r/announcements • • Mar 21 '17

TL;DR: Today we're testing out a new feature that will allow users to post directly to their profile

Hi Reddit!

Reddit is the home to the most amazing content creators on the internet. Together, we create a place for artists, writers, scientists, gif-makers, and countless others to express themselves and to share their work and wisdom. They fill our days with beautiful photos, witty poems, thoughtful AMAs, shitty watercolours, and scary stories. Today, we make it easier for them to connect directly to you.

Reddit is testing a new profile experience that allows a handful of users, content creators, and brands to post directly to their profile, rather than to a community. You’ll be able to follow them and engage with them there. We’re excited because having this new ability will give our content contributors a home for their voice on Reddit. This feature will be available to everyone as soon as we iron out the kinks.

What does it look like?

What is it?

  • A new profile page experience that allows you to follow other redditors
  • Selected redditors will be able to post directly to their profile
  • We worked with some moderators to pick a handful of redditors to test this feature and will slowly roll this out to more users over the next few months

Who is this for?

  • We want to build this feature for all users but we’re starting with a small group of alpha testers.

How does it work?

  • You will start to see some user profile pages with new designs (e.g. u/Shitty_Watercolour, u/kn0thing, u/LeagueOfLegends).
  • If you like what they post, you can start to follow them, much as you subscribe to communities. This does not impact our “friends” feature.
  • You can comment on their profile posts
  • Once you follow a user, their profile posts will start to show up on your front-page. Posts they make in communities will only show up on your frontpage if you subscribe to that community.

What’s next?

  • We’re taking feedback on this experience on r/beta and will be paying close attention to the voices of community members. We want to understand what the impact of this change is to Reddit’s existing communities, which is why we’re partnering with only a handful of users as we slowly roll this out.
  • We’ll ramp up the number of testers to this program based on feedback from the community (see application sections below)

How do I participate?

  • If you want to participate as a beta user please fill out this survey.
  • If you want to nominate a fellow redditor, please use this survey.

TL;DR:

We’re testing a new profile page experience with a few Redditors (alpha testers). They’ll be able to post to their profile and you’ll be to follow them. Send us bugs or feedback specific to the feature on in r/beta!

u/hidehidehidden


Q&A:

Q: Why restrict this to just a few users?

A: This is an early release (“alpha”) product and we want to make sure everything is working optimally before rolling it out to more users. We picked most of our initial testers from the gaming space so we can work closely with a core group of mods that can provide direct feedback to us.


Q: Who are the initial testers and how were they selected?

A: We reached out to the moderators of a few communities and the testers were recommended to us based on the quality of their content and engagement. The testers include video makers, e-sports journalists, commentators, and a game developer.


Q: When will this roll out to everyone?

A: If all goes well, over the course of the next few months. We want to do this roll-out carefully to avoid any disruptions to existing communities. This is a major product launch for Reddit and we’re looking to the community to give us their input throughout this process.


Q: What about pseudo-anonymity?

A: Users can still be pseudonymous when posting to their profile. There’s no obligation for a user to reveal their identity. Some redditors choose not to be pseudonymous, in the case of some AMA participants, and that’s ok too.


Q: How will brands participate in this program?

A: During this alpha stage of the rollout, our testers are users, moderators, longtime redditors, and organizations that have a strong understanding of Reddit and a history of positive engagement. They are selected based on how well how they engage with redditors and there is no financial aspect to our initial partnerships. We are only working with companies that understand Reddit and want to engage our users authentic conversations and not use it as another promotional platform.

We’re specifically testing this with Riot Games because of how well they participate in r/LeagueOfLegends and demonstrated a deep understanding of how we expect companies to engage on Reddit. Their interactions in the past have been honest, thoughtful, and collaborative. We believe their direct participation will add more great discussions to Reddit and demonstrate a new better way for brands and companies to converse with their fans.


Q: What kinds of users will be allowed to create these kinds of profiles? Is this product limited to high-profile individuals and companies?

A: Our goal is to make this feature accessible to everyone in the Reddit community. The ability to post to profile and build a following is intended to enhance the experience of Reddit users everywhere — therefore, we want the community to provide feedback on how the launch is implemented. This product can’t succeed without being useful for redditors of every type. We will reach out to you for feedback in the r/beta community as we grow and test this new product.


Q: Will this change take away conversations and subscribers from existing communities?

A: We believe the value of the Reddit experience comes from two different but related places: engaging in communities and engaging with people. Providing a platform for content creators to more easily post and engage on Reddit should spur more interesting conversations everywhere, not just within their profile. We’re also testing a new feature called “Active in these Communities” on the tester’s profile page to encourage redditors to discover and engage with more communities.


Q: Are you worried about giving individual users too much power on Reddit?

A: This is one reason that we’re being so careful about how we’re testing this feature — we want to make sure no single user becomes so powerful that it overpowers the conversation on Reddit. We will specifically look to the community for feedback in r/beta as the product develops and we onboard more users.


Q: The new profile interface looks very similar to the communities interface, what’s the difference between the two?

A: Communities are the interest hubs of Reddit, where passionate redditors congregate around a subject area or hobby they share a particular interest in. Content posted to a profile page is the voice of a single user.


Q: What about the existing “friends” feature?

A: We’re not making any changes to the existing “friends” feature or r/friends.


Q: Will Reddit prevent users with a history of harassment from creating one of these profiles?

A: Content policy violations will likely impact a user's ability to create an updated profile page and use the feature. We don’t want this new platform to be used as a vehicle for harassment or hate.


Q: I’m really opposed to the idea and I think you should reconsider. What if you’re wrong?

A: We don’t have all of the answers right now and that’s why we’re testing this with a small group of alpha users. As with any test, we’re going to learn a lot along the way. We may find that our initial hypothesis is wrong or you may be pleasantly surprised. We won’t know until we try and put this front of our users. Either way, the alpha product you see today will evolve and change based on feedback.


Q: How do I participate in this beta?

A: We’ll be directly reaching out to redditors we think will be a great fit. We’re also taking direct applications via this survey or you can nominate a fellow redditor via this survey.

6.7k Upvotes

6.5k comments sorted by

7.7k

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I do have a few problems.

What if we dont want to be followed by people?

What if we dont want everyone to know we are active in certain subreddits especially NSFW ones?

I personally do not like the profile page as it feels weird. Like it is a forum or Facebook profile page. I am fine chatting with other strangers without knowing where they are active in other subreddits or the choice of following them. I dont like to keep it personal as I like reddit as a more of a community based site.

Also, even if we can make certain things private or make our profile private, there will be subreddits that will require you to have a public profile to participate in the sub.

1.5k

u/HideHideHidden Mar 21 '17

What if we dont want to be followed by people?

We'll allow you to opt-out

What if we dont want everyone to know we are active in certain subreddits especially NSFW ones?

We're not surfacing any browsing or voting behavior on these pages. If you post to NSFW communities today, that already surfaces on your existing profile page.

I personally do not like the profile page as it feels weird. Like it is a forum or Facebook profile page. I am fine chatting with other strangers without knowing where they are active in other subreddits or the choice of following them. I dont like to keep it personal as I like reddit as a more of a community based site.

This is why we're testing this with a small group of users. We have a of iterations ahead of us.

Also, even if we can make certain things private or make our profile private, there will be subreddits that will require you to have a public profile to participate in the sub.

Great suggestions, taking this into consideration.

6.6k

u/Facu474 Mar 21 '17

We'll allow you to opt-out

I think it would be better, for existing users at least, for it to be an opt-IN system.

1.3k

u/HideHideHidden Mar 21 '17

We just launched our alpha and we still have a beta process before we any wider release. Feedback like this will help us understand if we launch with an opt-in vs opt-out. Thank you!

→ More replies (478)
→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (198)
→ More replies (123)

1.1k

u/Luna_LoveWell Mar 21 '17

I notice that the comments of the users in the beta are not visible, only the posts. That is really not helpful for those of us that create original content in comments and not with posts.

318

u/HideHideHidden Mar 21 '17

We're not intentionally trying to hide it. We're adding that in soon.

→ More replies (115)
→ More replies (10)

521

u/atheistpaperboy Mar 21 '17

Can a user's profile page be quarantined?

278

u/HideHideHidden Mar 21 '17

If we find users to be in violation of our Content Policy we will take admin actions the same as we would if the same thing happened on a single-submitter community.

→ More replies (101)
→ More replies (3)

999

u/DSShinkirou Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I'll raise my voice as yet another person who vehemently opposes this feature. It is my opinion that this initiative muddles the very value proposition that differentiates Reddit from many other profile/persona centric companies, such as Tumblr, Facebook, Twitter, and Snapchat.

Reddit is incredibly unique in the fact that it values the community/subreddit by asking its members to be upstanding community members, and even more incredibly by having a time honored tradition of forcing everyone to obey the same rules as the average user, so even great people like Bill Gates and Barack Obama can't just force their way to the top of Reddit.

Rewarding users to submit content on their own profile subverts much of what the Reddit community stands for: just visiting the Reddiquette rules alone makes it clear how many site wide rules are subverted by allowing users to advertise their own profiles for karma.

And regarding user discoverability; what makes the current user discovery experience on Reddit today compelling, is that you discover users based on common communities and topics of your choosing. Enabling users to escape the community paradigm means that the most popular users and power users are going to engage in a race to the bottom to gain attention; you can see this evidence by the fact that so many content creators on Snapchat, Youtube, Instagram, and others often love posting interpersonal drama with other same-platform personalities, or will stop producing content that they're known for to take a second to jump on whatever new popular bandwagon is happening at the time for more clicks and views. This is all signal-to-noise degradation.

I sincerely hope that Reddit does not lose itself to being lumped into the same mindspace as other profile-based social platforms, because I question Reddit's standings if it chooses to label itself as a competitor in such an already saturated field. This very feature threatens to do that. Please reconsider something that clearly goes against Reddit's mission "[sic] to help people discover places where they can be their true selves, and empower our community to flourish." https://about.reddit.com/ Your own site boldly states "The conversation starts on Reddit". The conversation, not the concert, or the lecture, or the speech, or interview, starts on Reddit. I ask that you choose to keep it that way.

→ More replies (3)

783

u/fringly Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Looking at the current example profiles, this seems like it's going to lead to brigading?

So say Kn0thing has 10k followers on his profile - he posts to aww and all his followers then see he has posted, go to aww and upvote him.

How is this going to be addressed, as it seems like it's going to lead to popular users having a massive advantage on communities where they post?

They get two bites of the cherry for their content to be noticed - nothing they put out will ever be overlooked. It creates a two tier level of users it seems.


EDIT - so kn0thing actually DID have a post on /r/aww from 1 month ago, which was sitting at +39 when I looked an hour ago. Now it is over 100 upvotes, so people are going to his profile, seeing other posts and then going and upvoting them.

What this means is that users who make a popular post can do something like add in a link to their profile, drive people there and get their other posts upvoted too. This not only changes the way that reddit works it makes brigading a core part of the reddit experience.

→ More replies (23)

7.6k

u/DrewsephA Mar 21 '17

I really don't like this idea. I come to reddit because it's different, because it's about the community, rather than the individual. If I wanted to participate in a site centered around status updates and profile pages, I would go to Facebook or Twitter or Instagram or Tumblr or even Snapchat. I like the idea of freshening up the user pages, but I don't think that content should be posted exclusively there. There's a sitewide rule against self-promotion, which I know you said doesn't apply to the userpages, but that's all this is, a way to circumvent the self-promotion rule. "Look what I've posted to my page, everybody come look at my page, give me pageviews." Part of the charm of reddit is finding a gem of a user in a subreddit, especially in the small ones. Now, rather than them engaging in the communities, especially ones built up around them (HPC, H3H3, etc), they're just going to post to their own userpages, because it's just easier.

→ More replies (86)

3.0k

u/white_lightning Mar 21 '17

Count me as a vote against this. This kind of feature will end up destroying subreddits. Why would a company, celebrity, etc. use a subreddit (or a "community" as you keep calling them) to post updates, do an AMA, or whatever when they could just use their profile.

This is just going to fracture subreddits that cover wider topics and decrease the conversation into something more targeted. Whole thing just feels anti-reddit

→ More replies (20)

2.5k

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

This seems to chiefly accomplish two things:

  • Removes power from subreddits and their mods and gives it directly to brands, something Reddit has been trying to underhandedly do for a long time
  • Confuse and muddy the waters between a user and a community. /u/leagueoflegends is not a 'user' in any sense of the word. Facebook eventually realized that having brands pretend to be people is stupid, and built Pages specifically to counteract this problem. Learn from their mistake, don't repeat it.

Both of these things I'm generally opposed to. This change seems unnecessary and unwanted. It's fairly disappointing development time was spent on this and not the huge backlog of needed fixes to the site.

→ More replies (35)

1.6k

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

I came to reddit to escape hell (Facebook) and found a sprawling mansion here for myself. Just as I was settling in, Reddit bulldozes it and puts up a shitty Facebook-Mart-whatever.

I don't like this. I wanted all of us to be anonymous, to be different and fucking far-away from the douches that scour and scavenge on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter. Except for in AMAs, I don't care if the person whose post I am commenting on is Bill Gates or Osama Bin Laden. I don't have a personal respect for any single one redditor, I have a common respect for all of us.

There is a reason we all are here on Reddit and not with the girls that are selling protein powder on Instagram to make a living.

→ More replies (10)

260

u/Average_Giant Mar 21 '17

TL;DR reddit is Facebook now.

→ More replies (5)

594

u/Zthe27th Mar 21 '17

I'm a content creator who does a bunch with some Reddit communities and this change has me concerned. I've done well because I've interacted with my communities. This change doesn't look like it will help build communities.

→ More replies (25)

398

u/FoggyTitans Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

PLEASE, don't do this. The moment things can be posted to user pages, companies will move in and try to amass huge followings on their user pages. We'll have businesses begging people to follow their pages. The subreddits will atrophy. The frontpage or its new equivalent will be rampant company promotions. "Love LL Bean? Be sure to follow our user page!" "Want more Star Wars updates, be sure to follow Disney!" Reddit as we know it would cease to exist. The soul, i.e. the communities, i.e. content upvoted based on true interest and not brand-power, would be gone.

Not to mention you'd be appealing to everyone's own narcissistic streak. Everyone would try to build their own personal brand, telling all of their friends to follow their reddit page, begging for more followers on posts, etc. The concept of having a relatively anonymous user page would fade away.

The worst part is implementing this idea in any fashion is opening pandora's box. There would be no stopping it, even if you offer an "opt-out" option, even if you offer an "opt-in" option! It would not take much to start a feedback cycle that fundamentally changes reddit. If you think people will just put up with this, you're mistaken, they'll leave.

→ More replies (8)

391

u/8007312 Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Direct from the reddiquette

Do not moderate a story based on your opinion of its source. Quality of content is more important than who created it.

Edit: Fixed quote

→ More replies (17)

874

u/ahBaiz6ReeL9Eucu Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Why?


Seriously, why? This is a great example of feature creep.

Please be wary of the unintended consequences. There's a tendency for optional features to become de facto required features over time. Case in point: Reddit was created with only username and passwords. Then recovery emails were added as an option. But some users hold others to a standard of having a verified email address. This comes up in comment sections from time to time (user for one month, no verified email, you must be an astroturfing shill). Soon not having a profile (and I do mean that as a profile in the Facebook sense of the word) will be a strike against a user in some subreddits. Perhaps AutoModerator will delete their comments.

Reddit has also seen a huge drop in quality over the past month or so since the frontage algorithm changed. Half of the frontpage is memes. And really terrible memes like "brain memes" and prequel memes which are copy-pastes of The Tragedy of Darth Plagueis. Plus there's all the softcore porn like /r/gentlemanboners. Yes, you can make an account and git rid of all that garbage, but a good portion of the site's visitors do not log in. Emojis are starting to show up in submission titles.

So now we have a dumbed-down front page and Facebook profiles. What's next? Log in with Facebook credentials?

→ More replies (32)

1.3k

u/Arseonthewicket Mar 21 '17

Yeh I really don't like this. That was my initial impression and I came in here to read more because often I come around to the admin's ideas (like the affiliate linking one). But no I still think this is a bad idea.

I think if anything this will discourage content creation by crowding out the average redditor in favour of power users. Users with recognition already get large boosts to their posts by being known in their subreddit communities, and this goes on to give them an initial momentum site wide.

I already think this pendulum has swung too far in this direction and away from individual's submissions. I think this will effectively strangle competition by raising barriers to entry via a form of intellectual property (branding). I think this has lead to problems on youtube and will cause even more problems for reddit, which by it's nature has a much broader scope.

Furthermore I see this as a step away from anonymity. Many of the currently most influential users have less anonymity than regular users, and many are known by their real names and faces. This is something paralleled by youtube where as youtube became more commercialised and promoted high view channels at the expense of more niche channels, and as old media organisations opened large channels on youtube, people became more and more linked to their real world identities. Even those that had aimed to keep a hard seperation between their private lives and their channel.

When I first came to reddit I used my real name, influenced by the rise of facebook and twitter I had thought that the time of not giving out your name on the internet was gone. But like most redditors I have come to realise that there is a big benefit and a relief from being able to interact anonymously with others online. Especially in an age of massive data surveillance, mining, and retention I think it is important to have somewhere online to come and discuss issues freely, without having to worry about mispeaking or later changing your mind. I have moved almost all of my online political debate and discussion, which I think is an important part of any democratic society especially for young people, from facebook to reddit for this reason.

The best way to get the correct answer is to post the wrong answer on the internet. Or in Silicon Valley parlence "fail quickly". I don't want to feel like I can't be wrong or can't fail online.

→ More replies (13)

3.7k

u/pinkiedash417 Mar 21 '17

I'm sorry, but this reminds me too much of what Yik Yak did last summer. For those who weren't aware, Yik Yak is an app where people can anonymously post small messages that anyone else around the same physical location can see and comment on (also anonymously, though if the original poster comments on their own post the comment is distinguished). Last March, they added Handles (usernames that would optionally show next to your post). In July they added profiles (which would show a karma number as well as a picture). And lastly in August, they took away the option to not have your handle be displayed on a post or comment, claiming they were shifting their focus from anonymity to discovery of people in their local community. Predictably, the app turned into a ghost town within days. By time they rolled back the changes a few months later, it was too late to bring everyone back.

While this change to Reddit doesn't have the obvious issues that changing an anonymous platform to a pseudonymous one does, it does share one major thing in common with Yik Yak's changes, and that's that it represents a shift in the site's focus from discovering communities to discovering users. Reddit was originally made to be, and has traditionally been, a news/link aggregator as well as a discussion forum collection -- both of which are services with a very "light" focus on discovery of other users, if any at all. People come to Reddit to discover content and entire communities (not to be confused with the people in said communities) centered around their favorite topics. To switch to a profile-based system, or even hint at doing so, is to desire to compete with Facebook and Twitter when your service is really nothing like either to begin with. Facebook works because people who know each other already use the service -- when a typical Facebook user "discovers" another user on Facebook, they usually discover that the person (who they already know) has an account, not that they exist. On Twitter it's the same, though there seems to be a bigger focus on content from brands (and in that way, there may be some "discovery of users"... but usually those are brands and artists rather than typical users).

I can really only see this going three ways, and they are 1. (the most likely and best for Reddit as a whole) Reddit continues as usual, except power users and writers also have profiles to boost their own content on, 2. Reddit becomes overrun by brands in a Twitter-esque fashion (or similarly to if Facebook only had Pages), or 3. (possibly as a logical conclusion after #2) Reddit users form a mass exodus find and/or create another site to be the de facto link aggregation service. All of these are missing any concept of ordinary users going out of their way to make profiles or discover other ordinary users they don't already know somewhere else. That concept -- of "user discovery" -- has been tried over and over again, and has mostly flopped outside of meetup-based communities, which are inherently limited by locality and by interest profile (and Facebook Groups pretty much has a monopoly on this right now). Overall, I think this is a change that should be approached with caution, if it's even fully implemented at all.

→ More replies (120)

342

u/SomeGuyWithAProfile Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I think that this is a bad idea. This makes reddit too much like a generic social media site. I also think it is kind of dragging content away from subreddits and onto profiles for no reason. You're saying that this is more for users to post their own opinions, but that can be done on a subreddit, and even if it can't, the user could just make on themselves. What makes reddit different is that it's more about the content than the person. This feature promotes the kind of Facebook-like features that people on reddit hate. Even the design of the page isn't like reddit at all. The whole thing is like a social media page. The huge header image, the profile picture, the blurb thing, posting directly to your page, etc. In fact, the reddit profile pages look remarkably similar to twitter.

Also, about the pseudo-anonymity thing, it isn't really just about people not knowing who you are irl. On reddit, people generally are going to read something and not know or care who wrote it (for most cases, anyways). Even if your profile on a site doesn't have your real name, people can still know you by the profile. I think this feature is kind of turning reddit into what is basically Facebook without your real name on it, and that's not what reddit is about. Reddit so good because you can make a post on any subreddit you want, and if it's a quality post, it can get noticed no matter who made it.

Reddit is supposed to form communities and discuss things anonymously online. This is separating people into their own little tree-houses that seemingly act like subreddits but with only one moderator. This feature is pointless and will only serve to diminish the good things about reddit. Reddit isn't about profiles, it's about subreddits, communities, discussions, etc. Having user profiles doesn't work towards any of that. It's more like a self centered type of thing common with other social media sites. Having a subreddit dedicated to just you or your company means that you will decide what discussion takes place here. One draw of reddit is that companies and people can't control how the discussion takes place. Now, if I, say, had some product that was controversial, I could just moderate my profile page (which I would use as basically a subreddit) to only allow positive feedback.

I guess I'll also comment on the design of the page in general. The header is too big, the posts should be more off to the side, the page takes too long to load, and the whole thing looks more like the mobile site for some reason. I guess if you're trying to make them look more similar that could make sense, but it looks weird in comparison to the rest of the site. User pages were fine before. They were simple, provided little information about the user and more about their posts and other necessary information. I'm pretty concerned this update could mark a shift towards users who use their own personal user-page/user-subreddit to post shit about them that belongs on Facebook, twitter, etc.

The thing that makes reddit special is that it isn't like other social media sites. The focus is placed on the content, discussion, and community because of the absence on features found on more tradition social media sites. Sometimes, less is more. Please don't ruin that.

→ More replies (1)

309

u/narwhalsare_unicorns Mar 21 '17

LETS GET SOCIAAAAAL on a platform where content is the only thing that matters and people want to stay anonymous.

→ More replies (4)

150

u/Fumblerful- Mar 21 '17

I do not like this idea. When I found Reddit two years ago, I fell in love with it because it did NOT promote celebrity status of users. Users had to work for that and even then, they were still just users providing content alongside everyother user providing content. To me, Reddit is about the subreddits, about communities making content and not about a few individuals making content. This change will shift reddit to a platform people already dislike. Look at what is happening with Youtube.

Youtube decided to switch to supporting major platforms and it feels less casual because of that. I don't want Reddit to shift over to that as well.

→ More replies (2)

140

u/67chevroletimpala Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I am a Redditor because i enjoy content, the collective aggregation by the whole community. The focus isn't the creators, the power to get customized aggregated content based on the points of interest of the user is the USP.

I'm going to leave Reddit as soon as you guys roll out this "new feature"

I am currently not on Facebook, Instagram and Quora precisely because they follow this structure of social media. I barely tolerate Twitter as atleast there is anonymity there.

This profile based content is useless tbh. I do not want to subscribe to everything a person is doing. Lets say Redditor X is a good at photoshop skills which i enjoy on the photoshop subreddit, but X also creates content for another subreddit for example bodybuilding or skincare, none of which I'm interested in. That's why i don't subscribe to those subs, but due to this profile following, I'm going to have to wade through everything that X posts on his/her profile while i don't get the content from other lesser known photoshop enthusiasts because the subreddit would be dead. Do you see the problem?

Please do not do this. Let me enjoy Reddit. Let it remain the goddamn FRONT PAGE OF THE INTERNET

→ More replies (2)

12k

u/DavesWorldInfo Mar 21 '17 edited Jul 10 '18

This is going to pull people, both the individual posters (whether they're a company or a Youtuber or a random person who makes a thing that catches on) and the subreddit general users, into the profile posts. And out of the subreddits.

Why would a game company, a creator, a whoever who has a thing that's gaining traction, want to post in a mere subreddit when they can focus all their posts on their profile page? Where they have mod control by default? Where they can tune and shape what they're doing.

What happens to various game subreddits when the developers, from small wanna-be indies all the way up to triple A devs and dev employees, stop posting in the subs and post only to their own profile? What happens to new and upcoming creators, like binging with babbish or sovietwomble when they stop posting in threads about their vids and only post on their profiles? Or when they only venture away from their profiles to link back to it?

Why would I talk about starcraft in /r/starcraft when I can talk about it on /u/blizzard and know they might be watching. Because it's their channel? That destroys /r/rts, /r/gaming, and so on. The examples continue in the same fashion.

This changes Reddit, fundamentally. It turns it into a clone of something it's not. It removes what makes Reddit interesting and engaging; the collective gestalt of all the users rising and falling based on how they want things to go.

One of the default 'rules' of Reddit is "participate, don't promote." How does profile centric posting help that?

And I say all this as a content creator. If you guys push this change through, I'll use it for whatever it's worth. While it lasts. But me and a lot of other people will be looking for the next thing. Making this change go live and wide sets a ticking clock on Reddit's destruction.

The community is what makes Reddit work. Not power users, and certainly not companies showing up to big foot and massage and control their messages they way they do everywhere else in life.

→ More replies (652)

582

u/Mickeymousetitdirt Mar 22 '17

Fuck this idea 100%. When I say this, I'm not exaggerating: I literally almost entirely stopped using every other "social" platform and, instead, started using Reddit. I absolutely love that there isn't this stupid, petty, and MOST IMPORTANTLY, this desperate need of self-promotion and narcissism. What is the point of subreddits if content can be posted right to users pages?!? WHO IS ASKING for Reddit to be another Facebook-type place, which is exactly what this implementation feels like? Like, honestly - who even asked for this? I haven't heard of anyone asking for this. I come to Reddit to get AWAY from traditional social media sites and to JUST see content, straight up content, and interact with people. I don't come here to "follow" people and I've never once had the desire to follow any particular person to keep tabs on their posts. I have become familiar with which users whose content I like post where. There is no need for this shitty "update". Stop trying to make Reddit another crappy social media site; there are already a million.

Believe it or not, there are a vast amount of people here who come here because of the things Reddit is NOT like; people come here because it's simple, it's unique, and it ISN'T another god damned Facebook. I pray this stupid shit doesn't actually kick in. Let it be known that I know no one has to share my opinion. And, I may be overreacting. But, I a world full of narcissism and disgusting and INCESSANT self-promotion, it is so fucking nice to get away from it when it comes to being on the internet. I'm not always on Reddit but, when I am, I would like it to be enjoyable.

Don't implement this shit. Don't.

→ More replies (10)

5.9k

u/BobHogan Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

Why are you trying to turn Reddit into a social media clone?

I didn't get an answer yesterday, but I really want to know.

Edit - /u/HideHideHidden, /u/spez, /u/kn0thing, I really hope you guys are taking this feedback seriously. Don't just look at the number of upvotes on this announcement and decide its good to go. As it stands right now, its at a 50% approval rating from the community, and its been dropping fast. Last time I checked on this thread (about 3 hours ago) you guys were around 62-65% upvote, and about 5 hours ago it was in the 70s. This started out as a controversial idea, and as this has progressed, the proportion of people who have upvoted this announcement has steadily dropped lower.

Not to mention that the top comments in this thread are all about how this will either be bad or how actual Reddit users don't want this. Note that they are the highest comments in this thread. These are the sentiments that your own users agree with the most. And collectively they have already obtained at least 21 gildings (only looking at the top 10 top level replies, not accounting for any gildings that may have happened in those threads), all about how people do not want this to come to Reddit.

I'm begging you guys to reconsider this heavily. This is not what your users want. A lot of us are feeling a bit betrayed, and you haven't given us a good reason as to why you went this route. You have several times now cited the difficulty in creating a personal subreddit to do exactly what you claim these user pages are for, so if that is one of the true focuses here, why did you not simply make that process easier? Reddit users, your users, are not happy about this change, and we do not want it to come to Reddit. We are, rightfully so, scared of the implications that such a change will bring later on.

→ More replies (453)

249

u/316nuts Mar 21 '17

i don't know what i expected

but this is drastically different than what i expected.

→ More replies (3)

458

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

The only reason I have a reddit account is because it had none of this profile page nonsense, it's a major reason I deleted my other social media accounts. People start becoming too self-centered and the purpose of reddit will shift from a fun community into content whoring and a lot more sponsoring and so on that turned YouTube into what it is today. I like reddit because the focus isn't the people, it's the topic at hand. With this change, the dynamic will definitely shift to what other social media sites have become. Initially, it'll be viewed as a "popular" change by the admins, which will encourage more changes to come, resulting in the focus of threaded discussions declining more and more over time. Think carefully for the long-term future of reddit, not the short-term.

Edit: also look how broken it looks in desktop mode on mobile devices. It doesn't even come close to the consistency reddit has.

→ More replies (1)

548

u/JManSenior918 Mar 21 '17

What's the value/advantage of this as opposed to the preexisting format of content creators posting their work in relevant subreddits? I thought the whole point of Reddit was to have communities where people who have similar interests can share their work/thoughts/whatever?

→ More replies (84)

631

u/ScanianMoose Mar 21 '17

My questions were left unanswered yesterday, so let's try again:

How will you counteract SEO spam?

Will you counteract SEO spam posted on user's profiles at all?

How will I be able to get spam and prohibited content off this site, especially if it's time-sensitive? Since we're sidestepping automod rules and human moderation here, there does not seem to be an adequate solution to this.

Your answers boil down to "let upvotes decide" and "spammers won't get many subs anyway", but we all know that this is not how this works.

How will I be able to find OC creators if not by their real name?

Will personal posts be included in the reddit-wide search (please no)?

Will we be able to differentiate between profile and subreddit posts i.e. will Toolbox still be able to compile an accurate report of submitted domain percentages (only subreddit posts)?

→ More replies (58)

1.6k

u/AllTheRowboats93 Mar 21 '17

I wonder if this will change the dynamic of the site.

→ More replies (498)

449

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

honestly one of the reasons I like reddit so much is because it's so slow to change. I like that down to the visual qualities, Reddit is still pretty similar to when I signed on 5 years ago. I still disable reddit mobile on my phone when I browse on mobile. Is that the digital-age old 'users are resistant to change' philosophy? sure, but there's a concrete reason why I use this site in the first place and I can't be the only one here who doesn't like the terms for engagement swapped out once I get comfortable.

This is one of the few places online I feel somewhat anonymous even if my profile is easily doxable- because the format isn't framed around 'individuals' but rather 'what' people post. I rarely feel a need to look at someone's profile, and why would I? I don't come to reddit for the users, but for the grand collage of what the users provide.

Third: 'content creators', like advertisers? Yeah we have some celebrities- people who spend all day posting, but isn't half of reddit reposted content anyway? How many 'content-creators' either don't have their own subreddits or profiles on other websites? Is this to counteract Reddit itself being farmed for clickbait?

Will we be able to keep the 'old' profile, should we prefer it?

I suppose we'll see.

→ More replies (4)

186

u/beekr427 Mar 21 '17

Here's how it'll work. Open r/all, *sees gif, "that was funny", goes to USER page in lieu of subreddit because THAT user was the funny one, fuck the rest of the sub. That guy is funny! FOLLOWED. Back to r/all, scroll on.

(insert death of subs here)

Not to mention the inevitable elevation of reddit celebrities. "You liked user x, others also liked user Y!" or "Recommended Reddit content creator : X" bullshit in feeds.

→ More replies (4)

599

u/hiero_ Mar 21 '17

As someone posted in r/modnews yesterday, I'm afraid this will discourage posting to subreddits and could hurt communities. I'm also worried that this change will ultimately only really 'help' the more "famous" redditors, while the majority will either never use this feature, or will never get to use this feature.

It seems to me there needs to be more emphasis on the 'friends' feature reddit has had for years, if this is the direction we're going

→ More replies (11)

81

u/ArmoredFan Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

If I follow /u/spez does it also notify me when he changes people's comments?

→ More replies (5)

75

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Reddit is great because it's NOT social media, this sounds like it is making Reddit more like social media. No thanks.

70

u/snissn Mar 21 '17

We’re taking feedback on this experience on r/beta and will be paying close attention to the voices of community members. We want to understand what the impact of this change is to Reddit’s existing communities, which is why we’re partnering with only a handful of users as we slowly roll this out.

you're not, you really are not engaging or caring about your users here. no one wants this. there's a ton of other things you can be doing besides this. This is just a prelude to a native advertising play that is going to completely kill reddit

→ More replies (1)

141

u/psychyness Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I'm rather apprehensive about this move by Reddit. I don't give a shit about individual people, and the community of Reddit is perfect for that style. It's something that made Reddit standout from other social media platforms.

This could be a huge mistake. Frankly I may dislike it enough to be looking for another Reddit alternative.

Not that anyone gives a shit about my opinion, but I spend so much time on this site I wanted to voice it anyways.

Edit: Fuck it. I'm not even worried about it anymore. I was for like, 5 minutes, and then I realized if they wanted to kill their site by making it into some stupid social media thing then there will definitely be a new Reddit anyways. Ah well!

→ More replies (4)

68

u/BloodGulch Mar 21 '17

Will this feature be canceled if this alpha test doesn't work well?

I hope this is a true trial, and not a "we've already decided this is going to happen".

I don't like it. Seems like a social network; there are enough of those.

→ More replies (7)

66

u/TbanksIV Mar 21 '17

So what happens to AMAs?

Presumably most high profile AMAs will now go through personal pages rather than the AMA sub or subs related to the person answering questions.

Moving this to the personal page allows those who do AMA's to delete questions they don't want to answer. As well as all comments that potentially challenge the hosts ideas.

Why allow the hosts of the AMA to control the narrative? For example if this was the case back when Woody Harrelson did his AMA he could delete every question that didn't relate to Rampart.

If Donald Trump does an AMA it will allow him to silence anyone who has a question he doesn't like.

If Papa John of Pizza fame did an AMA he could delete all posts that don't enforce a positive view of their product.

This change is not for the users is it? It's for the already prevalent mass marketing campaign on Reddit to flourish without challenge.

I wonder how Voats doing.

→ More replies (4)

63

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I very rarely comment on these things, however, this change kills what attracted me to reddit in the first place.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Since when are subreddits called 'communities'?

I smell marketing BS about "our visitors don't understand the word 'subreddit'"...

→ More replies (2)

648

u/nigborg Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Can you guys please PLEASE not do this? I understand every new CEO wants to add their own mark on reddit, but nobody is complaining about Power Users not having enough tools to garner followers. Most people don't really like the concept of Power Users to begin with, and you guys are actively supporting it here. I understand there are workaround (creating your own subreddit), but it's different when you as a company publicly approve and give them your support. Please, please, please, stop taking reddit farther away than its original purpose. You exist in the tech economy. When users stop appreciating what you're doing, they will go somewhere else. You don't want to be historically remembered as Digg 2.0

edit: I'm not an experienced moderator or an eloquent speaker, but I've created /r/rexit as a place to discuss what's going on with Reddit and what our options are. If anyone wants to help that would be much appreciated

→ More replies (8)

58

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17
ctrl+F 'twitter clone'

See my points have already been made several dozen times.

Wander away.

→ More replies (1)

215

u/TylerthePotato Mar 21 '17

I hate how social media sites cultivate an atmosphere that makes them successful and then try to integrate portions of other social networks that made them successful.

Reddit's not for creators, it's for communities

668

u/nothumbnails Mar 21 '17

Oh god no. Please no. I came here for the content, not to have the bastard child of twitter and facebook with a shitty layout looking back at me. These are forums 1st ='(

→ More replies (11)

53

u/Flecca Mar 21 '17

Wow. Way to turn into twitter, reddit.

50

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I dunno, I like Reddit because of the focus on communities rather than specific people. I feel like this is kinda unnecessary and just hurts that.

You say it's to give a home for people to put their original content, but can't subreddits already do that?

408

u/apparissus Mar 21 '17

Is this an attempt to kill Twitter?

→ More replies (86)

49

u/PM_ME_SHIHTZU_PICS Mar 21 '17

I genuinely think this is an awful idea. I'm not in social media because I don't like it. I don't want Reddit to feel like more of a popularity contest. Yes, there are users that we all like to see pop up from time to time, but that's the beauty of Reddit. We get to see them from time to time, the rest of the time it's just regular users doing regular user things. Allowing people to post on their profiles is going to make Reddit feel just like Facebook, and people on Facebook are leaving because it is Facebook. They are coming here because it is not.

Also, when I click the link to go to the alpha testers profiles I get a message saying that the link isn't available. I'm using Reddit is Fun Platinum if that helps.

49

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

i'm just going to copy this comment by u/venom0923. It speaks for me and if anybody else feels the same they should just copy it and paste it too.

"People have already stated my feelings more eloquently than I am capable of in this thread. Maybe my contribution to quantity will be of some value. I reiterate what the vast majority of this thread has said, we don't fucking want this. Tell the advertisers, or whoever is pressuring you to do this, to shove it up their ass. Let Reddit be Reddit, please. For the love of god, please. We harbor no loyalty to your sit, and if Digg or the fall of Yahoo to Google weren't signs enough that in the tech world things can go from lively to a ghost town in a quick second, let me remind you. The userbase has almost no confidence in the Reddit team anymore, and if a better Reddit comes along, we'll jump ship in a hurry. If you don't believe me, just keep pushing shit like this out. Just remember my comment in the future when you've driven your company in to the ground. Again, we don't fucking want this. Stop, pls."

330

u/1100000011110 Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I appreciate that you're trying to innovate and improve the site. I like the recent changes you've made to post scores, and I browse /r/popular way more than I used to browse /r/all. This change, however, feels like a fundamental change to the site, one which goes against why I joined Reddit in the first place.

I love that Reddit is focused almost entirely on content and community instead of individual users. Sure, there are "famous" redditors like /u/shitty_watercolour and /u/GallowBoob. But they got their fame by being frequent contributors who post good content. I feel this new feature could move some "famous" users' focus from subreddits to their own user pages, which could ultimately lead to a decrease in the overall quality of content in the subreddits that they would have previously submitted that content to.

I'm sure you've considered this option, but I think a happy medium would be adding some kind of "Pin to my profile" button to posts that you've made. They would essentially function as stickied threads in subreddits, only on the current iteration of the user page. This would allow users to highlight content that they feel is a good representation of who they are on reddit without introducing this new mainstream, me-first social media aspect.

*edited for clarity

→ More replies (19)

1.6k

u/BrahmsLullaby Mar 21 '17

I'm not opposed and don't think it's "wrong", but from an initial impression I see some features and concepts that take away the uniqueness of Reddit and make it blend with a lot of other social media platforms.

I could just be overprotective of my nostalgia from Redditing for a while now (this account doesn't reflect how long I have been) - but this seems to put an emphasis on names, people, brands - where my enjoyment has come from a focus on content.

I didn't have a chance to type out all my thoughts, and I'm just as interested to see how this plays out, just food for thought.

→ More replies (143)

47

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Bad update. Don't ruin this website by selling out to companies and making it another platform for them to sell their shit to us. Keep it like it is and never change.

281

u/Hsyn_ali Mar 21 '17

I don't like this

It's gonna a Facebook clone with people following other people instead of following subreddits devoted for content

→ More replies (2)

134

u/apocolyptictodd Mar 21 '17

Oh good so now the site is another shit social media clone, because, you know, that what I want when I go to reddit, I want FaceBook light.

Admins, do you guys just not realize why this site is popular? Can't you leave well enough alone? Why do none of you realize that you had a good thing going?

→ More replies (1)

92

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

One thing, I hate that the Reddit admins keep trying to make Reddit about the big users. I even remember you made Tom Hanks into a marketing scheme, and you started giving famous users flairs for the whole site? It's pretty bad, as Reddit is supposed to be for the masses, not for the upvotes and karma grabbers.

So, if this is to be a great thing it must be for the users and not for the sellers. Which will be really hard to do.

→ More replies (2)

45

u/tasmanian101 Mar 21 '17

This is clearly a change aimed at pleasing advertisers.

From the r/modnews announcement

Could these kinds of self-posts appear on r/all (or r/popular)? Yes

The new user page will allow a brand to build a following and in turn their user posts will reach the front page without any of the community moderation. This is clearly intended to allow brands similar control like twitter and facebook.

This change only makes it easier to game or bot the system. Without the moderation that popular and frontpage subreddits have this allows advertisements to directly rise to the front page of reddit with ease.

Likely the next major change will be promoted user posts.

42

u/ohwhatirony Mar 21 '17

Oh no. Part of what makes Reddit great is the uniform nature of everyone's profile, not giving one person more sense of their identity besides their post. If I wanted my original content in one place, maybe I could "tag" it instead of changing an entire profile (e.g. complete with cover photos). Or even have a section for links to other media in a profile (e.g. Deviantart, portfolios, Instagram).

One of the reasons I loved reddit is its integrity. You judge a person completely by their comment/posts (and occasionally their username), not by things like "signatures" and "avatars" that plague other forum-based sites.

42

u/Pondors Mar 21 '17

I come to Reddit to get away from Facebook. Don't you think turning it into a Social Media style website with profiles will reduce the quality of content, since people now have their personal reputation at stake?

The disconnect from your real and professional life is what allows for honest posting.

I get that you can opt-out, but once you open that can of worms there's no going back, especially if it's opt-in by default.

42

u/G65434-2 Mar 21 '17

Reddit: the front page facetwittersnapgrambook of the internet

41

u/commander_cuntmunch Mar 21 '17

This has the potential to fuck up Reddit. Interesting.

695

u/Joetato Mar 21 '17

This feels really Facebookey and I don't like it. I'm hoping they trash it during alpha and it never becomes a site wide thing. This feels like a change that's going to backfire and kill Reddit. You seriously need to abandon this, now.

→ More replies (39)

82

u/blackwaltz9 Mar 21 '17

This idea is dumb and you're all dumb for coming up with it.

→ More replies (2)

148

u/graaahh Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

This is not made clear in the OP. The admins are planning to allow posts to these pages to be shown on /r/all and /r/popular. I think this is a terrible idea, personally, though I'm not necessarily opposed to the profile page idea itself (I'm still keeping an open mind about being opposed to it though, depending how this goes). But I wanted to make it clear to anyone who only read the OP here that they forgot to mention these posts will go to /r/all and /r/popular too.

edit: Yesterday in the /r/modnews thread, they said posts on usersubs would be visible on /r/all and /r/popular. This was also one of the most hotly contested things in that thread, so I am shocked that they did not include it in the OP here. /u/spez has now said something about this not being definite yet. I guess we'll have to wait and see what the admins decide, but I still say that's a very bad idea.

→ More replies (3)

39

u/tanzmeister Mar 21 '17

This seems completely unnecessary and may destroy reddit...

174

u/cdos93 Mar 21 '17

it seems like this is going to be an attempt to pave the way into making reddit a social media site similar to Facebook, Twitter, etc. I'm not sure if it works. Facebook and Twitter have already locked the market down there.

Also I like reddit because it's not yet another social media site. I'm pretty apprehensive about this move.

→ More replies (4)

76

u/antihexe Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Do you think that having user profile posts show up on /r/all and /r/popular instead of only on the subscribers front page is going to amplify the super user problem? (You said this is something that is "possible" HERE.)

Isn't this entirely antithetical to the core of reddit which is facilitating and building communities -- i.e. the feature is more about one user rather than a collective creation itself?

I think an interactive user profile is a good idea. But I am not sold -- at all -- on its showing up on /r/all or /r/popular. Anyone have any arguments for this integration?

→ More replies (2)

253

u/GroggyOtter Mar 21 '17

Are you guys trying to make Redditbook? I don't see the real benefit here...

→ More replies (18)

137

u/sanityvampire Mar 21 '17

Oh, cool. This should be a great tool for content creators® and definitely doesn't seem like a way for corporate social media teams to shit up the site by creating huge, monolithic, "branded" accounts and filling the site with more useless, visually intrusive advertising.

→ More replies (8)

36

u/Catsaiah Mar 21 '17

If this leaves alpha then fuck reddit, damn I hate this feature

70

u/ImaNinja88 Mar 21 '17

I know you're still testing, but I feel that not having profiles is kind of what makes Reddit great. Sure, some accounts are well known (u/Gallowboob, for example) but the reason that Reddit has discussion like no other sites is because everyone is equal. Idk, maybe I have no idea how the site works, but not having profiles has actually been my favorite thing about Reddit.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Bobwayne17 Mar 22 '17

Wow this is a fucking horrible idea. When I go to a subreddit I go there to interact with EVERYONE. I remember the times where SWC would come to random big threads and paint funny shit, I remember when important shit from kn0thing was in places everyone could see, I remember rioters being forced to answer serious concerns on the league subreddits.

Things I've literally been a part of for years. Now you're telling me I have to follow them specifically? That what, they will no longer contribute to the discussion because we are all unworthy or something? Why can't they do what Reddit has ALWAYS done - create content in subreddits.

Obviously by my profile im no mega user or anything. I just have enjoyed Reddit for many years and I REALLY hope this doesn't happen. I don't want to see these people take this to their own profile instead of sharing it with everyone because I don't care about their profile. I don't. SWC won't paint things that I have the context for. It must not be important if kn0thing is rambling on his profile (like facebook). It must not matter to Riot to no longer interact in their subreddit ALREADY and post shit in their profile that the people of the subreddit deserve to see and discuss.

God this idea is terrible. I can't believe you've found a way to Digg this place but you have. You're all rich already, wildly rich. Why fuck it up for the millions of people that just LOVE being on Reddit? For more money? It doesn't make any sense. I can't believe a focus group for 20 normal redditors would come together and be hyped as fuck for this.

67

u/Oxxide Mar 21 '17

I don't understand this feature, why it was implemented, or what kind of show Spez is running over there, but this is laughably incompetent and makes me wonder how out of touch the admins really are.

You guys Digg that hole a little deeper with each new announcement. ;)

→ More replies (4)

33

u/CleavingClavicles Mar 21 '17

Yeah once I read brands I kinda tuned out.

119

u/Delta-9- Mar 21 '17

tl;dr

For some dumb-fuck reason we've decided to turn Reddit into Facebook.

I don't need one of the last somewhat cool places on the internet turning into another narcissism/advertising outlet. I'll go to Tumblr and Twitter if I want those things. I come to Reddit because the narcissism is buried in thousands of communities and the advertising is easy to tune out.

63

u/Erkumbulant Mar 21 '17

I know this will probably be drowned out by the wave of comments, but I'd like to say this anyway: what you have here is not Reddit.

It may be Twitter or Instagram or Facebook or every other social medium, but it isn't Reddit.

Most other popular social media are all about "me, me, me". Reddit is not, and that's why I'm here.

These pages don't even look like Reddit. At first glance I'd think it was a Twitter clone.

I really, truly hope that you reconsider this. It may just ruin the site.

60

u/KiraAzun Mar 21 '17

Honestly, this is a little scary.

First I used Tumblr, for about 6 months or so. Then I kind of stopped, not really feeling engaged at all with any posts I was seeing. Then I went to Twitter. I only used Twitter for about 2 months. Once again, I just didn't like the overall focus on who ever posted the tweet. Nobody discussed anything, nobody did anything except reply to who ever tweeted. Now, I've been using Reddit for 7 months. I pretty much love it. There's always something to read, cool things to talk about, and I can connect with others who have the same interests as me.

But with these profiles, I can't help like Reddit is trying to be more like the bigger social media sites like Twitter, Tumblr, Instagram, etc. And that difference is what makes me like Reddit so much in the first place.

When I first read this post, I didn't really understand what this ment, and thought it could work out OK. Then I started to read the comments, and this opened up my eyes to see what could go wrong. More people could follow a singular user, and less prevalence (that doesn't seem like the right word) is put on the communities. 99% of the time when I read a comment, I don't care who posted it. I only really look at the name if someone else mentions something, and I check who posted that comment. I might go "Oh, look, it's [blank], I've seen them on some other posts, they're pretty funny" . Then I move along.

Reddit to me is a place where it doesn't really matter who you are, you still have a chance to participate in the conversation. With profile pages for the most well known creators, or business, or personalities, it starts to feel more like everyone else doesn't really matter.

Thank you for reading, this has been my longest comment I've ever written. I hope I conveyed my message, I'm not the best writer around.

→ More replies (1)

734

u/HikeTheSky Mar 21 '17

Can you block stalkers or turn that function off?

→ More replies (347)

59

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

When's reddit's Snapchat clone coming out?

→ More replies (2)

29

u/snorlz Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

not sure i like this.

primarily because it gives certain people special status over everyone else. their content no longer has to go through the upvoting process, they get a free pass because all their subs will see everything they do (and upvote). that kind of defeats the crowd voting aspects of reddit IMO and soon we're just gonna see certain people over and over on the front page. not to mention all their shitty content appears to everyone who follows them.

These accounts are also definitely going to get monetized and turned into ad machines to some extent.

It detracts from the "community" feel of reddit and seems like its falling into normal social media trends, a la facebook or instagram or youtube.

83

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

No thank you.

54

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

As if reddit didn't have celebrity worship before, jesus christ

53

u/lildefendantcopy Mar 21 '17

I don't want this

26

u/PM_ME_2_TRUTHS_1_LIE Mar 21 '17

I sincerely think this is a horrible idea. Reddit it is a site where users come together and discuss in communities, not promote their own profile. That it its niche. When sites try to become something they're not, they can die fast. Look at Digg or even Yik Yak for an example. Yik Yak's niche was that it was an anonymous posting site for people to talk about their school/area. It was fun because it built community within the area. Then they added usernames, and it went to shit. If Reddit adds profiles, it will also turn to shit-- it will basically become Tumblr or Facebook.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

can an indiviual user disable their own profile?

25

u/funsizedaisy Mar 21 '17

I hate it. We all saw what happened to MySpace when they decided to change it all up. It died instantly. Reddit isn't a site about personal profiles. Let social media keep that arena. There's nothing else like reddit so changing reddit to be more like social media will completely kill the reason to even use reddit. This idea sucks, bottom line.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/The_Dawkness Mar 22 '17

Please, god no.

This is my first cake day. I've been here for exactly a year and I can absolutely say that reddit has changed my life. I honestly don't know what I used to do on the internet before reddit.

I'm a bit of a shut-in and I hate that I've only found this site so recently. I hear other redditors talk about how this site used to be with an incredible amount of fondness, and I wish I had been here to experience all of that, and I'm thankful for the last year I've had here. Every single change you've made in the last year, and the changes I've read about after the fact and their effects, I see to be on-the-whole, fine. Some of them have been questionable to hard-core, long-term redditors, such as the change making comments accrue karma and sponsored posts, but this takes it over the edge.

This change is a mistake that is obviously money-driven, and it will hurt the character of the site in a devastating way. While I understand that Reddit is a business and it is only supposed to be about money, this will hurt you in the long run.

Why would you want to be more like facebook or youtube? Reddit has a unique character and you are literally trashing it with this change.

Please don't do this.

24

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Feb 21 '24

workable vanish shy selective rainstorm roll rock resolute alive ad hoc

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

24

u/-ksguy- Mar 21 '17

In another comment you stated:

The goal of this product is to create a platform for creators

To me this sounds like a stepping stone to monetization of individual user profiles. Content creators with popular pages are offered the ability to place targeted advertisements on their pages - with reddit getting a share, of course.

Can you elaborate on whether this is part of future plans? I really can't envision this having any purpose other than being a stepping stone to a cash grab.

24

u/mango__reinhardt Mar 21 '17

I am not a fan of this change.

This site, while not strictly anonymous, fuels discussion without the fear of someone attaching your name to your open thoughts.

It's not just that though... attaching identity to content changes the dynamic of a social media site, and puts the focus on the people rather than the ideas.

Look at famous redditors like /u/Gallowboob. His limited anonymity changes the behavior of the community with which he interacts, simply because he is a known person. Creating a culture of lesser anonymity just creates a catalyst for the suppression and dilution of the culture itself.

Then, once you create an incentive for users to make them self known through followers and notoriety, you'll find that your social structure changes to those like instagram, facebook, twitter, etc. People without notoriety become less meaningful, and so does their content.

Likewise, filtering, "circles" of users, and increasingly narrowed exposure to "unliked" content and people will continue to make communities stale.

This is a myspace or digg level change. You're removing the essence of this site. Maybe not completely or immediately, but this is the first change of many that moves your business in the wrong direction to its user base.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a_1UEAGCo30

Watch Moot speak to this very thing, and think about why he protected that idea.

24

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

People have already stated my feelings more eloquently than I am capable of in this thread. Maybe my contribution to quantity will be of some value. I reiterate what the vast majority of this thread has said, we don't fucking want this. Tell the advertisers, or whoever is pressuring you to do this, to shove it up their ass. Let Reddit be Reddit, please. For the love of god, please. We harbor no loyalty to your sit, and if Digg or the fall of Yahoo to Google weren't signs enough that in the tech world things can go from lively to a ghost town in a quick second, let me remind you. The userbase has almost no confidence in the Reddit team anymore, and if a better Reddit comes along, we'll jump ship in a hurry. If you don't believe me, just keep pushing shit like this out. Just remember my comment in the future when you've driven your company in to the ground.

Again, we don't fucking want this. Stop, pls.

48

u/thiney49 Mar 21 '17

This seems to have broken the RiF app - nothing shows on /u/Shitty_Watercolour 's page for me.

→ More replies (6)

23

u/whoknewyouknew Mar 21 '17

This seems like the first step on a very slippery slope towards becoming a Facebook or Twitter. This is probably one of the worst things that can happen to reddit. Brb taking a snapshot of reddit right now so after it becomes Facebook we can go back to the good old days. I understand people don't like change but this is taking a huge turn as far as reddit goes. Down the Wrong path. Please don't do this. Im ending my gold subscription on my other account if this makes it way to the norm

22

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Well there's 3000 comments as of now, so my comment won't be read, but I'll try anyways.

I've been really supportive of reddit's decisions to innovate the past couple years, but I think this is a really bad idea. Reddit is about communities, not individuals. I feel like this change will make reddit feel more like youtube, where you're encouraged to follow personalities and see updates from them. What I enjoy about reddit is that everyone is on the same playing field, follows the same rules, and I feel like this taints that.

In an effort to try and understand your position, I've got a couple questions you can answer:

  • What is the goal of this change?
  • What kind of direction is this taking reddit? Where do ya'll envision reddit to be in 1, 5, or 10 years?

I know you guys are trying your best to avoid a digg-like exodus, but I feel like this could really upset the community. I've just got a really bad feeling about this.

44

u/Wildnothing1 Mar 21 '17

There's a fucking reason I don't use social media - I don't want a profile page, I don't want followers, and I don't want to follow anyone. This is just a stepping stone to turn reddit (soon to be plebbit) into an even bigger dick measuring contest and function as a shitty twitter feed. Also, allowing brands to make their own profiles is bullshit too. I don't want to be advertised to even more than I already am by corporate shills pushing their bullshit to the front page everyday under the guise of being a meme. But sure, reddit will milk this for some cash before letting this ship sink. ICEBERG AHEAD!

→ More replies (1)

42

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Turning REDDIT into FACEBOOK??

WTF for? :( Less anonymity sucks.

The great thing about reddit is/was that you never know you might be having a conversation with a world-renowned neurosurgeon or a high school dropout billionaire or just some homeless guy at the library. Making users not-equal is shit.

→ More replies (2)

56

u/nicolasap Mar 21 '17

When real life friends ask me "what is this reddit thing about" I usually say "it's like the other social networks you know, but instead of seeing content you don't care about from people you know, you just engage with content you care about from people you don't even want to know anything about. And that's the great thing."

It looks like reddit is becoming less great.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/seanjenkins Mar 21 '17

So basically Reddit becomes Facebook....

Who asked for this? And this is obviously wildly unpopular, can we at least have a vote?

→ More replies (2)

19

u/dancingonfire Mar 22 '17

I rarely bother with announcement posts past a glance but when I saw this one my stomach literally sank.

I am absolutely opposed to this.

Obviously, from your lack of responses in this thread you don't give a shit and that's the biggest mistake of all. The moment this place turns into another Facebook, I'm leaving. It seems like a lot of us agree with this sentiment and I doubt you'll get an influx of users with how similar it will be to other sites. Implementing this will likely kill you instead of making you money like you want.

→ More replies (1)

53

u/KLR97 Mar 21 '17

So, I'm a mobile user who uses the desktop site. That user page is almost functionally broken.

→ More replies (7)

37

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Do you think this is the end of Reddit? This is such a stupid feature and direction for the website. I really hope this leads to the death of reddit so I can leave this shithole once and for all

How the fuck is there not more outrage over this?

→ More replies (7)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

"Hey guys, I hope you enjoyed my post. Be sure to follow my profile and hit that upvote button. I'll see you guys next time!"

I swear, the first time I see something like that I'm quitting Reddit.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

This is an awful idea. We've come to reddit specifically to get away form invasive sites like Facebook where your profiles are the focus of the site. Reddit is supposed to be like the anonymous chat-boards of old, but ideally) less toxic than 4chan due to it being slightly less anonymous with usernames. With a feature like this, our privacy is yet again being stripped away.

35

u/phaser_on_overload Mar 21 '17

So you want reddit to be facebook now? You realize most of us are trying to get away from facebook right? Reddit isn't a social media site, besides a very, very few recognizable users the beauty of reddit is that no one knows who anyone else is when they are replying to a comment. That's what makes this work.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I do not like this at all. I do not want Reddit to turn into a place where user fight over followers like every other social media sight in the world. This is also going to lead to brigading of a popular users post (which is already a problem on Reddit) and it will also be easy for corporations to get a ton of upovotes (because of brigading) on posts that are really just advertisements (which is also a huge problem on Reddit)

The fact that users can't have followers or "subs" is one of the Key factors of what seperates Reddit from other social media sites that exploit it's users for ad revenue.

PLEASE do not implement this feature.

74

u/SirSchnurrbart Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I really don't care for this...as others have stated I like the relative anonymity of Reddit and would like to keep it that way.

EDIT: I was thinking more generally that the platform of reddit would become less anonymous as a whole. I like that everyone is anonymous...no profiles, no "about me descriptions", no pictures...just a history of content.

→ More replies (14)

16

u/ShaneH7646 Mar 21 '17

Admins are doing there usual question dodging. Nice

16

u/shassamyak Mar 21 '17

It's bad,very bad. It will hinter the organic threads. It's like following celebrities on Instagram and twitter. This will create an even bigger echo chamber besides the users with good number of followers will start endorsing products subtly.

Is it some sort of way to try to monetize famous users so that seeing this other original creators leave different other sites and come here on reddit because of its huge number of users? Is this the way to monetize reddit?

16

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Noooo please, this isn't facebook. Not having a profile like that is exactly what makes reddit different, give us profiles and it's no different to facebook, twitter, instagram

69

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

There is way too much white space. It looks like crap on a smaller screen. What happened to being able to see comments, or comments and posts? What happened to trophies, subs they mod, etc? Why the push to make reddit more like facebook or twitter? If we wanted that, wouldn't we be there instead? What about the tabs at the top like gilded? Why is reddit constantly trying to come up with solutions to problems that don't exist instead of focusing on existing problems?

→ More replies (2)

57

u/LawlessCoffeh Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

It looks too much like Twitter in style if you ask me. I think a blurb about yourself and a user icon are welcome additions however. It may be important that we should also have the option to mark things as NSFW, Including our profile pictures.

While we're on the subject though.

I'd like to have the option to block other users from viewing where I'm active, and this seems like a perfect opportunity to debut that feature.

This privacy feature has been a feature I've wanted to be a part of reddit for ages, in addition to taking action against thoughtcrime bans in general.

This allows some subs such as /r/OffMyChest to make actual thought crime bans based on where you're active. Regardless if you've made a post or broken any rules there. (If you ask to be unbanned, They'll give you a canned response about these subreddits they don't approve of, And state that they'll only even think about talking to you if you promise to never post there again)

IMO this is a grievous overstep of their authority of mods of one subreddit, and y'know, going through someone's post history to dig up dirt on them is just a plain shitty thing to do ._.

→ More replies (3)

31

u/Haber_Dasher Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Part of the beauty of Reddit is that nobody is behind this username. There should be no reason for other users to visit each others pages unless to find something they posted. This is a move on the wrong direction, imo. The internet is full of a million different social networks and profiles, the last thing we need is Reddit to move in that direction too.

31

u/PM_ME_YOUR_SUNSHINE Mar 21 '17

No one asked for this. Now that we know what it is we don't want it. Leading content creators are chiming in here saying they don't want it. Its a shitty google plus-esque idea. Its a transparent money grab.

My question is; could you not??

→ More replies (1)

15

u/NPR_is_not_that_bad Mar 21 '17

By far my biggest worry is that this will give incentive for users to only post on their profile pages - completely changing the site and rendering subreddits as second thoughts.

I understand the urge to want to highlight users that post awesome and exciting stuff, and at times I too would love to have a more prominent platform, but honestly Reddit is great because it is anonymous and people contribute together towards making subreddits informative, interesting and funny.

Please do not allow narcissism to enter the fray.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ReyIsntACharacter Mar 21 '17

"I want reddit to be more like facebook" - some asshole somewhere.

15

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

People will like this. It's the people that are in love with themselves that will like this. There is a large market for that. Reddit grew into what it is by appealing to those that aren't JUST in love with themselves. The crowd that only social media's on reddit to avoid the people that are in love with themselves (me and I imagine a few others) will hate this. Everyone was equal in their anonymity... now fake profile pictures and manufactured identities will skew how people's contributions are judged. DO NOT CARE FOR THIS ONE BIT.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/AvgHeightForATree Mar 21 '17

Hi there /u/HideHideHidden, I'd like to thank you for the all of the enjoyment I've had since I migrated here from Digg, many, many years ago.

I came here back in the day because Digg decided to implement some kind of weird social-media/power-user system that caused all of the users to leave and basically destroyed Digg, as a business, overnight.

Could you offer some recommendations for Reddit alternatives, once you realise that this is a terrible idea?

→ More replies (3)

14

u/CoGrown23 Mar 21 '17

I really don't like the idea of Reddit turning into another social media site. If that's what your overall goal is then go for it. Otherwise, I think a lot of users aren't too keen on this idea and you could lose a lot of the users if you go through with it.

14

u/Smantie Mar 21 '17

You know what this sounds like? LiveJournal. Personal pages that people can comment, community pages (subreddits) to join and post on, hell you've even got avatars and banners. By the way, how are you going to police those? If another Fappening happens how will you make sure users don't put the pictures in their avatars or banners? Because that could get you a nice big pile of lawsuits.

You really should have done some site-wide market research on this, instead of just asking the people who make monetary profit.

14

u/goldenbirdies Mar 21 '17

Why would anyone want this? This is a shit idea that's going to kill reddit. I don't give a fuck who anyone is or what they're up to, I'm interested in ideas, not personalities.

Hopefully someone will hurry up and build a site like the old reddit without all this social profile shit and we can all move there.

14

u/JediWatchman Mar 21 '17

ooooooo wow! we can post direclty to our prifile

fuck off you stupid fucking admins

14

u/T_____________T Mar 21 '17

It looks like other social media sites. The thing I like about Reddit is that you don't have to put any effort into your profile - deciding on an icon, a witty introduction statement etc. If I feel like doing that I can visit any number of other sites. Here at Reddit I feel like I can just relax and be in the moment of a particular thread or comment. I'm so tired of the internet wanting us to build up followers or likes or whatever ... I just want to relax here at Reddit. Pls don't do this.

14

u/Zenai Mar 22 '17

I have never seen a comment thread on reddit so unanimous such as this one. That said, I totally agree with literally every other post here. Giving a place for companies to drive traffic to for their marketers instead of giving them incentive to actually participate in the community associated with their company (where the people are in control, and not the corporation) is just fucking bonkers.

13

u/JustJoeWiard Mar 21 '17

So every user's profile will include what is essentially their own sub now, right? Am I understanding that correctly?

→ More replies (1)

13

u/syd_oc Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

Just no, please don't. In case you've not noticed, reddit works fine as it is. Please don't turn it into Facebook light.

This is a shit idea and whoever came up with it should be forced to communicate only through MySpace untill they've learned their lesson.

No, bad reddit, bad!

13

u/TheDude9737 Mar 21 '17

This choice is the opposite of what makes Reddit's brand. It's the beginning of the end, for sure.

13

u/funkyblumpkin Mar 22 '17

This feels so wrong and not Reddit. Reddit should be organized based around ideas & topics, discussions should not revolve around individual redditors or profiles. It takes focus away from what makes this site great. Content creators (aka users) are here to make Subs better, not the other way around.

Also... Won't this inevitably take content away from the subs where these users USED to post? It seems like this will drain whatever is left from this awesome tool and subdivide it into another favebooky insta- bullshit feed.

Am I going too overboard here?

35

u/Creator13 Mar 21 '17

I've been reading some of the comments and your reactions, and I want to add this: it is not hard to post OC in subreddits and gain traction.

I am not necessarily a content creator, but I do provide original content to subreddits. I like to think this is my pseudo-anonymous account, since I also have an account to post some of the photos I make. I would not want to post these photos to my personal account, where they will be seen by no one because I have no followers. I want to post them to photo subreddits like r/EarthPorn, r/photography or r/photocritique. Of course, seasoned users will still keep doing things like this.

For new users this system is incredibly confusing. They will not gain any traction in their profile posts since their posts will not be seen in r/all and r/popular (I also think that profile posts shouldn't be seen in these subs). Twitter and Facebook both have more active single users than Reddit. When you make a system in Reddit that is comparable to these sites, new users will try to imitate what they've been doing over at those sites. For example, if I have the possibility to set a profile picture, I will to look more dedicated. It also looks so clumsy to keep the default picture. This will make me set a profile picture, which is something that doesn't fit into the spirit of Reddit at all. I can guarantee that this will turn Reddit more towards the FB/Twitter-side of the social media spectrum.

Another problem: You are testing this only with people that directly benefit of it, and for them I don't think this is a bad idea at all. But the results of the test will not at all be representative of the way it will work when it is rolled out.

Based on all this, I think it's an okay feature (not great, but okay) when you separate these new profile account from the average 'lurker and sometimes-poster' account. Maybe introduce a button "Turn into personal profile" which will then make Reddit treat your profile as a subreddit in every way, save for the fact you can also post to subreddits and comment sections under that name. I think it's a terrible idea to give this feature as a default for everyone, because it will turn Reddit into a Twitter clone with added subject pages (also called subreddits).

24

u/golf4miami Mar 21 '17

The styling of this is just not right. If you want to be another Facebook or Twitter then you have done the right thing. But I don't think Reddit should be emulating those platforms. I stay off FB as much as possible because I don't want too much of my stuff shared on there. The anonymity here is another reason I like it here. I only have to share what I want to share. Making me post a profile picture and allowing ANYONE to follow me is a mistake.

12

u/jippiejee Mar 21 '17

This will be such an easy way to bypass our spamfilter, I hope you'll come up with a solution to filter submissions and comments that link to profile page posts.

12

u/3xplease Mar 21 '17

This feels like taking away from the community and placing focus on individuals. Like every other social network. It sounds lame to me, not gonna lie. We all know that 'try' and 'alpha' really means you're doing it, and just figuring out the details. So that sucks. I'm tired of following people; I'm more interested in conversations than individuals.

12

u/NottHomo Mar 21 '17

yo, we facebook now

12

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I'm sure it will be as successful as Google+.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/sooperdavid Mar 21 '17

Sorry guys but I don't think this is a good idea. Reddit works for a reason. We don't want it to be about 1 person sharing content, its meant to be about community doing it together.

When we started /r/Reallifedoodles the idea was to get as many people involved as possible making fun gifs, not it being about one person. If I wanted that I would of started /r/sooperdaviddrawsfacesonvideos or something

I see you're trying to change things (I'm not sure why) but you have something that works and opening it up like this seems quite digg like.

It seems a bit like you are trying to decide what people want to see, that you know best. You don't know what people want and it annoys people when you decide for them.

Maybe I am misunderstanding this feature but I don't think its what Reddit wants. I hope you dont mess this up.

12

u/7hr0wn Mar 21 '17

Will there be a way to completely opt-out of this system? Based on what I'm reading this profile system seems to be the exact opposite of what I use reddit for. Implement it for those who want it, but don't force those of us who don't to have profiles. I don't want my front page clogged with people's profiles, either.

Honestly, this seems like a huge step in the wrong direction...

→ More replies (1)

23

u/tragopanic Mar 21 '17

As a redditor for more than 10 years, the two things I'm proud of most are the subreddits I moderate and the trophies I accrued. Does this take away both? I'm on mobile and the example profiles are a mess (completely unreadable), so forgive me if I simply missed them.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

I see from the alpha user profiles there are posts to their profile listed directly next to their posts in other subreddits. Everyone has been told time and time again that voting on stuff from a user's profile page is bad and will get your account suspended. Is there a change on the official stance for this now? When I view someone's profile page do I need to be careful to only vote on stuff submitted directly to their profile and not stuff submitted to subreddits?

11

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

So Reddit is turning into Facebook. Awesome /s.

11

u/5k1895 Mar 21 '17

Nope. Do not want. Terrible fucking idea. This is the first step into fundamentally turning Reddit into Facebook. This place thrives because of the individual communities where like minded people can talk about whatever they're into. Honestly....what in the hell are you guys thinking?

11

u/craptaxi Mar 21 '17

Play this off as a big April fools joke and save face

11

u/Orlando_Curioso Mar 21 '17
  1. Where do I go if I want to learn about somebody or follow somebody's work? Their website. Facebook. Instagram. Twitter. Where do I not go (and not want to go)? Reddit.

If I am interested enough in a particular piece of content on Reddit, I will seek out the creator elsewhere.

2) Opt-in and opt-out is a false choice. I can see no realistic way that this does not fundamentally impact the way that Reddit is used. The opt-in and opt-out decision is one that would take place within the new system, not one that would determine anything about its being in place. In other words, this is not like: "In addition to checkers, we now also offer chess, and you can choose either"; this is like: "Instead of checkers, we now offer chess--but you can continue to play by the rules of checkers if you like." The game is just different!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/yeahsureYnot Mar 22 '17

This is a shitty idea and you all know it's a shitty idea. This isn't a typical "they changed the page format/menu/ui" complaint that we used to see from Facebook. This is a fundamental change in the way this site works and generates content.

11

u/speehcrm1 Mar 22 '17

Can't you see nobody likes this idea? I hope you enjoy the temporary boost in cash flow before this website pulls another Digg you fucking idiots

20

u/Stabilobossorange Mar 21 '17

You're trying to make this platform into social media. I purposely use reddit for how different, enraging and thoughtful it can be. Not because I want to waste my time with frivolous profile pages. If it moves into that direction, i will leave, just as I have with others.

Reddit has always had something special but movies like this, to homogenise the experience provided, with every other social media platform will be the end of that quality.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

Aaaand the downfall of reddit begins.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/__Iniquity__ Mar 21 '17

Meh... Not thrilled with this one.

10

u/rickarooo Mar 21 '17

Everyone will oppose this because it takes power away from users, mods, and subreddits.

The admins will push it through anyways because it gives power to corporations and advertisers, who will give money to the admins because they can now better control conversations about their products.

This is just the next step in reddits inevitable decline, and another example of how greed corrupts.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

/u/Shitty_Watercolour why the fuck would you support this shitty idea

10

u/Optewe Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

This feels vehemently anti-Reddit at its core. Consider me against this.

10

u/2Dement3D Mar 22 '17

You guys seem incredibly out of touch with your users.

10

u/freejosephk Mar 22 '17

literally the worst thing you can do, Reddit. I know my voice is small, but guess what, I don't want other peoples' voice to be big.

this is just utter garbage. literal barf.

way to wreck Reddit, hosers!!!

fucken seriously...what are you thinking? why would you do this? it makes no sense.

19

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

So its Facebook now? Why don't you just add the option to label it as Oc when posting? Then have it link to your username the same way all your other posts do.

Edit: I had more words. I use Reddit because its not Facebook but it is already close enough to make me uncomfortable. Any more steps toward it and I'll have to use something like 4chan instead. Looks like private browsing for me from now on.

9

u/Hermitia Mar 21 '17

So, facebook then. Yay

9

u/pSyChO_aSyLuM Mar 21 '17

It seems like many aren't fans of this new feature, myself included. I think it's just going to take away from already established communities/subreddits and seems like a waste of time.

9

u/Sevenrue Mar 21 '17

I come here because it's not Facebook. Now you want to make it Facebook? I would be upset but willing to just not come here anymore. I'm one person so what's it matter to you anyway.

9

u/twists Mar 21 '17

I don't understand is reddit facebook/twitter now? Like this will only be beneficial to the top 1% karama whores of reddit. No one else is going to follow me for my great post that got 3 upvotes on /r/hockey. This just makes reddit look like its trying super hard to be it's distant social media cousin. If i wanted to follow someone I'd go to twitter or facebook. Reddit is a place of some anonymity. It also takes away from people visiting and contributing to subreddits. Why go to a subreddit if I can just visit someones facebook page, oops I mean reddit user page.

9

u/probablyuntrue Mar 21 '17

I use reddit because it's at least partially anonymous. This just removes the appeal of the site for me, if I want to follow people and post on walls I'll use facebook or twitter

9

u/star-gazed Mar 21 '17

I just felt sad when I read this. This destroys all the things that makes reddit unique. I know I'm repeating what other people have commented, but it's important for you guys to know that this is a big mistake.

9

u/prospectTV Mar 21 '17

All this does is silence dissenting views on products and companies by letting the company control the narrative. This is just another nail in the coffin.

9

u/spinsilo Mar 21 '17

Based on the replies to this post, it looks like Reddit is hellbent on bulldozing through this feature that no one wants.

Reddit, you would do well to listen to the users on this. You have a very passionate user base, and you are about to give everyone the finger here. Nothing will be gained from this. No company is bigger than it's user base.

We are here for the communities which are the backbone of Reddit. If you try to sway the balance in favour of brands and individuals, we will move on very quickly. Reddit is an extremely discerning community and a replacement will quickly be found. Our loyalty only goes so far. And if this becomes another ego driven user/brand orientated network, people won't stick around.

9

u/Sir_Grox Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

Fuck off, this is a pathetic corporate takeover and we all know it.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Yeah. I'll just leave Reddit if this happens. This is the kind of stuff that made me leave Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat ..

9

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

It's gonna take spez a really, really long time to edit all these posts to be supportive of this unpopular idea.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

"Yay another profile!" said no one. Ever.

So this is how reddit ends? This is so sad.

9

u/Laughing_Bandit Mar 22 '17 edited Nov 12 '24

important shelter lavish lush hard-to-find one public alive doll mysterious

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (1)

9

u/psychyness Mar 22 '17

It's funny because Reddit doesn't actually care about our opinions on this matter. They've already decided to move this direction and the odds of them changing their minds at this point are slim to none.

The only reason they are pitching the idea to us this way is to try and ease us into the drastic changes coming up.

I was considering sticking around to see this play out but I already know how this ends.

Just saying good bye to all you fellow redditors. I'm going to try out a couple of these alternative sites or maybe even 4chan.

It's been real. It's been fun. But it hasn't been real fun.

43

u/tuba_jewba Mar 21 '17

Don't fix things that aren't broken

24

u/zgf2022 Mar 21 '17

Can i opt out-out now and forever?

Do not want.

17

u/LordofCookies Mar 21 '17

I really don't want Reddit to turn into a social media page.
This will end up taking people away from subreddits and making them follow specific profiles (where the owners have total mod power over the content).

But I get it. This system is better for profiles that need/want proliferation. It's not something that I agree with (we already have Facebook and Twitter for that) but, oh well, business is business

Wasn't Reddit supposed to be a forum for anything and everything?

17

u/notwherethewindblows Mar 21 '17

Sounds like everyone really hates this stupid idea. Well done, Reddit. Might as well just reactivate my facebook at this point. Maybe I should consider joining twitter, too! I like Reddit because it's about following communities built on specific interests/topics, NOT following specific people who post whatever they feel like just to get attention.

I sincerely hope that you made this post so you could get feedback from redditors and that you'll actually take what we feel into consideration. Stop this nonsense now before you disappoint your users.

36

u/ignisanulum Mar 21 '17

But.. why? Reddit is about content, not people.

→ More replies (8)

16

u/itsaride Mar 21 '17

Pron profiles incoming!

16

u/aythekay Mar 21 '17

I feel like this could kill Reddits Content Quality.

It would handicap subReddits by creating a group of "Influencers"; similar to Instagram and vine; that would get priority over other users content, basically rendering the "Best" rating useless.

Content on Reddit is democratic, you look into a Topic/sub you like and find cool shit, if you add in "influencers", you intentionally subvert that.

I 'm not saying don't do it, I'm just saying be careful, by imitating other Social Media, you're abandoning your core competencies.

8

u/CalibanDrive Mar 21 '17

How will you protect users from being harassed? Will users be able to block and delete problem commenters? Will users be able to allow commenters on a case-by-case basis? Will users be allowed to opt-out of this feature all together

8

u/daytdog Mar 21 '17

I don't like this at all.

As others have pointed out, this change makes reddit seem more like a shittier version of every other social media platform. What makes reddit unique, at least for me, is the fact that I don't have to follow specific people to find content that I like, and that those same people aren't the ones that dictate what gets posted. This addition may give newcomers a bad idea about what reddit actually has its roots in -- community.

Maybe from a business perspective you guys may be thinking this is a great addition because it has all of the quirks that other social platforms have that lead them to success. I disagree.

8

u/FreddyFuego Mar 21 '17

Have any comments in here been edited by /u/spez?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/krugerlive Mar 21 '17

Please do not do this. I've been on this site over 9 years partly because of its focus on the discussion rather than the people discussing.

This may seem like a good idea to you guys, but it's not. You're killing the special sauce that makes reddit reddit. I'm sorry you don't see this.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '17

I am ugly which is why I don't have profile pics anywhere. I have no friends and no one cares about me so I quit Facebook. I am not interesting enough so I don't have followers on Twitter. Reddit was the only place where I didn't feel miserable. You had to ruin that didn't you.

8

u/Christoph3r Mar 21 '17

"Selected redditors will be able to post directly to their profile"

Fuck you for only allowing "select" people to do this. Really. Way to go, make the "ordinary" Redditor feel evel less special, less included, just generally less compared to those that you somehow deem as more special. A real asshole move.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/GeekScientist Mar 21 '17 edited Mar 21 '17

What the fuck. I got rid of every single social media account I had because I got tired of the popularity/pissing contest these kinds of websites create, but it seems like Reddit has finally succumbed to the FB/Twitter overlords. You know what sucks even more? This is going to kill subreddits; years of hard work are going down the drain in a blink of an eye. "Who needs subreddits when I can just follow the actual 'content-creator' instead amirite?!?!" I personally don't care about following others, that's why I joined Reddit.

This is frustrating. Good grief.

8

u/MisterTruth Mar 21 '17

Something tells me they will only get positive feedback from the beta testers since they will all be a select group of people they feel will confirm their biases.

8

u/gentlemandinosaur Mar 22 '17

This will pretty much eliminate /r/AMA.

They saw a chance to pull power away from that subreddit and took it. Now the admins can moderate the AMAs.

8

u/spoonycoot Mar 22 '17

This is fucking stupid

8

u/KnottyKitty Mar 22 '17

Are you guys trying to become Facebook?

I very much prefer the current semi-anonymity of reddit. No userpics, no giant banners, no bullshit.

Also, are you even familiar with reddit users? We're kind of a messed up bunch. Letting everyone choose images to go along with their profile is going to result in a million pics of dickbutt and probably at least a few pics of actual dicks in actual butts. Or dead babies. Or who knows what. Every quick visit to someone's profile will be a risky click. At least threads can have a NSFW/NSFL tag, warning us that we're about to see something unpleasant.

This is going to be a disaster. Get out the popcorn everyone!

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

RIP reddit You got fucked by this idiot CEO

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17 edited Mar 22 '17

This new rollout will fundamentally change the make up of reddit. It will no longer be about community and communication under a layer of quirky anonymity. It will pull in the Facebook people and thus reddit will become about self-promotion. New content will be often monopolized by personal accounts and people would be "forced" to follow others. From my point of view, I hate the idea of having to subscribe to other people's feeds. I want to subscribe to a community and banter with them. Please, for the love of anything that is good and genuine and fun in this world, do not take away our reddit and turn it into fucking Facebook.

8

u/bathrobehero Mar 22 '17

This goes against what makes reddit unique.

Reddit "forces" non-lurkers to participate because whenever they post something others can start a conversation. If people can post without the possibility of others reacting to it, people will not be participating, just essentially talking to themselves without any positive or negative reinforcements - as it is the case on many social media sites.

And a lot of content from companies and content creators would disappear from subreddits as people would only share them on their profile page. So subreddits, and therefore reddit as a whole would be much less useful.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Please no. I'm here to be anonymous and connect over interests and content. Profiles create cults of personality and branding. We don't need that here.

8

u/Hellman109 Mar 22 '17

Why are you taking away the focus from Subreddits, both the name and their importance to Reddit?

I believe this will make small communities on Reddit beholden to the larger posters. So for instance you have a small but well functioning subreddit and suddenly soemone with a lot of profile followers posts in your subreddit? Like it or not, you're subreddit just got brigaded.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17 edited Apr 18 '18

deleted 0.7136 What is ^^^this?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

I've already commented on this but I have to comment again. The greatest thing of Reddit is it brings so much content to users and not the bullshit we see on Facebook/Twitter.

I've been introduced to whole other world's out there, expanded my horizons, learned new things, found new hobbies and spoken to great people.

I get the pleasure when I come across comments from famous redditors, because it's in the moment and I didn't search for it.

Don't change our internet home, it's where people of all backgrounds can come together and not be judged off face value.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/speehcrm1 Mar 22 '17

Here it is folks, the site-killer

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Lol "content creators" ... you mean advertisers

It's a sad day when 4chan starts to look better than reddit

8

u/wildwalrusaur Mar 22 '17

I am strongly opposed to this idea.

Reddit is the only social media site I use with any regularly (haven't logged into Facebook since Christmas). This seems like the first step towards facebook-izing Reddit.

If that happens, I'll simply stop using this site too.

8

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '17

Wow, I've scrolled through a lot of parent comments and, so far, I've yet to see a positive comment.

As nobody else will see this due if being late, I guess this is aimed squarely at the admin that posted it.

It's overwhelmingly clear that this is unwanted. How you proceed from here on out could very well decide if reddit lives or dies. You say you are taking feedback into account, we will soon see if that is true. If this idea goes ahead, it is clear that reddit is no longer for the users. It would be a shame if that happened but, to be honest, that's exactly what I'm expecting.

I've had a good six year run here, I'd love to see another six but I don't see it happening.

As one more voice in the crowd, please don't do this.

15

u/Dont____Panic Mar 21 '17

I posted this in /r/beta also... but:

On this page:

https://www.reddit.com/user/Shitty_Watercolour

There is a link on the new profile-post to: "(self.Shitty_Watercolour)".

This link points to: https://www.reddit.com/domain/self.Shitty_Watercolour/

Clicking this link results in a redirect loop in all browsers I have tried (Chrome, FireFox and Internet Explorer). Both logged in and not logged in, with and without RES.

Night mode: false
RES Version: 5.4.3
Browser: Chrome
Browser Version: 56
Cookies Enabled: true
Reddit beta: false

→ More replies (1)