r/HFY • u/A_Glass_Of_Whiskey Human • Jun 06 '18
OC-OneShot Bureaucracy Never Dies
"Yes, what is it now?" This, cooperation with aliens, thing seemed like less and less of a good idea the more he actually had to cooperate with them.
"I have detected a suboptimal configuration of your waste tanks." Oh please not this stuff again.
"The what?"
"Well you see-"
"Wait wait, how much will this impact the final project?" The aliens had an expression of what he presumed was slight annoyance.
"In your units, about 1.235kg of mass after changing all of them."
"And how many are there?"
"About 100, why?" Why him? Why always him!
"Look here, we don't care about that. It's too small of a difference." Please let that work, please! But the alien disappointed him once again by continuing to speak.
"Maybe so, but over a long enough time-"
"Listen here do you want to know why they are too large?" He blurted out after remembering something.
"You mean.... you know?" Maybe this angle could work.
"Of course I do, now just listen.
Originally all the vast storage tanks were used up rockets boosters that were repurposed for that purpose. Makes seems, a bit extra in the tank and minor control system and voila extra space! So a lot of tools and configurations were developed with this size in mind. When we started to actually produce them offworld there was already a whole ecosystem for support and handling of these older models. Of course since the optimal solution was so close, they just used the slightly suboptimal to better be able to function with the older stuff.
So simple story right? Except it doesn't start there. As it turns out the rocket boosters themselves were actually suboptimal. The people designing them wanted them slightly larger but they had to be able to pass through a tunnel on their way to the launch.
This tunnel used the US Standard railroad distance between the rails of 4 feet and 8 1/2 inches. An odd number to be sure, so why that one? Well that was the one used in England, and the US railroads where built by English expats.
So, why did the English use that specific number? Because the people that build the railroads also build the tramways and that's the distance they used.
So again, why? Well because they used the tools that were used for building wagons, which used that distance between its wheels.
Why? Because any other distance would have broken the wagons on some of the old long distance roads.
So who build the old long distance roads? The first long distance roads in Europe were built by Imperial Rome to be used by their legions.
So in the end, why did they establish this specific wheel spacing? Because they had to be usable by the Roman war chariots. Since these where standardized they all used the same spacing. Which happens to be the space needed to fit two horses side by side.
So you see, in the end, its rather simple. The reason the tank is slightly too large is because of the precise measurements of a horses arse."
The alien, having sat in stunned silence as the wave of intormation hit him, could finally get a word in. "So wait, lets me see if I got this right. This thing, the chariot, was thousands of years ago? Before you even hade the most basic of technology or even the glimmer of a rocket. This has propagated through time to affect your waste tanks suboptimally?" His voice reaching almost a shrill as he got closer to the end. "Please tell me this is an remarkable exception!"
"Oh, you don't even know the start of it!"
Oldest source for this that I could find (from 2001), although it has been told countless times.
23
u/sco_black_scorpion AI Jun 06 '18
It should be "It's too small of a difference"
"Listen here do you want to know why they are too large?"
7
u/Seblor Human Jun 06 '18 edited Jun 06 '18
This seems like a retranscription from the Exoconference speech of the french youtuber Bruce Benamran (AKA e-Penser) :
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCcziTK2NKeWtWQ6kB5tmQ8Q
Speech link (in french) :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omNX_8WcrRY
Edit : I just want to point out that I hold no grudge to OP whatsoever, I just want to credit the source.
3
u/Kromaatikse Android Jun 14 '18
A nitpick: the track gauge of a railway and the loading gauge of what it can carry are only very loosely related. A quick look at the average locomotive will show that it physically overhangs the rails by a considerable margin, especially on a narrow-gauge line.
In particular, the loading gauge of Japanese 3' 6" "Cape gauge" railways is wider than that of most British 4' 8.5" "Standard gauge" railways. Most standard-gauge railways have considerably larger loading gauges than the British standard, despite having the same track gauge.
I believe this is partly because some early British railways laid four rails equidistant from each other (ostensibly to permit running oversize loads down the middle), and there was only limited scope for moving them further apart later on. (Certainly this was true of the Stockton & Darlington, and the Liverpool & Manchester, but I'm not sure of any other examples.) Most other countries built their railways a little later, borrowing expertise and experience from British practice; American railways in particular built their trains very wide and tall, because most of their routes ran through open, wild country with no need for bridges or tunnels or even buying the land first.
Conversely, the Great Western Railway was originally built to a 7-foot "Broad gauge", most lines later being converted first to "dual gauge", supporting both Broad and Standard gauge trains, and then to purely Standard gauge. The Broad gauge tracks' loading gauge was very generous, but after the conversion to Standard gauge, the tracks were gradually relaid to fit more into the same space, using the smaller loading gauge typical of standard-gauge British rolling stock.
The major impediments to increasing the loading gauge on an existing railway are usually bridges and tunnels, especially the latter. The ECML electrification involved rebuilding most of the bridges over the line to clear the new overhead wires, and several tunnels also had to be enlarged, which was a difficult and dangerous procedure. One tunnel abruptly collapsed during this process, entombing several workers and their machinery, and the railway had to be rebuilt to go around the hill; trains were diverted by another route while this was done, causing much congestion at Carlisle.
177
u/sco_black_scorpion AI Jun 06 '18
Excellent story. I lost at this
You need to curate your short stories into a book. I like the way you provide your inspiration at the end with links. Please continue to do the same.
50
u/bimbo_bear Human Jun 06 '18
OH man... that guy is going to be so unhappy once he starts to get into code bases... layers upon layers upon cobol lol
10
u/hilburn Human Jun 06 '18
I enjoyed the story, even though I feel like I've read it before. It's an old engineering chain email iirc
However there was a lot of "where /were" mistakes which.. Please fix
9
u/Nanocephalic Jun 06 '18
This reads like an episode of Connections. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connections_(TV_series)
5
u/Twister_Robotics Jun 06 '18
I always loved that story.
3
u/Turtledonuts "Big Dunks" Jun 06 '18
The narrator is a little hard to pin down, so it would be nice if you could clear that up. But it's a hilarious story.
3
u/Shock_Lionheart Jun 06 '18
Tell him about Imperial units of measurement next!
2
u/tommyfever Jun 06 '18
Hello! I enjoy your stories buy you need a proofreader, lol...
"Oh pleas not this stuff again." Should be "please"
Your first "were" is correct but the next two instances of "where" should also be "were"
2
u/gridcube Jun 06 '18
I think you meant to use "too" almost every time you use "to"
2
u/Averant Jun 06 '18
Hah, this makes me want to write my own experience with bureaucracy. We have rules, and then we have exceptions. And then we have exceptions for the exceptions. And exceptions for those exceptions. And we have rules for the exceptions of the exceptions of the exceptions.
A rule that has no wiggle room will swiftly break.
2
u/aldonius Jun 07 '18
I believe this concept is usually called "path dependence".
1
u/UpdateMeBot Jun 06 '18
Click here to subscribe to /u/a_glass_of_whiskey and receive a message every time they post.
1
u/HFYBotReborn praise magnus Jun 06 '18
There are 15 stories by A_Glass_Of_Whiskey, including:
This list was automatically generated by HFYBotReborn version 2.13. Please contact KaiserMagnus or j1xwnbsr if you have any queries. This bot is open source.
1
u/slow_one Jun 06 '18
... and true, too
1
u/nPMarley Human Jun 07 '18
Ah, a look into the evolution of engineering.
1
u/DeepBrine Sep 03 '26
I first saw this as a mimeographed story stuck to the bulletin board over the community coffee pot.
The internet did not exist but mimeographs did and fax machines were starting to become common.