r/anime • u/kwaherif :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kwaherif • Mar 08 '15
[WT!] Bounen no Xamdou (Action, Sci-Fi, Fantasy, Romance) How something flawed can also be good.
MyAnimeList: http://myanimelist.net/anime/4177/Bounen_no_Xamdou
MAL Rating: 7.88
Bounen no Xamdou is also known as Xam'd: Lost Memories, is an anime whose genres are really hard to pinpoint. It has a lot of elements of all kinds of different genres which makes it more or less makes it stand out.
As you've probably noticed I've mentioned in the title that this show is flawed and it's true, however that doesn't mean it's bad - indeed it's not bad at all but you have to keep in mind that this show does have it's problems which might discourage you from watching the show. In spite of it's problems though I think it's worth the watch, just keep in mind the problems it has.
Why should I watch it?
- Characters: This show has some of the best characters I've seen in anime. Each and every character feels unique and is not a stock character.
Main characters:
- Akiyuki Takehara the protagonist: He is likeable and is not your standard MC who simply remains actionless or simply gets pointless power ups. You can relate to him and his actions make sense. In addition, watching his interactions with the other characters is also fun and feels very ogranic. Overall I found him a good and enjoyable character.
- Nishimura Haru: Akiyuki's friend since childhood, she's a strong female character who you cheer on throughout the series. She has some nice development and chemistry with the protagonist. She's proactive and her actions also makes sense, she makes a good companion to Akiyuki
- Nakiami: The badass plane piloting chick who knows how to fight, yet isn't the standard kuudere archetype. Her actions and character make sense and she's not overpowered. She's a pretty moral person. It's fun to see her argue with the main character and also interact with the support cast who all appear to be so different from her. She feels like an "outsider" type character but she's really badass.
- The supporting cast: In my opinion the single strongest point of this show. The supporting characters are all great and unique, from the awesome female captain of the ship, who can take an entire army with her sniper rifle, to the funny Akushiba who's an amazing sprinter and perv yet really funny. We have an Indian inspired character who pilots an airship and is a father figure, we have have the fat mother who serves as the chef and cleaner who also has her badass moments, but in the end there are two supporting characters who really stood out to me - Akiyuki's father and mother. Those two have some of the best dialogues that I've seen, they felt so real and emotional, when they were on screen I could feel myself smiling just because how much I liked both of them even though they always are at a disagreement between each other. I really didn't know if I liked the father or mother more, both of those characters felt really realistic and really enjoyable
Overall I felt the supporting cast did feel organic and realistic. There are so many fun characters that you don't usually see. Everyone's personality felt unique and that made it a great experience.
- Atmosphere: The art and characters play a big role in the immersion. You could really feel the fun, adventure and rough moments of the crew, the art really helped with that. It really felt immersive and beautiful. The world is really beautifully crafted and looks really nice, the show takes place in a couple of different locations so you could really experience the different places of the Xam'd world.
What kind of problems does this show have? Even though I enjoyed this show, I felt that it wasted some of it's potential. With such great characters, world and atmosphere it really fell short on it's story.
- Nothing is ever explained. Most of your questions remain unanswered and you never get to know some very important questions. Who are the Northern Government? Why is there a war? What are the mech like things anyways? There are many questions left without answers which I didn't like
- There wasn't any real story There's a war, and people use different kinds of mechs and weapons. That's the entire story, from what I could tell. But no, really this is a result of the above problem. We have a war but why did this war start? We only really know that 2 factions are at war and one of them is bad because they use some sorts of biological weapons and that's it. We never see why these factions are doing what they're doing or the reason why there's a war in the first place.Some of the arcs have some story but it feels like they never contribute to the main story and that's probably because there's so little of it.
Is it worth even with it's flaws? I'd say yes. Give it a watch. The characters and atmosphere can carry this show. In spite of its problems I found this anime pretty enjoyable and I would recommend it to other people, however if you really are a person who likes to focus on story, I would avoid this anime if I were you. On the other hand, if you can turn a blind eye to it's problems you too can enjoy it.
6
u/PurgeJuls88 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PurgeJuls Mar 08 '15
I just saw this 2 weeks ago. It was a little hard to understand but very enjoyable though.
8
u/candeewolf Mar 08 '15
Completely disagree. The story is the strongest part of the show and longing for more of it isn't a flaw for others to be discouraged.
While I understand some of your critiques about the show, they seem unfair and could be equally applied to most "other-world" stories that run in 26 episodes or less.
For the time allotted, I thought the story made enough sense while not detracting too much from main characters' stories. If they were to spend time explaining the lead-up to the war in-depth (they did explain it occasionally throughout the series), they wouldn't be able to explain the fall, rise, and history of the most important characters.
It's not unfathomable to believe that wars can break out over trivial, historical aggressions which transform into conflicts that span long periods of time. Which is exactly what the anime seemed to be hinting throughout its run. If you want specific information of the history of each region, the anime would have to run at least another season.
It really seems like you wanted the history of their world narrated over a period of 5-6 episodes to explain all the questions you have because the tidbits of information that they did spend time explaining all of your questions wasn't enough. And unfortunately that's a problem that a lot of anime have when there's a lot of source material and no guarantee at a 2nd season. I think if you're more accepting of what they present to you in the present story rather than asking for a history lession, these problems wouldn't be discouraging nor detract from the show.
2
u/Tentaculat :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Tentaculat Mar 08 '15
I added this to my list yesterday so it's nice to see a more detailed explanation of this show. As for the war and the story, depending on how it's handled I could be fine with it. Most animes/movies/etc have a tendency to trivialize war in order to "explain it" to the watcher/readers which can be annoying sometimes. Most people that are part of a war have no idea why it's happening and instead are usually given excuses as to why they have to sacrifice themselves for their country instead of the actual reasons ( it's resources 9/10 times ). I think that as long as the story of the people in said war is compelling and the characters are well thought out and have good chemestry, there doesn't need to be a "point" to the war.
But yeah I'll try to give this a chance soon when I'm done watching my current stuff.
13
u/Scoin0 :K:https://kitsu.io/users/Scoin0 Mar 08 '15
When I watched this I kept thinking of Eureka Seven.
6
u/2deep4this Mar 08 '15
I would describe Xam'd in one word: bewilderment.
In most series, the basic premise is introduced at the beginning to give the viewer an idea of what's going on. Even a simple statement like "oh, all these guys have psychic powers" in Index would suffice. In Xam'd, not so much, and it doesn't bother explaining anything for the rest of the show either. Stuff happens, but nothing was ever explained. Xam'd and Humanforms are thrown around, the mc gets a mask, and the Emperor shows up... ok, I still have no idea what these things are and why they are happening.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 08 '15
And guys, the opening! its soooo good! Xam'd OP
1
u/Ivalance Mar 08 '15
The first and last time I watched this show was back in 2008. Thus, I don't remember a single shred of the story anymore, though I don't remember hating it.
I also remember that I loved how grand the scale felt, the feelings that harken me back to epic animes like the ones made by Hayao Miyazaki and Digimon: The Movie. Obviously the production quality aren't as good, them being featured films and all that.
Another thing that struck me as good was the ending song, Vacancy by Kylee. I dunno why but it fit the vibe of the show very well. A little bit generic pop rock song, but I loved the melody, still listen to it from time to time.
Another show that IMO has a similar feel is Fractale. But sadly I didn't finish that one because I didn't feel it was as engaging as Xamd, but will definitely get back to it one day.
1
u/Nasaku7 Mar 08 '15
Well i watched Bounen before Eureka both were so great but have to admit i like Eureka more
1
u/warpticon Mar 10 '15
This show is so weird. I love so many things about it, but I feel like total product was really lacking somehow. It's the rare show I think would have been a lot better if it had been about twice as long. It's just so compressed and dense and overwhelming in its existing state, and it hurts aspects of what it's trying to do.
Haru is still the greatest forever though.