r/anime • u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler • Jun 02 '24
Announcement Niche Comment Face Suggestions - 10 Million Subscribers Edition!
##Hey Everyone!~
As promised as part of our 10 million subscribers celebrations. We gather here today to investigate the depths of our screenshot folders and hopefully find some gems that are worth sharing.
#Wait, what even IS a comment face?
If you use Reddit's redesign, or any mobile app, then comment faces won't be something you see. They are a legacy CSS feature supported on old.reddit. To post a face, you require a bit of formatting and the name of the comment face and that displays the relevant image. For example:
[](#awe)
Becomes:
We have a full wikipage with all faces and instructions how to use them here.
Foreword on Scope
If I am right it has been 9 Million Subs and nearly five years since we last had free-form nominations.
Reddit seems to be supporting old.reddit but they have moved on to promoting different views of their sites. In my eyes comment faces have become a staple of the old guard, members who have been here a decent while. The set as it stands has favorites and others that are rarely seen, but to me it has felt cemented. And with that I have been cautious and reluctant to offer a 'full refresh' like times past. I think seasonal faces have been a great sweet spot of doing something in limited space but the question has been continually asked: "Any chance we can X?".
We have been at the edge of CSS & image limits for forever, so if there is to be more something has to give. We shortened a few animated faces awhile back to make some breathing room (which is now being used). In addition to this I am planning to convert [](#headpat) to a static face. Headpat currently takes an entire image slot and its sole sacrifice offers 30-40 additional static faces.
But it feels imprudent not to poll the community on this. So please have your say here.
Nominating
Share niches you think we are missing, even if you don't have a face yourself to cover it.
As always here are some things to consider:
-
Much like seasonal faces, we only have scope for static face suggestions.
-
Faces that fill an unfilled niche will be more likely to be chosen.
-
You're trying to 'sell' your suggestions, try to explain why it's awesome, how it'll be used, what niche it fills, etc.
-
They're going to be resized, so the face should work at the smaller size - if you have RES it can be super useful to see what a face would look like when resized.
-
I'll be resizing them myself, so try to give me the best quality version of the face you can find. However, feel free to provide a suggested crop if you feel that sells your suggestion.
-
It is appreciated if you include the name of the anime the face is from. Makes my life easier when updating the wiki's later on.
-
Suggestions with text in the image (i.e image macros/memes) will likely be ignored.
Nominations will be open for two weeks (June 16th).
We look forward to seeing your suggestions.
•
u/badspler x5https://anilist.co/user/badspler Jun 19 '24
Your submission is now late.
It may be considered since this process takes a tad more time than seasonal faces, but there is no guarantee.
8
u/cppn02 Jun 02 '24
I'm repeating this every time the issue comes up but
is such an obvious candidate for trimming down.
I am shocked it hasn't happened yet.
6
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of [](#squaremug)
You might be thinking "Surely r/anime has enough mug and cup comment faces already!" After all, we already have:
But we don't have a SQUARE mug yet. We definitely need a stupid, impractical SQUARE MUG.
12
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jun 02 '24
I'll give a small group now while I remember. But I know there are other niche face I want to suggest if I can remember where I saved the screenshots.
Weather Related (hot and cold):
Celebration
Lighbulbs -- We have all these thinking faces, but nothing for when you're done thinking or when you have an idea
Miscellaneous
Old Faces
12
u/Nebresto Jun 02 '24
Had a quick look through the already submitted ones, and.. some of y'all missed the part about submitting niche.
Whatever, I'm not the one sorting them. Not like all of mine are fully niche either
Sleep, morning, blanket etc
Spoiler stuff, listening/reading We don't really have any faces relating to spoilers, apart from so here's some to use in some varying scenarios, and not just limited to spoilers!
Drink, alco, etc
Money
Scheming, think, etc
Or better yet, we combine & Think of the stonk possibilities!!
Shock, reactions
Hype, friendship, misc
This was a lot more than I thought it would be. I guess that happens when you start preparing years ago, and then the nominations never came. ..Until they did, lesss go baby
12
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 03 '24
I found enough for a second batch, so here is another random assortment of unfilled niche faces:
UnboundForbidden Love (Tropical Rouge Precure) -- We have faces for yuri love and boys love and normal romance. but what about the love between girl and dolphin?10
u/drstripjo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hanten Jun 02 '24
First small batch. I'll do another one when I find good dance/not listen/punch face. For now:
Two curious/tell me more/investigation/lurk faces. Two Hyouka faces are mostly used for this, more variety would be nice
One ero face. There assman for ass, cultured can be used for boobs, feet also can use one
And two meme faces I don't expect to go through but I have to nominate them:
If it makes space for 30-40 more faces, then 100% yes.
10
u/Akiyabus https://anilist.co/user/yabus Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 04 '24
#whatamireading Worried Edition (Trails in the Sky OVA) - When what you are seeing makes you worried.
Flaunting (Trails in the Sky OVA) - When you want to display your superiority.
Relaxing (Aria the Animation) - When you finally get the chance for a good rest.
Peeking (Aria the Origination) - Do we have any peeking commentfaces?
Head Empty (Kaguya-sama) - When you lost your will to think and want to have nothing to do with any thoughts.
Ready for battle (Train to the End of the World) - When you are ready to go at someone.
Objection (Umineko) - Objection.
10
u/laughing-fox13 https://myanimelist.net/profile/laughingfox13 Jun 03 '24 edited Jun 03 '24
Cooling off (Bloom Into You) - we don't really have any commentfaces for battling the hot summers
Lifting up sunglasses (Paripi Kongming) - we already have a Kongming face but this would be nice to have since he looks like something caught his eye (and isn't disgusted by it) although this one is a bit harder to see his face
#BearWithMe (Yurikuma Arashi) - It would be nice to bring this one back plus it's Lulu and she has great faces
Thanks and congrats on the 10 mil!
also just wanted to post Akira10
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jun 03 '24
I would like to nominate #bonk from Samurai Champloo to deal with horny Redditors.
9
u/drstripjo https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hanten Jun 03 '24
Another small batch:
Happy crying from Uma Musume S2: Rice and Teio
And Opera wink from RttT. Its
cutecool. Imagine needing a reason to use acutecool winking face8
u/chilidirigible Jun 02 '24
[](#heyyou): Pointing at the viewer, but not the same tone as [](#eyythisguy). Also repping the retro comment faces of yesteryear.
8
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
Gintama
One Piece
Crayon Shin-chan
Other shows:
Oh yeah, for suggestions: a #taking-notes commentface, when you see an informative comment or reply, that doesn't exactly fit with.
8
u/Shocketheth Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
I forgot to prepare for this, buuuut here goes my contribution:
Gintama:
#greetings - use to celebrate the fateful encounters or for reunions with old friends
8
u/chilidirigible Jun 03 '24
/u/TheRiyria wanted a fresh #bii, today's Shuumatsu Train Doko e Iku gave us one.
8
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24 edited Jun 05 '24
The niche of PLEASE SHUT UP: [](#bequiet)
For when you need someone to stop talking (or not start talking in the first place). (/u/TheRiyria had a similar suggestion but I think the hand over mouth has more clarity of meaning than the white X of tape.)
Alternative image
8
u/chilidirigible Jun 05 '24
One category which is largely absent: Characters driving. It's somewhat America-centric, but we do spend a lot of time driving.
I think they categorize themselves in terms of the emotions being expressed.
Gunsmith Cats:
One
Two
Lucky Star:
One
Two
K-On!!:
One
Two
Pui Pui Molcar:
One
Two
YuruCamp△:
One
Two
Plenty of other series which have characters driving, but I don't have them immediately close to hand to sift through more screencaps. If you find this idea interesting, jump right in!
14
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 04 '24
Girls Band Cry :
[](#arigato) - For when you're extremely grateful to another user of course.
[](#shiteatinggrin) - We do have [](#evilgrin), but it's not...shit-eating enough.
[](#ooooh) - For when you discover something awesome.
Like say gex[](#wtf) - Self-explanatory
[](#finallyhome) - Would probably see some use among CDFers
[](#headpat) the economic version
[](#gremlinnoises/#aaaaaaaaa/#angy) - admittedly this one would be better as a gif but I had to
[](#dodgedabullet)
[](#youpleb)
[](#snekblep)
Other shows :
[](#thebetteraqua) (Soredemo Ayumu wa Yosetekuru)
[](#islatomato) (Plastic Memories)
[](#notamused)/[](#sleepymisaka) (Railgun)
[](#youpleb2) (Rikekoi)
[](#BLANKET) (Yuru Camp)
[](#goodmorning) (Yuuki Yuuna S3)
[](#bitchwhat) (Kaguya-sama)
[](#getmarriedbeam) (Uchi no Kaisha no Chiisai Senpai no Hanashi) (version with text just in case)
[](#trustmebro)/[](#aoialwayslies) (Yuru Camp), basically the comment version of /j
[](#rainyday) (Angel Next Door)
7
u/michhoffman :Ij::Ik::Il:https://anilist.co/user/michhoffman Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
Some part of this Holo dance clip (probably the last bit) needs to make its way into an animated comment face. As for the niche it would fill, we only have 1 dancing comment face right now, and I hardly ever see it used. This one would surely be more used here and would contrast well with the sad Holo comment face.
7
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Jun 02 '24
To pull a couple of things from our Discord server, I don't think there's a comment face that covers straight concern like
:concern:does. Same for a straightforward "acknowledged" like:isee:but I think the proposed #wakarimasu would cover that at least indirectly.7
u/OrangeBanana38 https://anilist.co/user/OrangeBanana38 Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 03 '24
A small batch from me, first:
Food related
#FoodAwe (Symphogear) -- we don't have any reactions that admire the food before eating it
#pizza (Yuru Camp S2) -- Who doesn't like pizza?
Working out
#workout (Aikatsu) -- we need something for when we are actually working out #mugistronk and #faito are more before or after the fact, not during.
#WorkingOutIsHard (Aikatsu) -- same as above, but for when you are struggling
#jogging (Aikatsu) -- still the same, but jogging is a very common workout
Misc
#TakingNotes (Aikatsu) -- for when someone says something so important that you gotta write it down version 2
#RunningLate (Uma Musume S1) -- A twist on the classic running with toast on your mouth. For when you gotta go real fast because you are late
#LookAtThat (Aikatsu) -- Kind of a middle point between the shocks and #neat, observing something and being surprised/worried about it
The other two niches that I couldn't find in my collection were:
7
u/BatteryPoweredFriend :KI::KJ: Jun 02 '24
#award, #medal or #quality
The current ones in the Approval category are pretty much all just gestures, whereas this is presenting an actual desirable item to indicate approval, like what reddit silver used to be, except this would considered expotentially more valuable than reddit silver because it's from Satania herself. There's text, but it's text that was in the original source and not a post-edit addition.
Can also be used in a similar way many users use many of the Smug/Smirk category faces, except like with Approval, all of those current faces are just gestures, whereas Satania indicating superiority with physical credentials is distinctly different.
Vigne also approves of adding this as a comment face
7
u/DutchPeasant https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotJames Jun 03 '24
Might post more later, but for now I'll post
PayRespects (Space Dandy) - We don't have a prayer commentface, and it can also double as a salute commentface where it would fill a more solemn role. Some more Watanabe representation has never hurt anyone either.
7
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24
The niche of anime girl band performing: [](#rock) or perhaps [](#cgdROCK)
I don't know if you've been following all the news about the latest secret anime trends, but my informants tell me that there might just happen to be a certain trend of holy crap where did all these anime about girls (WHO ARE NOT IDOLS) making a band come from?! Surely we need a comment face to also jump on this bandwagon!
To fully capture the spirit of this trend, I think it really needs to be an image that includes the characters performing, with instruments visible, and it has to be multiple characters together not just the one (as much as I'd love a Himeko jamming out comment face). Which is a tall order, but I think it can be achieved.
I've got a couple of potential suggestions but not 100% happy with any of them, necessarily. Might go looking for more later.
https://i.imgur.com/uwq4lnA.png
https://i.imgur.com/jibSwMM.png (yes, these are anime boys, how scandalous)
https://i.imgur.com/sCgyh5Q.png
https://i.imgur.com/oenViw4.png (this one is too wide, but I do really like the arrangement of the girls facing towards each other as they rehearse, lots of visual clarity to it. I could photoshop them closer so we could use this without it being so wide)
6
u/chilidirigible Jun 02 '24
could certainly be trimmed, I think most of the time it's mentioned it's because people haven't even considered both how long it is and how the mood changes when the entire animation plays.
is also a contender for dramatic shortening.
6
u/GallowDude Jun 02 '24
[](#twoyearsworth) - For when the sakuga hits
6
u/TakenRedditName https://myanimelist.net/profile/TakenMalUsername Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
I never have anything prepared.
Just things I have on hand since I wasn't sure what niche meant. Just tentative basic names for them:
I know animated ones are not accepted, but I just want to share these for fun. #koitospin from Golden Kamuy and #online(? The name shitposting is already taken) - Kyousougiga are just two fun GIFs.
Oh good because there are some niches I feel, but don't have an exact pick for them:
As for my two cents on this topic. I always felt like was excessively long so I would definitely like to see it shortened at the very least. It has 3 distinct parts comprising it. Either the first or the second more intense head pat is more than enough.
6
u/punching_spaghetti https://myanimelist.net/profile/punch_spaghetti Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
Yuyushiki
#chilly - Because everyone gets a little cold once in a while. But also maybe a little lonely or sad. This one has range, baby.
#kitty - Don't you get tired typing out how the cat in your favorite anime is cute? Use Yuzu here. Save time. Enjoy life.
#rule34 - We have some blushing faces, but nothing that directly references the fact that most of us are looking at our high-quality art on computer technology. I want to be able to respond to the copious amount of fanart shared on this sub with something simple.
#shame - We have similar faces, yes, but none that cover eyes, per a discussion /u/notsosnarky started in CDF the other day. Make Snarky happy. Let us cover our eyes in embarrassment or shame.
Run with the Wind
#dichotomy - Sometimes there's a stark different between things. Sometimes there's a fun duality. And Prince is always great for visual storytelling.
#scream - It's a reference to a classic piece of art. What's not to like? Do you hate art?
#masscasualties - These anime kids and their terrible cooking have gone long enough without a commentface to reflect their misdeeds.
#disguise - Sometimes you need to go incognito. No one will ever recognize you in this fancy mustache.
Misc
#measure - Measuring is important. have your ruler handy with this, a face from Interspecies Reviewers!
#watcher - With a crop like this, who wouldn't want to stare semi-awkwardly at their fellow r/anime users with this face from On-gaku?
