r/WritingPrompts • u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod • Apr 22 '16
Moderator Post [MODPOST] 3rd Annual Novelette Contest Finalists Voting
The final voting round is here! Sorry for the delay in posting this thread, if anyone wants to throw a work at home job my way so I can make posts like these faster, feel free. Those exist, right? Anyway, there were a lot of great entries for the contest. The first group had a four way tie! We've decided that all the ties for first place will move forward.
EVERYONE WHO ENTERED IN THE CONTEST CAN VOTE
That's right. If you entered a story (and didn't delete it before voting began) then you can read all the finalists stories and cast a vote. You will have two weeks to read the entries so it's best you get started now if you haven't already.
Finalist Novelettes
- Craters - /u/FormerFutureAuthor - 7777
- Beautiful Exit - /u/travsmavs - 8536
- One or Ten - /u/Schneid13 - 17392
- Villainous - /u/FireWitch95 - 7634
- The 9th - /u/AllHackNoChops - 9725
- Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus - /u/Weerdo5255 - 12700
- Blessed are the Bound - /u/JeniusGuy - 8618
- The Importance of Books - /u/sleepyhollow_101 - 10580
- Box - /u/Jayefishy - 14040
- To Knot Or Not - /u/the_src - 8800
- Holly Went for a Walk - /u/page0rz - 8300
- Burning Beethoven - /u/MachinaEm - 7613
Voting rules:
- Only those that entered the contest can vote.
- You have until May 7th at 11:59PM CST to read and vote.
- You can't vote for yourself.
- Vote by replying to this post saying "My vote is for /u/username for "Story Title"." After that you can add any additional comments you want.
- If you do not vote, you will not have a chance to win.
- Voters who entered the contest but didn't make it to the finals will have a chance at gold just for voting.
- If there is a tie it will be up to myself and /u/SurvivorType to cast a tie breaking vote.
I think that's it. That's all the info you need, right? Just making sure. Have fun and happy reading!
•
u/avukamu /r/avukamu Apr 24 '16
My vote has been, and still is for /u/page0rz despite reading the stories for a second round for "Holly Went for a Walk".
•
u/jhdierking May 08 '16
My vote is for /u/page0rz for "Holly Went for a Walk."
Honorable mentions (in no particular order) for "Blessed are the Bound," "The Importance of Books," "Box," and "The 9th."
I enjoyed the finalist stories. Thank you to everyone for sharing them. I did not have time this round to give constructive criticism, but if any of the authors would like some feedback on their story, just let me know.
•
u/FireWitch95 May 02 '16
Voting for /u/page0rz for 'Holly Went for a Walk.'
•
u/resonatingfury /r/resonatingfury May 06 '16
The Importance of Books by /u/sleepyhollow_101
•
u/RyanKinder Founder / Co-Lead Mod Apr 22 '16
Any off topic comments that aren't a vote can be made in reply to this comment. If you'd like to see all the entries into the contest you may do that by clicking here.
•
u/ScarecrowSid Brainless Moderator | /r/ScarecrowSid May 07 '16
My vote is for /u/sleepyhollow_101 for "The Importance of Books"
•
u/fauxkit /r/MyFinEnglish May 08 '16
All of these are really great, but I still have to lean towards The Importance of Books by /u/sleepyhollow_101 .
•
u/Weerdo5255 /r/CGWilliam May 08 '16
I'm voting for /u/Schneid13 for One or Ten.
It was a rather on the nose execution of the prompt, but it was done so well that I can't not vote for it!
•
u/Jayefishy May 08 '16
/u/FormerFutureAuthor for Craters!!
•
u/AJ_Sully Apr 30 '16
my vote is for /u/machinaem for Burning Beethoven. Great job everyone! Crafting a story as good as these and getting readers to see that is not an easy feat.
•
u/apzimmerman May 02 '16
/u/MachinaEm for "Burning Beethoven".
•
u/MajorParadox Mod | DC Fan Universe (r/DCFU) May 08 '16
My vote is for /u/travsmavs for "Beautiful Exit"
•
u/bigrickcook May 03 '16
My vote is for /u/Weerdo5255 for "Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus".
Some really good ones, and I had a hard time deciding between this one and Burning Beethoven. Good job, everyone! Great contest.
•
u/page0rz /r/page0rz May 04 '16
I'm riding /u/MachinaEm's "Burning Beethhoven" all the way to the finish line. That's my vote.
•
u/KCcracker /r/KCcracker May 07 '16
My vote is for /u/MachinaEm for 'Burning Beethoven'.
•
u/Just-a-Poe-boy May 01 '16
*/u/FutureFormerAuthor for Craters
•
u/sleepyhollow_101 May 07 '16
My vote is for /u/MachinaEm for "Burning Beethoven."
•
u/LovableCoward /r/LovableCoward May 07 '16
My vote is for /u/JeniusGuy for Blessed are the Bound.
•
u/Illseraec May 01 '16
I vote for /u/page0rz for "Holly Went for a Walk".
I love stories that have dialogue and exposition, and the way the story was told over the course of the novelette was great. Wonderful pacing and a satisfying tale of coming-of-age and the realization that the grass is only as green as you make it. Good work.
•
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '16 edited Apr 24 '16
Being in the last round means I'm allowed to vote. ;D
I vote for One or Ten by /u/Schneid13 I was guessing the entire time and the ending gave me feels. It almost made my eyes water. No other entry did that, so THANK YOU FOR THE GOOD READ AND GOOD LUCK!
If there was a 2nd place, it would be Blessed are the Bound. Creepy yet I couldn't let it go after the first event, hehehe.
And lastly, a shout out to The 9th for capturing the setting so well that I could actually see myself living it.
Again, good luck to all of you! :DDD
•
u/[deleted] May 03 '16
My vote is for/u/pageOrz for "Holly Went for a Walk"
•
u/chondroitin May 04 '16
My vote is for /u/page0rz for "Holly Went for a Walk." The somewhat generic title severely undersold the story. I was most impressed by how it was aesthetically structured - it was very easy on the eyes and the mind with its variable paragraph lengths and well-interspersed dialogue. That made it stand out over the many great stories, all with wonderful plots, settings, and characters.
•
u/Schneid13 /r/ScribeSchneid May 07 '16
My vote is for /u/Weerdo5255 for Adam, Artemis, Atlas, & Icarus.
This story just really stuck with me even in the final round. Good luck!
•
u/[deleted] Apr 30 '16
[removed] — view removed comment
•
u/the_src May 06 '16
/u/MachinaEm for "Burning Beethoven"
Excellent story
•
u/Bilgebum May 06 '16
"Holly Went for a Walk" by /u/page0rz! Enjoyed this story immensely, it hit all the right notes.
•
u/V_the_Victim May 01 '16
/u/sleepyhollow_101 for "The Importance of Books."
There was not a single story that I disliked, which made voting difficult. In the end, I decided to stick with my first round vote because it contained my favorite utilization of the original prompt. The puppetmaster vibe and the different characters' choices flowed so well with the setting, and I loved the mystery that followed. Wonderful stuff, /u/sleepyhollow_101.
Thank you to everyone else for the excellent reads, too, and good luck!
•
u/AllHackNoChops May 06 '16
/u/Schneid13 for "One or Ten."
•
u/FormerFutureAuthor /r/FormerFutureAuthor May 06 '16
/u/Jayefishy for "Box"!
•
u/IAmTheRedWizards May 07 '16
My vote is for /u/page0rz and "Holly Went For A Walk"
•
u/quantumfirefly Apr 26 '16
I vote for /u/page0rz for "Holly Went For a Walk".
•
u/Tom_Teller_Writes Apr 28 '16
/u/page0rz for Holly Went for a Walk. Great job! Powerful pathos
•
u/JustLexx Moderator | r/Lexwriteswords May 07 '16
My vote goes to /u/sleepyhollow_101 for "The Importance of Books."
•
u/JeniusGuy /r/JeniusGuy May 01 '16
My vote is for /u/sleepyhollow_101 for "The Importance of Books".
Man, I feel like the hardest choice was only picking one story to vote for. They were all so good, but ultimately I had to go for the same story as the first round. "The Importance of Books" just really captured the theme of the prompt, and created something really special.
Also, a shout out to /u/Schneid13's amazing "One or Ten" coming in as a close second in my book. In a perfect world, it would have also gotten my vote (along with several other stories).
Once again, great job /u/sleepyhollow_101 and best of luck to everyone else!