r/FreeGameFindings • u/StOoPiD_U Creator • Jul 26 '17
Mod Post Google Authentication, VK, Ghame.RU: What Stays, What Goes (Strawpolls)
Main EDIT: I feel like this bears repeating. As per usual, with every vote and discussion we have about this. The strawpolls wont be the only thing that we use to make a decision. Just because they are one way, doesn't mean it's the one we go with. Comments help more. Everything is going to be taken into consideration.
Been wanting to look into these things for a while. Touch up on old bans, look at hidden removal items, come to a good conclusion for now.
Google. We banned the use of google/youtube authentication for giveaway offers some time back. At the time, there was worry it was too invasive, and that it was a lot of permissions to give up. Some time has passed, and this form of authentication has started to rise with some sites again. So good time to review it. Should we undo our ban here? Should we adjust it to only allow certain permissions? Vote below, and let your voice be heard in the comments as well!
VK. This is one I know little of personally, but it should be discussed. From what I know, VK is another form of authentication, primarily used in Russia (shot in the dark there). I've only seen the thing used in Russian sites, whatever. Anyway, there's a big issue that lies here. It requires your phone number to work. Little odd to give that up for offers. It's a bit much, and I'm inclined to go against it, but let me know what you think.
Ghame(dot)ru. I know very little here again, but here it goes. Russian site, messy, broken offers(?), triggers virus detectors, etc. Again, inclined to continue with axing it, but I've heard from a few people now that it's a perfectly usable site, and that they've gotten items from there plenty of times. So I don't know.
Alright, so let me know what you think. Comments and votes are very much appreciated. Thanks for reading!
EDIT: Fixed typos, and the link for the third vote.
EDIT2: I suck, fucked up the title a little in the third vote. Still works though.
8
u/AlexBear012 Jul 26 '17
what about the queue site one? keychampions
5
u/Trislar Ex-Moderator Jul 26 '17
Ghame is fully tied to the VK vote basically.
A 4th vote to put up about Browser extensions.
3
u/retsamyar Jul 29 '17
I just wonder why we keep revisiting this google/youtube question. It is a matter of privacy and the requested authentication is extremely invasive. Nothing has changed so why are we revisiting this? Or is it just a matter of pushing it on us until the site owners get enough fools to vote for it with the promise of free keys?
11
u/timtimH Jul 26 '17
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VK_(social_networking) VK is the among the top 10 most popular websites in the world and has a pretty clean record. OFC you can trust them with your phone.
If you don't like the GA, don't enter, it's that simple, expecially if there are flares for that. I'm already forced to manually check some of the banned sites because a bunch if selfish pricks didn't want to set up a flare filter and instead decided to ruin it for everybody like a dog in the manger. If you want to ban everything that displeases your clique, consider setting up a twin reddit without dumb restrictions or something.
2
u/unhi Jul 26 '17
I believe the 3rd poll is wrong. It's got the same question about VK as the 2nd poll.
7
u/13_is_a_lucky_number Jul 27 '17
No, No and No. It's good that the three aforementioned things aren't allowed here, in my opinion ;)
5
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
Where is the mavelousga?
3
u/andercosta2016 Jul 27 '17
Got Bacteria on ghame.ru. I have an antivirus protection on my browser, but this site doesn't allow adblocks. This site has tasks needing VK account. I had to make a VK account to make this tasks, and don't have any problem.
3
u/varishtg Jul 27 '17
I'm surprised with where the polls are going. Steam auth should be the basic auth to be used for giving away all things steam. Why do they want our google auth. And it's not just simple token with an age range and other stuff, but a whole bunch of permissions, which can be pretty invasive. Next thanks to google auth maybe they'll even start asking to post stuff on google plus. We already have FB and Twitter.