#snack - Be a good redditor and eat your vegetables, like this gentleman from Planet With.
#elementary - When you have a mystery to solve, do it in style, like this totally normal and not slightly terrifying girl from And Yet the Town Moves.
#thebutton - If you don't decide to include this one, he'll press the button! He'll do it! He's a crazy dog! and you have no idea what will happen, do you? So be smart, and don't anger the dog from Given. Include this in the new batch.
6
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of pointing
I sure do love a good point. it's amazing that we only have two comment faces that have any pointing, and neither is really about the pointing. #pointandlaugh is about laughing at the person you're replying to, and #smugpoint is doing the Fonz to applaud them on a great pun.
Actual comment faces about pointing could be a shocked point at the person you're replying to, a joyous let's get started point, a heroic "I'm going to defeat you" point, an it's your turn point, a wholesome "I'm looking at you" point, a tsundere flabbergasted by you point. the "you're a pervert, don't deny it" point and its corollary "I've spotted a pervert" point, and so, so many more. Not to mention the most famous point of all, the mugipoint.
I don't have any one particular suggestion, but the comment faces catalogue could definitely use an upgrade to its pointing game.
6
u/chilidirigible Jun 15 '24
We have a lot of drinking represented, but little food.
[](#mywaifumadeyouasandwich) is the only thing we have which is someone giving someone else food.
I specifically wanted something which would apply that to birthday cakes, since that does get plenty of uses in responses to others saying that it is their birthday.
It turned out that I don't have a whole lot handy for that (which I can easily remember or find). And most don't present the giving with the desired camera angle.
Macross Delta: All cake, no people The wider shot is harder to interpret at comment face size, though is more along the line of what I was looking for.
Akiba Meido Sensou would work for a cake reception from the other angle, though I had to resort to quick paintbrushing to add a version with cheaply-produced lit candles.
Gundam Suisei no Majo
And for something totally different while we're here, food presentation via Symphogear AX's Beef Stroganoff scene.
6
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jun 15 '24
I have one small batch of random miscellaneous niche faces:
Kabedon (Wotakoi) -- I don't think we have a kabedon face. So here is one for the masses to use when slamming walls at people.
Blankstare (Date A Live) -- Can never have to many faces to stare at people when they do something stupid
Get the camera (Date A Live) -- our only camera comment face is when seasonal neat is picked for a camera. Which doesn't always happen and sometimes we get binoculars instead. This will give us a permanent photo face for neat goes in a different direction
Peek (Date A Live) -- I mentioned this one earlier. We should have a face for when there's something cringy or embarrassing or scary you don't want to watch but still do anyway. uncropped version
Scorn (Spice and Wolf) -- for when you truly need to look down on those other people and show off your wise arrogance
Sing a long (Yuuki Yuuna) -- someone said they wanted a singing face. Here is my suggestion for it. uncropped version
Reading (To Love Ru) -- maybe its more a peek than a reading. But surely it'll find some niche in one of the two groups.
Hype Cry (Haiyore! Nyaruko-san -- Why cry sad tears when you cry excited joyful tears instead?
Embarrassed (Bang Dream Garupa Pico) -- when you do something embarrassing
Poke (GochiUsa) -- what better way to get someone's attention than to poke them in the cheek.
6
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jun 17 '24
Seeing as how this is still stickied, I assume that means we're still allowed to nominate stuff? Just gonna add in a last-second nomination for this (which should be cropped, maybe something like this) as an alternative to that doesn't look... weird? I've heard people say his expression makes #calmdown look perverted in the past.
Source is Yu-Gi-Oh! 5Ds. I'm thinking #noviolence or #pleasestop could work for the code?
6
u/chilidirigible Jun 18 '24
There's no reason that Discord should have more magnifying glass inspections than here.
And hey, it's not precisely the same mood as the Hyouka one.
5
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jun 02 '24
Might have more later, but for now, I have some Back Arrow ones to nominate:
And I also have
a different frame ofan old one I would like to bring back if possible, as I am still upset by #whatisthisguydoing being removed five years ago. Similar things like or are a bit too judgy, is too shocked, and is for messed up stuff. #whatisthisguydoing is the perfect middle ground out of all of those, so yeah. Please bring it back.5
u/chilidirigible Jun 02 '24
I nominated this five years ago:
[](#psych): Getting yourself worked up.
5
u/_____pantsunami_____ Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
i might comment with more later, but in case i forget or dont do it ill just nominate this one for now:
#sakuracry
sure, we already have a lot of crying commentfaces, but this one can be used when you see something really cute and it makes you want to uoh cry because its so cute. think about it
5
u/junbi_ok Jun 02 '24
#badnews (Dantalian no Shoka) - for when somebody delivers shocking news, like you're being audited by the IRS (or the Yuri on Ice movie was cancelled)
#ohmy (Tensai Ouji no Akaji Kokka Saisei Jutsu) - crop it so it's just the lady on the right and it's a polite shock reaction
#blep (Tensai Ouji no Akaji Kokka Saisei Jutsu) - a playful tongue protrusion
#faroffyonder (Sousou no Frieren) - looking off into the distance, searching
#naruhodo (Sonny Boy) - a nonplussed reaction
#stressoverload (Shiroi Suna no Aquatope) - can't handle the pressure
#fireyoutrage (Megami no Café Terrace) - for when u mad. really mad.
#itadakimasu (Kanon) - rub-a-dub-dub, thanks for the grub
#petappreciation (Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T) - appreciating the furry friends in our lives
#jollycooperation (Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T) - a joining of forces
#iknowkungfu (Toaru Kagaku no Railgun T) - I don't think we have any martial arts faces
#rockingout (Soredemo Machi wa Mawatteiru) - we have listening to music faces, but no playing music faces
5
u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ Jun 02 '24
Fish needs to be brought back. As I said in the meta thread many years ago, I didn't even participate in the originating trend, and collapsed it every day, and yet, it's a great comment face. And it's from an anime, not fanart. It expresses a form of disgust and displeasure covered by no other comment face.
FISH = Whatisthisidonteven
I never post in comment face threads because I aggressively refuse to sign up to an image hosting site or clutter up my sub. But I need to again suggest that we need a biii-da comment faces. An actual tongue out and eyelid pull face.
You can find one at the end of Someday, In the Rain. although there have been others since I first suggested this (but don't remember).
We also need animated Kanade punching people, but that would use up all your new space.
5
u/SwampyBogbeard Jun 02 '24
I guess there's already one Pop Team Epic face, but I don't really feel it's Pop Team Epic enough. Not sure what to add though. There's so many options, and it's been ages since I watched season 1.
Maybe Hellshake Yano or a frame from one of the songs. "All hope is gone" from Shining Shoulder or the smashed TV from OP1 are the first things I can think off, but there's definitely something better I can't remember.
I want Sabagebu! to have one, but I can only think of three scenes that barely work without the subs or context. Punch/Revenge, Yakuza and Beyond Good and Evil. I wish I could nominate
(These can actually be used in comments... sometimes. The crab episode is great, but will almost never be relevant in normal discussions)
Man, I should rewatch Sabagebu! It's still one of my favourites, but it's been a decade since I watched it and I had to find these images on the internet.
I should've already had a folder full of screenshots ready.
Princess Principal and Id:Invaded would also be nice, but I've got literally no ideas for "unfilled niches" from those two shows.
5
u/entelechtual Jun 04 '24
/u/theriyria why did you let the mods work you to the bone like this?
5
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24
The niche of when you see a cute cat: [](#cat)
It's amazing that the entire catalogue of current comment faces doesn't have a single cat in it (sideeyes does not count). How am I supposed to react with a single comment face when somebody posts a picture of their cute cat?! /u/punching_spaghetti pointed out this niche already, but this one has an actual cat in the picture.
5
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24
The niche of when you spy on something or are secretly curious: [](#spy)
We have the one #curious comment face but it's a very open, in-your-face, PLEASE TELL ME I'M SO CURIOUS kind of reaction. This one would be for when some exchange is happening in the comments that you don't want to join in on yourself but you are curious to stare from concealment and watch it unfold, and that sort of thing.
5
u/SU-trash https://anilist.co/user/zig1000 Jun 05 '24 edited Jun 05 '24
Some MyGO ones, all of which seem to have basically no equivalent-niche emotes, surprisingly:
5
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of numbered scores: [](#zero) [](#one) [](#two) [](#three) etc...
Okay hear me out on this one. We all remember that #seasonalapproval from JJK with the '10' signs.
But what if we had all the numbers from 0 to 10 as comment faces?! That would be so amazingly useful! You could pose a rating question and get a bunch of comment face answers that are the different scores people think it is, and so on. Brilliant!
I don't have all those numbers but that whole thing of holding up a small placard with the score on it is such a common thing in anime I don't doubt we could find all of them.
5
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of yuri for the yuri fans: [](#roommates)
Like it or hate it, there's certainly a large contingent of fans on r/anime who get very excited about the slightest hint or prospect of any romantic intentions between two female characters in any anime. This is the comment face for them. Maybe it's even the corollary comment face to #yoihug.
[meta] And just like many anime that the yuri#fans horde get excited about these two girls from Megazone 23 really are just roommates that stare deeply into each others eyes, nothing more.
5
u/TehAxelius Jun 11 '24 edited Jun 11 '24
Sometimes, we all make mistakes. But sometimes, it's not a huge mistake. Perhaps the mistake is merely part of your nature. It is in these cases that we need a commentface to show an appropriate level of remorse (or lack of it). Now, some might say that we already have #teehee, #killitwithfire or maybe even #yuishrug, but I say: That is not enough. We need something new, something that can channel the right level of "oops shrug" with "silly tounge". Something for when we've done something like spreading rumors around the office that our colleague is about to go on a marriage interview.
For this purpose I present to you the hottest forgotten animeme of 2022, from 1994's hottest Police comedy anime You're Under Arrest OVA.
Here provided with gallery including an example resize or the slightly less silly fiddling #aheto moment (with downcast eyes version and resize example).
for reference, exact moment is from roughly 6:35-6:39 in episode 3 of the OVA. Source is from DVD-rips with all the quality of oldschool OVA VHS preserved
5
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jun 12 '24
I have returned to argue for a very important missing niche. The niche of Catgirls!
And who better to fill this niche than best Princess Connect Re:Dive cat Kyaru, a girl of many faces who also happens to fill a few other missing niches among r/anime faces.
For example, there are many possible faces, such as:
If it wasn't clear, these are all from Princess Connect.
5
u/TakenRedditName https://myanimelist.net/profile/TakenMalUsername Jun 16 '24
Don't have good names for them, but some last-minute submissions:
5
u/saltedbeansprouts Jun 17 '24
Last minute suggestion.
[](#impuredesires) from OniMai.
5
u/chilidirigible Jun 18 '24
Building/tool usage (now there's a niche use case) courtesy of Do It Yourself!:
https://i.imgur.com/l0tHKG9.png
https://i.imgur.com/lMKF5uB.png
4
u/mysterybiscuitsoyeah xB:xC:B:x3:Y: Jun 02 '24
u/theriyria
4
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jun 02 '24
Pretty please, for the love of everything that is (un) holy: Gushing!
That whole scene was full of good ones; Gushing 1 Gushing 2 Gushing 3
(Though perhaps some cropping would be needed to DeNSFW them!)
Also, I don't know if we already have one and I simply missed it, but I often wanted to use a comment face for someone squinting (in suspicion)...
Something like this (Simpsons), or that squinting dog meme from a show I seem to have forgotten...
A reaction when someone says something dubious (seriously, or in joke).
And at last: I promised in a META thread that I would stop yapping about this, but let's break that promise, given the thread's about this: I really wish there was a way to have seasonal comment faces from the later half of the season... We're missing on so many potential comment faces by adding the new ones when most shows are around 6 episodes, and some are at like 3-4!
4
u/chilidirigible Jun 02 '24
Throwing the suggestion out there for anyone who has one handy, but I don't have a good example at the moment:
A checklist, on a clipboard or a sheet of paper.
4
u/baseballlover723 Jun 02 '24
Ah darn, I thought that #unexpected (Re:Zero) could be a good one for something that comes out of nowhere. But the animation is critical to it, so I don't think there'll be space to consider it.
As a side note, I wonder if something could be scripted up to track usage (particularly animated ones) to see if there are easy pickings for retirement or compression/conversion.
4
u/H-Ryougi https://anilist.co/user/DizzyAvocado Jun 03 '24
#stinky
#stinky2
#vitamins
#itsmagic
#whatisgoingoninthisthread
#whatisgoingoninthisthread2
#whatisgoingoninthisthread3
#thatsnotmyfetish
#cold
#therockeyebrowmeme
#compromisingposition
#loligrin
4
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24
The niche of dancing: ???
#dancewithit is the only comment face about dancing that we have, and it isn't actually just a straightforward dancing comment face, it's really more of a "deal with it" face that has a dancing aspect for extra flair. So we don't really have any comment face that is just plain dancing.
The tough part though is that a static comment face doesn't easily convey dancing. I don't have any particularly great suggestions for a static frame for this, but would be a good one to think about.
4
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24
The niche of cuddling: [](#cuddle)
We have hugs, but what about cuddling?!
4
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of [](#psyduck)
It's the exact opposite of
4
u/Shimmering-Sky myanimelist.net/profile/Shimmering-Sky Jun 08 '24 edited Jun 13 '24
You know what, fuck it, I know I made a comment in the Discord that we should've banned seasonals from this, but we have a severe lack of blushing male characters, and no one fits that bill better than Haruka from Wind Breaker, so I'm nominating that. Not sure if this should be #harukablush or #megablush or something like that.
Edit: Actually, today's episode had an even better one that also hits the niche of a character going full "I-It's not like I [insert tsundere thing here] or anything, baka!", so I'll nominate this one as #tsundereblush
I also spotted this shot in today's episode that could work as a "dragging someone along for the ride" kind of deal (whether the person using it is the one doing the dragging or the one being dragged). I guess #draggedintothings or #alongfortheride could work as a code, but they're both a bit long so I'm sure there's a better name somewhere if this gets picked.
4
u/chilidirigible Jun 15 '24
Another assortment:
Adding to my earlier suggestions for faces which involve driving, too many people in a car from Super Dimension Fortress Macross.
Adding to the previous hour's food suggestions, offering cake to someone from K-On!.
Missing niche: People dancing socially. One and two suggestions from Crusher Joe. Maybe could be a two-frame animation as they're merely okay statically? I don't have much of a selection for this particular niche, though.
Enjoying food in a consistent manner, not like how [](#seasonalfoodie) is highly variable in its presentation: Kantai Collection.
Holding the cute thing, more intense than [](#jibrilaww): Kantai Collection.
4
u/Nebresto Jun 15 '24
#binyaaculars - Ars on Titan
A counterpart to . Binoculars is a much more hyped type of interest, while #binyaaculars brings in some "Mm, nice." type of energy into the mix. Also the name is a pun.
Also also, it was in the first ever seasonal faces batch, before the hall of fame was instated, so on that note as well it should have gotten hall of fame, being the best face of its group.
4
u/DarkAudit https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkAudit Jun 16 '24
[Gushing Over Magical Girls]
HornyJail - Could end up being the default response to any /u/pantsunami CDF post.
4
u/Nebresto Jun 18 '24
Did anyone submit any magnifying glass ones? We need an inspecting face
kinda like this, actually
3
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
Edit: Nevermind, it's already permament!
I don't know what show it's from, but that comment face from last season (?), the person holding the mic toward us, should be made permanent imho!
While I didn't have that many opportunities to use it much myself, many were using it in threads like AQRADT to ask questions to people, and I thought it was a perfect fit!
3
u/FelixAndCo Jun 02 '24
We need absolute cinema to celebrate peak degeneracy. The text doesn't even need to be legible for it to be recognizable.
https://www.reddit.com/r/MahouAko/comments/1bq5qtc/absolute_cinema_by_khyleri/
(Source: https://twitter.com/khyleri/status/1773379522970423747)
There was also that image from MahouAko with the two girls turning cartoony with a perplexed expression. Would be great for a "huhhhhh, wtf did I just read" to supplement the current options, which lack that dumbfounded expression. No idea where to find it though.
3
u/JollyGee29 https://myanimelist.net/profile/JollyGee Jun 03 '24
This is pretty niche, even as far as niches go, but I've felt the lack of a sing-a-long commentface before, so here are some options for #singalong:
Strike Witches (this is precropped, full shot here.)
Symphogear G
Symphogear G
Symphogear XV
Most of these could double as a speaking loudly face, similar to but without the aggression.
3
u/chilidirigible Jun 04 '24
/u/JollyGee29 for more #singalong, well, you know me.
DYRL
MacD
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 04 '24
The niche of serving up fresh beats: [](#dj)
Music suggestions, discussion, and even some users posting their own created music happens a decent amount in this sub. We have #listen/#seasonallisten but they tend to be a reaction to music being shared. This comment face would be the one used by the person sharing the music (like the #ama of music comment faces), or even just introduce a bit more variety in the music-related comment faces.
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of waifu santa claus: [](#santawaifu)
It might get a lot of use around December for some reaosn.
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of maniacal laughter at a diabolical plan: ???
As far as I can tell we don't really have a good maniacal cackling comment face, the sort of thing that a supervillain would do when all their evil plans are coming together. Maybe #yorokobe is supposed to be this, but I don't find that meaning very clear to it and don't see people using it that way much.
There's a lot of directions you could go specifically on this idea, but maybe the ol' Ego pose would work for it.
3
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of go (censored) f&$% yourself: [](#censoredfyou)
I saw someone already suggested the Girls Band Cry middle-finger pic, which I definitely think is awesome. But if the mods are feeling like they don't want to have an actual middle-finger-out comment face but would be okay with it censor-blurred, this is an actual unedited screenshot from Ribbon-chan, the show really did mockingly pixelate it exactly like that.
3
u/baquea Jun 07 '24
Well, after a quick browse through my reaction folder, my offerings are:
...I will be back.
3
u/Mage_of_Shadows Jun 14 '24
Will have to retake some of these without subtitles
Horimiya - [](#goodadaptation)
Ya Boy Kongming - [](#mywaifu) - Bot-chan replacement?
Sailor Moon - [](#myjobhereisdone)
Made in Abyss - [](#eyetoeye)
SSSS Dynazenon - [](#recharging)
Sora no Woto - [](#TwoPiece)
Oddtaxi - [](#seasonalpensive) - new category?
Dungeon Meshi - [](#stopcooking)
Oshi no Ko - [](#thegoodstuff)
3
u/GallowDude Jun 15 '24
Yu-Gi-Oh - [](#itsnotfair)
3
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander Jun 16 '24
I wasn't gonna suggest anything, but given how expressive my favourite anime series happens to be I couldn't not at least take a shot at making a Kare Kano face happen. I might nominate more later tonight if submissions are still open by then, but for now:
3
u/KendotsX https://anilist.co/user/Kendots Jun 16 '24 edited Jun 16 '24
Gintama
or thisOther shows:
* Note: the
democraticteademocratea is named as such for marketing purposes only, it does not necessarily contain tea.3
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander Jun 16 '24
Batch two of Kare Kano faces:
3
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Jun 16 '24
I have two last suggestions for a niche of the shock variety we don't have yet: a soul leaving the body. For when you're shocked to death.
Spy soul (Yozakura-san Chi no Daisakusen)
Rabbit Soul (GochiUsa) / uncropped version
3
u/Tarhalindur x2 Jun 16 '24 edited Jun 16 '24
Right, let's see if I can get stray "this should be a commentface"s from a couple of past rewatches and a couple of other stray ideas in under the gun:
(Mind the potato quality on some of these, that's what happens when your copy is a 2000s vintage fansub.)
Mai-HiME:
[](#interrupt) (needs a crop - I suggest this)
[](#reallynow)
[](#ihavearrived)
[](#lappillow)
[](#RAAAAAGE)
[](#bannedinchina)
[](#lostabet)
[](#ORLY)
[](#biggerfish) (actually maybe we shouldn't let CDF have this one; also probably needs a better crop)
[](#pounce)
[](#throughherstomach) (if nothing else please replace #whyhime with either this or #interrupt)
[](#nanithefuck)
Higurashi:
[](#AREYOUNOTENTERTAINED)
[](#nipah)
[](#OMOCHIKAERI)
[](#uhohspaghettio)
[](#whathappensinhinamizawa) [Higurashi] The funniest part is that the implication is false here - that's the soy sauce bottle - but true elsewhere
[](#pachipachipachinanodesu) (please?)
[](#trivialinconvenience)
[](#innocent)
[](#innocent2) (bad crop but my copy is hardsubbed so it's the best I can do)
[](#irecognizethatreference) (again, would do better with a different crop but hardsubbed)
[](#obvioustrapisobvious)
[](#considerthefollowing)
[](#smugsonozaki)
[](#yourplottingscaresme)
[](#gaijin4koma)
[](#lolidisdain)
[](#renashock) (probably superfluous given what we have but putting it up anyways)
[](#stadlerandwaldorf)
[](#contented)
[](#yousaidwhat)
Ore, Twintail ni Narimasu:
[](#holywar)
[](#schemingscience)
Madoka Magica:
[](#unpleasantlyfamiliar)
[Madoka Magica] Why yes I did choose that one because it is so innocuous without context yet will be instantly familiar to anyone who actually watched the show. That's the entire point. (Took a bit of effort to find a good frame + crop to avoid showing the actual spoiler, but I like the result.) Alternate name option: #ifyouknowyouknow.
3
u/chilidirigible Jun 17 '24
/u/pantsunami asked if a headbanging face had been nominated, there doesn't seem to be one, [](#grandhype), as noted elsewhere, is generally not used for such, so.
Something at least in the headbanging region, from K-On!!.
2
u/Shocketheth Jun 03 '24
I have another comment face to share
Victory! - Dragon Quest: Dai no Daibouken
2
u/SometimesMainSupport https://myanimelist.net/profile/RRSTRRST Jun 03 '24
There's and that apply for responding to comments, but this is an anime subreddit. Would like a #whatamiwatching for use in episode or rewatch threads.
2
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of [](#penguinhead)
Sometimes you are a penguin head.
2
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Jun 05 '24
The niche of BOYSQUEE: [](#bsquee)
We do already have a few comment faces of this general nature, such as:
,
but they are ALL of girls squee'ing at adorable things. Let's give the boys one, too! People are always squee'ing over cute things constantly in r/anime, I think another one of these that sorts of comment faces that puts in some variety would not go amiss.
2
u/Ramsay_Reekimaru https://myanimelist.net/profile/tehsnowlord Jun 05 '24
I nominate the niche of a laughing girl- [](#mikolaugh or kikyolaugh)
All the laughing comment faces we have are animated apart from seasonallaugh and crazedlaugh so I feel a relatively normal laughing face would be a good addition. Not to mention the girl I am nominating is my waifu
which is the major reason for the nomination.Plus seeing a perma serious character smile/laugh might destress anyone who happens to see the comment face. It happens to me all the time!Also reinstate notaccordingtokeikaku!
2
u/baquea Jun 07 '24
A few now from my misc. screencaps folder:
2
u/chilidirigible Jun 15 '24
Niche: Things you can use to make yourself a niche.
That's right, chainsaws.
Cuticle Tantei Inaba
Akiba Meido Sensou
2
u/chilidirigible Jun 16 '24
Falling somewhat into meme coverage for a niche, but we don't have something in the vein of fishing or trolling, using the literal for the figurative.
Hooked from Akiba Maid War or just fishing from Cowboy Bebop. I do see the problem that the fishing pole doesn't come through that well at comment face size.
2
u/_____pantsunami_____ Jun 17 '24
here's one more suggestion before the deadline:
#itsover - alternatively: #owarida (anime is Kakegurui)
2
u/Akiyabus https://anilist.co/user/yabus Jun 18 '24
#ChitandaInspection - Full version
#MayakaInspection - Full version
Thanks to /u/Nebresto for the idea.
3
u/1EnTaroAdun1 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Totesnotaphanpy Jun 02 '24
[](https://imgur.com/a/X0m4enl)
2
u/Legitimate_Stress335 Jun 17 '24
what