r/MobiusFF • u/vulcanfury12 • Dec 06 '17
Tech | Analysis EE vs. Magic, and Diminishing Returns: A Case Study
INTRODUCTION
Whenever a a player achieves a HOF or obtains a new Job, they go to the daily questions thread and ask: What Custom Panels should I use for more damage? The reply is usually Element Enhancement. However, with the introduction of HOF and jobs with MASSIVE EE (like S1C and his 250% Earth Enhancement) Magic panels suddenly find themselves in the spotlight because adding more EE in this case will yield a lot of diminishing returns. The issue is that no one quantifies this, because no matter which you choose, you are affected by it. The question should be: By how much? So, I took it upon myself and tried a test scenario.
THE SCENARIO
To find out which panels will do more damage, I took my HOF S1C with the following stats:
Job: HOF S1C
Magic: 738
Element Enhance 305
Card Base Attack: 851
Card Final Attack Stat: 28882
The Card Base I used is an Alvl 8 Ranger Hecatoncheir Sicarius. The Final Stat is the number you see in the Abilities section of the Deck Builder. You can see the total Element Enhance of the job in the Auto section. To see the effects of these panels, we will only take into account the Final Attack Stat (because considering debuffs, buffs, other abilities like improved crits and Break status of the target would introduce too many variables.) From these, we can work back the Final Attack Stat formula:
Final Attack Stat = Card Base Attack * (1 + (Total Magic/100)) * (1 + (Total Element Enhance/100))Plugging in the numbers from our control scenario will yield the same Final Attack Stat. This is also the reason for the diminishing returns, because you are adding to a modifier (magic or EE) instead of multiplying the whole thing when you add the custom panels. From here, I calculated the values assuming you add 12 Custom Panels: one scenario for all magic panels, and another scenario for all Element Enhancements.
Custom Panels | Cumulative Magic | Cumulative Earth Enhance | Card Attack (Magic Panels) | Increase vs. Control | Diminishing Returns | Card Attack (Enhance Element) | Increase vs. Control | Diminishing Returns
- |- |- |- |- |- |- |- |- | 1 | 12 | 5 | 29,295.68 | 1.43% | 1.43% | 29,238.66 | 1.23% | 1.23% 2 | 24 | 10 | 29,709.26 | 2.86% | 1.41% | 29,595.23 | 2.47% | 1.22% 3 | 36 | 15 | 30,122.85 | 4.30% | 1.39% | 29,951.80 | 3.70% | 1.20% 4 | 48 | 20 | 30,536.43 | 5.73% | 1.37% | 30,308.37 | 4.94% | 1.19% 5 | 60 | 25 | 30,950.02 | 7.16% | 1.35% | 30,664.93 | 6.17% | 1.18% 6 | 72 | 30 | 31,363.61 | 8.59% | 1.34% | 31,021.50 | 7.41% | 1.16% 7 | 84 | 35 | 31,777.19 | 10.02% | 1.32% | 31,378.07 | 8.64% | 1.15% 8 | 96 | 40 | 32,190.78 | 11.46% | 1.30% | 31,734.64 | 9.88% | 1.14% 9 | 108 | 45 | 32,604.36 | 12.89% | 1.28% | 32,091.21 | 11.11% | 1.12% 10 | 120 | 50 | 33,017.95 | 14.32% | 1.27% | 32,447.78 | 12.35% | 1.11% 11 | 132 | 55 | 33,431.54 | 15.75% | 1.25% | 32,804.35 | 13.58% | 1.10% 12 | 144 | 60 | 33,845.12 | 17.18% | 1.24% | 33,160.92 | 14.81% | 1.09%
As you can see, from this scenario, adding Magic results in more damage for our S1C. This is mainly due to the very high Element Enhance. But what if he didn't have the Earth Enhance Panel from HOF?
SCENARIO 2
Job: HOF S1C
Magic: 738
Element Enhance 55
Card Base Attack: 851
Final Attack Stat: 11053
Custom Panels | Cumulative Magic | Cumulative Earth Enhance | Card Attack (Magic Panels) | Increase vs. Control | Diminishing Returns | Card Attack (Enhance Element) | Increase vs. Control | Diminishing Returns
- |- |- |- |- |- |- |- |- | 1 | 12 | 5 | 11,211.93 | 1.43% | 1.43% | 11,410.21 | 3.23% | 3.23% 2 | 24 | 10 | 11,370.21 | 2.86% | 1.41% | 11,766.78 | 6.45% | 3.13% 3 | 36 | 15 | 11,528.50 | 4.30% | 1.39% | 12,123.35 | 9.68% | 3.03% 4 | 48 | 20 | 11,686.78 | 5.73% | 1.37% | 12,479.92 | 12.90% | 2.94% 5 | 60 | 25 | 11,845.07 | 7.16% | 1.35% | 12,836.48 | 16.13% | 2.86% 6 | 72 | 30 | 12,003.36 | 8.59% | 1.34% | 13,193.05 | 19.35% | 2.78% 7 | 84 | 35 | 12,161.64 | 10.02% | 1.32% | 13,549.62 | 22.58% | 2.70% 8 | 96 | 40 | 12,319.93 | 11.46% | 1.30% | 13,906.19 | 25.81% | 2.63% 9 | 108 | 45 | 12,478.21 | 12.89% | 1.28% | 14,262.76 | 29.03% | 2.56% 10 | 120 | 50 | 12,636.50 | 14.32% | 1.27% | 14,619.33 | 32.26% | 2.50% 11 | 132 | 55 | 12,794.79 | 15.75% | 1.25% | 14,975.90 | 35.48% | 2.44% 12 | 144 | 60 | 12,953.07 | 17.18% | 1.24% | 15,332.47 | 38.71% | 2.38%
As you can see, adding Enhance Element in this case will yield a lot more damage than Magic.
CONCLUSION
For the number crunchers of this sub, it shouldn't be any surprise. If your job has:
- High Magic but Low EE, adding EE gives a lot more damage
- Low Magic but high EE, adding Magic gives a lot more damage
But for those who don't do the computations and/or newbies, you now have quantifiable proof and a method to test things out for yourself. Also, for those wondering why the Magic Panels give 12 instead of 8, stats from Custom Panels also seem to be subjected to the HOF Stat Multiplier.
EDIT:
For those who want to try and do their own calculations, go to this link and download a local copy.
8
u/deathrose55555 [JP] 1051-9193-b915 (KotR X) Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Good work, though admittedly the situation might get more complicating once you factor in buffs to Magic (e.g. Faith / Trance) and buff to EE (e.g. EE buffs / Ability Chain / Martial Combat / Berserk)
Alternatively, players can try out this custom panel simulator from Altema (if you can navigate around...); things might get less clear-cut when a job has high Magic / high EE (e.g. Sword Saint) or low Magic / low EE (e.g. Fist Saint)
4
u/MrGianni89 Dec 06 '17
I mean I get the suggestion, but what can be considered high EE or magic?
S1c has around 800 magic and 300% element, as ace striker. 800 is to be considered low? and 300 hight?
What abouth the mythic (hof) sage. It will have high magic (i suppose around 1300) and low element. So I should just pick fire or wind and +% element of one of the two? What a waste!
4
u/mao_shiro Actual Evil Reddit Mod Dec 06 '17
Added your thread to the list, good work !
2
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '17
Beautiful! That was an excellent study!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Not sure how to explain, but it ain't hard to just remember the following: x*y=z if x is the greater value, it will always be better to max y until it reaches x. If you increase the smaller number of both, you will add the greater number one time. If you increase the greater value of both by one, you are simply adding the smaller number to it. Thats why i prefer new coefficents (like Chains or Weakness), because this is the greatest increase of dmg, we can get(weapons, some cards like Bahamut: FFXIV, or HoF Panels). Btw, sorry for my horrible description.
4
u/Logan_Maransy Dec 06 '17
Because the two stats are weighted equally, you ideally want them to be the same to maximize damage. However that concept has built into itself the fact that adding 1 to one of the stats is equivalent to adding 1 to the other stat. We see very clearly that is not the case here so the optimization is a little more complex. As shown in this example, you are able to add 144 magic and only 60 EE for the same "cost" (filling up the custom panels).
So the general rule of thumb is the following: whichever stat you can increase more of proportionally when it is in the multiplier form, that's what you should add to your custom panel. The multiplier form is the (1+stat/100) number, not just the stat number.
