r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • Apr 19 '19
Map Thread #95 Results & Notes πβοΈ
Welcome to the official results thread for Map Thread #95! Following are the upcoming changes to the official TagPro Map Rotation.
Additions
Lemon by DragonBeast
Carrera by alchemist, Fronj, Ball-E
Removals
None
Throwback Rotation
Draft
Rocketballs
Cabin
Command Center
Marrow
Cosmic
Danger Zone 3
Mzungu
Blooper
Trebuchet
Micro will be removed from rotation forever.
Notes
Notes on notes:
What we write is to be taken as constructive criticism. We sometimes test all the maps in one sitting; we can't break the news gently that each map isn't great if we want to maintain our sanity. Please understand some comments will occasionally sound frustrated.
The notes are anonymous and randomized so we don't get harrassed.
Don't expect perfection or even consistency. If we all had the same opinions there would only need to be one of us.
Take no comment as an MTC member echoing other members.
Changes To The MTC
There were some changes to the committee's members this thread. We would like to welcome our newest member DragonBeast /u/DragonBeast2
We are looking for new members of the community to join us, here is a quick video to maybe get you inspired to be a part of the MTC.
Please fill out this application to be considered for opens slots in our organization.
We heard you, and we've listened and we've changed the number of map submissions from 3 to 5!
Your votes on maps influence rotation. Please remember to vote after each game! Below are comments about each addition/removal where MTC members may or may not give their personal opinions/feedback. Please give us yours.
Congratulations to all the mapmakers who have influenced the rotation! Keep mapmaking!
8
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 19 '19
Please Discuss The New Addition Carrera by alchemist, Fronj, Ball-E
7
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 19 '19
Please Discuss The New Addition Lemon by DragonBeast
7
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 19 '19
Please Discuss The Increase of Map Submissions 3 β‘ 5
5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 19 '19
Hello all, we are taking steps to improve transparency on the MTC voting process. In order to do so, we have heard and incorporated feedback from the community. Therefore, we are excited to release results from this thread with explicit context:
Solo Testing Results:
Vienna (61653): Score [Y = 4 | M = 1 | N = 1] = 0.62
Dead_Star (61579): Score [Y = 0 | M = 5 | N = 0] = 0.2
Noodle Arms (61637): Score [Y = 0 | M = 1 | N = 4] = -0.36
Ouija (61656): Score [Y = 0 | M = 1 | N = 4] = -0.36
Stronghold (61651): Score [Y = 1 | M = 1 | N = 2] = 0.05
Sakura (61647): Score [Y = 0 | M = 2 | N = 3] = -0.22
Windsor (61669): Score [Y = 0 | M = 2 | N = 3] = -0.22
Lemon (61686): Score [Y = 4 | M = 2 | N = 0] = 0.73
Carrera (61348): Score [Y = 2 | M = 2 | N = 0] = 0.6
e (61531): Score [Y = 5 | M = 1 | N = 0] = 0.87
Salem (61555): Score [Y = 2 | M = 2 | N = 2] = 0.23
Divert (61548): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = -0.5
Catapult (61122): Score [Y = 1 | M = 2 | N = 2] = 0.08
Boko Harambe (61341): Score [Y = 2 | M = 2 | N = 2] = 0.23
Acid Map (61626): Score [Y = 2 | M = 3 | N = 1] = 0.35
BACK (61566): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 5] = -0.5
Cynoid (61562): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = -0.5
Prelude (61631): Score [Y = 1 | M = 0 | N = 5] = -0.25
Buster (61501): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = -0.5
Puke (61543): Score [Y = 2 | M = 1 | N = 2] = 0.24
Hillbilly (): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 5] = -0.5
g (61515): Score [Y = 0 | M = 3 | N = 2] = -0.08
Keep away (61533): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 5] = -0.5
Jukebox (61547): Score [Y = 4 | M = 0 | N = 1] = 0.7
Rover (): Score [Y = 1 | M = 0 | N = 4] = -0.2
Woggit (61567): Score [Y = 0 | M = 1 | N = 3] = -0.33
Scavenger (61578): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 5] = -0.5
Aerator (61604): Score [Y = 2 | M = 0 | N = 3] = 0.1
Penisylvania (61605): Score [Y = 0 | M = 1 | N = 4] = -0.36
Look, beating off is my passion and I'm not about to give that up for some woman that loves me (61619): Score [Y = 0 | M = 1 | N = 4] = -0.36 Space Bound (61624): Score [Y = 0 | M = 2 | N = 1] = -0.03
Darwin (61649): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 3] = -0.5
Ineffable (61661): Score [Y = 1 | M = 0 | N = 3] = -0.13
Space Pirate (61732): Score [Y = 1 | M = 1 | N = 3] = -0.06
Initial Testing Results:
e (61531): Score [Y = 6 | M = 0 | N = 1] = Pass
Lemon (61686): Score [Y = 6 | M = 1 | N = 0] = Pass
Jukebox (61547): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 7] = Fail
Vienna (61653): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 7] = Fail
Carrera (61348): Score [Y = 4 | M = 1 | N = 0] = Pass
Acid Map (61626): Score [Y = 1 | M = 0 | N = 6] = Fail
Puke (61543): Score [Y = 3 | M = 2 | N = 2] = Pass
Boko Harambe (61341): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = Fail
Salem (61555): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = Fail
Dead_Star (61579): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = Fail
Aerator (61604): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 6] = Fail
Catapult (61122): Score [Y = 0 | M = 0 | N = 4] = Fail
Final Voting Decisions:
Rotation Additions:
Whiplash: [ Y = 0 | N = 4 ] Fail
Carrera: [ Y = 3 | N = 1 ] Pass
Lemon: [ Y = 5 | N = 0 ] Pass
Nuke: [ Y = 0 | N = 5 ] Fail
Rotation Removals:
Joji: [ Y = 1 | N = 5 ] Fail
Tetanic: [ Y = 1 | N = 4 ] Fail
Sugar Hill: [ Y = 2 | N = 3 ] Fail
Other Administrative Votes:
Change map limit to 5: [ Y = 6 | N = 0 ] Pass
Make a minimum amount of maps that make top maps: [ Y = 0 | N = 3 ] Fail
Send out applications to join the MTC: [ Y = 4 | N = 0 ] Pass
Consider rolling submissions with nomination based testing to be scheduled once 10 (or however many) nominated maps have been seconded: [ Y = 0 | N = 4 ] Fail
Add DragonBeast to the MTC starting in thread 96: [ Y = 3 | N = 0 ] Pass
Dismiss micro: [ Y = 4 | N = 0 ] Pass
7
u/Blupopsicle Ball-E Apr 19 '19
can i get uhhhh
permanent reduced rotation
https://www.reddit.com/r/TagPro/comments/b9hwg4/discussion_it_has_been_3_months_with_only_18_maps/
7
u/TheGoldenNewtRobber Fronj, MTC Senior Consultant Apr 19 '19
The MTC is watching and listening to this thread (and I encourage them participate as they feel fit), please donβt be afraid to comment on anything and make suggestions. Additionally, you can find us on discord for more conversations such as receiving more in depth and specific map feedback in a more private setting if you prefer.
2
u/c00ldud3 Ryanoceros / rye bread / RocketSkates | Ex-MTC Apr 19 '19
IDK how keen I am on the maps that were added, but hey, I'm glad at least something got in. Something is better than nothing. We'll see how they play.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '19 edited Apr 19 '19
new mtc member gets map in rotation. ive always wondered have ye thought critically about whether or not ye have a bias in the testing to maps made by yere own kin? yere way overrepresented in maps making it through the rounds out of all the maps submitted, at least back like a year ago to 18 months. I dont know now but this is the first map thread i see in a while and new mtc member and new map from him
edit: anyone making it this far: their votes are public which of course has an influence on voting even if they don't think it does. There should also be an effort to anonymise the maker of a map being tested to remove biases present in the MTC
-1
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee Apr 19 '19
Please Discuss the Throwback Rotation and Permanent Removal of Micro