r/anime • u/lukeatlook :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lukeatlook • Feb 23 '15
[WT!] Yuuki Yuuna is a Hero - "The lesser you know coming in, the better"
The best part about some shows is getting to experience them with a community, with all the reactions, speculations and jokes. The anime fanbase has their expectations, tastes and preferences, and sometimes the previous experiences heavily influence how new shows are received. This works especially well when the show midway through its run develops into a situation where NOBODY has any idea where it's going next. That is the case here.
The lesser you know about Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha del Aru, the better. So if you trust my recommendation - which this time isn't a "this is kinda bad but very fun" one, but a genuine "this is a hidden 9/10 gem" - you can move straight to watching. If you need a little push, read on.
The viewing experience is heavily influenced by having watched a certain very popular show with similar premise, but that only makes it more interesting (which I explain later on). Technically the genre expansion occurs right in the first episode, but I guess it's even better if you go in completely blind.
- Genre (marketed on release): Slice of Life, School
- Actual Genre: episode 1
- Type: Original animation + Multi-media release (LN prequel, LN sequel, VN, very possible further expansion)
- Similar To: episode 1
- MAL score: 7.61/10 (link)
Premise
Hero Club is a small group of middle school students dedicated to helping people. At foundation it consisted of just the main character (Yuki Yuna), her wheelchair-bound friend Togo, and the club's president, Fu, but now it's also Fu's younger sister Itsuki. The club helps out in some minor things like preparing a school play for children or finding owners for cats. The girls receive personalized cell phones from Fu with a special Hero Club app.
Everything past this line is spoilers for episode 1.
What is so good about it?
The plot. It's one of these deceptive "keep watching, it's worth it" shows that only get gradually better with time. Don't expect a perfect ending, though, as some things are still open to interpretation.
The visuals. The whole show has consistently good style, but the forest dimension the girls get thrown into to fight is just beautiful. Action and animation is fluid and entertaining, and just as pleasant for the eye as the backgrounds.
The characters. The girls (the show was intended to have no male characters) are cute and likeable, but far from shallow. Their interactions are entertaining and the emotions they feel are shared by the audience. As I've mentioned, one of them is wheelchair-bound, which is a rare thing to see in a magical girl show, and that element is expanded upon.
The music. When a show wants to portray emotions, visuals aren't always enough to cut the deal and powerful music is helpful. So is in this case. The soundtrack fits the visuals like a glove.
Once the plot reached the critical point, the BDs climbed to global top 10 on Japanese Amazon and sold out of stock in numerous other online shops. It was one of the best-selling shows of Fall 2014, surpassing Amagi Brilliant Park and Psycho-Pass 2 and losing slightly only to Yowamushi Pedal: Grand Road. Somehow it sort of flew under the radar in the West, and it's currently #1312 in popularity on MAL.
The inevitable Madoka comparison
So yeah, as soon as people realized it's a magical girl show and the author of Akame ga Kill (a show where everybody dies until you stop caring) wrote it, the comparisons with Madoka became unavoidable. And, surprisingly enough, this has vastly enriched the watching experience.
What happened here was that people's expectations and fears made everyone that much concerned about where the show was going, and when it began to present its own value, the voices saying "Madoka ripoff" were silenced, and viewers appreciated it for what is has done differently - while maintaining the dreadful feeling of "I have absolutely no idea where this is going".
The basic differences are in the artistic approach: Madoka has its grim Labirynths, drawn as in some old, creepy Russian animation, and YuYuYu has beautiful, colorful world of the Jukai, which is still an acid trip, just a good one. While Madoka works on a high contrast between sugar sweet school life and grimdark witch activity, YuYuYu is much more uniform and subtle in its themes, changing the content, but not the style. The opening sequence, peaceful and heartwarming at first, will become a melancholic tearjerker once you've realized the meaning behind it.
While I was throughly entertained by Madoka's plot, I think I was just as much emotionally moved by Yuuki Yuuna, if not more. Overall one thing is for sure - we now have a good piece of evidence of Madoka's tangible impact on magical girl anime.
Summary
Want a show that will toy with your expectations, and then exceed them? Try Yuuki Yuuna. Hold on if you think it's not going anywhere. It will definitely be worth it.
TL;DR: Anime fans are horrible people who want to watch cute girls suffer.
Previous: A Certain Scientific Railgun - Next: Shingeki no Bahamut: Genesis
2
u/Harlequina :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Harlequina Feb 24 '15
So I'm trusting you on this one, OP. :P I'm gonna watch it based on the first sentences you wrote and nothing more. I mean that sure sounded interesting, so I gotta try it this way.
13
u/ss_lmtd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ss_lmtd Feb 23 '15
Suuure, that's what the Shinju-sama said...totally worked out for our heroes.
18
u/bigfoot1291 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bigfoot1291 Feb 23 '15
On episode 5 of this show and can confirm, is great so far.
12
u/hilkito Feb 23 '15
I watched it last week, and it's amazing. I really wasn't expecting everything to happen that way. I really got some Madoka vibes in the first episode, but was incredibly surprised by how the show did everything.
Of course, I compared it to Madoka, and I think it's almost as good or just as good, imo. Some of the aspects are better handled in Madoka, and other aspects are better handled in YuYuYu, but overall, I think they're both great.
Also, I didn't even know this was an original creation of Takahiro; I was incredibly surprised. As an AgK manga reader, it hyped me for the last arc.
I recommended it to a friend, and he loved it too. If you liked Madoka, you're either going to like or hate YuYuYu, since the opinion about it is very divided, imo.
2
u/FoleyX90 Feb 24 '15
Just finished episode 9 based on your recommendation. Can't contain my feels.
1
u/einherjar81 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Einherjar81 Mar 21 '15
I know this post is kinda old (by Reddit standards), but I feel the need to emphasize this further.
For anyone unaware, the OST music for YuYuYu was done by MoNACA, and much of it was specifically composed by Keiichi Okabe. Okabe chose to utilize the vocal talents of singer Emi Evans for a number of the insert songs on the YuYuYu soundtrack, and they're brilliant, like the pair's other collaborations: the soundtracks for NieR and Drakengard 3.
3
u/stalinchan Feb 23 '15
I hugely enjoyed this anime while it was airing and liked how Yuuki Yuuna Ep 5+ Spoilers
8
u/BBSNYPUR Feb 23 '15
I liked the show, but it wasn't amazing. Some of the characters were boring, not a whole lot about how the world works was explained, and I disliked the ending. It was a fun watch, but nothing mindblowing. Also was hard not to compare it to madoka.
6
u/Amestris :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Salinga Feb 23 '15
I really wanted to like YuYuYu, but I ended up disappointed.
I liked the ideas of how
I also agree that having a disabled protagonist and was a refreshing change. Unfortunately, the end trivializes the entire thing and Going by the early SoL episodes, I was getting the impression that the whole wheelchair thing wasn't for the sake of plot for a change, but clearly that was not the case. Code Geass had a similar problem. Guilty Crown, even with all its other problems, had a step in the right direction with Ayase.
Also this is more nitpicking than anything... but why is Togo mostly pushed around by Yuuna when she is capable of taking care of herself? Aside from that though, I do like Togo as a character, regardless of physical condition.
1
u/JapanCode https://anilist.co/user/TheJapanCode Feb 23 '15
I watched the first 2-3 episodes when it was airing and then dropped it. Maybe I'll have to give it another chance
4
u/ckwng :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ckwng Feb 24 '15
This may be a bit late, but if you enjoyed Yuuki Yuuna, know that Yuuki Yuuna is a mixed media project.
Yuuki Yuuna (Yuyuyu) itself is the main body of the story.
A prequel LN that started monthly serialization a few months before Yuuki Yuuna aired exists, called Washio Sumi wa Yuusha de Aru (Wasuyu). Wasuyu is translated into English in it's entirety of 8 chapters, as well as the bonus chapter included in the tankoubon. For those who can read Japanese, Wasuyu can be purchased on the Japanese Kindle store.
A one-shot epilogue called "Sonoko After", published in Dengeki G's in January (the March issue) has also been translated into English. Dengeki G's is also purchasable through Kindle for those who can read Japanese.
A visual novel included with the first Blu-ray volume, has been translated into English via patch, and contains various stories that take place between Episode 3 and 4.
A second visual novel will be included with the sixth Blu-ray volume as well.
Various other information about Yuyuyu has also been translated into English:
The Flower Language of Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru
The Hero Record
Miyoshi Karin wa Yuusha de Aru
The Yuyuyu Glossary
Aurora Days / Inori no Uta
The Music of Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru / Hoshi to Hana
Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru Staff Comments
Terui Haruka wa Yuusha de Aru
Kurosawa Tomoyo on the Bonds of the Cast of Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru
Kishi Seiji, Takahiro, and Uezu Makoto on Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru
2
u/empress_of_moe Feb 23 '15 edited Feb 23 '15
I'd argue its more of a French/Western European style
But hmm, nice WT I guess, its just hard to do a WT for a series which you can't spoil too much.
And seriously, the Madoka clone calling should have stopped when the protagonist transformed Kamen Rider style, anything beyond that was just silly. But then again, people are seriously calling stuff like Wish Upon the Pleiades (Originally aired a few days after Madoka) and 6♥Princess (Origins from 2010 so it came before Madoka. Actually based on HC Precure.) Madoka clones so I guess there isn't much logic behind it.
2
u/onlyforthisair Feb 23 '15
Still waiting on FFF
2
u/Shieya Feb 23 '15
Also, much like Madoka, this was a show I went in blind on, purely because of all the adorable fanart. :')
2
u/fsik Feb 24 '15
The twist was interesting and the alternate interpretation of the ending is better than whats widely accepted. However, I still found this kind of average.
2
u/smithrooks :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smithrooks Feb 24 '15
Great recommendation. I've finished the series, and I have to say it's amazing.
2
u/Jaeger-bomb-bastic :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheRedYeti Feb 24 '15
I disagree with this statement. I personally still think of it as a Madoka rip-off although it was still enjoyable. I'm impeded from thinking this show is great when it's already been written before and I accept that most shows are hardly original concepts but I feel it's obvious for YuYuYu.
1
u/Tazzeh Feb 23 '15
Thanks for this great WT! post! I've watched the series myself, but always had difficulty with how to recommend it, given I don't want to spoil it :P
1
u/kotomoon Feb 23 '15
I hate the person who recommended this to me when I asked for cute fluffy shows like K-on.......
1
u/kwaherif :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kwaherif Feb 23 '15
I've been meaning to watch this for a while and I've heard good things about it.
Hopefully it won't disappoint, thanks for the recommendation.
1
u/readitmeow :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bluur22 Feb 24 '15
One of the first MAL reviews states:
this anime is a sequel to the LN 'Washio Sumi wa Yuusha de Aru', it's highly recommended that you do NOT read it before this, don't even look at it's synopsis as it contains spoilers.
What do you think? How necessary is it to read the LN prequels before starting this series?
-10
u/BigBlackPenis Feb 23 '15
I can't believe there are people who enjoyed YuYuYu. It was one of the most boring shows I've ever watched, and absolutely do not recommend it. Not once did I compare it to Madoka Magica. I watched every single episode wanting the show to impress me with its own merits.
What I got was extremely dull slice-of-life with bland characters. The only redeeming quality it had was
-10
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '15
Until episode 7 its just generic moe magical girl. That is way too long to wait.