r/colony • u/OsoOsoOo Collaborator • Jun 28 '18
Discussion [Colony] S03E09 - “The Big Empty” - Discussion Thread (SPOILERS) Spoiler
Discuss!
65
Upvotes
r/colony • u/OsoOsoOo Collaborator • Jun 28 '18
Discuss!
60
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
Bram had that really, really ,really evil look in his eyes.
22
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
So we are seeing the previous episode from the other point of view. How about that.
8
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18 edited Jun 28 '18
So for the people who downvoted the hell out of me last week about the putting a tracker inside that briefcase lol. Y'all have some explaining to do lol
JK
(edit: I'm not sober, I like y'all)
67
u/Kwanyinagain Jun 28 '18
My favorite line this season. Broussard: "You think well-adjusted people do what I do?"
61
u/Kwanyinagain Jun 28 '18
Sarah Wayne Callies did a fantastic job directing this episode!
45
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18
Damn. I thought he was actually going to drown Snyder.
39
u/WebbieVanderquack Jun 28 '18
Wow, that was intense. Hand out some Emmys.
A few thoughts:
I know a lot of people weren't thrilled that we were suddenly back in a colony, and the banality of middle-class suburbia, but one of the things I love about this show is how suddenly the scenery changes. Filming the majority of an episode's scenes in an expensive hotel, and most of those in a store room with only a handful of props, worked really well.
I was also impressed that what started as an interrogation rapidly became a case of three men - Will, Snyder and Bram - acknowledging that they all bear their share of guilt.
Seriously, the emotional stuff was really intense. Peter Jacobson and Josh Holloway's performances really shone.
32
u/olily Jun 28 '18
I don't have a problem at all with Will not killing Snyder. Will was conflicted about Snyder, for some good reasons and some not so good reasons. Some of what Snyder told him was true--he did warn them to leave the camp and he did act as an older relative for months with the kids. Will had no way of knowing Snyder was lying when he said he didn't make the call, but it was possible (in Will's mind) that he was telling the truth about that, too. What broke Will's resolve to kill Snyder was when Snyder said that he buried Charlie, and that he loved him too. Such a simple comfort to Will, but I think the idea that someone treated Charlie with respect when Will couldn't be there to protect him (or his body) broke through Will's hatred.
I like how Will confronting Snyder and then letting him live seemed to break him out of his post-Charlie depression (PTSD, insanity, what you want to call it), as evidenced by him being nicer to Katie, telling her to have a nice day. He faced his emotions while dealing with Snyder, and it was cathartic for him.
Every time a commercial came on, I realized I was tensing all my muscles. This episode was intense.
22
u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 28 '18
First, the positives. The tension was great. I was touched by the scene with Katie watching Will sob. I didn't have the reaction of others here finding Will's reaction unbelievable. Will broke down similarly when he was beating the snot out of the bald engineer guy, so the writers did try to set this scene up. Uncle Al pulled his heart strings.
However, we knew what was going to happen in this episode, and even less happened than I hoped. It was obvious to everyone that Will was going to let Snyder go, because of Snyder's silver tongue. However, I hoped the plot would be advanced by letting us see the island's "holding facility" that Everett mentioned last episode. Snyder went there between the last episode and this one! Argh! It's probably just a bunch of people in pods, which we've already seen, but I hoped we'd get more information.
Snyder starts the interrogation with a believable lie that Broussard busts him on. Another thing he says here that I don't believe is that the podified people are the biological weapons. I don't think they are the biological weapon that Seattle is supposed to be developing, according to an IGA document. Podification was something LA was doing as well, and nobody said LA was making biological weapons.
Almost the only plot advancement we received was the briefcase with vials of blood and Petri dishes (or whatever). This obviously has a large chance of being the biological weapon: killer bacteria. Maybe the lettuce is just the vehicle for killer bacteria (as I speculated). Everett said this sample came in on a plane. If true, from where and from whom? What is the intended use/target? I understand the Petri dishes, but then why the vials of blood?
We saw them testing the graphene-like sheet versus a drone's weapon. This seems to be a season 1 style drone with (IMO) a micro-minigun, so standard bullets, but a lot of them, and small caliber. So, I don't think we learned anything that Broussard's experiment didn't already show us. Well, we did learn that workplace safety has really suffered during the occupation, as the lab technician walks right where the mini-gun had fired moments before.
Everett told the courier to take this sample to "prototyping". Hurray, some new information. So the destination was a prototyping lab. Previously, when the courier dropped off a briefcase and received a pile of boxes, Broussard called it an "exchange", but it seems it wasn't a barter - he was just dropping off a new sample and retrieving the prototypes from the previous technology sample, like clockwork. That's not how it's going to work with a prototyping lab, where the schedule is going to be unpredictable. It can't possibly be a clue. It's bad writing.
Everett cautions the courier to follow protocol, which apparently involves driving down a narrow alley into a probable ambush. It can't possibly be a clue. It's bad writing.
21
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18
Omg i loved that no hesitation bitch slap
19
u/Viktor2905 Jun 28 '18 edited Jun 29 '18
Snyder is my favorite character. And I hate him at the same time.
15
u/Savvaloy Jun 28 '18
Huh. I'd forgotten Bram had a body count.
15
u/Kwanyinagain Jun 28 '18
I loved how Kynes dealt with Snyder's invasive insistence on staying in "his" colony. Basically oh, OK, well, you are so very important that I will have a security team shadow you 24/7. And you will need to tell us your every move in advance. Enjoy your snooping.
24
u/baconandeggs666 Resistor Jun 28 '18
That was a fantastic episode.
I have this gut feeling that Snyder will either kill himself or get killed by Bram. He was so traumatized, he didn't rat them out.
10
u/Kwanyinagain Jun 28 '18
TIL: Don't drink with Broussard.
10
u/BlueManiac Jun 28 '18
Damn, I really liked this episode, very emotional and the acting was awesome.
8
u/xocgx Jun 28 '18
I’m wondering if we will find out Keynes is in contact with the OTHER aliens.
7
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
It's like a sci-fi version of Oceans 11.
7
u/Sheik-mon Jun 28 '18
I absolutely love this season, just fantastic. Everything about it.
6
u/msmerrilees Jun 30 '18
Jesus...that toilet scene was intense!
11
u/PowerEliteJin Collaborator Jun 28 '18
Kinda figured Snyder was going to be let off the hook somehow
5
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
Wait!!! They use their phones for EVERYTHING IN SEATTLE!!! Well, well, well...
5
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
How did the doorman know that there was someone from the IGA was staying at the hotel?
5
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
Spoiler
9
u/DrunkenDave Jun 28 '18
I just want to say, the emotional intensity of the scene reminded me a great deal of the Lost Episode The Brig, in which Sawyer finally kills the man that conned his parents which led to their deaths.
Only the outcome this time was different. Holloway nails it for the second time.
8
u/EmilMR Jun 29 '18
pains me that there won't be a season 4 (probably). this season was so much better than 1/2. It's been really good, writing is much better, pacing is great, never a dull moment, stakes are the highest they've been, great variety in set/locations used during the season and much more beautiful tbh. what a shame...
4
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
I could see the IGA trying to take Kynes out because he was able to talk with the hosts. At the same time, this is coming from Snyder and I can only trust him as far as I can throw him.
4
u/iv_dx Jun 28 '18
yeah, Peter save the
dayepisode again. What a wonderful actor !It seems to me he also writes dialogues for Alan Snyder )
4
u/Kwanyinagain Jun 28 '18
So what was in the white briefcase at the beginning? The one Kynes said "Just came off the plane"? And... there are planes now?
4
u/iamnotsimon Jun 28 '18
So will is one of these precursors but not sleeping? That's why he doesn't get attacked by the drones..... Does that mean he could be a sleeper agent?
4
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
So do they even have drones in Seattle? I mean I seen the one they had inside the lab. I know we haven’t seen the need for them yet. Do you guys think the drones that are inside the walls are on hibernate mode? The last time we seen the drones was during the Seattle Uprising.
7
u/redditman6 Jun 28 '18
Wonder what will come of Amy. Loved the way Broussard just said "aight" when Amy said she was done with Will. The sneak peek for next episode did not have her in it, and Broussard was with Will.
3
u/Kwanyinagain Jun 28 '18
Prototyping. Where the scientist is working with the bulletproof material and a drone.
So is Kynes reverse engineering alien (or supposedly alien) tech- or are he and his employees developing it in the first place?
3
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18
Great Episode! Colony just gets better and better event though this episode was very contained.
It's so hard not to empathise with Will on so many different levels. Charlie's death has had some real consequences for everybody and that's really great writing.
I honestly thought Will was going to kill him but Will knows that even if he does it won't bring Charlie back and that is usually what sits at the core of revenge arcs.
I do believe Snyder felt true guilt at the death of Charlie and that he was trying to do some right as Proxy. His arc has been really compelling.
Also; Will is an Outlier. Looks like those Outliers have been enhanced. Bring on the War!
P.S. I could watch Peyton List forever :P
5
u/WarmGas Jun 28 '18
Did I miss a scene? When did Bram get looped into the team?
2
u/htbdt Jun 28 '18
Can someone tell me how Bram got involved? He was communicating with Amy, which is weird. Did they meet off screen? Did Will bring him in? Doesnt make sense.
He says to Will "you talked me into helping you and now that were here you cant pull the trigger!" So I GUESS Will pulled him in knowing he was CP?
2
u/hey_ulrich Collaborator Jun 30 '18
I miss the religion stuff.
3
u/Prodiq Jun 28 '18
You could clearly see how Snyder tells parts that are true and some lies in between like the rap called for backup. So it all becomes reasonable. Will said it best...
2
u/ricky_lafleur Jun 28 '18
Bram should know that he doesn't need a gun to kill Snyder. He could've just beat him to death.
2
u/Ssme812 Jun 28 '18
Why didn't they just kill him already :/
2
u/McIntyre2K7 High Ranking IGA official Jun 28 '18
When are we going to get some action in this episode???
2
u/EtherealSekrets182 SURVIVOR Jun 28 '18
I may be insane for thinking Bram is sexy all of a sudden.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '18
Damn it! Are you kidding me?!?!
1
u/teandro Jun 28 '18
What happened to the camera, did Broussard take it?
1
u/CruiseMissileImpact Jun 28 '18
Okay so I'm like really confused.
Do Broussard and Amy know about the second alien species and the RAP interrogation yet, or...???
1
u/2_Fingers_of_Whiskey Jun 30 '18
I love that Bram is still totally Resistance! He didn't sell out by taking that "Community Patrol" job after all. I wanted him to kill Snyder. I'm getting sick of Snyder as a character (the actor is really good though). This was the perfect opportunity to finally kill him off. Hopefully he later sacrifices himself to save the remaining Bowmans, somewhat redeeming himself.
I wish that Katie had gone to comfort Will at the end, but she just sat there.
1
u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jun 30 '18
Might the security detail that Kynes assigned to Snyder have been blackjacks? I've been wondering for quite some time if the blackjacks work for Kynes (blackjacks have the List and so does Kynes), and this security detail did the same thing as blackjacks, asserting authority through intimidation. Like blackjacks, they demand ID of others, and never show their own.
Another thing that was odd about their behavior was that they backed off when Snyder gave his implausible story about his bruises being from an S&M quickie with a woman. Snyder wasn't even in his top form, being visibly shaken, so they should have seen something was off. Maybe they were cool with what happened to Snyder? Shouldn't they have found the maintenance closet within the nearly half hour that Snyder was gone, instead of hanging out in the lobby?
1
u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jul 04 '18
I'll cache some predictions here. These are low probability to actually occur. If you go psycho on me, I'll encrypt any future predictions.
1
u/MichaelHall1 #Colony'sDeadJim Jul 04 '18
Needs more sticky glue.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '18
can someone explain the list to me?
0
u/and_yet_another_user Jun 28 '18
And another episode where we go from a position of only Will, Broussard and Amy working together, to one where suddenly Bram is involved, and we just have to assume that he was recruited offscreen by his dad.
ofc some idiot is going to try to justify this lazy writing by saying that Bram later, right near the end of the episode, revealed Bram's dad spoke to him off screen lol
And I'm getting tired of Amy's character. She started out with promise of being someone of importance in the story, but now is being demoted to one of just a moral conscience for the resistance unit that is struggling to save mankind from aliens and their human collaborators. That and the side issue for some fans to pine for a Broussard/Amy ship.
And please stop putting MVP Snyder in life threatening situations, we all know he is not going to die. This is the problem with plot armour, it removes any suspense from characters danger scenarios.
-5
u/jaggypillows Jun 28 '18
Will Bowman sucks at fake crying.
Snyder is too good of a character to kill.
I loves the beginning scene from the perspective of the courier. /applause
Amy and Will are totes besties
I am looking to buy 1 bulletproof alien condom.. please send message
<3