r/anime • u/Xyyzx :As::At::Au:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Echinodermata • Feb 25 '18
[WT!] So, Houseki no Kuni. Wow.
I managed to miss this one last season and just caught up with it over this weekend; I had nothing better to do last night, so I thought I’d investigate the first episode of the weird CGI mineralgirl show.
…and then marathon-ed the whole thing from start to finish. Literally sat there without getting up for anything like it was a five hour movie. It’s brilliant; I had no idea there was something out there that could so easily topple Made in Abyss from my AOTY spot for 2017, but there it was (and I really liked Made in Abyss).
If you’re not already aware, the very basic premise is that a small society of immortal, androgynous mineral-people are fighting a thousands of year long war against creepy, shiny buddhist ghosts called ‘Lunarians’ who want to kidnap the mineral people and take them away to the moon. …even if it wasn’t also brilliant, it has originality going for it in spades! Should you have the ability and time, I strongly recommend you at least give the first episode of this a try, so here are some (spoiler free!) reasons to do so;
First of all, the hybrid 2D/CGI animation is gorgeous in a way that I’ve never seen anywhere else. Anyone who avoided this one because of a prejudice against CG animation, please give this one a chance! I think the slightly surreal and artificial setting helps, but the way the show takes advantage of the underused strengths of CGI and the seamless blending with traditional 2D is stunning. I’ve always been a big advocate of the Polygon CGI shows and movies, but the natural movement and expressiveness of the models in HnK make the characters in Sidonia and the new Godzilla look like awkward plastic mannequins in comparison.
It’d be easy to point to the fantastic gem effects as the biggest strength of the CG stuff, but to be honest it ended up being the ‘camerawork’ that really impressed me there. There’s a scene in particular in Episode 10 where a character is running and hiding from a pursuer, that’s done in a single long, unbroken take following them around the room; it massively ratchets up the tension in the scene, and it’s something that just wouldn’t have been practical to do in 2D with the time and budget constraints of a TV anime. There are also several action scenes that reminded me a lot of the best 3D manoeuvre gear fights in the recent run of Attack on Titan, but the CG elements that make that kind of movement possible are much more fluidly incorporated here in HnK.
This isn’t CG for the sake of saving money or cutting corners. This is properly harnessing the ‘new’ tech to do things you couldn’t achieve with the traditional methods.
Second is the writing. I’m generally not a huge fan of single-cour shows; the vast majority of them feel to me like two-cour scripts that have been viciously hacked down to 12 or 13 episodes. The pacing is often odd, character development gets weirdly accelerated or suddenly cut off, endings come out of nowhere or are disappointingly anticlimactic. It’s only very occasionally that something like Death Parade comes along, where a single cour manages to feel like a complete and satisfying experience. Houseki no Kuni is definitely getting added to that short list.
There are characters in this show that get introduced and have complete arcs across 20 minutes of screen time that I cared more about than protagonists from shows that ran to 50+ episodes across multiple seasons. The simple but memorable and conveniently colour-coded character designs do a lot to make every one of the fairly large cast distinctive, but the writing and direction is a masterclass in characterisation using small moments and minimal dialogue. Unusually again for a mostly CGI show, there’s always a lot going on in the background in HnK, and even the most minor characters all get to display plenty of personality in their expressions and reactions to events, rather than just standing around like inactive NPCs in a video game.
The protagonist, Phosphophyllite (Phos, for short) in HnK is a joy to watch. Superficially, they come off as a stereotypical ‘cheerful well-meaning klutz’, but there’s a subtle introspective depth to them right from the first episode that sets them apart from your run-of-the-mill MC. They start out the show as the youngest and weakest of the group, but the fact that this is a group of powerful, ageless immortals where you could be the useless youngest and weakest individual literally forever gives the standard underdog story an edge of hopelessness that really made me feel for poor Phos right out the gate. Phos’s character development over the course of the series… Well, I’m not going to spoil anything at all on that, but it was definitely the most compelling character arc I’ve seen in any anime for a long while. Again, HnK managed to do more with Phos in 12 episodes than I would have thought possible in that limited runtime.
On top of all that, it has some great comedic moments through all twelve episodes. The personality clashes between the various characters often play out in a way that’s totally hilarious, and every joke also ends up giving you more of an insight into them at the same time. The integration of comedy with more dramatic scenes is also done almost perfectly, something which a lot of shows that try to blend the two can stumble on (I’m looking at you, Mahoutsukai no Yome). The comedy always feels natural, and never ends up undermining the drama like I’ve often seen elsewhere.
Third is the art direction and music; Houseki no Kuni is gorgeous, and not just ‘for a CG show’. For me, it’s right up there with Made in Abyss for the best looking and sounding show of the year. The island setting is beautiful, but at the same time bleak, cold and vaguely ominous, and the silent, shining, smirking ‘buddhist angels’ that make up the Lunarian antagonists of the story are unconventionally terrifying.
The muted colours of the backgrounds are contrasted by the brightly coloured crystalline hair of the gem-people, the style and exact shade of which was chosen well enough that I don’t think I over had problems telling apart the otherwise identically-dressed characters.
These character designs remind me a lot of one of the best things about Kemono Friends; in that show, each character’s personality was really cleverly crafted to match the nature of the animal represented in the design, and here they do a similar thing with the real-life gemstones the characters are made of. The gem is reflected the character design, the character design is reflected in the personality of that character, and it gives the whole thing a sense of consistency and verisimilitude.
The music is also fantastic, switching between upbeat ‘adventure-ey’ orchestral stuff for the more relaxed antics of the main cast, chilling ritualistic percussion for the terrifying Lunarians, and some really beautiful pieces on the Chinese Erhu and piano in some of the melancholy moments. Unfortunately not on Spotify (yet!) but I’m definitely going to see if I can get a hold of this one to listen to independently of the show; it’s that good.
…I should probably stop typing now before this gets any further out of hand than it already has. So sue me, I really enjoyed this and I want to spread that around as much as possible!
TL;DR: Houseki no Kuni is great. Put aside any preconceptions you have about CG animated shows and go watch it.
EDIT: Also I did not expect this to take off quite like it did, so thanks for the comments everyone, and thanks for the gold to whomever granted it! I hope all the newcomers to HnK enjoy it as much as I did!
114
u/24grant24 Feb 25 '18 edited Feb 25 '18
Season 2 please Orange
Consider checking out the manga after you've finished absorbing all the information and themes from the anime. I've collected some of my favorite pages in an album here, no spoilers if you've finished the anime. I suggest starting the manga from the beginning, not because anything is missing, but the art style and tone is so different it's great to experience both. Here is a video comparing the two that you can watch once you've caught up to the anime in the manga. As an og source reader I am very pleased with it as an adaptation, it really compliments the source material and adds depth.
And here is the OST so you can check that out.
43
u/VoyeurTheNinja Feb 25 '18
Phos' story was something that hit me hard, considering my own desire for self-change. The manga just continues with that wonderfully and now I can't wait for both the next chapter and an announcement for season 2 just to see more animated stuff.
29
u/Nielloscape Feb 25 '18
The exact wording with the review you wrote on MAL
https://myanimelist.net/reviews.php?id=272434
Getting the most out of it, huh? :p
55
u/stormarsenal :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AsherGZ Feb 25 '18
Nice write-up. The colloquial style honestly makes it an easier read than those written like a research paper. I've been wanting to write WT!s about some of my favorite shows for so long but have no idea where to even start. Reading this made me realize that it's perfectly fine to just let out my inner fanboy and gush about them. Maybe I'll give it a shot now.
5
u/Moldef :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Moldef Feb 25 '18
Loved reading your thoughts on Houseki no Kuni. It's also definitely the AOTY for me (though I haven't seen MiA just yet). I was so greatly surprised by this show. It's one of only four series now that I rated 10/10 (out of like 150 series).
I have to scold you though for not pointing out how amazing Phos' VA was. I think Kurosawa Tomoyo is playing a not-so-small role in why we all enjoyed this anime so damn much.
9
u/Erallor Feb 25 '18
Loved reading this! Certainly going to watch this asap!
3
u/BLACKOUT-MK2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/DelayedLaserBoom Feb 26 '18
I genuinely loved it and it took me completely by surprise. One little detail I liked was how if ever a character's limbs made contact with something like a wall, it sounded like two rocks scraping together. Even the sound design of how their bodies interacted with the world was convincing. God, I hope we get a season 2, because this is one of those rare occasions where a show manages to feel "charming".
4
u/HYMREDDIT Feb 25 '18
Was there even traditional 2D in the show? I thought it was full CG.
Might've been blended so seamlessly that I didn't notice then
175
u/lilyvess :Df::Dh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lilyvess Feb 25 '18
Always love to hear more Houseki no Kuni love!
people also should go check out the fanart scene. They've got a pretty active community and the use of color and material ends up creating some absolutely breathtaking artwork.
Just
Some
Examples
61
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '18
"Hmm...it's not bad. Let's see episode 2."
"Well, now I have to watch it."
28
u/Shinkopeshon Feb 25 '18
This show blew me away. I would've never checked it out if this subreddit didn't hype the shit out of it.
18
u/Guaymaster Feb 25 '18
This is the part that the manga has difficulty to convey. Some of the character designs are rather similar, but you can make out the differences thanks to bodily language and colour, but the manga being static and in b/w...
Anyway, the anime is incredibly faithful to the manga, except for the last episode that wanted to close or put on stand by the plot threads that were opened over the course of the series but didn't manage to come to fruition. This means a few things were changed or skimmed over, so if you want to continue reading but don't want to start from the very beginning, start from chapter 32.
This series has incredible writing.
12
u/rembrandt_q_1stein https://myanimelist.net/profile/sir_rembrandt Feb 25 '18
I love to read texts fruit of an intense love an passion towards the topic. This demonstrates it.
15
u/cf18 :JA::JB: Feb 25 '18
So, have these sub reached any conclusion on letting Dia win the best guy or best girl pool?
6
u/UltimateEye :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PerfectVision Feb 25 '18
I love this WT! great job with writing it. It had a really great flow to it really gave it a nice personal touch while not being completely colloquial - I struggle to get that balance in my own writing a lot of the time
As for the show, it's absolutely a must watch. Last year had some particularly strong gems with Made in Abyss, Tsuki ga Kirei, Rakugo S2 and Sangatsu no Lion. But Houseki no Kuni was not only the biggest surprise for me but possibly even my favorite of the year. It's tough to call because I don't quite feel it stuck the ending as well as Made in Abyss but the overall package may have been more enjoyable.
Still, I completely agree that it's possibly the new gold standard for CG animation (as far as anime TV series go) which is an impressive technical achievement.
6
u/Cryom :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SerpentesX Feb 25 '18
I've been wanting to make this thread since I saw the show as well, but didn't really know how to do it since Houseki no Kuni just has so many damn things going for it. But you said a lot of it beautifully, so thank you for that.
I had a lot of the same experiences as you, watching it a season late and doing it all in one sitting. I really, really hope people check it out and acknowledge it as AOTY. It's just so perfect.
6
u/TheDeadRed :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheDustyRed Feb 25 '18
It really was a surprising show. Before it I completely swore off any heavy CGI anime except for mecha (and even then I would gripe a little about it while watching). I'm not really looking forward to it getting a second season though, since I didn't really like where the manga went, but I'd love to see Orange improve on this animation style for their next shows.
6
u/XoNtheHAWK Feb 25 '18
Dia-chan best girl
6
u/stargunner Feb 25 '18
le hidden gem
6
u/cdbriggs Feb 26 '18
Never heard of this till now. I will definitely be checking this out!
5
u/multigrain_cheerios Feb 25 '18
If you liked the anime, try reading the manga. The artstyle is unique and pleasing to look at (imo), and the story is just as good. The parts after where the anime ended are even better
9
u/speckledlemon https://anilist.co/user/speckledlemon Feb 25 '18
You know, there is a word that describes this.
I read somewhere else (and agree with) that the odd motions in CGI which can be very off-putting (I don't care for it much) are a strength here. Do you think a bunch of glorified rocks are going to walk around just like humans or other animals? It imparts a certain clunkiness that's really appropriate for them.
I'll admit that I turned off Kemono Friends after about 5 minutes, in part because of the CGI, but I have seen this before. In music, we say the instrument chooses the person, and Hibike reflected that, making it that much more enjoyable. HnK proved to me that having background understanding enhances everything. Watching all these minerals and gems being personified that I've read about in books and seen in person over the years was eerie. The look is spot-on. For example, this is what rutilated quartz (not rutile) looks like. Benitoite has a certain look because of its host mineral. If you ever have a chance to see a mineral/gem exhibit (this is one near where I live), go, because they are more beautiful in real life than in the show.
Coincidentally, possibly the best VA from Hibike Euphonium is also possibly the best in HnK.
For those who are interested, information about the OST/OP/ED can be found on VGMdb. I would not recommend listening to the OST before finishing the anime. But, do listen to it, because even when taken alone, it is flawless.
4
u/FrighteningEdge Feb 25 '18
I’ve been going on a “In Another World” anime marathon and need a change of pace, will definitely look it up OP.
4
u/RobbieReinhardt Feb 26 '18
I also binged this series for the first time this weekend.
9.5-10/10
It gets high marks across the board from me (music, art style, animation/movement, character development, comedy, fight scenes, world-building, etc). I think the only demerit I can think of is that the Lunarians aren't very interesting (their design gets old without change or dialogue).
That's okay though because it allows the show more time to build the world and give every jewel their own personality traits.
I believe that the most appealing thing about this show is going to be the quality of writing and how it really feels like the author respects the watchers' intelligence by not lingering on plot devices for overly long.
HOWEVER, BE WARNED: Phos (MC) may really get on your nerves with all the crap s/he pulls in the first 7 or 8 episodes. Trust me. I found her childish ignorance to be quite grating. Since I've finished the series, I can now say that that ignorance was intentional and justified. And by the end of the series, Phos shows a meaningful, sobering, and satisfying development of her character.
2
u/tlolm Feb 25 '18
I am so with you.
That sound direction was on point. I can barely imagine it without color, though I hear the art in the manga is great.
Aaaaargh so frustrating only having one season.
2
u/HuoXue :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/HuoXue Feb 26 '18
Well, just finished binging it after seeing this recommendation. Still kind of digesting things, but I'm torn.
The visuals and audio were really good.
But...I really don't know what's going on. I mean, if it's just a setup into the main story, that's fine, but I feel like I should know more after 12 episodes. On that front, I'm a little disappointed.
2
u/LawlessCoffeh Feb 26 '18
Guess I should see this one then.
2
u/arbitwah Feb 26 '18
I really really hope they get a second run for this series. The left the anime right before phos goes through another super drastic change. And side characters really start to develop as well.
2
u/jurble Feb 26 '18
The small Lunarians are meant to look more Hindu than Buddhist. They're supposed to look like soldiers and archers from the Mauryan Empire. The big Lunarians are supposed to Rakshasas and Asuras. All these things and their art styles were brought along with Buddhism, but the art distinction is purposeful and hints at what's actually going on, if you know buddhist history/theology (the author went to a Buddhist school).
2
u/Lophyre Feb 26 '18
Better than made in abyss? That's a bold claim. I guess I have to watch and see for myself
2
u/Saya_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Saya999 Feb 26 '18
I really wasn't expecting to like it so much either after reading the synopsis and thought it was a show people were overhyping just because of good animation (which I don't really give a damn about in general) but the characters and mystique of the world were really interesting.
I recommended it to a friend right after binging it, but they said they stopped at ep. 2...I think I really got into it at ep. 3 when a certain character was introduced.
Went and marathoned the manga after and wasn't disappointed (sometimes stories tend to drop off the longer they go). I feel like the mangaka has a clear direction. Really hoping it gets another season or two to tie it up neatly.
Also recently got myself a Shiro plushie that I now proudly display in the back window of my car.
2
u/Nickward :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/nickward123 Feb 26 '18
Welp, stayed up till 6 last night binge watching the whole thing
2
u/Robo1999 Feb 26 '18
Your write up sums up my exact feeling about HnK! I wasn’t sure what to expect, but I couldn’t stop watching once I started. I’m now reading the manga and I’m re-watching the series too.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Well, OP, ya got me to watch the whole show. Just finished.
Easily a top anime of 2017, right up there with Made In Abyss. Absolutely loved the show. Beautiful, great cinematography, pacing, music, characterization, and action scenes. It really picked up after the Ocean, too.
Sits somewhere in my top anime, personally. I'll have to read the manga now because there's no way I could wait for a potential second season.
4
u/NeroTox228 Feb 25 '18
I really enjoyed it as well but not more then made in abyss
2
u/Miragephan Feb 25 '18
I hated Houseki no Kuni trying to watch it last season but your glowing recommendations has made me reconsider trying it out. I absolutely detest CG centric stuff so it could possibly of just been my vigorous hatred stopping me from enjoying the first 3 episodes.
2
u/Wolf6262 Feb 25 '18
Doing gods work out here making more people check out this blessed show.
1
u/gkanai Feb 26 '18
The Soundtrack is up on Amazon Japan for sale, and they have a English interface, so you can just make an account and order it.
TVアニメ「宝石の国」オリジナルサウンドトラック コンプリート ~ 藤澤慶昌
1
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '18
i'm a bit of a stickler for quality... but does anyone else insist on waiting to watch the bluray versions rather than the versions aired on tv?
or to put it another way, has anyone who has seen the bluray of Houseki No Kuni seen any improvements compared to the tv?
i'd much prefer to watch the finished product, even if the changes are generally too subtle to be noticed. at the very least, terrestrial tv broadcasts in Japan are 1080i, whereas the bluray should be 1080p.
1
u/hikikomori80 https://anilist.co/user/hikikomori80 Feb 25 '18
You did such a great job with this that I think I'm going to rewatch the show very soon. Again.
Thanks for spreading the love!
1
u/fun-things-are-fun Feb 25 '18
Very underrated. loved it
1
u/Adrelandro Feb 25 '18
would you recommend watching the anime eventho i didn't enjoy the manga?
Edit: i also kinda of dislike the style of animation they chose, nothing against cgi, but the designs simply don't grab me
0
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment