Anything at 4 or above, I'd taunt and then drive (due to ignition).
At 4 and without ignition and no innate resistance, you'd get say 0.8 (from taunt) x 0.8 (from drive) = 0.64 = 36% reduction which is close enough to the 35% from just pure driving.
At 4 and without ignition and say 20% innate resistance, you'd get 0.8 x 0.6 = 0.48 = 52% reduction which close to the 55% values from just pure driving
At 4 and without ignition and say 50% resistance, you'd get 0.8 x 0.3 = 76% reduction which is higher than the theoretical max of 70 from ele resist.
At 3, go for the drive. Assuming they have 0 resistance, you get a 20% reduction anyway. If they have high resistance (say 50%), it becomes 70% to drive (assuming they're additive). If you taunt, you get 0.5 x 0.8 which is actually only a 60% reduction in damage so therefore driving is better).
Below 3, obviously drive because no orbs to taunt. :D
This is all assuming that the resists from drives are additive to innate resists and therefore has a 70% cap and also that it is a flat 20% reduction from the taunt.
tl;dr with ignition, taunt and then drive at above 4, without ignition, they're similar enough at low innate resistances but at higher values, taunt then drive may give more benefits. At 3 or under, go for the drive.
As for the drive, vs taunt at 3 orbs: it would seem driving is best when dealing with the final attack or other aoe.
However, if a kill is not guaranteed, taunting should always be the go to action, as it results in a 100% damage redirect of any single target attacks while still providing nearly as much aoe protection through pact as through the drive. Overall, greater protection.
Edited to add rough values for extra damage HK took post pact. This was about 1.5-1.6x what he'd normally take without pact.
If I had to guess, it could be something like an extra 20% each unit that's in the team. It'd be interesting to see how this gets affected by 2-3 man teams. Might do a bit more testing on MD.
As a personal preference, I like to use an off element taunt (ideally one that matches guard A) so that I can better the odds of putting up max resists (taunt + 3 orbs for max resist with drive ignition).
I find that if things go wrong in a 5 star, it goes wrong at the start (usually from people having 0-2 stacks of resist).
But why use an off-element taunt? I'm talking in the context of carries and most carries can at least one shot guards in one turn.
If you use an off element taunt and then the enemy dies, you're not doing yourself any favours. Also, drive ignition covers for the loss in 3 orbs so really it's the same effect as pure driving.
That's all I'm talking about.
Anyway, I feel we're miscommunicating here so let's just move on.
In a situation of a full carry, it is even more imperative to maximize stacks of resist to handle the situation of the boss dying on turn one. Don't want to be caught going into the final attack with just a pact to keep that Amalthea alive.
The purpose of using an off element taunt is to forgo the pact, and instead use all your orb to maximize resist, while still controlling who the boss targets and remove buffs. Using an off element taunt, you only need to start/generate 3 orbs of the boss' element to maximize resist (in contrast to having to start with 4 orbs, and generate 2-3 more, a tall order).
There is a big down side if using a matching element taunt: that you put off getting resist up till the second turn(short of rng). I expect this to go away as tanks get better shift options and aren't as screwed by rng at the start of the fight; but till that happens, it's a risk that should be taken into consideration. Using an off element taunt puts the rng more in your favour.
I think you're misunderstanding drive ignition or forgetting it.
If you have 4 orbs, you use 3 for taunt and then get a 3 orb drive ignition which then gives +3 orbs worth of drive on your next drive.
This makes them at least equivalent in terms of stacking resist AND also gives the flat 20% on top AND gives taunt.
So tl;dr off-element is bad for one turn kills especially if you have 4 or more orbs or ignition.
Wait: Scratch that. I think what you're saying is forego the pact altogether and then use ignition from the off element and get a full 6 orb reduction.
I tested this when pacts were released and saw a straight 20% reduction. I can find the screenshots and message hustory where I discussed it with someone
It looks like your post might be a question. If so, please redirect your question to our Question Megathread. You can also try asking in our Discord server, or investigating our Mobius Wiki. If you have received this message in error, for example on a discussion post, please feel free to downvote and ignore it.
3
u/mao_shiro Actual Evil Reddit Mod Dec 06 '17
Good work, i'll add it to the megalist :)
1
u/eigerblade Dec 06 '17
I guess I was mistaken. If I have only 3 orbs as a defender, I'll prioritize the taunts from now on.
Although I can also tap attack a few times first then drive the orbs, hmm..
1
u/mthucs Dec 06 '17
Edited to add rough values for extra damage HK took post pact. This was about 1.5-1.6x what he'd normally take without pact.
If I had to guess, it could be something like an extra 20% each unit that's in the team. It'd be interesting to see how this gets affected by 2-3 man teams. Might do a bit more testing on MD.
1
u/mthucs Dec 06 '17
Tested again to see effects of number of teammates on damage HK took.
It with just Amalthea and HK this time. She took about 20% less damage and he took only about 18% more damage.
Seems that for each teammate, you get roughly 20% extra damage.
1
u/MuteTiefling Dec 06 '17
So, could one conclude that pact is effectively adding elemental resist to each party member?
I ask because there seems to be diminishing returns when everything is stacked up.
Edit: nevermind, misread your findings. It's just taking a flat percent off.
1
u/Taborabeh 208d - 0c1c - 3575 5* Warrior of Light: FFI Dec 06 '17
You guys are awesome! Thank you for all this info. Very valuable :)
1
u/abyraz Dec 06 '17
As a personal preference, I like to use an off element taunt (ideally one that matches guard A) so that I can better the odds of putting up max resists (taunt + 3 orbs for max resist with drive ignition).
I find that if things go wrong in a 5 star, it goes wrong at the start (usually from people having 0-2 stacks of resist).
1
u/DdrNerd Dec 06 '17
I tested this when pacts were released and saw a straight 20% reduction. I can find the screenshots and message hustory where I discussed it with someone
-5
u/AutoModerator Dec 06 '17
It looks like your post might be a question. If so, please redirect your question to our Question Megathread. You can also try asking in our Discord server, or investigating our Mobius Wiki. If you have received this message in error, for example on a discussion post, please feel free to downvote and ignore it.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.