r/anime • u/faux_wizard • Aug 03 '19
AMA Finished AMA with foreign animators working in the Japanese industry (Zucchinijuice, William Lee, Remy Clarke) LIVE!
I am pleased to announce that our AMA with a number of wonderful webgen animators will be starting now! Our guests are all foreigners who are actively working alongside the Japanese industry to bring us the anime that we love. These talented individuals include:
Zucchinijuice: /u/secretzucchini
Credits: One Punch Man, SSSS.Gridman, To Be Heroine
William Lee: /u/WilliamLeeAnim
Credits: Girls and Panzer, Beyblade Burst, Aikatsu, Wizard Barristers, Inazuma Eleven, Striving for Animation youtube
Remy Clarke: /u/Remy_Clarke
Credits: Space Battleship Yamato, Hisone to Masotan, My Hero Academia, Akane Sasu, Kirinn Lemon ad
Alongside them will be aspiring animator Jarrett Martin who helps run the highly informative and informational channel Striving for Animation channel on youtube and it’s sister forum Sakuga Foundry alongside William Lee.
Jarrett Martin: /u/soraskellington
Credits: Striving for Animation YouTube, Sakugafoundry.com founder
Tomorrow evening Striving for Animation will be releasing an interview with Will, Remy and Zucc, where they talk about a lot of common questions people interested in the anime industry might have. If you missed the AMA, this video might answer some of your questions!
27
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Aug 03 '19
So these questions aren't really for a single one of you, but all. Feel free though to ignore questions you feel don't apply to you:
Nr 1: Most of what fans know about anime budgets is speculative, mostly because we get no numbers and people who'd have the numbers dodge when questioned, or, as the interpreter at an Q&A told me, have to dodge. I'd guess that this is probably because of NDAs, which made me wonder: How is it for you animators? Do you have NDAs concerning your parts in productions and if yes, how strict are they?
Nr. 2: I recently read an interview of Misu Yamaneko, an italian animator in Japan, who wrote that
Is this true? Do keyframe animators and secondary keyframe animators get the same pay for a cut in general, or is this only true for this specific kind of case? What factors determine the pay for keyframes?
Nr. 3: The word "Sakuga" has experienced something of a change in western fanspeak, where it's used to describe moments/cuts/scenes in which the animation is exceedingly better than in others (as opposed to just "animation" or "drawn picture"). Do you have a stance on this, if yes, what is it? Does or did it ever affect you in any way?
Nr. 4: Finally, unrelated to the anime industry: what would you say is the most challenging part of your day-to-day life in Japan as a foreigner? What is easier than you originally expected?
22
u/zhongzhen93 Aug 03 '19
Fresh Malaysian Animation undergrad here. A lot of my friends who are interested in animating Japan get disheartened when they hear about the working conditions/pay of animators in Japan. They tend to decide to just stay local and go 3D (Maya etc).
Thank you for answering our questions.
17
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
I just want to thank you for your work on Gridman and Rikkas thighs.
9
u/ranran_giran Aug 03 '19
Just to preface, I'm an animation student and while my teachers have been unexpectedly supportive of my stylistic choice they told me to find other ways to learn how to animate like animators from Japan because none of the instructors in my school have practical experience doing anime.
My question is, how should I approach learning to animate like Megumi Kouno for example? I feel like the obvious answer is to analyze cuts she's animated but I don't really know what I should be analyzing for when looking at the works of other animators.
8
u/ICD2_ Aug 03 '19 edited Aug 03 '19
Zucchinijuice: How many model sheets packs were produced for the production of SSSS.Gridman?
William Lee: I'm struggling to identify this After Effects plugin, can you contact a colleague on the compositing team? I'm looking for how the light glints or "incident light" I think it's called when you translate it from Japanese, not sure on that though.
https://imgur.com/a/aNqWKfT
Jarrett Martin: When you only animate the hair in an inbetween, how do you "stitch" it seamlessly from the body of the character's previous frame so that you don't have to retrace the whole character?
https://imgur.com/a/3Q1nj7r
7
u/MrYesHere Aug 03 '19
This is a question for everyone. When you're working on a show, does the type of show affect how much time you have to work on it? (For example, does working on a popular show mean you have more time to work on it compared to a lesser known show)
One last question, but sort of related to the previous question. How much is an anime worked on before it's announced or is it just a bit of planning and then once it's announced does it start to be fully worked on.
7
u/FierceAlchemist Aug 03 '19
For all of you, what is the most surprising thing you've learned from actually working in the anime industry?
7
u/soraskellington Aug 04 '19
Our video accompanying this AMA is live on youtube!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjQvwzahV1s&feature=youtu.be
6
u/Vin13ish Aug 03 '19
To everyone, what was the biggest challenge of working on anime and what is the big lesson you learn from being involved with anime show?
Which anime you are the most proud with?
5
u/Alamin_0l Aug 03 '19
What visa did you have when starting out and how did you maintain it with less than minimum wage?
5
u/Karina_Ivanovich :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Karina-Ivanovich Aug 03 '19
This is for William Lee, why aren't there 14 seasons of Girls und Panzer yet?
The actual question for you all is who do you consider to be the most influential animator in the industry?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
What type of animation y'all prefer more, character animation or action? Effects, creatures, and nature itself as well.
4
u/itsvicente3 Aug 03 '19 edited Aug 03 '19
First of all, hats of to you guys for pursuing stylistic animation in a foreign country with salaries far too low to compensate for the daily animator struggle. All the best for you and your families.
My first question is this: How did your family react to your decision to work for Japanese animation studios? What led you to make that decision to begin with?
Next: Anime still tends to hold a stigma of immaturity in mainstream western culture due to certain objectionable tropes. Do people outside of the industry ever misunderstand your work as perverted or distasteful? How do you or would you deal with this?
Finally: What are some things you've learned in the industry that you wish to pass on to aspiring animators? What do you regret not doing when you first entered the scene? Or what things are you confident helped you along your path which could help others?
Again, respect to you guys for all that you do. Keep up the good work.
4
u/celerym Aug 03 '19
This is an awesome AMA, thank you for organising and doing it!
Do you find yourselves working in the type of animation you like to watch? Or are you at the mercy of whatever jobs come your way? Or are you tied to specific studios? Do your Japanese counterparts assume anything about your art direction or abilities that they wouldn’t with local animators? I mean because of perceived cultural differences not discrimination or something like that.
4
u/Torque-A Aug 03 '19
What’s the average time frame you have to animate a scene/episode? I recall that one of the Naruto animators tweeted that the animation-intensive fight from episode 65 said that entire sakugafest has to be done in two weeks - does that differ when dealing with seasonal anime compared to weekly?
4
u/gunscreeper https://myanimelist.net/profile/mywargame Aug 03 '19
Do you often watch or rewatch the anime that you worked on? Do you sometime find things that you thought you could do better?
3
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Aug 03 '19
General question: what kind of tools (hardware/software) do you use for your work? Is everything digital these days?
3
u/UncoJimmie Aug 03 '19
Who are y'all's favorite animators/biggest influences?
3
u/UncoJimmie Aug 03 '19
For Zucchini: I heard Studio LAN worked on Carole and Tuesday #15 but were left out of the credits. Do you know what happened there?
3
u/ImRinKagamine Aug 03 '19
How's your first experience was?
Do you all play Fate Grand Order?
Been to Tomorrowland?
What countries are you originally from?
How's the culture of Japan different from the countries that are you originally from?
3
u/Taivasvaeltaja Aug 03 '19
What do you see doing in 30 years?
3
u/navybluemanga Aug 03 '19
I see solid black line quality as the norm for animating digital animators. I also see clean up with transparent looking lines. What's the industry standards on line quality?
3
u/Benskrapfen Aug 03 '19 edited Aug 03 '19
3
u/srlynowwhat Aug 03 '19
Thank you so much for being here. I'd love to have some question if the AMA is still live.
3
u/500scnds Aug 03 '19
A big thank you to the mod team who organised this and to the animators contributing their talent to our favourite anime who've taken the time to answer us viewers' questions!
I had a fun time browsing through the Q&A, and I hope it's not too late to offer up some questions of my own:
3
u/Sharebear42019 :FC::FD: Aug 03 '19 edited Aug 03 '19
What makes you like the webgen style?
3
u/zhongzhen93 Aug 03 '19
I find it difficult to find people who are interested in animation and are willing to give feedback, what places/discord servers do you recommend to join ?
3
u/LittleTinySock Aug 03 '19
How do you keep your motivation and not get burnt out?
5
u/DirtBug Aug 03 '19
Is your life basically hard mode Shirobako? Thanks.
4
u/TheBanishedPrince123 Aug 03 '19 edited Aug 03 '19
u/secretzucchini I was just wondering what happened with One Punch Man Season 2? Was there timing issues because this season's animation was really off and used blurring effects a lot. Will we be getting a clearer version in the future?
2
u/NaxdaruBlaze Aug 03 '19
I got a question for all: as I am an aspiring artist myself who is facing some challenges in improving myself, what hurdles did you face on your way to becoming talented?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
Thank you so much for taking the time out to answer questions!
Did you have a lot of professional experience before entering the industry?
2
u/oODovahBearOo Aug 03 '19
How should one get into animation? Ive been thinking of picking it up.
2
u/Escolyte :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Escolyte Aug 03 '19
A question for all of you, how do you draw?
And by that I mean whether you're predominantly drawing from the shoulder, the elbow or the wrist etc.
I've been trying to practice my drawing fundamtentals and in one tutorial I've found they strongly advocate for drawing from your shoulder.
I've been trying to put that to practice but I can only manage it when I'm being very conscious of it, as soon as I get more into drawing practice I often switch back to my intuitive drawing.
Did you learn to change how you draw and if so what change was that and how did you get over the struggle?
2
u/ThePandaUshanka Aug 04 '19
Anyone who can respond is appreciated :)
How has working in animation changed how you view parts of your everyday life? Do you look at your surroundings differently?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '19
Dunno if the AMA is still active but I got some questions! Don't know if some are already answered...I am still a high secondary student who wants to pursue a career in anime animation, no pretty sure how or where to begin..
2
u/Rexg11 Aug 04 '19
I'm a first year student planning to what you guys so it makes me really happy to know that it's not that far fetched of a dream. I just have four things I'd like to ask:
2
u/Typed_on_Twos Aug 04 '19 edited Aug 05 '19
2
u/nathanachan Aug 04 '19
Thanks for taking the time to do this ama and release an interview. If it isn't too late, I was wondering if anyone could share some resources that talk about the Japanese animation pipeline, common techniques, translated documents, recommended books, etc.
1
u/collapsedblock6 myanimelist.net/profile/collapsedblock Aug 04 '19
This came from seeing a thread of people shitting on the animation quality of an anime, so my question is: what exactly goes on when an anime quality goes down the drain and still goes airing? Shows like Marchen Madchen or My Sister, My Writer were the animation was just incredibly bad and receives non-stop backslash.
Like are the directors and animators aware? If the production goes so wrong, why continue?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment