r/colony • u/V2Blast Geronimo • May 17 '18
Discussion [Colony] S03E03 - "Sierra Maestra" - Discussion Thread (SPOILERS) Spoiler
47
Upvotes
r/colony • u/V2Blast Geronimo • May 17 '18
43
u/zi3i May 17 '18
I am wondering if the Rap/Click started to talk only when Will showed up or would it talk anyways. Maybe its like with the drones, the host scanned people around and it recognized Will from the list, marked him "ally" so he started to talk to him. So maybe the Clicks talk about Human = Ally wasnt about "all humans" but those from the specific list where Will is.
To bad that old beard got a mental breakdown and stopped the talk becouse it didnt go the way he wanted, now he needs to sit in the corner and sulk a while.
35
u/teandro May 17 '18
Theory: Raps are being hunted by some enemy with similar ships and honeycomb armor. The enemy aliens seem to be biological. It could be the species who made them as some warrior AI set up to conquer, so it's all the Raps know. They probably turned against the biological aliens, who now want to finish them, so these Raps are the remaining survivors. They run everything in an amoral conquer / find valuable assets / be efficient mode.
34
u/agentup May 18 '18
The raps weapons are highly effective against humans. It is instant disintegration.
That implies that their enemy is organic as well.
As far as the RAPs treatment of humans as their allies. If i recall correctly there are differing opinions among the RAPs. It makes sense some might be harder than others. Also think of our treatment of animals. Yeah we are generally good to them but we also eat them and experiment on them.
That said, given how many humans they enslaved then doomed to die of radiation poisoning on the moon. Allies is a very loose term. It’s more like slavery vs annihilation
In any case this episode was the game changer. The viewer can now connect lot of the dots from previous seasons
27
u/TrevorW2018 May 17 '18
What do you guys think about when will was talking to the guy when they were digging? My theory is that is the actual guy with the bunny holding a stick of dynamite tattoo..
Clearly the guy running the camp isnt who he is saying. Look how to lied to katie then went and used the gauntlet.
BUT ALL I THOUGHT WAS WHAT THE FUCK SNYDER??
Why does snyder always have some valuable ass information he suddenly spouts out?? Like “that does NOT look like a host ship, their ships are more streamlined” “there was rumors that the hosts have enemies” and now “the host is online!”
First thing i would do is bring snyder to the host and say ok dude start talking. I want to hear everything you know that even remotely involves the hosts or the plans. He knows more and needs to be vetted
And WHAT THE HELL? The host talks?? And did anybody else notice how they left the faraday cage WIDE open. Like dude now the hosts can track you guys and where the unit is. The gate was wide open!!!
27
u/[deleted] May 19 '18
Humans are the enemy.
It showed last season that Raps had made contact with the US government in the past. What if the transitional authority is just a clandestine group created by the governments of the time (50s/60s) and that everything happening to humans (the blocs, the factory, the drone enforcement) is just the work of this group. Imagine the Raps came to Earth in peace and told the governments in complete cooperation about the forthcoming incursion between the Raps and the Enemy and offered technology and resources to help with the “transition.” The Authority had used the war between the Aliens as an excuse to obtain global control over humanity and the Raps had allowed the governments autonomy as to not hinder their new allies and show complete cooperation. That all the crap humans have suffered are not the Raps but from humans themselves and the Raps are legit friendlies and are just the scapegoats.
23
u/the_fast_reader Collaborator May 17 '18
I was ready to call bullshit on them actually having a Rap for a good half of the episode... and then it went from 0 to 100 in ten seconds.
It confirmed some theories that were being discussed here but still leaves some interesting questions.
Why the list? How much of what the Rap said is the truth? What's that dome?
22
u/zi3i May 18 '18
I noticed something interesting in that talk about annihilation scene.
When Will was standing in front of the Rap, the rap was talking about "Human=ally", after the annihilation info, Kate grabbed Wills hand in front of the rap. The rap modified his earlier answer to "Human=ally=partner", its possible that the "partner" is reffering to Kate. It saw her grabbing "Human" therfore must be important to that human, so it added Kate to Will as partner, therfore Kate might be drone immune now, as "Human=ally was modified by the partner part as Kate"
Time will show when she faces a drone directly.
21
u/TrevorW2018 May 17 '18
I dont understand why the HOSTS didnt just fly their ships over our planet and announce “ATTENTION HUMANS, AN EMEMY ALIEN RACE IS CHASING US. WE NEED TO DEFEND OURSELVES AND YOUR PLANET AGAIN THE INCOMING ATTACK. Please prepare for our ships to land.”
I really think a lot of humans would actually help.
I kinda think the host was telling the truth. But then again, maybe it was a lie?
20
u/ricky_lafleur May 17 '18
Can anybody translate the numbers the Rap/Click said?
2 7 break 0 6 break 1 5 stop 15 stop 4 5 7 positive 44 break { repeated once}
Are they right ascension & declination or galactic coordinates?
Captioning said 98.77 parsecs but I hears one hundred before that. Contrary to Han Solo, a parsec is a unit of length and 198.77 parsecs is about 648.3 light-years.
20
u/[deleted] May 19 '18
Hat-tip to u/zi3i for a calling out the Rap calling Will human ally and Katie partner. Thinking of it this way (that Will is the ally not humanity in general). With that in mind I thought about the times we've seen Will spared by drones which lead me to another guy we've seen spared by drones: Broussard. Well, in this episode we witness Broussard and Amy wander by an "enemy" alien ship (I think) and she get sick but he does not.
Maybe, Will and Broussard share a common genetic resistance to whatever is emanating from the enemy ship. Maybe that's why the Raps need them, to fight the enemy.
Just a thought but it would definitely connect a few strands.
15
u/Flip17 May 18 '18
We know from past season that the Raps had made contact with earth before the colonies were set up. My theory is that the Raps, much like Reapers (for you ME fans) are trying to preserve the diversity of organic life in the universe and that the organic enemy that is pursuing the Raps wants to eliminate anything that is not their species. My guess is that the Raps are an uploaded consciousness of all of the species that had their organic presence destroyed. This is why humans were being sent to the Rap ships in the pods... to have their consciousness uploaded to the Rap network, but I digress. So the Raps tell the world leaders what is happening and if the Human race is to survive in an organic form here's what we gotta do... its gonna be messy and lots of people will die, but its better than the alternative.
15
u/Edreynolds379 May 22 '18 edited May 23 '18
I have been reading through posts here and I think one thing is certainly true. The Hosts are not the enemy of the humans. The Transitional Authority is responsible for all the atrocities. Why? Some dialogue from S03E03:
MacGregor: But you killed hundreds of millions! Click: Human. Ally.
And later on: Click: Humans. Equal partner.
Perry sure he's saying that the human partner (TA) has done all the killing.
So I think we knew that the Clicks have been on Earth for a while. Wasn't there an episode that suggested they made contact in the 50s? If so, anyone remember which episode? If this is the case, seems some humans got advanced tech back then (or at least directions on how to make it) and used it to create an "alien occupation" for purposes of domination of other humans. A super state. They are working with the Clicks to build defenses against the biological aliens. It's been up to the humans how to organize the humans and they've used the stick instead of the carrot.
Also, this would explain why the TA was so desperate to recover the gauntlet when it was lost initially (and still is...isn't it Snyder's job to get the gauntlet back?). If the gauntlet lets people talk to Clicks, the TA sure wouldn't want that if they've been the bad guys all along.
I bet Clicks' pursuers are the race that created them.
No idea what's going on with the humans who have been spared by the drones and walkers (like Will). Maybe they carry something that could kill the biological aliens? Maybe they are immune to something? Whatever it is, the TA is leaving them alone.
14
u/rangerxt May 20 '18
"We are allies. This explains why we splat so many of you."
13
u/langley10 Grey Hat May 17 '18
Questions from this episode:
So what the heck is the dome? Obviously rap but what is it?
And the rap... confirmed it's a machine/ai... and the raps aren't the worst, they have an enemy that's worse... or so it says... Is it lying though, can it lie?
Also what are the crates for?
And what the hell is the camp secret issue?
11
u/un_tiralovia May 18 '18
I didn't understand the scene where those guys reached the group with the truck. Why did they do that?
11
u/muircertach May 17 '18
Does the guy running the camp already know what the RAP was saying? Is that why he stopped it. Or is he a fanatic and that just does not fit with his worldview so he stopped it?
10
u/Polishrifle May 21 '18
No way this show gets renewed for season 4. The ratings are just abysmal at this point and literally half of what they were in the first season. Unless the fact that netflix picked the show up will allow it to continue but this episode revealed too much , almost as if they’re setting this season up to provide as much closure as possible.
9
u/tomanonimos May 17 '18
I'm not surprised since they basically said this in the season promos. Spoiler. Unlike other speculation, I do not believe the Raps are an AI race who were manipulated by the Elite humans. I think the Raps are basically a super advanced UV (unmanned vehicle; similar to our current UAV). I can't believe that an AI would have enough emotion to destroy an entire colony if one of their brethren got killed. Recall in season 2 where all the humans were afraid of the LA colony blocked getting blown up if they didn't transfer the AI core to a different housing unit.
9
u/Tokyogerman May 17 '18
Great episode, as so often with Sci-Fi Shows, what was the most gripping to me was the scene where they talked to the host. Sooo interesting.
Will this show survive this season though? How long do the writers have the story planned? I looked at the ratings this season and am already dreading the cancellation of this after my favorite Sci Fi show The Expanse got cancelled and is fighting for its life right now.
This show could have lots of interesting story things left to tell too.
9
u/argalarga May 17 '18
Nice to get some answers about the raps. We had at least an inkling that they were AI, but I wonder if the round cores are their true form, or only containers for that. Are they entirely noncorporeal, like the wormhole aliens in DS9? Or are they advanced living computers?
I'd imagine the "allies" language from the rap dovetails with the advance planning we saw in the season 2 premier. We know the raps set up a network of collaborators before the arrival, so I wonder if they approached high-ranking humans with a more equitable deal, and the humans basically figured out a way to sacrifice millions of lesser people in trade for safety and power. Hence, the colony/bloc system.
9
u/culingerai May 17 '18
If this is what a rap/click looks like then what did the Bowman's see in the crashed ship in the last episode? Why were they surprised by the appalearance of this?
9
u/[deleted] May 19 '18
the rap's drones (and now the walkers) keep zapping people around, we've seen it in this episode, but people keep making excuses for them, I don't get it...objectively, they are the enemy, because they kill people, notwithstanding whatever other motivations they might have
8
u/Kwanyinagain May 17 '18
Wow. What an episode!
Started off a little slow, with more annoying mysteries about the politics of the resistance camp. Then bam! We're talking with a Click!
Really nice to see new people commenting too.
8
u/PerpetualAscent May 17 '18
where was Wayne Brady
7
u/eMouse2k May 17 '18
HMMMMMM....
Posted a year ago...
Spoiler
7
u/xocgx May 18 '18
Didn’t the shadow moving behind the tarp look like an alien walking around?
When they spoke to the rap, he had no legs....
7
u/and_yet_another_user May 18 '18
So Amy says she has to give their info to the camp in case something happens to them. Good plan. When she finds out the camp is not receiving, she doesn't backup the info to the relay she was going to give it to for transfer to the camp. Maybe nothing is going to happen to them now the camp is not receiving, yeah, makes zero sense.
7
u/MaKTaiL May 22 '18
Did anybody else get an Age of Ultron vibe when the RAP started talking? Fantastic episode!
7
u/enricowereld Jun 18 '18
Woah this show got really good
6
u/Kwanyinagain May 17 '18
Do we believe a word out of the Rap/Click?
6
u/Ssme812 May 17 '18
Good episode but that ending was weird. I thought someone was going to follow them or pop up
6
u/JPWhiteHome May 18 '18
Now it seems he raps are at least partly if not totally robotic this may explain why raps experience time differently.
If the rap is a robotic host for a conscious mind then the robot may have a very very fast processor much quicker than organic brains. Therefore a rap maybe able to process hundreds of thoughts in the same time as an organic brain thinks of one. If so then time would "appear" to be slower for a rap thanks to the rapid thought process.
I don't think there is any special time travel going on, its a conscious mind that experiences time much more slowly, and as such a rap will experience a longer lifespan.
The significance of the gauntlet isn't clear. Maybe its a secondary copy of a mind so if the "head" of the rap is damaged and mind lost then the gauntlet can allow for the mind to be transferred to a new robotic body and reactivated, allowing for theoretical immortality.
6
u/[deleted] May 19 '18
The show keeps getting better and better. They’ve truly got me hooked with the storyline and mystery of it all. I really hope this isn’t the last season, otherwise we might not get the answers we’re looking for.
6
u/AssWormJim May 17 '18
Could the Hosts enemy have already established a foothold on Earth? I was thinking maybe the spooky magnets dome could be a base for either side.
11
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
Yes everyone who predicted that the raps are rogue AI escaping from their biological, bird like masters was right, it was pretty obvious after the s03e01 reveal at the end. Not sure why advanced sentient AI would need human labor though, maybe it is like some others predicted - they might have some hard coded restrictions on their own reproduction, otherwise they could just become Replicators/Borg and be unstoppable.
also I'm torn about the interrogation being too much on the nose.. it's like we went from knowing nothing to everything. But I guess it had to happen sometime
5
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official May 17 '18
I don’t know how to feel about this episode but there’s so much to talk about!!!!
5
u/Kwanyinagain May 17 '18
Watching Broussard and Amy raid the drugstore reminded me how many things we take for granted. We assume they will be available so long as we have money to buy them. Things as simple as rubbing alcohol and gauze.
5
u/Kwanyinagain May 17 '18 edited May 17 '18
I'm really liking Amy. It was good to see some of her backstory, and to get a look inside the San Fernando bloc.
Edit: Why do you think her floaty necklace has the initial "K" on it?
5
u/mariuolo May 17 '18
Also McGregor kept Dougal MacKenzie's beard.
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
I noticed something interesting on the way the Rap talks. It uses different voices and intonations. I am going on a limb here and that each voice is a personality or distinct AI within itself.
Female voice = diplomat
Male voice = tactician
These are of course just a placeholder but you get the point.
Also its clear that the guy running the camp cannot reconcile his point of view and idea of the world to the reality of what the rap is saying.
4
u/baconandeggs666 Resistor May 17 '18
"Holy shit."
4
u/mellena I do it for the rations May 17 '18
Great episode!
4
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
it's a pity they had to put this psycho nazi labor camp into the show...it's almost unbearable to watch the scenes in there
7
u/Polishious_ May 17 '18
Anyone else notice the rap's use of 'equals' in place of 'is'? ("Humans equal allies...")
It annoyed me at first: The writers had just tried to liken the rap to a computer by using something mathy in a natural language sentence, but they ended up having their machine misuse '=' the way placard holding hippies do (e.g. If 'fur = murder' means 'fur is murder', then murder is fur).
But giving the writers the benefit of the doubt: although 'humans = partners' seems false because the resistance and the raps are not partners, from the rap's perspective, the statement would be true if
Really, it's probably nothing - but it seems like a sloppy mistake for the show's insightful writers.
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
I'm sure this has been said a million times, but my theory is that the Raps established colonies to destroy the humans who aren't strong enough to survive & fight off the (now unknown) third species.
2
u/AsianThunder May 17 '18
Not going to read any thing in this post bc o haven’t seen the episode yet. I just started watching and binged the first 2 seasons. Downloaded the USA network app so hopefully I could watch tonight’s episode at work but it’s not posted yet. When do they usually post new episodes on the app?
2
u/[deleted] May 18 '18
the rap was lying, of course, that's not how "allies" treat allies
the bald old guy is mentally unstable and will have to be removed sometime, although there is the problem of how to deal with his guards, which will probably resort to violence at the slightest pretext...otherwise he's right, the raps are the enemy
4
u/Splub May 18 '18
I think the rap was lying. I believe the raps came to Earth just to colonize it but then these other aliens who maybe the raps wronged in the past showed up to take them out.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment