r/anime • • Feb 17 '15
[WT!] Girls und Panzer
Girls und Panzer. Literally what it says on the box, and so much more. Many /r/anime users at the time were justifiably skeptical about this anime-original story when news of it first broke. It had a ridiculous case of production hell, with a delay on the last two episodes that lasted way too long.
Alright, let's begin.
Right off the bat, you ask, "wait, literally? You mean, girls, and TANKS?"
Well, um, yes. It's a ridiculous premise, and Girls und Panzer knows this. So it takes that idea, and cranks it up to eleven. Might as well go all the way, right? You won't really worry about how tank combat is regarded as a feminine discipline, when teenagers are slinging live rounds at each other in WWII tanks.
Oh yeah, they live in boarding schools built on gigantic aircraft carrier-style ships. The OVAs even add to and explain the lore. Suspension of disbelief, much?
Because Ooarai Girls High School has 8 tanks, and tanks need a few people to control, there are about a bajillion "main" characters, and opponent characters.
I'll be upfront, with just 12 episodes and a couple of OVAs (pretty much only one of them is actually full-length), you're not going to see much character development. Heck, you won't know half the character's names.
Mercifully, the show focusses heavily on the main 5 characters, Miho, Mako, Hana, Yukari and Saori, in their WWII German Panzer IV.
For whatever strange, inexplicable reason, the final showdown in episode 11-12 had the longest delay time I can recall in recent years. Postponed, then postponed again. That's two seasons.
This sounds like a recipe for a huge flop. Instead, what we got was the very definition of a sleeper hit.
First off, more so than anything, Girls und Panzer is a sports anime. It's not a slice-of-life, it's not ecchi, just good old-fashioned action.
Girls und Panzer is actually pretty refreshing in this regard. It kind of has this old-school feel, an almost-retro artstyle and what could be described as a classic textbook coming-of-age storyline. Yet at the same time it's such a breath of fresh air when the focus of an all-girl cast is actually the action scenes and not endless sexual exploitation. Well, except the obligatory bath scene of course.
Here's where the show excels. It has jaw-droppingly amazing action scenes. The battles are nothing short of fantastic. I cannot not sing endless praises about this. It's mostly david-vs-goliath battles, which means the occasional cheeky, crafty victories and plenty of humour. At the same time, this anime will get you hyped. I've introduced many people to anime through this series, and usually there will be plenty of "holy shit"s exclaimed.
If you're a military/tank buff, you'll love this. The tanks in the anime reflect the attributes of their real-life counterparts, except exaggerated greatly for comedic effect. The same could be said about the actual combat. The opponent characters are stereotypes of the countries and leaders they parody, reflecting these blatantly in battle.
The CGI used is impressive as well. You'll hardly notice it, let alone find it much of a bother.
Last of all, rewatch value. Whenever I recommend someone try Girls und Panzer out, I end up watching it with them. Always. It's definitely something you can see again and enjoy just as much the first time round.
Despite the number of "anime taboos" this show commits, it was very commercially successful. Unless you're really particular about the whole suspension-of-disbelief thing, you're probably going to enjoy Girls und Panzer. 2 years after it finished, I guess you could say that this anime isn't exactly on most watcher's radars, driven away by the premise and artstyle. Even so, it retains a loyal following from both anime and military communities, a testament to its surprisingly universal appeal.
TL;DR a bonafide sports-action anime in a clever disguise, Girls Und Panzer is a fun watch for both new and old anime fans. A good wildcard pick for weekend entertainment!
If you watched Girls und Panzer and liked it, please, send me a message!
42
u/nirvanemesis :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/racingmiku14 Feb 17 '15
Just finished it yesterday. For a show that I thought would be just moe girls in tanks, it's actually tanks with moe girls. The tank battles were always intense and I liked the commander's strategies to get around heavier tanks. I think it does what it wanted to do perfectly. Looking forward to the movie!
EDIT: By the way, if anyone wants to watch it on Crunchyroll, Episode 8 on there is missing a really cool scene!
5
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '15
Do I have to send a message too?
I liked it. Sports anime with your typical cliches, except the sport is out of this world. Relies on less pandering than some sports anime I could mention. If you're watching sports anime for slice-of-life moments then I don't know what to say except blame the recent deluge of sports anime falling into the SOL trap.
10/10 memorable music and tanks as well as antagonists.
2
u/lvlasteryoda Feb 17 '15 edited Feb 17 '15
Fuck this. I had this somewhere in the depths of my endless anime backlog but you, Sir, made me watch it ASAP. I heard great prises about this anime from so many places now it's maddening not to know it.
2
u/dcresistance https://anilist.co/user/dcresistance Feb 19 '15
Don't forget that it's also getting a movie. Eventually.
28
u/ChuckCarmichael Feb 17 '15
Even the bath scenes weren't sexualized. You never had these long panning shots along the girls' bodies or them groping each other while saying cliched lines like "It's okay, we're both girls." They were always just sitting down and talking to each other.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '15
Bought the PS Vita game as soon as I heard about the anime. Haven't played the game yet. Haven't watched the anime yet. Schedule problems.
6
u/iddothat Feb 17 '15
Fun fact, if you watch Shirobako, they make reference to the directors previous work which had a lot of the same problems as Girls Und Panzer. And guess what? Shirobako and Girls Und Panzer have the same director!
11
u/JinnRummy Feb 17 '15
I think the most amazing thing was the lack of any panty shots with their skirts being that short. Respect.
4
u/MeteoraGB Feb 17 '15
Girls und Panzer is hilarious and an underrated anime. It also helped that I enjoyed the anime when I was playing World of Tanks at the time.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '15
I'll just leave this here...
7
u/funtimesayshi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SkyNoHoshi Feb 17 '15
Girls und Panzer was my very first anime that I watched. It was definitely enjoyable to say. Girls and tanks, when I first thought about it, I thought of 'is this how anime works?' and such. Curiousity just hit right off the bat.
I would say that the story is somewhat interesting. The school battles out different other schools of different cultural aspect by tanks and I admire how the girls try to win them. The characters are great, especially for this girl called Miho, who wasn't willing to take on this tank competition at first, due to some family background.
1
u/lvlasteryoda Feb 17 '15
Erm. I looked at MAl and there's quite a lot of Specials and OVAs listed. How do I go about watching it all in order?
3
u/Miami33155 Feb 17 '15
Great show. If you really liked it, head over to /r/girlsundpanzer! Great community who also love the show.
6
u/fgsfds11234 Feb 17 '15
world of tanks: the anime, basically.
1
u/roccct :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teratoma Feb 17 '15
While I enjoyed the series for the most part, I have to complain about the forced drama that adds nothing to the show besides annoyance and the SoL moments which were quite boring because pretty much the entirety of the main cast was forgettable.
And one of the worst things about it is how there was an entire episode of them preparing for a fight only to completely skip it(which was later made for an OVA).
That wouldn't be a problem if those SoL episodes weren't a chore, like I said earlier(considering I loved Katanagatari spoilers.
Still, the premise and setting(giant fucking aircraft carrier), actual battles and the side characters were very entertaining making the show overall fun to watch.
4
u/dummeq Feb 17 '15
girls und panzer is definitely what got me into anime. although it is far from flawless it's still one of my favourites =D so much lighthearted fun and highly rewatchable. and what really sets it apart for me is the music: since every opponent team is based off a different country they use this countries military march as theme. it's is awesome and make some of my favourite scenes: tea + british grenadiers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zaM0zXCN0cs moe girls singing katyusha: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QA-qmYJJUA4
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '15
This was a sneaky good show. I really enjoyed even my brother who isn't an animal fan watched it with me because of the great action.
2
u/chunky_2336 Feb 17 '15
Funny how I accidentally watched this show when I started my dive into anime last year, I saw girls in tanks and assumed it was that another anime with something similar. (same thing can be said about rail gun with rail wars) Really enjoyed it, as just watching the show and not critiquing it I was entertained, the detail to tanks were great, the tactics explained kept you what might come and perhaps even guessing what they can think up. And when left on a cliffhanger I was edger to see the next episode instead of going to bed, Overall I really liked the tone of the show and kept me up beat and had my attention through out most of the show.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '15 edited May 27 '17
Bye.
2
u/chilidirigible Feb 17 '15
GuP also was/is so popular for unofficial World of Tanks mods that eventually some official mods were released and a Japanese server cluster opened. (I thought of posting a link to the trailer for that, but it's full of fight scene spoilers, including the big one.) But before that the WoT forums and subreddit went a little crazy from the moe invasion.
2
u/TyagoHexagon https://anilist.co/user/4692 Feb 17 '15
It's one of those anime so ridiculous that I just had to give in and enjoy watching it. Not certainly one of my favorites, but it was a good watch.
2
u/Dresdenverser Feb 17 '15
Just finished watching it today. Pretty good anime with decent action scenes and not too much Slice of Life drama. I may now have Katyusha playing on loop.
2
u/AngryWatchmaker Feb 17 '15 edited Feb 17 '15
The english dub was just god awful. Every "huh, eh, and uh" that sounds okay in the original Japanese is painfully mimiced in english, its hard to listen to.
But the technical aspect of the tanks, munitions, and the like were done very well.
If you are going to check it out, I would say watch it subbed.
1
u/gamesbeawesome :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gamesbeawesome Feb 17 '15
I love this show. I didn't think moe and tanks would mix. This show proved me wrong.
1
u/rarz Feb 17 '15
I rewatched this a few months ago with two friends and a lot of whiskey. It was glorious. :D
-13
u/Joyduck7 Feb 17 '15 edited Feb 17 '15
My brother reccomended me this, and I told him I would watch it if it had any death in it. Because, you know, when I watch things about war, tanks and live ammo, I find it hard to take it seriously at all if it just forgets half the sustenance behind the genre, especially when it just trivializes the tragedy and the point of war and weapons.
He never came back to me. And I have seen 0% of this show as of today. Was he wrong? Is this show, filled to the brim with tanks, battles, and war, actually not dark? and as a result will it forever remain off my plan to watch list?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment