r/hentai • u/Kicken • Mar 05 '19
Reddit, Anti-Evil, Brigade Signalling, And You NSFW
Hey everyone! I wanted to provide another update on the current state of things, where we are at, and the things we are concerned with at the moment.
Section 1 - Reddit Administration
Anti-Evil
For those of you that are unaware, “Anti-Evil Operations” is the name of Reddit’s team that enforces their content guidelines. While we have not changed how we have been judging what content was and was not permissible based on our best interpretation of Reddit’s guidelines, Anti-Evil certainly has.
Historically, we have taken the stance that the artistic intention of the portrayal of a character held far more value than any out-of-context information about the character. To put that in more blatant terms - we didn’t care if a character was canonically underage, if they didn’t look underage. If anyone looking at the image without background knowledge of a character would say “Hm… Probably not a kid.” then we deemed it permissible. This was based on Reddit’s content guidelines seeming focused towards things that could be allegated to encouraging Pedophilia - a sexual attraction to prepubescents. Given this context, we thought it reasonable that if an image did not specifically cater to sexualizing a character that appeared prepubescent, that reasonably, there should not be an issue.
This policy served us well, with almost no instances of Anti-Evil stepping in from the shadows to take action against a post or a user for quite some time. Atleast, until recently. While there has not been any notable changes to the meaning of the content guidelines, there has observably been a massive increase in the amount of actions that Anti-Evil has taken on r/Hentai and related subreddits. Many of these actions also entail the banning of users without warning.
How Does Anti-Evil Decide What Is Permissible?
In truth, we can only guess. u/Constipat8, a notable user of r/Doujinshi, had their account permanently suspended with no response to an appeal for content which involved women that appear fully mature, with large breasts and wide hips. The catch? They were wearing high school outfits. Never mind that high schoolers can be above the age of consent and there was nothing to suggest they weren’t otherwise. This alone was enough to warrant his account being banned indefinitely, without warning, and with no response to an appeal.
Since then, we have seen a continued trend of simply wearing a high school outfit being the only link to characters supposedly being underage. Images such as this one and this one were targeted for removal and their users banned, despite there being no grounds to claim that the artist was appealing to pedophiles in art style or content.
This notes a drastic shift as it seems Anti-Evil is taking a new stance that canonical age does matter, despite also demonstrably disregarding canonical ages when they feel like it. Some examples of the futility of using canonical age include a hundreds year old vampire being disallowed or someone less than 10 years old being apparently just fine. Both of these highlight that canonical age is entirely useless in determining if the works actually encourage pedophilia.
Why the sudden shift?
After the banning of Holofan4life, an admin response to his appeal was posted on the relevant subreddit. Among other information, an interesting comment was made.
The subscribers of anime-focused communities are also highly aware of the purported ages of certain characters, and as you experienced, they will not hesitate to report content involving underaged characters to us.
This reads as a very bold and self-justified statement to me. It really reads as though the person writing this believes that there is a group of people organized against this content…
Section 2 - Anti-Loli Activists
Report Brigading
For the unaware, brigading, also called raiding, is when a call is put out to take action against a certain post/user/sub. This can take many forms and call for different things to happen, such as vote brigading, where a community is called upon to up or downvote a post in another community. Brigades may also seek to spam comments, suppress dissenting opinion, or flood Anti-Evil with reports, in hopes that sheer numbers alone will achieve their goals.
Basically, brigading is when one community forces itself on another. It is my observation that there are certain subreddits organized specifically to brigade for the purpose of getting certain users and subreddits banned. Of course, such activities are against Reddit’s site-wide rules. So far, that has not yet stopped these people from targeting posts, users, and subreddits with harassment and reporting posts that do not adhere to their subjective view on what is or isn’t in good taste.
Those participating in brigading compile lists of users and subreddit which they feel are in violation of their subjective ideals, posting them within their community for targeted action. These types of brigades have seen the removal of content, banning of users, and even of entire subreddits that by any decent judgement are not in offense to site-wide rules. The actions of these subreddits muddy the waters of what should or shouldn’t be allowed by flooding Anti-Evil with reports against things their community disapproves of. Actions like these has resulted in the banning of entire communities such as r/NewGameXXX that had no focus or interest in under age content. Posts have been made expressing regret for this specific brigade, as no real under age content was being pushed on r/NewGameXXX . However, such failure in judgement and eagerness to respond to a “call to action” is exactly why brigading and witch-hunting are disallowed - because mob mentality is not reasonable.
Brigade Signalling
Often times, it is not uncommon to see comments such as these which highlight a supposed moral outrage against what is being depicted. These comments serve as signalling for others within certain communities to take action, sometimes with explicit calls to action as well. These activities are against Reddit’s site-wide rules against witch hunting, brigading, trolling, and harassment. These users are acting in bad faith, with the pretentious ideal and self-admittedly “half-joking” goal of “protecting the lolis”, but have failed to understand the border between a healthy joke and destructive brigading. They are acting with little to no consideration on the impact to the users in which they are brigading or the larger confusion caused by their “half-joking” exacerbated outrage.
Section 3 - What We Are Doing
About Brigading
Ironic as it may sound, we can’t call for the mass reporting of such communities, even if they are breaking site-wide rules. That would, as it is, be in violation of witch-hunting and brigading rules. What we can do is work towards making their signalling be clearly unacceptable.
Moving forward, any comments which attempt to point out, put in question, or suggest a character’s age will be removed. This includes comments both asserting that the character is under age or above age. To be clear, this also extends to “This is Illegal”, “FBI”, and “Lolice” type memes. Posts depicting characters such as Raphtalia often contain messages encouraging “protection”. These types of message will be prohibited as well.
Concerns about a character’s under age status are encouraged to be sent to the moderation team for review.
The fact is, these faux-outrage comments lead to confusion. It is unlikely that Anti-Evil is staffed by individuals that are acutely aware that these comments should be treated as a joke and possibly malicious. These types of comments encourage Anti-Evil to act in cases where they otherwise shouldn’t due to perceived community pressure.
Users that participate in these kind of comments will have their accounts permanently banned without warning. If it was your first offense, simply message us an assurance that you will no longer partake in these actions, and the ban will be lifted. I would ask that if you see comments that break the rules stated above, please report them to us. If you become aware of a post referencing or linking to an r/Hentai submission with a “call for action”, please inform us.
About Anti-Evil
Due to Anti-Evil’s increased rate of taking action on users, no matter how established a character is within the 18+ community, we will be taking increased efforts to remove posts which possibly offend Anti-Evil’s sensibilities. Because the exact nature of what is or isn’t allowed is highly subjective, the enforcement of this may seem nonsensical at times. I humbly apologize for this. We don’t wish to see our users’ accounts be banned if we can do anything to prevent it. With a pending request to the admins to clarify on their current rules, we have acted in good faith to continue abiding the ToS.
Don't like this? We don't either, for the reasons listed above. Let the admins know.
We will be researching further in regards to what we can do to provide our users with a better platform for sharing content without overbearing, subjective, and puritanical enforcement from the shadows. If you have any suggestions, please leave them in the comments or message us directly.
tl;dr Some communities are trolling us, signs of this trolling will get you banned. Meme responsibly.
36
u/Horsefucker9000 Mar 06 '19 edited Mar 06 '19
Just leave reddit. Admins are not incentivised to respond to this post at all, much less help or respect us.
32
u/dercporno Mar 06 '19
It should be well understood that Reddit’s ownership is not above what tumblr did to itself.
30
u/immortalreploid Mar 07 '19
This is just getting ridiculous. Why the fuck should anyone care about what kind of drawings other people are fapping to?
28
u/cornflakes32 Mar 06 '19
I'm late to this but same thing happened to me. Posted on poke porn and got permanently suspended without anyone telling me. I'm fairly new to posting so it exactly affect me, but no one gave me a reason why I was banned. Although a mod from hentai beast reached out saying nothing was wrong, I never got the account back nor was given a reason as to why I was banned.
62
u/Carbine64_ Mar 05 '19
Reddit's looking as though it's gonna transform into Tumblr and I don't like it. Man fuck America's dumb laws and reddit's dumb policies, I want the old days back.
75
u/ohlookaregisterbutto Mar 06 '19 edited Jul 17 '25
reminiscent soft command resolute rinse touch afterthought tan smell rainstorm
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
15
u/twthesecond Mar 06 '19
My two cents: Maybe Reddit admins going too far this time, but it seems you are one of few subs with a reasonable stance on this stuff, doing it based on physical appearance not whatever out of context lore says. I appreciate it.
7
u/bigthrows123 Mar 10 '19
A bit late to this. Used to post here more often before I disappeared for a while, but I've always appreciated what you've done as a mod Kicken, especially for a sub like this.
I see you're actively engaging with the brigading sub in question. Not everyone would put as much effort as you are right now. I'm sure this is cutting into personal time a bit too.
You got our support, with the words here in this post by others spoken and I'm sure even with the people that have not unspoken.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
I love how Reddit bans brigading, but full on supports it.
There are nore of us then there are of these chumps. Maybe we should find out what subs they are regular too, and brigade them back. I don't normally support sinking down to another's level, but wtf else are we supposed to do?
5
u/Ultiran Mar 12 '19
We just wanna fap man.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '19
How about just don't post anything with characters that look to be of questionable age?
2
u/StopHavingAnOpinion Mar 20 '19
Hey moderator, I am not sure where I am supposed to post this question.
Is there a tag for 'sex starved' milfs?
2
u/_ThetaBeta_ Mar 22 '19
I feel like this sub will go down soon. Fucking brigadiers.
2
u/Conscious_Implement8 Jul 25 '23
Are you kidding me
2
u/PM_me_Kitsunemimi Apr 21 '19
Fuck, and I thought the lolice was a meme sub some time ago.
17
u/Disappointed_Echoes Mar 06 '19
reddit is only concerned with concerned advertisers now. they know their only real revenue is pushing sponsored content so everything is going out the window.
10
u/JyntendoR34 Mar 08 '19
I fully support Reddit dying out, the way it's set up right now and the mindless drivel on this site that upvote anything on the front page, even if it's a repost from 2 minutes ago; it's just a cesspool and these rules just make it worse. People just don't seem to give a fuck anymore and subs I loved are going to shit because of it (Rule34 comes to mind). I prided myself on posting decent content regularly but now it's just too much hassle, too much loopholes to jump through and too many idiots upvoting garbage to the front-page, it's just not fun anymore. Unfortunate but not surprising what is happening. Freedom of speech is slowly dying and it's not even the government's fault this time, it's ours and all these jackass snowflakes that will stand on any soupbox to make themselves heard. Humans really are pieces of shit.
9
u/fuzzythelion Mar 06 '19
wait my man Constip8 got banned? :(
14
u/SkyIcewind Mar 07 '19
I don't mind the removal of loli one bit, ain't really my jam.
But goddamn, they'll ban you for posting hentai of any character with breasts smaller than a C-cup...Because small/flat chested women dont exist apparently, must obviously be underaged.
I get sick of goddamn F-cup titty monsters sometimes.
7
u/Evarrisette Mar 07 '19
It seems I've been a target of such thing.
My 2 year old account with 146K zKP got suddenly banned for me allegedly posting bad stuff.
Reddit's current rules are annoying and vague that can be easily be subjected to abuse!
4
u/EntaiDaisuki Mar 18 '19 edited Mar 18 '19
Year after year the world of happiness is crumbling. Why can't we just fap to death?
Someone! Put ME back on YEAR 2012!
Tumblr = No Hentai
Imgur Albums = ALL HIDDEN *rip billnyethehentaiguy.imgur.com
Year Mid 2015 More rules implemented (if you know what I mean)
Bandits' Loots Banished
Edit: My blood boils reading this post. If THEY'RE really against CP. Send a job application to FBI, CIA, POLICE to combat REAL CP. Not being a bunch of edgelords fighting crime wannabes. REAL pedos doing crime outside the internet. They act to REAL, LIVING, BREATHING BEINGS. Most people just want to jump on the hypetrain while wearing horse-blinders without even thinking hard and deep.
1
u/AdministrativeTour78 Jan 18 '22
Is there anything protecting the content of gay posts?
3
u/jchoneandonly Jun 15 '22
Do basically reddit douchebags are being stupid censorious assholes. What else is new
2
u/TotesMessenger Mar 06 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
2
u/OreoSwordsman Mar 14 '19
Aw, that means I can’t “woop woop, that’s the sound of the lolice” anymore. Damnit. Gotta get more creative.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '22
Somehow never stumbled on this post. Very well written comprehensive breakdown of the issue. Its just such a shame that recently a Lot of stories have been revealed where these virtue signaling folkes often have risque anime/manga likes themselves. Makes it seem so stupid.
My thanks to the mod team for your efforts!
1
u/HecateX Mar 20 '19
The solution is is simple stop using reddit. Its layout is garbage anyway.
1
u/Extemejojofan Dec 01 '24
Poopy
1
u/doctorduck19 Jun 13 '23
Just wanna say. Thank you porn guy for giving me social info that is uber relavent. Took a sec to read and understand as I'm dumb as shit. Mad respect and appreciation for the knowledge. Hope you are well. Fuckin love ya!
-11
u/SentientBowtie Mar 06 '19
Stop posting content that violates Reddit guidelines and it won’t get removed.
0
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
51
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '19
[removed] — view removed comment