of a tricky cut and a doppelganger, that's him.
Mr. Carson, the teacher, has been on my shitlist. Let's examine what he is up to this week...
Mr. Carson pulls the tarp off the telescope. It just happens to be aligned perfectly. He tells Bram that he's seeing "the Sea of Smyth", a.k.a. Mare Smythii, which is located at the equatorial edge of the Moon, marked in pink here. Viewed from Earth, the craters there would be edge on, not an overhead view as he sees.
Bram asks, "Why is it so blurry? Did I get the wrong lens?" With the Moon engulfed in clouds, Mr. Carson replies, "No, your lens is decent. It just wasn't ground for the specific optics of this telescope." If there was a lens aberration, the edges of the image would be blurry and smooth, but here the edges are sharp and jagged.
There are three types of optical telescopes: refractors, reflectors, and catadioptrics. A refractor uses a lens, a reflector uses mirrors, and a catadioptric uses both. Mr. Carson's telescope has the form of a reflector, because the eyepiece is near the opening. This type of telescope needs no lens (except the eyepiece). A curved mirror is at the base, and a small flat mirror is used to redirect the image to the eyepiece. However, some catadioptric telescopes also have the eyepiece near the opening. I almost nailed Mr. Carson as a liar about the lens, but catadioptric telescopes save him. Still, I doubt he chose this complex design for his do-it-yourself telescope.
To review, it's suspicious that the telescope was properly aligned, Mr. Carson lied about the Sea of Smyth, he didn't mention clouds as part of the reason for blurriness, and the edges of the image were not blurry but they would be if Mr. Carson was correct about the lens being a bit off. The eyepiece position plus lens of Mr. Carson's telescope would only make sense it if were catadioptric.
Like most telescopes, Mr. Carson's telescope has a finderscope on its side. Unlike other telescopes, Mr. Carson's finderscope is on the underside of the telescope, where you wouldn't be able to use it due to the large support stand of the telescope.
I'm a relative n00b, but I think it's Reddit tradition to reply at the end of the thread. Another absurdity is that the telescope view had no quivering from the atmosphere and no movement from the Moon, (e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4aqh1WTVV4). About this episode, Adam Busch, who plays Mr. Carson, commented said, "I don't trust anyone that [sic] uses wooden nickles."
but I think it's Reddit tradition to reply at the end of the thread
Not really. It makes more sense to reply to the person to whom your comment is actually responding. That's the entire purpose of the comment structure being the way it is, rather than like a typical forum where there's no structure to the comments (and it's all just in a row).
It's like sci-fi CSI! I still like this show, though. There are some things about it I love: the fact it's mostly normal people going about their lives after some crazy global catastrophe of which we only see the aftermath, the mysterious hosts always lurking in the background (for those two reasons I'm constantly reminded of The Leftovers), and now the moon prison scene just hooked me for good. I still can't say I love it yet, though, but it's growing on me.
Realistically, it comes down to the fact that the people who wrote the script for the character dialog, and the people build the telescope prop, and the people that made the moon graphic aren't communicating properly.
"we need a DIY looking telescope for these scenes" vs. "we need a DIY looking telescope for which one character is going to ask for a lens, and then comment that it doesn't look right, because the lens they get isn't the same specific kind."
"we need a kind of blurry graphic of the moon through a telescope with a factory on it." vs. "when we look at the graphic, one character will mention the visibility of Mare Smythii, and that it is blurry because of a lens aberration."
IT's also possible, that the writers don't know about the various types of telescopes, and pulled Mare Smythii out of a hat.
The point of the fuzziness was to set up the plot goal of leaving the colony to get to Mt Wilson to use the better telescope, and it just so happens the kid know how to get out. Also his dad is thinking of getting out. I think at least one character, is going to spend some time outside the wall in S2
The image itself was totally unimpressive to me. I guess the rectangular area is what Mr. Carson is claiming is a base on the Moon. You can find more impressive rectangular areas. They can arise when a meteor impacts an area with fault lines.
I was bothered by Bram suggesting an expedition to Mount Wilson Observatory; immediately after that scene they show Griffith Observatory, which is within the Walls. However, they showed telescopes sitting on top of shelves in the Red Hat headquarters, which suggests Griffith Observatory would be disabled.
Bram asks, "Why is it so blurry? Did I get the wrong lens?" With the Moon engulfed in clouds, Mr. Carson replies, "No, your lens is decent. It just wasn't ground for the specific optics of this telescope." If there was a lens aberration, the edges of the image would be blurry and smooth, but here the edges are sharp and jagged.
Oh, wow, I noticed that, too, and I'm a total layman! Even I thought that was a weird answer, like a "I'll create a GUI in Visual Basic, see if I can track an IP address" answer. Fucking TV writers, dude...
The Earthrise Carlos sees out his big ass window is literally the famous Earthrise photo taken by Apollo 8 from lunar orbit. Note the mountain at left and the light patches on either side of it. Even the storms on Earth match. The conclusion is inescapable: they have been transported into lunar orbit and back in time to December 24, 1968. Actually, there is another far more likely possibility, which is that they're still on Earth, maybe even still in L.A. And dumbass Carlos doesn't notice that Earth never changes: its clouds stay the same, maybe even its phase.
There is one difference between what Carlos sees and what the Apollo 8 crew saw: Carlos sees stars. Recall how hard it is to see stars near the Moon at night, and then think of it being 8 times as big and twice as reflective (as would be the Earth.) Again, it suggests the image is bogus.
There's also the issue of gravity, but the show addresses that with a sign that reads "Gravity: normalized".
About the blood-coughing guy who was dragged away, the "Raps" probably want them to think it's from radiation. The Apollo crews didn't fry, basically because their trips were short. If the Factory were on the Moon or in lunar orbit and not shielded, then people might start getting radiation sickness. But I think the the Factory is on Earth. So, the "Raps" might give drugs (e.g., blood thinners) to a worker who is ready for retirement. Then nobody is going to come to his rescue as the blood-vomiting worker is dragged away. Alternatively, it could also be contamination from whatever they're working with. It could be biological, like a hemorrhagic fever virus.
The Earthrise Carlos sees out his big ass window is literally the famous Earthrise photo taken by Apollo 8 from lunar orbit. Note the mountain at left and the light patches on either side of it. Even the storms on Earth match. The conclusion is inescapable: they have been transported into lunar orbit and back in time to December 24, 1968. Actually, there is another far more likely possibility, which is that they're still on Earth, maybe even still in L.A. And dumbass Carlos doesn't notice that Earth never changes: its clouds stay the same, maybe even its phase.
I'm pretty sure the most likely explanation is that the showrunners thought they could use a classic image of the Earth from the Moon without anyone noticing.
Do you think that's actually something they intended for the viewer to notice? Do you think they'd intentionally reference a real, currently-existing company?
It seems much more likely that that is the company that actually made the elevator where they filmed the scene, and they didn't blur it out or whatever because they didn't think anyone would notice or care. Occam's razor.
Why go to all that trouble to con factory workers into thinking they're on the moon? Nobody on earth thinks the factory is on the moon, and the captives obviously don't. It's a lot of trouble to go to just for a bunch if prisoners who are not there by choice anyway.
True, but there are simpler ways to scare prisoners out of tunnelling under a wall, especially if they already believe the world has been taken over by aliens. I mean, if fooling people into thinking they were on another planet was a viable way to control a prison population, the US would already be doing it.
This is some heavy Game of Thrones/Walking Dead kind of show! Anyone can die! And it comes complete with one annoying teenager that I very much dislike.
The whole episode I wanted to go back to the Moon prison. What a tease. I was thinking they were just on Earth until I noticed the window didn't really look like a normal prison window, plus it was waaay darker than it should be, then the camera moves out the window and hey, it's Earth.
Haha. That would be one hell of a twist, like the writers just up and decided to give everyone the finger. Honestly, I'd still watch after that just to see it play out. With all the other secretive shit the Hosts do that wouldn't surprise me.
Edit: One thing I still don't get is their black-market economy. It seems like they have to pull a lot of strings just to get little shit we take for granted. I'm pretty sure the telescope parts were included in that. I just wonder how the hell the Hosts regulate all those items and which items they've outlawed.
There's been talk that the aliens beam stuff up. I imagine that and all the colonies. The red glowing lines that follow the top rims of the wall just screams power to me.
Man, we need more East Coast live redditors. I'll bite the bullet and just force conversation from now on just in hopes we get some more people involved
What do the factory vats hold? The capacity (screenshot) is labeled in terms of "BBLS", which is oil barrels. When I had only seen the preview, which didn't show that label, I said they might be fat-rendering vats, with the output possibly being bio-diesel. For an ironic example, in an episode of a post-apocalyptic reality show called The Colony (emphasis on "The"), the participants turned pig fat into fuel. If you think about it, the Transitional Authority's huge armored vehicles get about 3-9 miles per gallon, and it's doubtful that oil is still being imported from Saudi Arabia or Alaska. Plus, today L.A. gets most of its electricity from oil, and they still use plenty of electricity in Colony.
Oh I just realised you're the same guy who doesn't think the factory is actually on the moon. So I guess that would be plausible, if they're on the earth and using the humans they've killed for oil (although it's a pretty inefficient way to get it).
I'm still not convinced they're just conning the prisoners into thinking they're on the moon. It would be a ludicrous ruse. And you're basing this theory on the fact that the producers used a photo taken by the Apollo 8 crew.
I have to agree with /u/V2Blast. Occam's razor and all that.
How many dead Americans would be required to fill all these vats with bio-diesel?
The capacity of one vat is 4660 oil barrels. There are 42 gallons per oil barrel, so 195,720 gallons. There are at least 32 vats, so the capacity is at least 6,263,040 gallons of oil. A German scientist turned cats into bio-diesel at the rate of 2.5 liters (0.66) gallons per cat. Average weight of a feral cat is ~6 pounds, but I'm going to use a neutered house cat's ~12 pounds. Average weight of an American is 179.7 pounds, so 15 times heavier and roughly same body fat percentage as your average old house cat. So, about 10 gallons of bio-diesel per American. So it would take roughly 620,000 Americans to fill the tanks with bio-diesel. That number will be higher if they are also used to make bacon, since some fat would go with the meat.
I'm sure there are at least millions of dead from the surrounding areas, given that downtown LA is uninhabited as are vast other areas.
How much electricity could be generated assuming the vats are full of bio-diesel?
You can convert one barrel of oil to about 1.6 megawatt hours (MWh) of electricity, so the vats would provide about 10 million MWh. For the year 2014, Los Angeles county used 70 million MWh, but that's no doubt a lot less in Colony.
Okay, you're right, but California gets 95% of its coal power from other states (not in the Pacific Coast Region), so I don't think the Colony can rely on coal. The El Segundo power plant is natural gas today, but I wasn't able to find that in my first search, so I fell back on (old) firsthand knowledge: the El Segundo power plant used fuel oil in the past. It appears El Segundo Power destroyed two of the oil plants in building the natural gas facilities, but two oil plants remain, mothballed. Today, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power produces just 5% of its power from green sources. So, I say, fire up the oil plants in El Segundo and make use of rendered dead bodies! It's green! Soylent Green.
Broussard gave the British guy's plan to Quayle. Later Quayle said he had reviewed it and gave it his thumbs up. But I suspect Quayle was working for Snyder all along, and anyway by that point Quayle had already met with Will on the bus, saying he wanted to sell out his cell. If Snyder didn't already know about the plan, he could have learned about it when he met with Quayle and Will, because Quayle said he wanted a "pass, and a full-stocked pick-up truck," and then handed Snyder a piece of paper, saying "to avoid confusion, here's a list." The paper was overkill for that, unless it had other information, like perhaps all the details about the resistance plan with respect to the visiting VIP.
Despite what Snyder said to Helena, I think Snyder would prefer to avoid a performance review from his boss' boss. Plus, Snyder probably would like to get a promotion, just like Will got a promotion.
Space radiation is high and unlike presumably aliens, we have little ability to withstand it for prolonged periods without serious protection, and a makeshift lunar base built in a year sounds like anything but.
But most likely its the nature of the work, whatever they are harvesting, that makes the Factory a death sentence.
As organized as the aliens are on Earth, I really don't see the lunar base being "makeshift". If anything I think the aliens know humans are expendable so they're just treating them like cattle.
True but it is interesting that even on the moon the need humans for manual labor and even for maintain order. This shows the Hosts have limits that they would expend resources to move humans to the moon to do whatever they are doing. It may also show a technology limit that they can't build robots to do the work
Oh, yeah, you're right. I didn't think about that side of it. If they were advanced enough they wouldn't need us at all. I sure don't recall seeing any humanoid robots, just the drones. Another thing to consider is if the aliens were powerful enough the humans would know they don't have a chance in hell and there wouldn't even be any Resistance. I see no way for that small group of freedom fighters to overcome an advanced alien race that's taken over the entire planet, so they must think they have a chance somehow. That's the thing about this show that gets me the most, and I'm really interested to see how it all plays out.
18
u/Who-the-fuck-is-that Mar 04 '16 edited Mar 04 '16
Moon prison. Trippy as fuck. This show is so similar to The Leftovers in that disoriented post-cataclysmic sense it makes me think the premise was shown to producers as "It's like The Leftovers, but with aliens!"
Edit: "I got her." "You don't got SHIT!" haha
10
u/V2Blast Geronimo Mar 04 '16
The episode had potential, but I really hate the fact that even though Will knows Katie's secret and Katie rightly thinks Will suspects her, they're just pretending everything's normal. The only reason for this is so the show can bring it up again in the season finale or something.
The revelation that the Factory is a moonbase was pretty cool. Hopefully we'll see more of it again soon.
8
u/jack9lemmon Resistor Mar 04 '16
WHOA. What!?
Edit: Yay, is this that start of Resistance Sawyer?
12
u/ramonf KATIE DIE PLS Mar 04 '16
weekly comment hoping for katie's death
6
u/jack9lemmon Resistor Mar 04 '16
I had a feeling Broussard wouldn't fall for it, but damn this shit blew up fast.
5
u/Artful_Bodger Collaborator Mar 06 '16
That shaved head Occupation officer/soldier bears watching. That street head shot was sure expedient -- if denying the possibility of interrogation was your goal.
8
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 04 '16
Mr. Carson, the teacher, has been on my shitlist. Let's examine what he is up to this week...
Mr. Carson pulls the tarp off the telescope. It just happens to be aligned perfectly. He tells Bram that he's seeing "the Sea of Smyth", a.k.a. Mare Smythii, which is located at the equatorial edge of the Moon, marked in pink here. Viewed from Earth, the craters there would be edge on, not an overhead view as he sees.
Bram asks, "Why is it so blurry? Did I get the wrong lens?" With the Moon engulfed in clouds, Mr. Carson replies, "No, your lens is decent. It just wasn't ground for the specific optics of this telescope." If there was a lens aberration, the edges of the image would be blurry and smooth, but here the edges are sharp and jagged.
There are three types of optical telescopes: refractors, reflectors, and catadioptrics. A refractor uses a lens, a reflector uses mirrors, and a catadioptric uses both. Mr. Carson's telescope has the form of a reflector, because the eyepiece is near the opening. This type of telescope needs no lens (except the eyepiece). A curved mirror is at the base, and a small flat mirror is used to redirect the image to the eyepiece. However, some catadioptric telescopes also have the eyepiece near the opening. I almost nailed Mr. Carson as a liar about the lens, but catadioptric telescopes save him. Still, I doubt he chose this complex design for his do-it-yourself telescope.
To review, it's suspicious that the telescope was properly aligned, Mr. Carson lied about the Sea of Smyth, he didn't mention clouds as part of the reason for blurriness, and the edges of the image were not blurry but they would be if Mr. Carson was correct about the lens being a bit off. The eyepiece position plus lens of Mr. Carson's telescope would only make sense it if were catadioptric.
3
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 04 '16
The Earthrise Carlos sees out his big ass window is literally the famous Earthrise photo taken by Apollo 8 from lunar orbit. Note the mountain at left and the light patches on either side of it. Even the storms on Earth match. The conclusion is inescapable: they have been transported into lunar orbit and back in time to December 24, 1968. Actually, there is another far more likely possibility, which is that they're still on Earth, maybe even still in L.A. And dumbass Carlos doesn't notice that Earth never changes: its clouds stay the same, maybe even its phase.
There is one difference between what Carlos sees and what the Apollo 8 crew saw: Carlos sees stars. Recall how hard it is to see stars near the Moon at night, and then think of it being 8 times as big and twice as reflective (as would be the Earth.) Again, it suggests the image is bogus.
There's also the issue of gravity, but the show addresses that with a sign that reads "Gravity: normalized".
About the blood-coughing guy who was dragged away, the "Raps" probably want them to think it's from radiation. The Apollo crews didn't fry, basically because their trips were short. If the Factory were on the Moon or in lunar orbit and not shielded, then people might start getting radiation sickness. But I think the the Factory is on Earth. So, the "Raps" might give drugs (e.g., blood thinners) to a worker who is ready for retirement. Then nobody is going to come to his rescue as the blood-vomiting worker is dragged away. Alternatively, it could also be contamination from whatever they're working with. It could be biological, like a hemorrhagic fever virus.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16
This is some heavy Game of Thrones/Walking Dead kind of show! Anyone can die! And it comes complete with one annoying teenager that I very much dislike.
6
u/miba54 Mar 04 '16
Other than the Moon revelation, I don't think this was a very good episode. It felt like everything was all over the place.
2
u/TheMightestTaco Mar 04 '16
Just my own little theory, I think the walls are giant power lines.
2
u/jack9lemmon Resistor Mar 04 '16
Man, we need more East Coast live redditors. I'll bite the bullet and just force conversation from now on just in hopes we get some more people involved
2
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 04 '16
What do the factory vats hold? The capacity (screenshot) is labeled in terms of "BBLS", which is oil barrels. When I had only seen the preview, which didn't show that label, I said they might be fat-rendering vats, with the output possibly being bio-diesel. For an ironic example, in an episode of a post-apocalyptic reality show called The Colony (emphasis on "The"), the participants turned pig fat into fuel. If you think about it, the Transitional Authority's huge armored vehicles get about 3-9 miles per gallon, and it's doubtful that oil is still being imported from Saudi Arabia or Alaska. Plus, today L.A. gets most of its electricity from oil, and they still use plenty of electricity in Colony.
1
u/argumentumadabsurd Mar 05 '16
TURN OFF THAT FUCKING SLEEP AS ANDROID ALARM!
Even the indoor scenes have bird noises? You are driving me insane!
1
u/Maiklas3000 Cleric Mar 08 '16
Broussard gave the British guy's plan to Quayle. Later Quayle said he had reviewed it and gave it his thumbs up. But I suspect Quayle was working for Snyder all along, and anyway by that point Quayle had already met with Will on the bus, saying he wanted to sell out his cell. If Snyder didn't already know about the plan, he could have learned about it when he met with Quayle and Will, because Quayle said he wanted a "pass, and a full-stocked pick-up truck," and then handed Snyder a piece of paper, saying "to avoid confusion, here's a list." The paper was overkill for that, unless it had other information, like perhaps all the details about the resistance plan with respect to the visiting VIP.
Despite what Snyder said to Helena, I think Snyder would prefer to avoid a performance review from his boss' boss. Plus, Snyder probably would like to get a promotion, just like Will got a promotion.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 04 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment