r/anime • u/lukeatlook :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lukeatlook • Feb 22 '15
[WT!] A Certain Scientific Railgun - Magneto as a tsundere schoolgirl
Before we get started, look at this GIF.
If you're as much in love with it as I was when I saw it, there's no need for further recommendation and you can move on straight on to watching Toaru Kagaku no Railgun. If you need some more information, though:
- Genre: Action, Fantasy, Sci-Fi, Superpower
- Type: Manga adaptation/Light Novel spin-off, 24 episodes + 24 episodes + 4 OVA
- Parent Story: A Certain Magical Index
- MAL score: 7.93/10 (first season) 8.23/10 (second season)
Premise
Take the typical "cute girls doing cute things" premise, add superpowers much like in X-Men, spice it up with some omnious background - and you've got it.
Misaka Mikoto is one of the top espers in Acedemy City, a unique place inhabited in majority by students developing their superpowers. Her roommate, Kuroko Shirai, almost as talented as her, works in the student municipal police, which usually means doing mundane jobs like picking up the trash - but not always. For some reason Misaka gets caught up in her friend's job from time to time, as the various events turn out to be connected in a more grand scheme of things when the girls explore the events unknown to Acedemy City's public.
What is so good about it?
MUTANTS. I mean, espers. You know the drill.
So many times the shows with superpowers in an urban setting are overtalked (Monogatari series count, I guess), focused on non-superpowered characters (Durarara), or otherwise disconnected from what you'd expect, grown up watching shows like X-Men: Evolution. Not this time. Academy City is full of espers of all kind, and the whole place is dedicated to their education and development. Not all of them are at equal power: very few are as talented as the protagonist, her roommate is on high level, but not quite at the top, and many people possess minor abilities or no powers whatsoever. Anyway, the whole setting works like a charm and is probably the best example of "superpowers in everyday life".
The characters are great and memorable. I've enjoyed numerous shows where I didn't bother to memorize the character's names - not this time. Misaka is, as the title of this post says, a tsundere Pikachu (which is the expected state of things with a Pikachu), Kuroko's voice actress (also found in Seitokai Yakuindomo as the reporter for the school paper) steals every scene she's in, Uiharu is just straight out adorable and Saten has a different ring for everyone (some people love her, some hate her, and some treat her as a background character as she apparently is in the source material).
Then, when you think that the show will be all slice of life and comedy, things go unexpectedly serious - and awesome.
What is bad, then?
Index. Index is bad. She's a human parasite disguised as a nun.
On a serious note, the transition between cute lighthearted everyday life and grimdark oh-my-god-what-the-fuck revelations might be a little bit distracting - not as bad as in Akame ga Kill, but still a little bit "uneven". Also, the die-hard fans of Index light novels will dismiss Railgun as 90% filler, and some people might dislike the series altogether.
There's also the fanservice, which, even though it's toned down after the first few episodes, might be heavily off-putting. Expect one-sided teasing between the two pairs of girls.
Should I watch "A Certain Magical Index" first?
Short answer: No.
Long answer: No, the chronological order is Railgun -> Railgun S -> Index I -> Index II. Some events of Index and Railgun occur simultaneously, but in most cases it's the events of Railgun that affect the plot of Index, not the other way around, and Railgun S ends before Index I does. Here's a day-by-day episode-by-episode timetable. Also, the key point of this watch order is that you get to know the best arc of the Raildex story from the MUCH better side, with a good few episodes of more backstory.
If you want an optimal watch order, see episodes 1-6 of Index I at any point before Railgun S, as they contain the only event from Index that makes direct impact on Railgun.
EDIT: In my personal opinion Railgun is more polished and worth recommending than Index, but there are people who say otherwise. You should probabyl watch both shows to forge your own opinion; I recommend this one over the other.
Summary
Experience schoolgirl X-Men living their youth in a city full of battlemage priests, soulless scientists and juvenile criminals; they may or may not encounter some of these groups. Expect a fair dose of action, mystery, superpowers and slice of life.
TL;DR: Best girl gets a spin-off and her own girl harem, spin-off turns out to be better than the original.
Previous: Symphogear - Next: Yuuki Yuuna is a Hero
44
u/__U_WOT_M8__ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iThoughtSheWas16 Feb 22 '15
Does Railgun really require a WT? Its parent series Index has a popularity ranking of #67, and Railgun is at #121. The whole TOARU franchise gets mentioned quite frequently on /r/anime too.
14
u/Enigmaboob :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KURISUTINAA Feb 22 '15
I think the best way to go about it (personally) is Index -> Railgun -> Railgun S -> Index II , only due to the fact that starting off with Index helps build the world a little more beforehand, and the shared story arc between the two is covered better in Railgun, so it builds up hype. Great show though!
Also, INDEX III WHEN
18
u/ChuckCarmichael Feb 22 '15
I don't get why so many people don't like Index (the show, not the character; the hate for the character I understand), yet praise Railgun. I think that Index does a really good job at building a cool and interesting world, and the plot is fun. Railgun has its good story arcs, but the entire second half of the first season and almost the entire second half of the second season are filler, with boring characters and generic villains who are evil just for the sake of being evil. I dropped Railgun S halfway through the goth loli arc because I couldn't get myself to care about anything that was going on. I also don't like what they did to Kongou in the anime. Manga-Kongou is much better.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '15
Question o/ what's WT? I'm new on reddit so i don't really know
3
u/TacticalTable :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TacticalTable Feb 23 '15
Ugh, I kinda enjoyed the first half of Railgun, but dropped it in the second half. Misaka was interesting, but I feel like the show didn't try to explore the implications of her power too much. They had entire episodes where absolutely nothing supernatural happened, showing panty shots of middle school girls, or covering characters who I had no reason to care about. (Seriously, who cared about that Antiskill woman when they decided to make an entire episode about her?) I might watch Index 2 because at least the plot is allowed to move forward, but Railgun left a bad taste in my mouth.
50
u/TeraVonen Feb 22 '15 edited Feb 22 '15
I'm sorry but repeting in two full paragraphs that "Index is heavily flawed" and "Railgun is better" shows a lack of arguments.
Those [WT!] were made so people can promote animes they have a good opinion of. Yes, liking series is a part of a personal preference. Disliking is also a personal preference. However demoting an anime to promote its spin-off is not really suitable. Your job here is to hand over to people your good opinion about Railgun and convince them to watch it, trash-talking Index is totally pointless. Imagine if [Don't Watch This] submissions were allowed, I can write why, for example, SAO is bad and it would reach the front page, but I would offend those who actually liked the show.
People don't care if Railgun is better than Index or not, they just want to know if it is worth watching.
Edit: 2 words.
22
u/Atronox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Atronox Feb 22 '15
You only need one reason to watch Railgun, and that is best girl MC
That said I do love this series, not only for best girl, but the rest of the gang as well. You get a reward for watching the first season which is still good, with the even better second season.
7
u/MjolnirDK Feb 23 '15
The thing with this show is, that it is an actual good show. Lot's of production value thrown into it. Sure it does have the usual beach/bikini episodes and the story at least of the first season is nothing new (S2 does make up for it), but the characters and their usage of abilities with competent writing make this a really solid and entertaining show. There is lots of parasocial interaction as well, if you are into that.
5
u/naivat10 Feb 23 '15
People who enjoy Railgun might be a fan of the subreddit /r/onetruebiribiri
4
u/naivat10 Feb 23 '15
I heavily agree with this post. I fucking love Railgun and its awesome characters. I'd recommend this to just about anybody.
1
u/Jubnik02 Feb 23 '15
i feel like i wrote this
i have never found someone with such a similar opinion as me
1
u/alamaias Feb 23 '15
Okay, the gif has made me want to watch. Could someone tell me what the names of the series are in the order they were released/intended to be watched?
1
u/MakutaArguilleres :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Arguilleres Feb 23 '15
I tried watching A Certain Magical Index and while I was at first interested in it, I very quickly got bored and dropped it. Is Railgun that much better?
3
u/TheLonelyDevil https://anilist.co/user/TheLonelyDevil Feb 23 '15
How have I never seen a single watch thread of the Index series on /r/anime?
3
u/Soveriegn :K:https://kitsu.io/users/214 Feb 23 '15
Hey man, WT! is for promoting a show not bashing on one. Promote Railgun without bashing Index...
5
u/urban287 https://myanimelist.net/profile/urban287 Feb 23 '15
I'll just leave this scene here for anyone still undecided.
Scene is unrelated to main story - from the first episode of Railgun S.
2
u/J3N0V4 Feb 23 '15
Until you brought it up I didn't think about it to much but there are a couple of clever parallels between Magneto's back story and the Sisters arc that have no possibility of being intentional.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '15
Railgun is amazing. I loved both Railgun and Railgun S.
Just a quick thingy: Railgun focuses on Misaka Mikoto's friend group as a whole, whereas Railgun S is mainly about Misaka's personal growth and whatnot. Her friends are still a big part of it though.
2
u/pwizzler Feb 23 '15
I highly recommend that people read the Railgun manga, which is much better than the anime. For some reason they decided to make mediocre non canon filler arcs and ignore some of the very well done manga arcs. Some of the characters in the anime also tend to act out of character and frankly much worse than in the manga. The Railgun anime is alright when it follows the manga, but it can't compare to the quality of the original work.
1
u/hiss13 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ashen_Miko Feb 23 '15 edited Feb 23 '15
The Railgun anime. Oh my god. A place where I can rant.
The anime is mediocre. If you watch the anime at all, watch only the Sisters Arc since that is the one thing that the Railgun anime did right…and even then, I find minor flaws (though I admit that they can be nitpicky). The remainder is a poorly adapted mess that turns a good action series with dark undertones that barely scratches the surface of the world of the series into a typical four-girl moe series (a la Lucky Star, K-on!, etc.) with action scenes interspersed in between.
Take your mention of battlemage priests, for example. Nope. Railgun touches nothing related to magic unless you've read the recently completed arc in the Railgun manga or the two SS novels.
Let's talk about the world it tries to represent. One of my favorite parts of the underground/darkness of Academy City is how well established the depths of the darkness in the city is. The Railgun anime tries to do the equivalent of covering a huge pitfall with a tarp. Take Shinobu in Railgun S. After the Sisters Arc, she was never seen again in the manga or mentioned in any of the other media. This served to demonstrate the ruthless and unforgiving nature of the dark side of the city and the lengths that it will go to in order to prevent secrets from leaking out and such. By leaving her fate open, it left a lot open to the imagination and really served to hammer that home. But then comes Silent Party where she's saved by the power of friendship in under two weeks by (what that picture in the OP aptly calls) the Slut Brigade. For a better timeline, look at this. Minor spoiler warning as it does contain names for arcs unadapted by the anime.
What I attribute this to is the fact that JC Staff failed to sell Railgun for what it is and decided to pander to the SOL/moeblob lovers out there.
TL;DR: Railgun anime sucks. Read the far superior source material and save yourself the time.
EDIT: Therestina is a blemish on the Kihara name. Worst Kihara ever.
1
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Feb 23 '15
The anime that I watched that got me into watching more anime :)
Love it! The blend between SoL and Action was great!
1
u/MeteoraGB Feb 23 '15
I was about to ask if I should watch Index first or not but thankfully you answered my question, I only decided to want to watch Index because I heard Misaka Mikoto was a very well written character and wanted to see if that was true or not.
I guess I'll decide whether or not Index is worth pursing 6 episodes into anyways, so that I don't just immediately write it off without watching at least parts of it.
1
u/krfz41 https://anilist.co/user/krfz41 Feb 23 '15
I have come across the first opening of the show only my railgun and I can't stop listening to it. That's how I learned about the show. I was not sure whether I should watch Index first, but I guess I'll start watching Railgun.
1
u/PAK-FAace Feb 23 '15
Ah, I love Railgun! Season 2 especially with the Sisters arc which in my opinion, is one of the best arcs I've seen from an anime so far!
1
u/nsleep Feb 23 '15
Your timeline is wrong, it's much more complex than that.
http://toarumajutsunoindex.wikia.com/wiki/Anime_Timeline
And I'd recommend anyone who liked Railgun watching Index though, at least up to the Remnant arc where Kuroko really shines.
Edit: This timeline only includes the anime events, there are prior events to the ones listed there and some more in the middle if you take into account the Index/Railgun novels and the Railgun manga.
-2
u/zaturama008 Feb 23 '15
Your shit taste to make titles and reviews is retard
0
u/CrackLawliet Feb 23 '15
Either OP has never seen Railgun, or has no idea who Magneto is. Misaka's powers are over electricity. Not magnetism. Pretty different. As expected of /r/anime though.
-12
u/AnimeElitist Feb 22 '15 edited Feb 23 '15
edit: classified information