1
u/Bop_Bi Dec 06 '17
How about it if I add 12 x Attack +10? I had Ragnarok + 25% Earth!
1
u/Mobius1337 https://www.twitch.tv/mobiusfm Dec 06 '17
I think you have to factor trance and faith in your calculations or else your results will never be completly accurate. Last time I checked, EE was better in the altema damage calculator.
1
u/irikyu Dec 06 '17
I noticed this with Mage and AS.
My Mage has around 1.2k magic and 355% water enhance while my AS has around 800 magic and 396% water enhance (AS is using the EE panels).
I've noticed a huge difference in damage. With my mage I can beat a broken sicarius using 1 blue varuna while on AS i need around 3 blue varunas.
Based on this does this mean that the 400% magic difference is a big difference maker?
1
u/chkkrt Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Without HOF, magic should be increase by 8% per panel only.
And I expect diminishing return to have positive slope (the more u add, the size of diminishing increase.) so, question about how it’s calculate.
Oh. and lv8 sic card should be 766 attack power, iirc.
1
u/lcmc Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
One thing to note is generally EE should still be better due to the fact a 200 magic weapon is pretty common for people who have been playing a while, and people are more likely to use magic fractals over EE fractals since they are more versatile across jobs and builds. The weapon and the fractals will likely give ~300-350 more magic to any job greatly increasing magic panels diminishing returns.
Edit* for example my s1c with his normal build is at 900 magic even without magic panels.
1
u/Xenomorphica Dec 06 '17
This is the obvious to most people though. What people generally ask is when you have both high magic AND high ee, what should they do, because every other time than that it's pretty obvious what gives more of an increase. What they really need is some kind of ratio of magic to ee to maintain for when the values for both reach high points
1
u/Elysium-Noct Dec 07 '17 edited Dec 07 '17
It's (Base Magic + CP Magic)(1+Hall of Fame/100)(1+Card-Magic/100)+Weapon Magic for those who are asking. This goes also for HP, Attack and Break. Tested on lvl 350 Cloud
1
u/MrGianni89 Dec 07 '17
Also: +% magic or element from the fractals, how enters the equation?
1
u/IJustNeedaAccount Max OBed Ultimate Chaos Rental: 2061 8ad6 0e46 Dec 08 '17
After a test by DdrNerd , we have concluded that Faith and Trance acts independent of your magic stat
So i guess you can remove those 2 now? (And btw, your current calculator factors Faith and Trance as +0.5 and +0.3 respectively, rather than as a multiplier, making it even more worthless)
And i have checked myself that Fractals multiply into the Panels, while didn't do enough to confirm if it rounds off or up for all panels, or factors in the decimals when handling multiple panels
1
u/ayassa Dec 06 '17
good work. well, i can't do math better as much as you, though i assumed it should be better to increase the lowest relevant stat to make the output better. i'm relieved that your math just made my assumptions correct. so, thank you
1
u/WickedSynth Dec 06 '17
Omg thank you for this post, I've been asking about this stuff alot lately, and actually started working on a full damage calculator that I might or might not decide to post here once I'm confident most of it is correct. I appreciate the work you put into this!
1
u/JayMeadows Dec 06 '17
So in other words; Keep your Magic and Enhancement of equal and balanced level for best outcome. Gotcha'
1
u/raineFF ☆BloodRiver☆ Dec 07 '17
amazing.... mind blown...
1
u/Leongard Aerith:FFVII "Buffs Please" Dec 07 '17
And now this dilemma can be laid to rest. Thank you for your work!
1
u/Mobius1337 https://www.twitch.tv/mobiusfm Dec 07 '17 edited Dec 08 '17
https://imgur.com/a/dx5od math checks out
-1
u/ForThoseWithWings Dec 06 '17 edited Dec 06 '17
Your misuse of the term “diminishing returns” is offensive. It’s no wonder the gaming world is filled with players who think every multiplier is diminishing when we get guides that misuse the term.
This topic was covered fairly extensively when panels were released: you should have referenced older posts.
The calculator is the best way for most players to determine what is best for them. I’ll just swap panels in game to see whether my damage goes up or down, but stats have never been better in panels for me yet.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment