r/anime • u/ModieOfTheEast • Jun 27 '24
Watch This! "Mysterious Disappearances" - A lot more plot and not just "plot"
TLDR: Despite having a lot of interesting ideas and some really strong and unique characterization for their main characters (together with development), Mysterious Disappearances was largely ignored in the Spring Season of 2024. This was of course due to the fact that there were a lot of high quality shows, but also because it had a very unique (and probably off-putting) combination of tags together with a more average animation quality. However, I think if you give this show a chance, you will find that its main strength is neither the mystery-horror nor the ecchi part, but the interesting and well developed characters that ultimately lead to a strong ending that diverges from the manga (according to source readers) but is therefore also able to give you a good conclusion to this story.
Introduction
Mysterious Disappearances comes with a very specific combination of tags being mystery, supernatural (which goes a bit into horror) and ecchi. For this thread, I will therefore explore the effect these tags have on the show to give you an idea if you should skip it because of it, before doing a larger analysis for why you should watch the show even if you might not be a fan of these tags.
Content
- Supernatural Mystery
- Ecchi
- Slice of Life
- Ending (no spoilers)
- Spoiler Section
1. Supernatural Mystery
Two of the three tags on the MAL page for Mysterious Disappearances are "Supernatural" and "Mystery". The way these two genres affect the story is pretty simple. Sumireko Ogawa is a 28 year old author, but because her stories do not do well, she has to work in a book store to make ends meet. Her coworker in this store is Ren Adashino who together with his sister Oto is on the hunt of what they call "curiosities", supernatural elements in this world that they can trade in for tickets for an underground train that can bring you into different worlds (more on that later). These supernatural elements can take the form of a lot of different things: A book that can make you young again, students suddenly overheating, people being kidnapped by a young girl wearing red or even fans of a certain V-Tuber collapsing from exhaustion. In order to solve and finally catch these curiosities to trade them in, Sumireko, Ren and Oto (together with other involved parties) not only have to find out what kind of curiosity they are dealing with and use this information to finally get rid of it.
The curiosities at play here are usually following certain asian folklore, which can be a hit or miss for some. If you are like me and you don't know much about asian folklore, then some of these reveals can feel like they come a bit out of nowhere (though I feel in one case this part is used deliberately, for more information go into the spoiler section). Of course, if you are more familiar, that might not necessarily be the case. However, even then, one particular detail about these curiosities is that they are not just following the known rules, but they are all morphed in some way. This morphing could have either been because they have been fused with other ghosts or because they are a reinterpretation of an old curiosity in the modern world. If you enjoy this kind of thing which has been present in other shows about the supernatural, then I think you are quite at home. And even if you are like me and you don't know much about these things, you can still find enjoyment in it, since at the end of the day, all these curiosities are linked to a character in the show (be it main or supporting) and therefore there is an emotional connection that makes the story work.
One thing I mentioned above is the aspect of "horror" and while horror isn't one of the tags on MAL, a show about the supernatural will obviously be close to this genre as well. And while there are moments where the show leans into this aspect, they are never long and they are also never going into gore or really scary depictions. The horror mostly comes from the atmosphere and the unknown. So I think, even if you are a scaredy cat, this shouldn't be much of an issue. At the same time, if you are looking forward to horror, don't expect it to be as prevelant as in Dark Gathering for example.
2. Ecchi
Now, this part is probably the most controversial aspect, because having the tag ecchi often already means that people don't even want to watch it. And I can totally understand it. However, I also want to say that the "ecchi" aspect of this show is pretty light in comparison to other shows in this genre. That might not be true for the manga from what I heard, but it is definitely for the anime. And this isn't just because there is no nudity as we have seen in some shows of Winter 2024 but mostly because these "ecchi" elements are reduced to some characters saying a few perverted lines every now and then, a total number of two panty shots, and bathhouse as well as pool scenes and of course Sumireko having some of the biggest breasts in anime. Again, this might already be enough for some people to not want to watch it and that's totally fair, but I personally would say that the "ecchi" element in this show, while noticable is not necessarily a detriment. Especially because a lot of these moments are also used to portray a growing bond between the characters (I know how that sounds but more on that later). At the same time, if you are going into this show, BECAUSE it has this tag, don't expect too much from it. It's not nearly on Winter 2024 levels of degeneracy and if you are looking forward to it, the manga is (from what I heard) probably the better choice then.
3. Characters and Story
Now with these two big elephants out of the room, we can finally focus on what I think makes this show better than some people might think and that's the story and especially its characters. As I already summarized in the first section, the show is about Sumireko Ogawa, a 28 year old author who had a big hit when she was a kid, but who could never write anything of worth afterwards. Together with the siblings Ren and Oto Adashino, she is looking and ultimately capturing curisities so they can be traded in for tickets that can bring the siblings back to their own world. Because yes, these two came from a different world and are now looking for a way back. The story therefore focuses on these different cases and the characters in those cases who are at the center of every curiosity. This means you get to meet a wide variety of characters, all with their own individual issues and a lot of different topics get tackled from wanting to turn back the time and be a child again, over bullying to things like deadly diseases. These stories obviously are very dependent on the characters that they focus on and while they are never really long (mostly 2-3 episodes), they usually work very well and some of them have really emotional conclusions.
However, the thing that makes these stories work even better is the fact that they are not just individual stories that have no connection. The connection is done via the main characters, mostly Oto herself. One of these curiosities for example appears in her school, with another one she wants to help a particular person since she can empathize with and a third one affects one of her close friends. This means, not only do they have an emotional connection to one of our main characters, but the supporting cast from these stories develops and stays with our main characters influences future events as well. Not only that, but what these stories also do very well are developing one of the main characters, Oto Adashino in a way that is subtle, but ultimately noticable and which plays a huge part ultimately in the finale of the show.
And I think it's this point, where I should mention that despite not being tagged as Slice of Life, some of the most important moments come from exactly these SoL elements. As I already mentioned, the cast met during these curiosities often stays with our main characters and one way this is done is through the SoL moments that separate the different curiosity cases. And I think it's important to mention this, because not only do these SoL elements make up a good portion of the show, they are also similarly important for the development of our main cast, especially Oto, as they show the gradual change in character over time. It's these interactions during downtime moments between Oto and Sumireko, but also Oto and other members of the cast that help you connect to them and show the growth they go through over time. Which is necessary in order for the ending to work as well.
However, it's not just Oto and the supporting cast that work very well as characters, but also our other two leads in Sumireko and Ren. While Ren is the one most knowledgeable about the curisities, he is also the part that brings in the much needed comedic moments. His banter with Sumireko is always fun and engaging and helps lighten the mood. But also Sumireko is a bit more complex than it originally seems. It is not just that she is stuck as an author, but it becomes clear over time that she is already nearing something similar to a midlife crisis at the age of 28. It also becomes clear that her childhood was probably not the best time. Yes, she wrote a story that got popular really quick, but the following pressure affects her to this day and seemingly also had impact on her school life.
With all that in mind, what I really want to point out with these characters here is the fact that the story does not hold your hand. Which seems weird because they explain most of the curiosities in detail, but when it comes to characters, they leave a lot to interpretation. And I personally think that this is very bold but also interesting approach that you don't see very often in anime. Of course, this is very subjective and some might even say it's bad. For example, most of the things I wrote above about Sumireko are things that I interpreted from her behaviour and not because they were told or shown in a flashback. We get to see how she wants to first go back to her childhood self which was brimming with fantasy and later we get to see how she just wants to enjoy high school life again. But we never get shown how her school life after writing that story truly went. You have to come to your conclusions by your own. The same is true for her "midlife crisis". It's never a big focus of the show, since it's more focusing on Oto's development, but there are moments that are just shown to us that give you the understanding that she isn't quite as happy as she seems to be on the outside. And which also plays well into the ending. In the end, everyone has to know for themselves if this is something they are interested in. But just know, you have to make connections for yourself at times in order to get the full picture.
4. Ending (no spoilers)
This is just a short text about the ending, though I won't go into any spoilers, but I think it should be mentioned. As I wrote in the TLDR, the ending for this show (as far as manga readers said) diverges from the original manga. As the manga is still ongoing, they basically decided to create an anime original ending to this story so that you get a satisfying conclusion at the end of this season. Of course, anime original endings are often divisive, but I personally didn't mind it as much. I am still looking forward to reading the manga and I think it's not necessarily a bad idea instead of leaving you in the middle of an arc. This might also be because I personally think that this ending fits the show quite well and a lot of the things set up in the beginning play into this finale. There might be one thing that could have taken a bit more time to have a better effect, but overall, I feel the ending is a good way to end the show. And if the manga ever gets so popular that they would want to make a second season, they can just do what other shows did and create a redo which starts at the beginning again.
5. Spoiler Section
In this section I just want to go into a bit more detail about one thing that I mentioned above (being related to the explanation of the curiosities) which is also a very good example of how the show wants you to interpret the events in it. So from here on [Spoilers up until episode 7]As I already mentioned, Oto and Ren are not from this world which is also shown in their special abilities related to their eyes. Oto can see where curiosities occur and Ren can even overpower these curiosities. However, in Ren's case, this power comes with a drawback as it heavily damages his eyes, so much that he bascially goes blind for a couple of episodes. Of course, this is why Oto doesn't want her brother to use this power. Fast forward to a case where Oto really wants to help another person who is looking for her friend that disappeard a year ago. She really started to being attached to this person, but without going into detail, not only were they not able to save this friend, it might now even happen that this person gets affected by the same curiosity. However, when they meet up with Ren, he apparently was able to stop the curiosity temporarily. The way he explains is that this curiosity is a morphed version of toilet bound Hanako which went through a transformation in Taiwan. Therefore, he was able to stop her by showing her a test with a score of 100. However, this information, while making sense, comes a bit out of nowhere and is also different to what was told about this curiosity previously. Of course, you could now just believe Ren. After all, his explanation is as strange as all his other explanations, but you can also make the interpretation that Ren did use his eyes and to not make Oto worry, he came up with a somewhat logical explanation. And even if you don't believe this interpretation, this is pretty much how a lot of the moments can be looked at and require you to interpret them yourself.
