r/colony • • Feb 03 '17
Discussion [Spoilers] Colony S02E04 "Panopticon" - Episode Discussion Spoiler
Original Air Date: February 2nd 2017
Episode Synopsis: Spoilers
Trailer: https://youtu.be/6_MHGZK0luQ
24
Upvotes
36
u/CoffeeAttack Feb 03 '17
I'm way more interested in the whole structure of the show rather than the actual human drama, so seeing the central HQ for the human administration was very interesting.
35
u/sum1rand0m Feb 03 '17
I'm so glad Charlie doesn't buy into The Greatest Day bullshit.
30
u/carpy22 Feb 03 '17
Global geopolitical intrigue yes!
20
u/OttawaMan35 Feb 03 '17
Panopticon: "a type of institutional building designed by the English philosopher and social theorist Jeremy Bentham in the late 18th century. The concept of the design is to allow all (pan-) inmates of an institution to be observed (-opticon) by a single watchman without the inmates being able to tell whether or not they are being watched. Although it is physically impossible for the single watchman to observe all cells at once, the fact that the inmates cannot know when they are being watched means that all inmates must act as though they are watched at all times, effectively controlling their own behaviour constantly. The name is also a reference to Panoptes from Greek mythology; he was a giant with a hundred eyes and thus was known to be a very effective watchman." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panopticon
19
u/Meeha Feb 03 '17
That was a really chilling episode.
I loved the inception views of the Bowman household.
16
u/Lokarian Feb 03 '17
Did anyone notice that they said they need to recover "Host's vehicle" instead of "artifact" at one point ? Would support the theory that aliens are alien AI, or upload mind copies of Aliens.
13
u/mineralwatersoda Feb 03 '17
Can someone explain the pins in the first scene? What was the 2nd pin? Why change?
25
u/grumplefish Resistor Feb 03 '17 edited Feb 03 '17
Really liked seeing the council!! It does seem weird that the humans get to vote on total rendition. It seems to me they'd vote 'no' every time, unless there's some kind of very explicit alien standards and monitoring, which I suppose we can assume. I want more info about this.
I am glad Katie apologized to Will about lying. I see a lot of Katie hate on here, but no one blaming Will for his mistakes. Will also created this whole situation by lying about going to Santa Monica for NO REASON. After he learned how Bram got arrested (by the redhats he personally sent into the tunnel), he didn't admit that to Katie or seem to take any blame for it. In general, people don't blame law enforcement for the unintended consequences of their actions, even when those actions are in service of enforcing a law that is morally wrong and oppressive. They were just trying to move freely in their own world and build a telescope to learn about their new overlords, and now Bram is in a labor camp. Will messed up by putting himself in this position and now he's gotten his son sent to a labor camp and one wrong move away from the Factory. Worst of all, he continued to blame Katie for setting a bad example even after learning that it was the redhats he personally sent. Both Will and Katie messed up by lying to each other for no reason from the start of the show --and they jointly can be blamed for a lot of things.
I was annoyed they didn't have Katie explain more about why she doesn't dismiss the tutor. Also, go Charlie burning that book. Still, overall and perhaps I am callous, kinda super bored by Charlie's recovering-from-trauma plot. I like the conflict between him and the tutor though. I just want more political drama!!! I want to see the council and the higher ups.
It makes no sense to me that the blonde lady is going to commit suicide over being fired. I mean come on she can have any life she wants now, given alien occupation! Like I get she was a true believer who cares about her job, but this reaction strains believability for me. Maybe it was because of her guilt?? That make sense I guess.
Excited to see more about these watchers at the end. But, are they watching everyone?? If so, they should have caught Katie by now. Are they just watching the govt employees? If so, they should have caught Katie by now.
10
u/mellena I do it for the rations Feb 03 '17
Im coming around on Katie. Charlie is a bad ass. Gracie is wonderful and I Lyndsey is the WORST.
10
u/blacksalami_8000 Resistor Feb 03 '17 edited Feb 03 '17
This was a good ep. Liked how Helena was portrayed as being genuinely scared and stressed and I really liked the world building in the beginning. The bowman drama was allright too. I think it sets things up nicely for Will and/or Katie to become involved with the resistance again. Curious to see where we go from here.
The surveillance has a bit of a plot hole though, because surely Burke would have checked the bowmans out too when he noticed that Jennifer was looking at them? I'm hoping this gets addressed later, because theres no way a guy with Burke's credentials didn't get a wiff of what was going on with Jennifer watching the whole thing
9
u/antigravitytapes Feb 03 '17
Great episode for the international court, bad for still not having Broussard.
Kate is getting better, but she's still off the mark blaming Will for trying to find Charlie in the beginning. IIRC, she was involved with Broussard right since the get-go (correct me if I'm wrong). Also, It was AWESOME to have Charlie plainly say "Why not just get rid of her?", but then of course he took it too far. Just fire the lady instead of firing the lady.
Did that court debate wiping Los Angeles off the map? That's pretty brutal, and only cements the futility of the Resistance. The lack of Broussard makes these Resistance cells seem so weak and fragile: their leader tried to cut a deal and apparently a highschool kid and his astronomy enthusiast teacher are an entire "cell", as Kate says. It'd be nice if the Red Hats actually had more of a challenge; there wasn't much of anything rebellious going on in this episode, but maybe the show is simply past that phase and is headed in an entirely different direction.
9
u/the_fast_reader Collaborator Feb 03 '17 edited Feb 03 '17
Really interesting episode. Charlie is a smart kid, that year in Santa Monica made him more mature than his age, that's for sure. He seems pretty traumatized and trying to not show it though. He's also having none of that creepy teacher's cult preaching, I'm curious to see what he will be up to, I don't think they spent a whole season and three episodes getting him back just to put him in the background.
9
u/david-saint-hubbins Feb 04 '17
More world building and action; less family melodrama. Please and thank you.
13
u/BShep_OLDBSN Feb 03 '17
Liked this episode.
Loved how Charlie burned that creepy woman-child book of alien bs.
Wonder if Jennifer will really kill herself.
6
u/tlht Feb 03 '17
Curious what the lives of all the desk jockey surveillance people are like. I guess they all live down there underground and are forced to work like in the labor camps?
6
u/Moara7 Feb 04 '17
well that was unsatisfying. We end the show just about where we started, plot-wise.
6
u/kccustom Feb 05 '17
Holy shit, I started out hating her but felt so bad about how alone she was at the end.
5
u/mineralwatersoda Feb 03 '17
What does total rendition mean?
4
u/azriel777 Feb 04 '17
Random thoughts
Not much to say about this episode, it was very boring. I don't give a shit about the drama, the world setting is actually pretty cool, but the writers are not doing anything with it.
6
u/baconandeggs666 Resistor Feb 03 '17
That summit meeting....reminds me of something.
6
u/V2Blast Geronimo Feb 04 '17 edited Feb 04 '17
For those who don't know what the title is a reference to, here's the Wikipedia page.
I think the season so far has been a definite improvement. We're getting more of a look behind the scenes of the Occupation, the Bowman family is mostly reunited and communicating honestly with one another, and we're getting a more nuanced look at the humans working with the Occupation.
I really felt for Jennifer this episode. She was definitely in a difficult position, and even after being deemed weak and untrustworthy by Will (to be fair, he's right that she doesn't really have the training for it), she chooses to protect the Bowmans and ends up seemingly committing suicide at the end - presumably because she knows she's going to get caught for deleting her surveillance logs of the Bowmans. I was quite sad about her apparent death :(
(Random observation: when she logs out of the computer, her username is visibly spelled as
MACMAHON_Jthough sources seem to indicate that her last name is McMahon.)I'm glad Will realized they were being watched, and it's nice to see that the Bowmans have committed to working together and communicating honestly to keep their family safe. Looking forward to the rest of the season.
EDIT: Forgot to mention the kids! Charlie seemed to react predictably to being home again at first, but it seems he's starting to get acclimated again - and he's also figured out a way to get rid of Lindsey for now without stabbing her. Meanwhile, Gracie sees that Charlie's having a little trouble getting used to things, and eventually just lies on the floor next to him to show him that she's there for him. It was a pretty sweet moment :)
Also, check out the AV Club review of this episode: http://www.avclub.com/tvclub/colony-watches-tragic-character-makes-meaningful-s-249628
2
u/[deleted] Feb 05 '17
Why do you guys think she dropped the pin and never picked it up at the meeting? And why do you think that lady almost seemed reluctant about the meeting or was that just me?
1
u/V2Blast Geronimo Feb 10 '17
You forgot to distinguish this post.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment