r/anime • u/BigBlackPenis • Mar 16 '15
[WT!] Shigurui – Tired of childish anime tropes? Try this: a brutal, un-apologetic look at the life of samurai with disturbing violence.
This isn’t Rurouni Kenshin. This isn’t a shounen with the power of friendship. There’s nothing romantic about samurai here.
The plot revolves around life in a dojo. There’s a rivalry between an apprentice and a new recruit, there’s assassinations, there's backstabbing, and there's the dojo master is going senile. Not in a funny way either.
The fights are intense. They’re not “epic” with flying and buildings being demolished. No, characters will stare each other down for minutes because real melee combat doesn’t involve spinning and twirling. One mistake, and you’re either dead or you’ve lost a piece of your body. There are sometimes clever tricks and tactics, too.
The violence in this show isn’t the embarrassingly edgy type like Hellsing Ultimate. When someone is cut with a sword, there isn’t “battle damage.” They’re real injuries with slices of flesh taken off.
The pacing is slow and methodical.
The animation is very muted. I’ve never seen so much gray. There’s no such thing as color in this show. Characters are drawn realistically.
Together with the violence, the methodical pace, and the muted colors, it all creates a very suffocating and depressing atmosphere. It makes you glad you don’t live in such a harsh time.
There’s even a dub which surprised me. Check it out on Hulu.
Try the first episode on YouTube sub or dub.
Be warned, the first episode takes place in the present and the rest of the show is a flashback leading up to that moment.
Edit
Some negatives. The pacing can be too slow. Unfortunately, a lot of the fight moments are barely animated due to low budget. The scenes can literally too dark to look at sometimes. It can get confusing due to the many scene cuts and Japanese names. You have to pay attention.
5
u/FixiCasting :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Fixisan Mar 16 '15
Sounds too good to be true, tell me about the negatives!
17
u/daddy_shank :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gmancam Mar 16 '15
One of the best Samurai centered series. It's also done my my fav studio, Madhouse!
I love the sense of realism the battles showed. No power ups or unrealistic fighting here. Fights are decided in a matter of seconds just like in real life battles.
21
u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik Mar 16 '15
Hm, getting on MAL...
Well, another show on PtW won't hurt, will it?
8
u/DuderonymousLex Mar 16 '15
Shigurui is one of my all time favorites and I'm very happy to see it getting props on here.
33
u/einherjar81 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Einherjar81 Mar 16 '15
Uh, I have to disagree with that. The nipple scene in particular is pretty edgy.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15
Definitely the best thing about this show for me is the way the morality works- I straight up could not tell who was the good guy- it's not one of those things where there's an anti hero who's clearly in the right, or a likable villain, I was extremely morally confused by the end of the series. The characters are fighting for themselves and for those they're loyal to, and there's only one out-and-out evil character in the whole series- who happens to be the protagonists father-figure mentor that he almost worships.
5
u/mikachuu :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mooniestar Mar 16 '15
This show was the first anime to make me feel physically sick to my stomach. I think I've seen enough anime to know "Hey, this isn't real, he isn't actually experiencing pain, etc." But that first episode did me in.
5
u/OhMilla Mar 17 '15
One of the best comments was I've seen about it is, "I'm a 30 year old man. I am too young to be watching this."
5
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
Having studied kenjitsu, I'll add that this is still a little theatrical. Duels were done without armor, and the fight often ended at first blood. Still, I appreciate an animation where people aren't spraying blood like firehoses. I also like more realistic fights.
Still, thanks for sharing. I'll definitely check it out.
6
u/dertswa687o :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dertswa687o Mar 16 '15
Sold.
It sounds intense. OP, you painted a very vivid picture of this show in my head so I commend your writing for that.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '15 edited Mar 17 '15
But is it "Trust and Betrayal" violence level?
I will watch anyway, you spiked my interest with "Tired of childish anime tropes?".
Edit: Holy shit, never mind. Just watched the first 5 minutes and im already sold. Will definitely watch this.
3
u/hashbeardy420 Mar 18 '15
I found this series to be startlingly beautiful. The almost absurdly grotesque violence is meant to draw you into the emptiness of the characters, much like the animation uses over exposure to separate characters from the real world. Yes, it is slow, brutal, and ridiculous in its level of misogyny, but Shigurui offers something more for someone who wants to stomach the madness. More than anything, I felt like this was a tale about isolation rather than violence.
1
u/vesper8008 Mar 17 '15
um... this anime is kinda boring.
4
u/GuyWithSausageFinger Mar 16 '15
Well, you sold me with the title.
I avidly avoid anything with what are considered the modern "childish tropes" anyways, but the brutal look at samurai life with disturbing violence is something that just really appeals to me.
5
u/JTricks :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JTricks Mar 16 '15
This is one of the best WT! posts I've seen. First one that had a show I've never heard of and a great description that has definitely caught my interest. Great job OP.
2
u/dabritian :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dabritian Mar 16 '15
I was thinking of watching Another in my darks and serious part of my anime watching cycle but this looks like it would do better.
2
u/Stushoe Mar 17 '15
interesting
2
u/LancerFIN :AP:https://www.anime-planet.com/users/LancerFIN Mar 17 '15
7/10. Unusually gory. Rare to see in anime.