r/anime • u/ExoticSignature :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Jin28 • Jun 20 '18
[WT!] About a certain Isekai i started on a whim, Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash.
NO SPOILERS, atleast no more than what you'd read on a MAL Sypnosis.
Info:
Streams:
An Isekai Anime, what comes up in your mind when you hear somebody mentioning the genre?
An OP MC, Characters fitting predefined character tropes, low level monster and level bosses, getting levelled up like crazy, attaining a harem only for him to get cockblock by each girl in turn, and Character development getting lost somewhere in between.
Now i know, there are good ones like Overlord and Log Horizon, which focus on the worldbuilding and storytelling more ,i like them, sure, but in this thread i am going to talk about a certain under appreciated Isekai, which i liked way more.
So yesterday night, My sleepy ass was already extremely tired but there's this rule that i have befire going to bed, to watch an episode of any anime i like, or not, doesn't really matter, as an escape mechanism,you know?
So i stumbled upon this anime in the A-1 pictures folder of my HDD, and tried giving it a shot.
So, a bunch of characters fighting a goblin, uhmm, log horizon vibes but pretty mehh..
Ok.. maybe i should just sleep.
"Guys, We can't even fight a Goblin, the weakest monster in RPGs even after ganging up on him 6v1"
They were desperate, so was the Goblin, they all were fighting for their lives,so was the Goblin.
It felt (Sur)real.
My Dead fish Hikigaya Hachiman eyes sparkled, and i was curious.
"What is the realistic approach?"
"Am i watching an Anime?"
"I may have slept in between and have entered dream mode, r..right? right?"
NO
It was a reflection of what would happen if someone like You, or, me, or any person reading this post would feel, or do to survive if one gets truck-kun-ed to some other world.
I made myself a cup of coffee and binged through the whole show that night.
PLOT and General Thoughts
Fear, survival, instinct. Thrown into a foreign land with nothing but hazy memories and the knowledge of their name, they can feel only these three emotions resonating deep within their souls. A group of strangers is given no other choice than to accept the only paying job in this game-like world—the role of a soldier in the Reserve Army—and eliminate anything that threatens the peace in their new world, Grimgar.
When all of the stronger candidates join together, those left behind must create a party together to survive: Manato, a charismatic leader and priest; Haruhiro, a nervous thief; Yume, a cheerful hunter; Shihoru, a shy mage; Mogzo, a kind warrior; and Ranta, a rowdy dark knight. Despite its resemblance to one, this is no game—there are no redos or respawns; it is kill or be killed.
It is now up to this ragtag group of unlikely fighters to survive together in a world where life and death are separated only by a fine line.
The Music (especially the insert songs,wow) , the amazing unique characters, they actually being developed (along with the generic seeming annoying guy), the atmosphere and the amazing Water pallete drawn backgrounds(and a lot of wallpaper material coming up with them) all suit the theme of the show very well.
It might seem slow paced , but trust me,or not (watch and find out for yourself, you will do that, won't you? Onegai?), The pacing actually works in the favor of the overall atmosphere of the episode extremely well.
Like laid back shows?
It almost feels like a SoL (with a very soothing no dialogue-just music montage in Episode 2) 50% of the times.
Love me some action?
It has very well choreographed close quarter fights, a lot of them infact.
Morality and Perception
One of the things i liked about the show is the realism. About how there's actually blood all around, yesterday you didn't even know where you were and now you have to take a life and if you won't,it would be yours which would be taken. It's kill or be killed, about how it isn't just as easy as waving your black sword at a fire breathing mega creature. About who is the real monster here. Survival of the fittest in it's truest sense.
Romance fan?
There's plenty.
Love Unexpected turn of events?
Well, Spoilers Spoilers!
In search for a new Waifu/best girl?
There are two. Both are adorbs.
Love a show that ACTUALLY get renewed for a second season?
Well, This show most likely isn't gonna get one. I know, it sucks.
You might feel empty inside after finishing it and lurk somewhere around here finding someone to talk it out with, in any case, this post would be here for a while,right?
The inner thoughts of the characters might resonate with you, the glorious eyecatchers in between every episode is like an icing on the cake, and the character interactions and their growth as a group is something to cheer for.
You might come close to tears, or you might find it suprisingly refreshing, but you will take something from this show, which i believe is a characteristic of a good work of fiction.
Crying doesn't mean you are weak;Enduring doesn't mean you are strong.
EDIT: Our main characters who have formed a party have to overcome many challenges ,including group dynamics and making their own place as a respected group in this unknown city in the world of Grimgar, and Fighting monsters tougher than the ones they fought yesterday. At the end of the day, Fir better or for worse, It focuses on the SoL-esque problems more than having an end goal in sight.
EDIT2: Added Plot sypnosis.
TL;DR:
A realistic Isekai with realistic characters, one you shouldn't miss even if you don't like the genre. All in All a potential masterpiece,
Hai to Gensou no Grimgar
12
u/tjdraws https://anilist.co/user/TACTICIANJACK Jun 20 '18
After reading this post, I know why you liked the show. But why should anyone else? You're not explaining or elaborating on any of the things you mention about the show as good points. What genre is it? Hell if I know! What are the characters like? I have no idea! What is the setting? Other than knowing it's isekai, video-gamey, and fantasy, I have no idea- were they isekai'd into a video game? A video game like world? What's that world like? You're not giving any details about the show, just going on and on about how you experienced the show and that you like it a lot. I know the reasons why you like the show- but not the reasons behind those reasons. What makes the atmosphere good? The characters, the setting, the plot? Why do you like those? Why would other people like those? Your WT answers none of those questions, which are key to a successful and coherent WT.
7
u/bagglewaggle Jun 20 '18
The only thing I know about this show after reading your WT! is 'people fight a goblin'.
ಠ_ಠ
44
u/Char-11 Jun 20 '18
I know many people found the anime to be boring, or slow or whatever, and I understand why they would think that way.
But I loved this show.
The way it questioned the morality of killing in a fantasy world. Adding realism and weight to their fights(mostly) and having genuine character conflict.
I also really really enjoyed how they used the passage of time as a way of healing wounds, and how they put in so much idle speech for characterisation. Its in those empty spaces where nothing really happens where ironically, the most happens. We learn what the characters are like, how they talk, how they move, how they interact with each how, how they deal with loss, pain etc.
Like I said, lots of people will probably find that boring. But its an approach I found incredibly refreshing and underutilised. And for that, this show was definitely for me.
I gave it a (subjective) 10/10
12
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
I liked how weak the characters were and how everything was just so hard for them. They spent a lot of time together and building their internal relationships. I liked this so much that I hunted down the source material and when J Novel Club publishes another light novel E book, I download and read it. The world building and the suspense builds because you never know when your favorite characters might get hurt or worse. You really root for them and want to see them improve even a little.
Overall a good anime and a great light novel read.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
I like isekai because it's a fun fantasy romp, not because it's super realistic.
Although Re:Zero may well be more your thing, as every nerd would fall for the first cute girl that gave them any sign of affection and want nothing more than to make her happy, whilst lacking the skills to understand her feelings.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '18
I loved it. It was such a unique show. the art and the characters were just so different
-1
u/bagglewaggle Jun 21 '18
This isn't a bad hook, but it's far too long. Make it maybe half that length.
All of that is plagerized from MyAnimeList. Shame on you. If you're going to plagerize, at least use a source that isn't noticeably better written than your own work.
This isn't a complete thought or a sentence. Even if it was 'the music was good', that's still not explaining why the music is good. Are there creative instrumental choices or vocal arrangements? Does the series use music in creative ways? etc.
You're not explaining what makes them amazing or unique. That sentence means nothing. 'The characters get developed' is the minimum possible standard, not a reason for praise.
What kind of atmosphere? What's the theme of the show?
What are you trying to say here? You mention what the pacing isn't, but you don't explain how the show is paced, and you still haven't explained what the atmosphere is, so mentioning it does nothing.
So it's a slice of life, and the pacing and atmosphere you were mentioning were in reference to a slice of life?
...so it's an action slice-of-life?
...what?
This is rambling nonsense. You are not saying anything coherent here.
So it's a action/slice of life/romance series, with lots of all three. The fuck?
So it's an internal-monologue driven series with...in-between episode...things, and they grow(?) as a group? Again, this isn't coherent and it's not specific enough to tell me anything.
What you are describing is not a slice of life. I still have no idea what this show actually is.
'realistic Isekei' is an oxymoron.
This might be the worst WT! I've seen. The best part was the part you stole from MAL.
0
u/NihonNoRyu Jun 21 '18
now start reading the novel from the beginning :D