Conclusion
Mysterious Disappearances is a show that I think a lot more people might enjoy if they give it a chance. The show has a very good mix of mystery, supernatural and slice of life elements, which are all being glued together by the strong characters in the show. Especially Oto's development which is subtle but noticable and Sumireko's character, which leaves a lot to interpretation were some of the most interesting things to come out this season imo. Of course, the show won't win any awards with its animation and the ecchi parts can be enough to put you off, but if you don't mind either of these things, then I think this period between Spring and Summer season can be a very good point to try it out. As I mentioned, it even has an anime original ending that gives you a satisfying conclusion to the story imo, so it's not even like you are necessarily hoping for a second season (though I wouldn't mind them adapting the whole manga story if is out at some point). And who knows, maybe you find it as surprsing as me. Because in this sea of really strong shows this season, this was the one that I found to be the most unique.
28
u/DrinkGinAndKerosene Jun 27 '24
I liked it a lot. It kinda reminds me of Otherside Picnic
26
u/fer_sure Jun 27 '24
To add to your point about subtle characterisation: Sumireko is lonely...possibly the loneliest character I've seen in anime. Other than Ren (and her boss at the bookstore), she has no human connections present or even mentioned in the anime. No parents, acquaintances, pets, friends, or lovers. I don't think we even see her talk to the clerk at a convenience store when she's buying her beer.
What was her life like before meeting Ren?
13
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin Jun 27 '24
Imo it was a great supernatural mystery series. I adore Oto. Dark gathering fans will really like this one.
12
u/Xythar Jun 27 '24 edited Jun 27 '24
This show made me tear up on like three separate occasions. I was a little disappointed with how they basically ran out of time at the end and left an entire arc hanging - if any show could have benefit from a 13th episode, it would be this one. But overall, definitely one of my top 3 of the season. Would agree with the recommendation for anyone who likes supernatural mystery or just good old emotional character drama.
Also, OP and ED are both certified bangers.
5
u/PaintOptimal2198 Jun 27 '24
i enjoyed this one alot. wishing for season 2
5
u/LolziMcLol Jun 27 '24
There are so many things about the show that have very little relevance to anything else going on and often it's not even acknowledged.
Like one of the main characters' outfit changes mid season to an outfit that is incongruent with the rest of the show. They explain how she got the outfit in the next episode in 2 lines, but none else acknowledges it. It has no impact on the show.
In one of the later episodes a side character gets scared by one of the main characters boobs (?) which leads to a few exchanged lines but does not affect the way those 2 characters interact at all.
There are also, not one, but two ~2 min animated dancing/ singing sequences, which are noticeably better animated than any other part of the show and last unexpectedly long. One of them is completely irrelevant, the other you are lead to believe will have some relevance later but it does not.
There are lots of these weird, unexplained things that someone clearly wanted in the show and they make the show stand out in a positive way, at least in my opinion.
1
u/ChiggaOG Jun 27 '24
The majority of the story for Mysterious Disappearances is a “Monster of the Day” deal. It’s unique for a mystery genre, but not one that will brought back in the future for a Season 2.
1
u/thesnowlocke Jun 27 '24
I’ve still got a few episodes left and I like some of the ideas although I can’t say I’m keen on it compared to other great but underrated shows but we’ll see how it goes
1
u/antolleus Jun 27 '24
I don't mind spoilers because I don't plan on reading the manga so could someone explain ending to me?
[Mysterious Disappearances' Finale] Oto died and the guy with her at the beginning of the finale was her real brother, right. Like, why did she end up in this world with curiosity posing as Ren-nii or was it her brother that somehow turned into a curiosity? I didn't quite get it
1
u/IdiaShroudsfan Jun 29 '24
does Sumireko marry ren?
1
u/Belhgabad Aug 11 '24
I only read the manga some times ago, dropped it because of the release being to far from each other compared to the plot
Tried watching the anime recently and I might continue and pick up the manga again
Tried watching it with my gf and she didn't liked it at all, claiming that during the first episode the interactions between Rend and the main character are borderline (as in classical Japanese sexualise lolicon and shotacon topics)
Am I missing something or is it that bad ?
1
u/DaBluBoi8763 Jun 27 '24
Now try posting that on MAL or Anilist
1
u/Joel-Smith22 Jul 03 '24
Hope they add some OVA about the romance story of both MC'S
5
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '24
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '24
[removed] — view removed comment