As for VK, yes it is a somewhat reputable SNS in Europe and Russia, however it doesn't mean, you gotta join that as well. In that case we might as well join Baidu, tencent, line and the rest of the networks. Most people joining it via here are joining it for the giveaway. What the giveaway sites want is to promote their giveaway. Dunno how new users are going to be helpful here. Chances are the account will be flagged and or considered as spam and could face a Temp ban. Thought this is true for almost all social networks, we'd rather use our existing accounts than something new.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '17
Pretty much everyone else doesn't have these requirements to collect a 1 euro steam key... Why shouldn't these new sites adapt to their desired audience? Get rid of vk authentication, use facebook / steam auth instead. We never had those types of requirements before, neither should we allow them. An obnoxious precedent could be made here, just my 2c.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
well, i made a fake google for giveaways, and i did the same for vk, even if im not russian, its no biggie.
but the weird third site looks shady to me and should be banned.
2
u/AmeliaLovende123 Jul 27 '17
But I hate chroma browser and I'm user of Mozilla Firefox :3
0
u/Saulios Moderator Jul 26 '17
It is my opinion, but I think a subreddit should be banning close to nothing. And especially not authentication/permission things. People should be able to decide for themselves what they want or don't want to share, where needed posts can be flaired properly to warn, and/or automoderator (or our moderators) can post detailed warnings about what a website requires to receive a key from a giveaway on that website.
I know that some websites can take it (too) far regarding how to complete the giveaway, with cheap hosting/design, long lists of tasks, forced social media accounts, browser extensions (to name a few). But I think we need to properly warn people for this, not bluntly ban in every case.
On another note, this subreddit is not the only place where these websites are shared (various Steam groups and r/freegamesonsteam, to name a few). Banning them here won't likely change a lot on their side (certainly for Steam giveaways).
1
u/TheFapIsUp Jul 27 '17
Just voicing my opinion on getkeys.net, I've personally never had any success with this website, and I tried on my account and my GF's. I always either get a duplicate key, no key, or giveaway is over as soon as it's posted. Can we have a poll to see how the subreddit feels about this website?
1
u/Satsuz Jul 27 '17
I voted "No." for all of these, but my position is slightly more nuanced than that.
Sketchy shit needs to be ruled out, immediately. So it's a hard no on Ghame.
Phone numbers, obviously I don't want to ever give mine out. Anything that requires them should be no-go. As long as VK does that, then any giveaways requiring VK should be banned. If, however, VK is one option among others to participate? That is fine, because there is a route to the giveaway without divulging your phone number. It's unclear to me whether or not this is current policy, so I figured I would throw this out there.
As for Google/Youtube, I wouldn't mind it if we could be sure that the permissions were reasonable and safe. It does concern me greatly, though, because what might happen is we wind up with sites trying to push on that boundary or fool people into letting them cross it. Incidents seem a bit too likely to happen, since verifying the permissions means more work on behalf of the mod team.
1
u/ssszenith Jul 27 '17
i don't like to give phone number but twitter banned my account and will only unlock it if i add it, was using to enter givwaways and follow some stuff i like, that's extortion...no i still haven't told them my phone, but then i'm using another old acount of mine but not even entering giveaways with it to prevent a ban...
i don't approve any of the companies now demanding our phone like they are entitled to it, all of them, fb, vk, twitter, whatever...
but i'm pretty sure all of them require it to sign up now, shameful
1
u/steami Jul 27 '17
voted, thanks for making the polls!
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
I just made an vk account, gooddammit. Why not just put on a filter?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
You've been watching too many cold war era movies.
VK is pretty much Russian Facebook. It's one of the most popular sites in the world. More popular than Instagram and LinkedIn.
So does Google when you have Android and Facebook. In fact, if you don't have a phone number, Facebook will ask for scan of your ID.
1
u/Z2K1 Jul 28 '17
I personally used it to get multiple keys and it's great http://i.imgur.com/BeRy5cB.png
1
u/StrawberryGhostie Jul 27 '17
I don't think VK is harmful. As said, if people don't want to use it, well, they won't do.
1
u/fondleear Jul 27 '17
Nothing wrong with VK.
I was using them for mafia 2 mods long before they popped up in free game giveaways.
A few russian modders use VK to post links for mod updates and other stuff.
1
u/Necronomicron Jul 27 '17
Please, rename this subreddit to "BannedGiveaways" to fit the content.
0
u/water-monkey Jul 26 '17
I don't understand the issue with VK a lot of people have, all posts that require it are marked, it's very easy to set up an account. If you don't want to use it that's fine but why remove for other people? Just because it's Russian doesn't mean it's malicious.
0
u/codebreaker29 Jul 27 '17
my suggestion : Google should not be allowed
Other side : VK should be allowed as most of us barely use VK and i dont think much info is there on VK to be stolen or Misused
-1
u/termi21 Jul 27 '17 edited Jul 27 '17
Funny... i voted the opposite from the majority on all 3 questions.
Google -> No giving stupid permissions on Google/Youtube/Twitter should not be accepted. There was no "allow certain permissions" as you mentioned it in the above paragraph... so between just "yes" and just "no" the obvious answer is No. The better answer is to allow authentication with only very strict permissions. The majority voted "yes"... Weird.
VK -> VK is fine. It's the Russian FB. Maybe people should stop being afraid of everything Russian? It's getting funny. The majority voted "no"... (lol) PS. I am not from Russia
Ghame.ru -> Another site which i got 5 keys. Without any problems. No virus alerts. No nothing. So the answer is "yes". Although today in Bacteria they added the Google Auth thing which i DON'T LIKE. Cut the cr@p Ghame.ru, you were fine before and still most of the other people didn't like you, don't make it worse.
So the majority is ok to give stupid permissions on important accounts (google, youtube, etc), but they are afraid to register on the Russian FB. That makes zero sense. Really.
PS. Personally, the only site i don't use, is the one with the f@cking extension. I ain't installing sh!t for $0.03 games. Forget about it. Extensions are dangerous. And even if it is ok now, it can be updated to become malicious. So NO to that site.
0
u/Timmerito Jul 27 '17
Lol all of these surveys say no, so soon there won't be any free games left here
0
u/Necronomicron Jul 27 '17 edited Jul 27 '17
There is no any problem with VK, you will give your phone number to VK and not to those who create giveaways, you will never get spam or whatever on your phone and noone will know your number. Also it has english language so there shouldn't be any trouble with it. It is the same as Facebook (phone number looks like excuse) and noone complain about Facebook. Let's then ban Facebook and Twitter giveaways!
0
u/eilegz Jul 27 '17
I dont think that the use of VK should be a problem, the only issue with all the new website its how crap or unavailable it is, because those giveaway its running on a potato server, and making it a f5 simulator its just not right, what we should filter also its those giveaways with misleading titles, ambiguous tasks or fraudulent one that ask you to do the task but give you bad keys or dont give one at all
0
u/mrfun1993 Jul 27 '17
Repeat vote
0
u/robdiazbel Jul 27 '17 edited Jul 27 '17
You are being a crying baby about this, first you get a throwaway gmail account, and create athrowaway fb page, a throwaway steam account (this is what i did, you can use a spare code to get some shitty game on it) Now every time you open a giveaway, do it into incognito mode, since you (should) already have used the fb page, google account and steam account (disable the secure thing so you don't have to enter the code everytime) in your browser and have saved the passwords, it's just log in in every service IF you are asked to... about VK you should hit ->log in -> log in with fb -> you accept that vk uses you fb account (and fake cel number) and reload the page (and remember to hit the "..." next to follow and select suscribe to notifications) I voted "YES" to all Since you should always have a throwaway mail, the rest of the steps should always be easy.
0
u/fondleear Jul 28 '17
Just because a few people are butthurt coz VK doesn't work for them is no reason to ban a site that has VK as a requirement.
STOP WHINING !
I'm in London UK and have no probs. using vk .
Been using them for a few years now.
-2
u/PiSakura Jul 27 '17
The second and third should be allowed
0
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment