r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Apr 27 '16
Map Thread #63 Results
Additions
Removals
Updates
Starting with this thread, we will be adding comments about each addition/removal where MTC members may or may not give their personal opinions/feedback.
Congratulations to all the mapmakers who have influenced the rotation! Keep mapmaking!
19
Upvotes
4
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 27 '16 edited Apr 27 '16
Please discuss the update of Mapache Chief by Beast Mode. The version originally added to rotation looks like this.
4
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 27 '16
Please discuss the addition of Lights by Snowball here.
3
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 27 '16
Please discuss the addition of Hotspot by Loaha here.
3
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 27 '16
Give your farewells to Del by FLYMOLO here. RIP.
29
u/radianthero156 brazilian trash Apr 27 '16 edited Apr 27 '16
Sorry if I sound salty, but I predict this will go on to be yet another disappointing thread. What does it even accomplish? How does it solve the problems of the current rotation? If either of the 2 maps get 0.30+ rating, I'll be surprised.
First off, most people were asking for 30+ maps, and now we just went from 19 to 20. Also, I thought everyone agreed there is no diversity in the rotation? How are these maps diverse at all?
Hotspot was IMO the worst map in top maps 63. Not only its shape is really boring, defending on this map sounds like hell. It's easy to grab and mildly chasey with constant regrab trains. The defensive team boosts are one dimensional and easily avoidable by any competent FC. This looks like a worse Del... a map that just got removed. No offense, Loaha, but you can make much better maps. In fact, why did you give up on K1?
Lights is decent I guess, although the boosts seem kinda clunky/one-dimensional, seeing as they're close to walls. It has some neat routes for skilled players though. But tbh, if you're going to add this map, why not add ALPHA, Prime, Ratatat and Taxi as well?
Why not give Market a chance? It's completely innovative and unique, and has a crapload of support from a lot of people. I don't recall seeing a map hyped this much. It has been extensively played competetively, with nothing but positive feedback. Are pub players going to like it? Impossible to answer. But then again, what makes you think they're going to like Hotspot or Lights?
Lastly, can maps like Volt, Bulldog and even Shine make a return? Hell, I'd even take Kite and Rocketballs. I currently hate the NF rotation, and it has been exactly the same way for like 2 months already.
tl;dr MTC pls
10
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '16
I am curious on what happened to both NF maps? I though both were super good. Even with the lack on symmetry on one, I though it was a neat thing to try out.
7
u/TheEpicGhost Ex - Tagpro Apr 27 '16
I'm just gonna plonk my initial testing votes here, all maps have comments, take a look at your feedback! click on the red square where the comment is to see if i voted yes, no or maybe.
Keep in mind this is my views and my views only, in no way does it represent the views of the mtc as a whole
Also keep in mind these comments are more for my personal reference rather than feedback to you guys. Sorry if I wrote something shitty or unhelpful, These things take 10+ hours to do. If you'd like more elaborate feedback, drop a comment or send me a PM.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1JgHkXtQ9pRu3W1NixBdfe2CRMm17LTPjfu-hjXkY2L8/edit#gid=0
10
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '16
Glad you updated Mapache instead of taking out.
Also what is the MTC's stance on throwbacks? Quite a few maps should be looked at - Bulldog, Rush, Emerald, Renegade, Volt, Shine, Draft to name a few.
Some of the newer maps are growing on me - I really like Blooper
4
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '16
What about the changes to Micro?
6
u/Crisis_Averted Nice Apr 27 '16
Please discuss the update of the MTC's approach to Map Threads here.
3
u/Snowball_TagPro ❄️ Apr 27 '16
Woo! This one goes out to Bulldog.
3
u/KewlestCat NIGEL Apr 27 '16
Back to the drawing board. :c
4
u/mjmain damn, son! Apr 27 '16
WHEWRE BULL DOG
2
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '16
When do these go into effect?
2
u/Blazeth Dianna Agron Apr 28 '16
4v4 Maptest this Saturday! https://www.reddit.com/r/TagProTesting/comments/4grxqf/4v4_maptest_this_saturday_430_at_11_pm_est/
2
u/NadieTP Nadie - Origin Apr 28 '16
I don't understand any of the decisions in the past 3 map threads. I can sift through unfortunate-maps and find at least 10 maps that can be added to the rotation immediately, no further editing required. I can then go find at least 5 throwback maps that should have already made their way back into rotation.
I've almost completely stopped playing pubs over the course of the last 3 map threads because of the repetitiveness of the rotation. I turned stats off a few weeks ago and haven't turned them back on yet because I am constantly finding myself quitting out of games because I'm so sick of the same maps over and over.
What is the downside to implementing say.. 5 new maps every map thread?
1
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Apr 27 '16
Thoughts on alpha?
1
u/oorr23 ThePlaymaker // Tehuitzingo & Combine Apr 28 '16
Let me ask one thing...
Why is Mapache Chief still in rotation?
Doesn't the majority dislike this map?
1
u/girmluhk Gramps Apr 28 '16
Market or bust!
1
u/catalyst518 Catalyst - TPFG Dev Apr 27 '16
I only got to play Del a few times, but it seemed average to me, not as bad as the map stats page indicates. Why did it have such a low rating and/or why else did the MTC believe it should be removed?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '16
Yiss Snowball maps are best maps
0
u/[deleted] Apr 27 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment